

Recently, In a case involving an enforcement judge suspected of abusing official authority in the execution of judgments and rulings, Attorney Wang Wanting of Beijing Starrise Law Firm collaborated with lawyers from another firm. Upon review by the Intermediate People’s Court of Dezhou City, Shandong Province, in its second instance, The first-instance judgment was overturned on the grounds of unclear facts and insufficient evidence, and the case was remanded for retrial. Attorney Wang Wanting became involved in this case at the review-and-prosecution stage, co‑representing the first defendant, Li, alongside her collaborating counsel, and consistently maintained a defense of not guilty. After more than two years of tireless efforts, the case has achieved a significant interim milestone, and Li and his family have begun to see renewed hope.



The first defendant in this case, Li, is an adjudicating judge assigned to the Enforcement Division of a certain court. The procuratorial organ alleges that, between 2020 and 2021, he colluded with Zhang, a court clerk (the second defendant), and Tian, a legal professional (Zhang’s wife, the third defendant), to abuse their official authority by failing to perform their statutory duties in enforcement proceedings, thereby involving sums exceeding RMB 5 million and causing total losses of more than RMB 1.47 million to the parties concerned.
The court of first instance found the aforementioned facts and, on the charge of abusing power in the execution of judgments and rulings, sentenced Li to two years and three months’ imprisonment, Zhang to two years and six months’ imprisonment, and Tian to one year and six months’ imprisonment, suspended for a period of two years. Dissatisfied with the verdict, Li maintained that he had committed no crime and filed an appeal.
Thoroughly review the case file and verify each piece of evidence item by item.
In April 2024, Attorney Wang Wanting and her co-counsel accepted the commission from Li and his family to mount a defense of not guilty on behalf of the first defendant, Li. Upon accepting the retainer, the defense counsel meticulously reviewed the case file, systematically collated and thoroughly analyzed each piece of evidence, and prepared a detailed review memorandum exceeding 100,000 characters. At the same time, the counsel traveled to Dezhou on more than thirty occasions to meet with the client, gaining an in-depth understanding of the court’s enforcement procedures and their salient features, and rigorously verified with the client each factual issue and any ambiguities or inconsistencies in the evidence.
Identified key points of doubt and facilitated the procurement of evidence.
Following extensive analysis and investigative work, the defense counsel has determined that, in both enforcement cases at issue, Li was neither the case-handling officer nor did he arrange for or instruct others to abuse their authority during the proceedings. The only direct evidence linking Li to a conspiracy with the other defendants is the testimony of the second defendant, which cannot be corroborated by any other objective evidence. Furthermore, the defense contends that another court official is suspected of serious criminal conduct; however, this individual has been questioned solely as a witness and has not been subject to formal investigation or prosecution. In addition, there remain uninvestigated and unverified leads suggesting potential criminal activity in this case.
In response to the gaps and inconsistencies in the prosecution’s evidence, the defense counsel actively sought to obtain additional evidence, successfully securing materials favorable to Li and obtaining synchronized audio‑video recordings of his interrogations. Faced with hundreds of hours of video footage, the defense counsel devoted considerable time to meticulously reviewing each segment and cross‑checking it against the corresponding interrogation transcripts line by line. Ultimately, they uncovered a critical lead: the second defendant’s statement identifying Li as an accomplice in their joint conspiracy was highly likely obtained by the investigative authorities through unlawful means. This significant breakthrough further strengthened the defense counsel’s resolve to pursue an acquittal.
The first-instance trial featured a thorough presentation of evidence and cross-examination, followed by the submission of a detailed defense brief.
During the first-instance trial, in addition to presenting thorough and compelling evidence, cross-examining witnesses, and engaging in vigorous courtroom arguments, the defense successfully secured the appearance of three key prosecution witnesses. Through precise questioning of these witnesses and of the second and third defendants, the defense effectively exposed numerous serious evidentiary deficiencies in the case, thereby achieving a favorable outcome.
After the hearing, the defense counsel submitted to the panel a defense brief totaling over 20,000 words and a set of evidentiary‑challenge submissions exceeding 30,000 words, comprehensively and thoroughly articulating an analysis of the factual findings and legal application in this case. The counsel also highlighted the case’s demonstrative impact on multiple levels and the significant societal implications that the court’s ruling may entail.
The first-instance judgment did not adopt the defense’s arguments, but a turning point finally emerged at the second-instance level.
Regrettably, after more than a year of protracted waiting, the court of first instance did not accept the defense’s plea of innocence and instead convicted Li of abuse of power in the execution of judgments and rulings, sentencing him to two years and three months’ imprisonment. Although Li was finally released from custody following the verdict and able to reunite with his family, the road to vindication remains long and arduous.
Following Li’s filing of an appeal, the defense counsel promptly contacted the appellate judge and clearly identified errors in the first-instance judgment regarding the admissibility of evidence, the findings of fact, and the application of law. However, despite the appellate court’s recognition that the case involves significant disputes and its intention to hold a hearing, the procuratorial organ obstructed the proceedings by refusing to permit access to the case file and failing to cooperate with efforts to obtain additional evidence.
Faced with mounting pressure and numerous challenges, the defense counsel steadfastly maintained a position of innocence, engaged in active communication with the collegial panel, and repeatedly articulated the defense’s arguments and supporting evidence. After more than six months of proceedings, the Intermediate People’s Court of Dezhou City ultimately ruled to overturn the original judgment and remand the case for retrial, on the grounds that “the facts are unclear and the evidence is insufficient.” After nearly three years of perseverance and hardship, Li and his family have finally glimpsed a glimmer of hope, and the defense counsel has likewise come to see the prospect of achieving fairness and justice.
During the course of representing this case, as the defense counsel delved deeper into the evidence and gained a fuller understanding of the facts, he came to appreciate all the more the arduous nature of judicial work—particularly enforcement—and to recognize with increasing clarity that Li was by no means the so‑called “criminal” who had abused his official authority. Rather, he is an enforcement judge who has worked tirelessly and conscientiously, diligently fulfilling his duties, carefully weighing the interests of all parties involved, and consistently safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of the parties concerned.
The defense counsel was deeply moved by Li’s unwavering commitment to the rule of law and his tireless pursuit thereof, and fully recognizes that the proper handling of this case carries social significance that extends far beyond the merits of the individual matter. This concerns not only the fate of Li, but also whether the legitimate rights and interests of countless enforcement judges and tenured judges can receive the legal protection they deserve. Moreover, it bears on whether the practical challenges confronting enforcement work can garner greater understanding and support, and whether the courts’ relevant institutional frameworks can be further refined as a result.
We look forward to the original trial court, in its retrial, conducting a thorough and objective examination of the facts of the case and rendering a fair judgment in accordance with the law, thereby restoring justice for Mr. Li. Attorney Xinglai will continue to provide robust legal defense for Mr. Li until justice is duly served.
Attorney Profile
.
Wang Wanting
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Lawyer
An attorney at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, holding a Bachelor of Laws degree from Peking University, his primary practice areas include criminal defense, corporate compliance, and criminal risk prevention. He is particularly adept at handling cases involving economic crimes and official misconduct, and is qualified as a mining rights appraiser. Since commencing practice, he has participated in the defense of numerous entrepreneurs and public officials at all levels in sectors such as mineral resources, construction engineering, and import‑export trade, thereby amassing extensive experience in criminal matters. The cases he has handled have yielded favorable outcomes, including decisions not to prosecute, acquittals, case dismissals, and reductions in sentencing.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Shen Xinyu


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Contact number: 027-82288828
Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Building E, Weilan Business Harbor, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916
Related News
2026-11-12
