
Editor’s Note


This article is compiled from the lecture delivered by Attorney Zhao Yunheng at the Second “100‑Person Advanced Training Program for Criminal Defense Lawyers.”

The training program was organized by China University of Political Science and Law, focusing on professional development and cutting-edge practice in the field of criminal defense. The event brought together a distinguished faculty comprising leading legal scholars and seasoned practitioners, including Chen Xingliang, Gu Yongzhong, and Jiang Wei, while attracting more than 140 criminal defense lawyers from across the country to attend and engage in learning, garnering widespread attention within the profession. Throughout the series of high‑profile courses, Attorney Zhao Yunheng, the honorary director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, leveraged his extensive professional experience to deliver a specialized lecture on “Methods and Techniques for Persuading Public Security, Procuratorial, and Judicial Authorities with High Emotional Intelligence.” From the perspectives of communication art and strategy, this work offers criminal defense attorneys a professional framework for conducting their practice more effectively and enhancing case outcomes.

Professionalism First
Professional competence is the cornerstone of criminal defense—a fundamental consensus within the legal profession. The depth to which a defense attorney masters the law, while it may not surpass that of prosecutors and judges, should at least be on par with theirs. Only by grounding one’s practice in expertise can one advance persuasive arguments in defense, compelling the opposing side to take them seriously.
As judicial functions have become increasingly specialized, the public security, procuratorial, and judicial organs have, over many years, established a work mechanism characterized by clear professional division of labor in the criminal justice field—this is particularly evident within the procuratorate. At present, the procuratorates are undertaking internal institutional reforms, with each department focusing on specific types of cases. For instance, the financial‑crime prosecution unit has long handled a large volume of such cases; its accumulated theoretical grounding and familiarity with relevant legal provisions often surpass those of most defense attorneys—this reflects a professional advantage conferred by the institutional framework. However, defense counsel also possesses a distinct strength: the ability to devote deeper, more meticulous attention to individual cases. Given the sheer number of cases handled by the prosecution, it is difficult to achieve the same level of exhaustive scrutiny in every matter; by contrast, defense lawyers can concentrate their time and expertise on complex legal issues that intersect multiple branches of law, as well as on nuanced evidentiary details, thereby uncovering additional, persuasive arguments. Accordingly, professional competence remains the cornerstone of legal practice. In any given case, once a contentious legal or evidentiary issue is identified, it should be thoroughly elucidated and fully developed, so as to leverage its decisive influence over the case’s trajectory and narrow the opposing party’s room for maneuver.
Moreover, the choice of strategy and the manner of communication are equally critical. Take Beijing-based lawyers as an example: they are often stereotyped by outsiders as relying solely on three procedural defense tactics—challenging jurisdiction, requesting recusal, and seeking the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence. In judicial practice, the judiciary has grown increasingly adept at handling these three types of procedural defenses, making it progressively more difficult for counsel to succeed; nonetheless, they continue to hold significant tactical value. For instance, with respect to jurisdictional challenges, in certain “long‑haul” cases that remain unresolved, successfully contesting jurisdiction can often turn the tide. In a case our firm, Xinglai Law Firm, is handling—where a gaming company is accused of running an illegal casino—the matter has already reached the court‑review stage; however, the jurisdictional objection was largely upheld. If, during negotiations over jurisdiction, the case can be transferred to the location of the company’s registered office for trial, this could effectively alter the litigation landscape. As for requests for recusal, revisions to relevant laws and judicial interpretations have markedly narrowed the scope of application of the recusal system, significantly increasing the difficulty of securing a successful recusal. In contemporary judicial practice, when a request for recusal is directed at investigators, prosecutors, or judges, the ultimate aim is seldom merely to replace personnel. Rather, when the individuals concerned engage in procedural violations or fail to act, such recusal requests often serve as a procedural check, intended to draw the attention of the adjudicating body and higher judicial authorities to underlying issues, thereby prompting a review and correction of procedural legality—much like the old saying goes, “the old man’s real intention lies not in the wine.” Similarly, the procedure for excluding illegally obtained evidence faces comparable practical challenges: the rate at which such exclusion motions are ultimately granted by the courts continues to decline. Nevertheless, when defense counsel files an exclusion motion, the goal is frequently not simply to exclude specific evidence; instead, by exposing the unlawful nature of the evidence‑gathering process, they seek to indirectly influence the judge, thereby enhancing the prospects of obtaining a lighter or reduced sentence for the defendant.
Putting professionalism first also requires broadening one’s horizons, staying attuned to public sentiment and societal trends, and precisely interpreting and applying criminal policy—ensuring that one’s strategic positioning is sound. This is the very essence of professional competence. Rather than self‑promoting or straying from the core professional mission, we must place the interests of our clients unequivocally above all else.
Good-faith communication
On the basis of professional expertise, lawyers should maintain good faith in the course of their practice, regard judicial officers as a community of professionals acting in good faith, and communicate with respect and in a respectful manner, thereby avoiding unnecessary adversarial attitudes.
Young lawyers sometimes tend to display excessive aggressiveness in communication, particularly during court proceedings. When the judge, in the course of the trial, inadvertently overlooks a procedural step and invites the lawyer to offer their views, such lawyers may immediately object in a highly confrontational manner. In reality, in most cases, this is not deliberate but rather the result of oversight due to the judge’s heavy workload. Adopting a calm and constructive approach to dialogue—while safeguarding the rights of the parties and respecting courtroom decorum—often yields far better outcomes.
Last week, during a business trip to coordinate with the public prosecution authority, I found that they had been holding the case for several days without yet reviewing the case files. They assigned a young assistant—fresh out of law school and not yet certified as a prosecutor—to liaise with me. In response, I made it clear that our firm’s purpose in this visit was to serve as an effective partner to the prosecution, helping to clarify the facts of the case and systematically address relevant issues of legal application. I assured them that we would provide full support whenever their assistance was needed. This approach set a positive tone for subsequent communications with the prosecution. In my view, lawyers should first convey respect and a willingness to collaborate. Even if the other side initially adopts a more cautious stance, we must maintain professional courtesy and proceed with rationality and politeness. Such an approach not only demonstrates professional integrity but, from a strategic perspective, also better safeguards the client’s long-term interests.
If a conflict with the opposing party is truly unavoidable, even if you temporarily gain the upper hand during the confrontation, you should know when to stop and leave room for the other side. Remember that the litigation process remains under the control of the judicial authorities; if your relentless pressure prompts the opposing party to adopt an even more aggressive stance, it will ultimately be the defendant who bears the adverse consequences. While a tough, confrontational approach may win applause from the client and their family, it can end up undermining the client’s rights and interests—much like “losing the watermelon while picking up the sesame seeds.”
At the strategic level, I advocate avoiding unnecessary surprise attacks on evidence or arguments. While some contend that such tactics can exert pressure during trial, courts are fully capable of responding—through adjournments or other measures. Rather than relying on this approach, it is more effective to engage with the prosecutor early on, exchanging key perspectives and evidence to influence their decision‑making at the pretrial stage. Even if the opposing side seeks to exploit our goodwill and candor by launching supplementary investigations to plug gaps in evidence or arguments, fundamentally flawed evidence is difficult to remedy, and genuine deficiencies in the evidentiary chain are hard to close. We should nonetheless pursue our defense with professionalism and transparency, recognizing that the likelihood of success through surprise tactics is exceedingly low.
Be a good assistant.
During the course of handling a case, defense counsel should fully assume the role of a “supporting assistant” to the judicial authorities. In practice, I have repeatedly encountered rather unusual circumstances. For example, a few days ago I was working on an insider‑trading case that had been transferred to the procuratorate nearly a month earlier. Although the opposing agency indicated it could receive and engage in discussions, it also made clear that, owing to the ongoing special rectification campaign in the financial sector and the heavy workload, more than twenty days after the case’s transfer, the handling personnel still had not reviewed the case file. Under these circumstances, the other side requested that, when we visited for communication, we assist the investigating authorities in organizing the facts of the case, highlighting key evidence, and providing expert opinions on specialized issues. Given that this case involves securities‑related offenses—highly technical in nature and entailing legal relationships governed by other branches of law, such as civil guarantee contracts—it is particularly complex; they further asked us to conduct research and furnish relevant precedent cases for reference. We believe this is not merely “helping out,” but rather a responsibility to aid judicial officers in swiftly becoming familiar with the case details and accurately interpreting the applicable law, thereby arriving at sound judicial conclusions. To this end, we undertook extensive preparatory work: we extracted critical materials from the investigative files and compiled them into a detailed table of contents; conducted extensive case searches to identify representative precedents, attaching explanatory notes; and included pertinent excerpts from various statutory provisions. At present, the handling personnel have begun to rely on the materials we provided in their analysis—their current focus has shifted from the original case file alone to encompass our organized summaries, which they are now using to further assess the comprehensiveness of the evidence.
This kind of “assistant” role does not entail one party’s subordination to the other; rather, it is inherently forward‑looking. For instance, in law firms or civil society organizations when drafting internal rules or charters, or during the formulation of international treaties and corporate standards, the drafting entity typically holds the initiative and the power of discourse. The drafter’s standards become embedded in the entire drafting process, and their perspectives can serve as guiding principles. The same dynamic applies in interactions with public prosecution, judicial, and law‑enforcement authorities: whoever first submits systematic, professional materials will secure a favorable position in the ensuing technical dialogue.
Moreover, in judicial practice, even seasoned case-handlers may lack a deep understanding of fundamental legal concepts if they have limited experience with certain types of cases. For example, during a discussion with a prosecutor, we pointed out—based on the relevant statutory provisions—that the case should be classified as a corporate crime. We assumed this to be basic legal knowledge; however, the prosecutor, having encountered few such cases, was unfamiliar with the issue and believed that a corporate act could only reflect the entity’s will if it resulted from a collective decision-making process at the management level, failing to grasp both the applicable regulations and the realities of managing private enterprises. Accordingly, in court or during communications, we should adopt an “educational” mindset: even when we take certain legal principles to be self‑evident, we ought to explicitly cite specific statutory provisions to bolster the authority and persuasiveness of our arguments and prevent our views from being dismissed as mere casual remarks.
In addition to providing professional assistance, during court proceedings we should also actively help maintain order, with the aim of achieving rational persuasion. For example, when a defendant, overcome by emotion, delivers lengthy, repetitive testimony or even resists and disrupts the courtroom, the lawyer, with the presiding judge’s permission, may appropriately offer guidance to encourage the party to regain composure and reason, thereby helping to ensure that the trial proceeds efficiently and in an orderly manner—particularly by making the proceedings more receptive and less confrontational. However, when a judge improperly restricts or deprives the defendant of the right to speak, the lawyer must, in accordance with the law and on the basis of sound reasoning, vigorously assert that all participants’ rights be strictly protected, even if this leads to courtroom conflict.
In short, an outstanding defense attorney should strike a balance between assertiveness and restraint. I once handled a high-profile case heard by the Provincial High People’s Court. During the trial, the defendant displayed an intense desire to speak, and the proceedings were frequently disrupted by lengthy, repetitive statements. The presiding judge asked me to help communicate with the defendant. I explained that repeated testimony not only fails to advance the case but may also diminish the persuasiveness of the arguments; moreover, the exercise of one’s rights must avoid abuse and aim primarily at convincing the court. Accordingly, we effectively guided the defendant in managing the pace of the proceedings, thereby ensuring the trial proceeded smoothly. At the same time, regarding procedural disputes, we resolutely filed motions—pursuant to law—to exclude illegally obtained evidence, making no concessions on the legitimate rights and interests of our client. This led the court to summon multiple police officers and witnesses to testify. By pushing advocacy to its limits while knowing when to compromise appropriately, we ultimately secured a verdict widely accepted by the defendant and their family, the prosecution, the judiciary, and even the observers present. Such professional conduct leaves a lasting, positive impression. Later, in another case I handled, when procedural irregularities arose, I refused to cooperate in accordance with the law. Coincidentally, the court’s leadership included the very same presiding judge who had previously overseen the earlier case. Drawing on our prior collaboration, that judge recognized me as a lawyer skilled at working cooperatively, engaging in reasoned opposition, and respecting the law, and thus carefully considered and supported my procedural objections. Therefore, assisting the judiciary does not mean abandoning one’s principles. In highly adversarial criminal defense, cooperation is a shared expectation; only through measured, respectful, and disciplined confrontation can one earn genuine respect.
In summary, throughout the course of a case, defense counsel should serve as a “supportive partner” to the judicial authorities. For matters that are unfamiliar to the court—such as core evidence that has not been adequately examined—counsel should provide a catalog and summary of key evidence, data‑organization tables, and comparative charts of conflicting evidence. When legal provisions and their implications are unclear—for example, regarding corporate criminal liability, the possibility of mounting an acquittal‑based defense in plea‑bargaining cases, the distinctions between administrative and criminal evidentiary rules, or the differences between wager‑type contracts and ordinary contracts—counsel should promptly engage in legal education by supplying relevant statutory texts, interpretive literature, scholarly articles, case law, and, in particular, region‑specific regulations and precedents, as well as opinions from legal scholars. For issues involving specialized fields—such as electronic data, virtual currencies, or trade secrets—counsel should furnish expert opinions from practitioners in those areas. Moreover, when trial proceedings are disrupted due to factors attributable to the defendant, counsel should, either during or outside the courtroom, work to help the parties manage their emotions and maintain composure. By fulfilling this role as a supportive ally, we can more effectively facilitate the acceptance of defense arguments by judicial officers and safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of our clients.
Fight without breaking
During the adversarial phase of case handling, defense counsel should adopt a strategy of “contending without destroying.” It is essential to uphold the principle of confrontation rather than antagonism: we may challenge improper conduct by judicial officers—whether unlawful acts, omissions, or misinterpretations of the law—while refraining from attacking their personal character. We must manage conflicts within reasonable bounds, courageously stand firm, respond with flexibility, know when to stop, and maintain an appropriate balance between assertiveness and restraint, always taking as our fundamental starting point the goal of ensuring that judicial officers genuinely hear and internalize the defense’s arguments.
I once handled a case in which my client’s right to meet with me was initially obstructed. In response, I promptly pursued lawful remedies by lodging an objection with the leadership of the relevant authority. Following this action, the investigating agency duly and promptly arranged the meeting as required by law. Coincidentally, a state-run media outlet conducted an interview on how the procuratorial organs safeguard lawyers’ rights. Although I remained dissatisfied with the initial obstruction, I nonetheless offered an objective assessment of their subsequent corrective measures, commending their practice of upholding the right to meetings in accordance with the law and expressing hope that lawyers’ rights would continue to be fully protected. After the article was published, it helped foster a more constructive and smooth communication environment for the subsequent proceedings in the case.
Another case involved a major organized‑crime matter in Yunnan, in which the court’s president personally served as the presiding judge. Our resolute measures to safeguard our clients’ rights led to an interruption of the proceedings. At a stalemate, we proactively de‑escalated the situation by informing the court that, provided subsequent hearings fully respected and gave due consideration to the lawyers’ arguments, we would cooperate constructively to ensure the orderly conduct of the trial. This strategy reversed the adversarial dynamic; thereafter, the presiding judge consistently sought to consult with the legal team before making decisions. Relying on this communication grounded in mutual respect, we successfully secured the removal of the “organized‑crime” label from our client in the first‑instance judgment, thereby achieving our interim defense objectives through a strategy of “fighting without breaking.”
Throughout my practice, I have come to deeply appreciate that cultivating a professional relationship with the investigating and prosecuting authorities—one characterized by constructive tension rather than outright confrontation—is essential for effectively safeguarding my clients’ legitimate rights and interests. Such a relationship demands that we both uphold our principles and boldly defend our clients’ interests, while also knowing when to adopt a more conciliatory approach, maintain open communication, and strike a balance between criticism and recognition. Criminal defense—particularly in cases involving organized crime and evil forces—presents an extraordinary test of a lawyer’s endurance, wisdom, and art of advocacy. It requires skillful pacing: we must be willing to take a firm stand on matters of principle, yet also adept at defusing stalemates at critical junctures, thereby earning the respect—and even the genuine appreciation—of our counterparts.
Good at tattling
In the current rule-of-law environment, relying solely on adversarial arguments presented during court proceedings often proves insufficient to advance procedural fairness and rectify deviations. Consequently, while steadfastly upholding the legal bottom line, strategically seeking external oversight and internal institutional channels—commonly referred to as “filing complaints”—has become an indispensable supplementary measure for lawyers to safeguard their clients’ legitimate rights and interests and to promote judicial impartiality. Without sunlight, darkness will prevail everywhere.
With respect to the party against whom a complaint is lodged, accountability should be precisely attributed to the individual. When an unlawful act is committed by a specific person, the response should directly target that individual, rather than resorting to vague collective designations such as the Public Security Bureau, the People’s Procuratorate, or the collegiate bench. Current judicial practice emphasizes collective decision‑making as a means of dispersing responsibility—e.g., submitting cases to the adjudication committee or the procuratorial committee—yet, in both internal regulations and actual judicial practice, ultimate responsibility ultimately rests with the designated prosecutors and judges. Consequently, only by accurately identifying the specific individuals accountable can we effectively break the deadlock of diluted responsibility.
Secondly, when filing a complaint, it is essential to identify the sources of pressure on the responsible parties. Sometimes, even those tasked with handling cases face improper interference from both internal and external quarters. In such instances, defense counsel should bring the matter to the attention of both the entity that issued the wrongful instructions and the judicial authority handling the case. A defense lawyer’s appeal may, in fact, provide the responsible party—who is reluctant to follow orders blindly—with a legitimate basis to explain the situation to superiors or relevant departments and resist undue pressure, thereby creating a win-win outcome. With respect to mass‑involved economic cases—such as those involving the illegal absorption of public deposits—public security organs rarely intervene proactively unless a crisis has already erupted. However, once they do step in, if the lawyer contends that the conduct does not constitute a criminal offense, the complaint should be directed to the appropriate competent authority—for example, the department responsible for GDP growth or maintaining social stability—in order to address the underlying issues at their root.
As for the method of “raising concerns,” in addition to submitting reports through official channels, defense attorneys may also seek oversight from public opinion. Individuals who voice their views casually on social media face relatively high risks; I personally prefer collaborating with reputable, authoritative media outlets. Such outlets conduct rigorous investigations and fact-checking before publication, with investigative rigor and editorial control that rival those of lawyers, while also maintaining robust self‑protection mechanisms to ensure the accuracy and effectiveness of public scrutiny.
Many of my colleagues harbor concerns, believing that only outsiders are trusted to deliver a fair verdict. They worry that filing a complaint might bring adverse consequences in their local community, alienate others, and make it harder to practice law going forward. However, based on my experience, there is no difference between Beijing and other regions: addressing issues squarely—focusing on the matter at hand rather than personal grievances and adhering to laws and regulations—tends to earn greater respect from both adversaries and peers. This approach yields positive outcomes, whether in shaping the trajectory of a case or in everyday professional interactions and relationships.
Conclusion
In criminal defense, there is no one-size-fits-all “magic bullet”; each attorney develops their own set of proven strategies, and perspectives naturally vary from person to person. That said, the following types of conduct, while perhaps yielding short-term results in certain circumstances, are areas I personally choose to avoid proactively, out of professional ethics and a commitment to long-term career development:
First, there is the issue of secret recording: it should be used with extreme caution and never made public. Whether in private meetings or during formal encounters with judicial officials, secret recordings ought to be approached with the utmost care and avoided whenever possible. Even if such recordings are made, their use should be strictly confined to private verification or, when necessary, self‑protection; once disclosed, they fundamentally undermine the very foundation of interpersonal trust. Once a lawyer is perceived as routinely resorting to this practice, it will breed widespread suspicion among the legal profession, discouraging open and candid professional communication.
Secondly, there is the investigation of personal background—intended as a warning, not a threat. For example, exerting pressure by scrutinizing the opposing party’s legal professionals for past professional shortcomings or misconduct is a high‑risk strategy. While such an approach may serve as a deterrent, prompting the other side to take your expert opinion more seriously, once made public it effectively corners them, leaving no room for negotiation—and thereby overlooks the powerful underlying factors at play in the case. Even if the judicial system removes the individual in question, the replacement may well follow the same course, effectively closing off any possibility of rational dialogue on the part of the lawyer.
Finally, there’s the stance of confrontation: avoid extremes and uphold professional dignity. Whether you start off with a highly confrontational tone—“blowing up” and glaring—or simply “nod and bow,” abandoning your principles—both of these extreme approaches are best avoided. The former will instantly spark unnecessary hostility, while the latter risks having your professional value dismissed.
The numerous acquittals and reduced‑sentence verdicts I have secured have all been the result of carefully tailored strategies. When necessary, we employ whatever methods are most effective, without rigidly adhering to a single approach. Our relationship with judicial authorities is not one of zero‑sum confrontation; rather, in pursuit of our clients’ defense objectives, we engage with prosecutors, police, and courts with high emotional intelligence, leaving room for mutual understanding and cooperation. By deeply embracing the principle that “helping others ultimately helps oneself,” we strive for win‑win outcomes and maximize our clients’ interests.
Attorney Profile
.
Zhao Yunheng
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Honorary Director
Doctor of Law from Peking University. Director of the Chinese Society of Criminal Procedure, Special Appointed Legal Supervisor for Detention Centers under the Ministry of Public Security, Part-time Master’s Supervisor at the School of Law, Peking University, Vice President of the Peking University Financial Alumni Association, Part-time Professor at the School of Law, China University of Political Science and Law, and Off-Campus Graduate Mentor at the School of Law, Beijing Foreign Studies University. Member of the Criminal Law Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association during its 8th and 9th terms; Deputy Director of the Corporate Compliance Law Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association during its 10th term; Legal Expert with the Beijing Municipal Commission of Planning and Natural Resources; and Member of the Corporate Compliance Working Committee of the All-China Federation of Enterprises.
His primary practice areas are criminal litigation and the prevention and response to corporate criminal legal crises. He has handled numerous high-profile criminal cases in China, with particular expertise in cases involving official misconduct and economic crimes. His bilingual Chinese–English book, “The Great Defense: My Story of Criminal Defense,” has been published both domestically and internationally. He pioneered the concept of “Great Defense,” skillfully employing broad thinking and a holistic perspective to transcend the confines of individual cases, leveraging comprehensive strategies in his advocacy. With extensive experience in litigating complex and challenging cases of official misconduct and economic crime, he demonstrates masterful application of legal techniques and excels at navigating intricate social and legal relationships.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12
