
Practical Approaches to Managing Corporate Criminal Risks
▲
Click above to watch Attorney Wu Jialing.
An Analysis of Using Criminal Means to Facilitate the Exit of Private Equity Fund Projects
When
Once a private equity fund (hereinafter referred to as the “private equity fund”) has completed its capital contribution and become a shareholder of the target company, it enters the post‑investment management phase. The investment agreement typically stipulates that, following closing, the founders and the target company must fulfill a series of obligations and commitments, including compliance with non‑compete and fiduciary duties, maintaining financial and operational compliance, and obtaining investor approval prior to making material decisions. The agreement also includes corresponding default liability provisions, which may encompass restoring the status quo, paying liquidated damages, compensating for losses, or even triggering a share repurchase.
When the founder or the project company engages in misconduct, private equity funds seeking to protect their rights through conventional civil and commercial means often encounter significant challenges, including difficulties in presenting evidence, lengthy court scheduling, slow enforcement, protracted timelines, and low efficiency. Moreover, certain investment agreements contain contractual defects arising from insufficient drafting, thereby affording the project company and the founder room to raise defenses under both substantive and procedural law. In addition, in projects structured via a red-chip arrangement, although the corporate holding platform is located overseas, the company’s key personnel, core operations, and major assets remain within China—yet investment agreements typically stipulate that foreign law shall govern and that disputes shall be resolved by an overseas arbitration institution. If the remedies prescribed in such agreements are applied mechanically, this can result in exorbitant overseas legal fees and substantial time costs, while reliance on cross-border judicial assistance procedures further delays the recovery of funds; meanwhile, the wrongdoer may have already transferred or concealed critical assets during this period. By contrast, the lawful and prudent use of criminal‑law‑based dispute resolution mechanisms may yield more efficient and direct outcomes.
Obtaining and securing evidence in accordance with criminal standards.
To prevent problems before they arise, private equity funds should proactively cultivate an awareness of evidence collection and preservation, ensuring that every step in the process of obtaining and securing evidence leaves a clear record.
Wu Jialing
Star Lai Law Firm
Partner
wujialing@xinglailaw.com
Give due weight to the legality of the sources of evidence. During the negotiation of investment agreements between private equity funds and project companies, it is essential to clearly stipulate the investor’s right to information and the specific procedures for exercising that right, ensuring that such provisions can be effectively implemented in post‑investment management. If an investor obtains company documents through unlawful or improper means, or if the process of obtaining those documents is legally flawed, the investor may instead find itself constrained by the founders and accused of illegally appropriating trade secrets.
Emphasize the authenticity of evidence. During due diligence on a project company, private equity funds typically have access only to editable versions of financial statements. From the perspective of criminal evidence, such editable files are susceptible to tampering, raising doubts about their authenticity and potentially undermining the effectiveness of subsequent rights‑protection efforts. Accordingly, the author recommends that, during the early “honeymoon period” when relations between the parties remain amicable, key documents be promptly collected and preserved in their stamped, official versions.
Emphasize the relevance of evidence. In general, the primary objective of due diligence in private‑placement transactions is to gain a thorough understanding of the company’s operational status and legal compliance. If there is a prospect of addressing post‑investment risks through criminal measures, it is essential, during both the due‑diligence and post‑investment management phases, to proactively reference the constituent elements of relevant criminal offenses, systematically collect and scrutinize the company’s documentation, and continuously monitor key metrics in its financial statements, accounting records, and operational framework, thereby strengthening the evidentiary link between the obtained materials and the specific offenses at issue.
Huang Xinran
Star Lai Law Firm
Lawyer
huangxinran@xinglailaw.com
Offensive Negotiation
Offensive negotiation refers to a situation in which an investor, upon obtaining evidence of criminal conduct by the company or its founder, proactively initiates negotiations to reach a consensus on how to address the misconduct, thereby seeking redress of their rights.
Investee companies, founders, and management teams are often implicated in offenses related to executive duties as well as corporate‑operational crimes. Private equity funds and specialized counsel can, based on the specific circumstances of each transaction, gather and organize evidence, assess criminal risks, and, on that basis, devise negotiation strategies and post‑transaction response plans.
Compared with traditional civil and commercial remedies, adversarial negotiation is characterized by its penetrating power, efficiency, and challenging nature.
Penetrative. Unlike risk isolation among different parties in the civil and commercial spheres, criminal liability determinations can penetrate formalities, place greater emphasis on substance, and more readily trace responsibility directly to the founders and senior executives.
Efficiency. The primary consequence of resorting to civil and commercial remedies is being listed as a discredited party subject to enforcement; however, in practice, some individuals often circumvent the adverse effects of such designation through illicit means. By contrast, criminal offenses carry far more severe penalties and exert stronger deterrence on the parties involved. Consequently, adversarial negotiation strategies can frequently break deadlocks in rights protection and significantly shorten the duration of such proceedings.
Challenging. Given the high sensitivity of criminal proceedings and the complexity of private equity investments, conducting adversarial negotiations is highly challenging. Private equity funds must proceed with caution to avoid implicating themselves or their appointed directors and senior executives, thereby preventing allegations of extortion that could place them at a disadvantage. Even after reaching a new agreement through corporate negotiations, the execution and implementation of such agreements may still raise criminal‑law‑related concerns. Accordingly, the counsel retained by a private equity fund should possess comprehensive experience spanning non‑litigation, litigation, and criminal law practice.
Practical Analysis
Our team successfully conducted an aggressive negotiation targeting a senior executive of a startup that had recently closed its Series D financing. The portfolio company’s shareholder and executive engaged in misconduct during the course of the company’s operations. Following a comprehensive due diligence review, our attorneys uncovered evidence of the executive’s improper conduct, including unauthorized withdrawals of corporate funds, the execution of false business contracts and related-party transactions, improper reimbursement of travel expenses, and the unauthorized appropriation of company assets—actions that allegedly constitute the crimes of embezzlement and misappropriation of funds. On this basis, our lawyers negotiated with the executive on behalf of the company, ultimately securing the executive’s agreement to return the misappropriated funds and to step down from the portfolio company.
Conclusion
Misconduct by the project company or its founders is often subtle in the early stages. Private equity funds should cultivate a proactive awareness of criminal‑law risks from the outset and engage lawyers with criminal‑law expertise at an early phase. When addressing conduct that may involve criminal liability, private equity funds should employ lawful and proportionate criminal‑law measures, carefully implement risk‑separation protocols, and retain seasoned, multidisciplinary counsel to design and execute a comprehensive response strategy.
This article was published in the October 2025 issue of Commercial Law, under the original title: “Addressing Post-Investment Management Risks of Private Equity Funds Through Criminal Means” 。
Author Biography
.
Wu Jialing
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Bachelor of Laws from Peking University School of Law, and Master of Financial Law from Goethe University Frankfurt. Since beginning practice, he has accumulated seven years of experience at a top-tier law firm, demonstrating solid case-handling skills and extensive litigation expertise. In 2025, he was awarded the “Rising Star Lawyer Award” at the 10th Guike Annual Conference.
For many years, we have consistently provided comprehensive, end-to-end legal services to prominent investment institutions, private equity funds, multinational corporations, and large domestic private enterprises on both Wall Street in the United States and in China. Our practice spans the entire investment lifecycle—fundraising, investment, post‑investment management, and eventual exit. In terms of specific practice areas, we offer in-depth expertise across a wide range of fields, including domestic and cross‑border financing and investment, M&A transactions, corporate governance, and dispute resolution. We serve clients across a broad spectrum of industries, from traditional manufacturing and real estate to emerging sectors such as new energy, technology, the internet, e‑commerce, healthcare, biotechnology, education, and consumer entertainment.
Attorney Wu also possesses exceptional project‑management and coordination skills, coupled with outstanding communication and negotiation expertise. In multi‑party, high‑intensity, and complex transaction‑negotiation settings, he plays a pivotal role, securing favorable deals for clients and mitigating potential risks in the most timely and efficient manner.
Business Areas:
Cross-border and domestic investment and financing, M&A transactions, corporate governance, dispute resolution, and more.
.
Huang Xinran
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Lawyer
Master of Laws from Peking University, practicing lawyer in Beijing, and member of the Public Interest Committee of the Dongcheng District Lawyers Association. He has extensive experience in areas including commercial crimes, financial and securities offenses, corporate compliance and responses to government investigations, as well as antitrust and unfair competition matters.
During his career, he has provided criminal defense in numerous high-profile economic and official‑duty crime cases; handled administrative penalty responses and criminal defenses in the financial and securities sectors; delivered comprehensive and specialized compliance services to large state-owned enterprises, public institutions, and listed companies; rendered World Bank and multilateral development bank compliance investigations and sanctions‑lifting assistance to several overseas construction subsidiaries of state-owned enterprises; and offered antitrust administrative‑penalty response and compliance‑remediation services to Fortune Global 500 firms and listed companies.
Business Areas:
Criminal defense, corporate compliance and government investigations, public crisis management, antitrust and anti-unfair competition.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12



