CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

On November 2, the draft amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law was submitted for its first reading at the 25th Meeting of the Standing Committee of the 14th National People’s Congress. The draft comprises 55 articles organized into seven sections. As a frontline criminal defense lawyer, my overall assessment after reviewing it is as follows: protections for the right to defense have been substantially strengthened, with the tightening of restrictions on residential surveillance marking the most significant breakthrough; appeals and complaints now carry prescribed time limits for acceptance and require written responses; provisions concerning property protection largely codify existing practices, while leaving the issue of custodial management of enterprises involved in cases entirely unaddressed; moreover, the newly added Article 199, Paragraph 3, warrants close scrutiny.

  

One


 

Key highlights: Substantial progress has been made in the rights of defense, coercive measures, and procedural remedies.

(1) Right to Defense: Seven instances have been downgraded from “principles” to “procedures.”

This aspect deserves positive recognition, as the changes address issues that have long been bottlenecks in practice.

First, legal aid is extended from the trial stage to the review and prosecution stage (Article 35). If a criminal suspect faces a potential sentence of three years or more in prison and has not retained a defense attorney, the procuratorate may notify a legal aid agency to appoint counsel. Similarly, courts hearing cases under ordinary procedures may also appoint lawyers. This means that the longstanding issue of a lack of defense during the review-and-prosecution stage in serious criminal cases has, for the first time, received a direct response at the legislative level.

Second, it is clarified that on-duty lawyers have the right to learn about the case details, meet with the client, and review the case files (Article 36). In the past, on‑duty lawyers in guilty plea and penalty cases were often treated as mere “signing witnesses”; without access to the case file, they had no basis for judgment, and without judgment they could only comply. This time, at least the fundamental rights have been firmly established.

Third , Meetings are subject to a strict 48-hour time limit (Article 39). When a defense lawyer requests a meeting, the detention center shall ensure it takes place. No later than forty-eight hours to see detainees. The phrase “at the latest” is binding, which is far stronger than the previous vague wording “arrange promptly,” under which no accountability could be established.

Fourth, the obligation of relevant authorities to provide notice at different stages of the case and at key junctures is clarified (Articles 34, 88, 93, 175, and 176). Approval of arrest, referral for review and prosecution, extension of the detention period, return for supplementary investigation, and change of coercive measures, among others. In the past, such notifications relied on the conscientiousness of the investigating authorities; the timing was unclear and the methods inconsistent, leaving lawyers often able to do little more than call to inquire or rely on chance. By codifying these procedural milestones as mandatory obligations, effective defense can finally have a clear starting point.

Fifth, Review and approval of arrest should Interrogation of criminal suspects and consultation with defense counsel; review of the necessity of detention. should Conducted regularly; when the period of detention is about to exceed the possible sentence, should Release or modify coercive measures. (Articles 88, 95, and 98)

Sixth, The scope of audio and video recording during interrogations has been expanded to include cases that may result in a fixed-term imprisonment of three years or more. ; The exclusionary rule for illegally obtained evidence has been extended to Audiovisual materials, electronic data 。 (Articles 56 and 123)

Seventh, when a witness’s testimony undergoes a material change and becomes inconsistent over time, the witness shall appear in court. ; If a witness, having been duly notified, fails to appear in court and the authenticity of their pretrial testimony cannot be verified, such testimony may not be used as the basis for a verdict. The draft seeks to make the obligation to appear in court in certain circumstances legally binding. If this provision is actually enforced, it will provide a concrete basis for substantive courtroom proceedings. (Article 192)


 

    (2) Personal coercive measures: Detention at the place of residence represents the most significant breakthrough.

This amendment falls under Article 75 of the draft. The provision in the current law stating that “persons without a fixed residence may be placed under residential surveillance at a designated location” has been deleted, restoring the status of residential surveillance as an alternative measure to detention. Consequently, for criminal suspects and defendants without a fixed residence, public security organs will no longer designate a specific location for the execution of residential surveillance; instead, other compulsory measures shall be taken in accordance with the law.

“Without a fixed residence” “This loophole has been applied far too broadly in practice: even individuals who own property, have local household registration, and have families can be classified as ‘without a fixed residence’ and sent to facilities that fall outside the scope of detention center regulations. Designated residential locations are not considered places of detention, and lawyer visits require approval—over the past years, cases of torture during interrogation and incidents of unnatural deaths have all occurred within these spaces.”

It should be noted that the draft does not abolish residence permits; offenses endangering national security and terrorist activities remain subject to this measure. Following the reduction, How to prevent “using the pretext of endangering national security to impose de facto house arrest” , further efforts are needed to strengthen judicial interpretation and procuratorial oversight.


 

    (3) Appeals and complaints are subject to time limits and must receive written responses.

Article 49 of the draft adds a provision: Parties, defense counsel, and others have the right to directly file complaints or bring charges with the People’s Procuratorate regarding unlawful acts by judicial organs and their staff; the People’s Procuratorate may conduct investigations and verification and, in accordance with the law, put forward recommendations for correction. More importantly, specific time limits for accepting such appeals and complaints have been established, requiring a written response on the outcome within ten days of receipt.

Under the current law, Article 49 on obstructing lawyers’ exercise of litigation rights merely states that “a timely review shall be conducted, and if the allegations are substantiated, the relevant authorities shall be notified to make corrections.” However, “timely” does not specify a deadline, and “notification to correct” does not constitute a response; as a result, this right is effectively rendered inoperative in practice.

In 2012, a regulation issued by six government departments required a written response within ten days; however, as a normative document, it lacked sufficient legal authority, leading to inconsistent implementation across regions. If this requirement were now codified into law, accompanied by deadlines for processing and an obligation to provide a written response, its nature would fundamentally change: failure to respond within the prescribed period would itself constitute a new, identifiable administrative violation. We could then file further appeals or bring charges on that basis, bring the matter to the attention of procuratorial oversight bodies, or raise it during court proceedings as a procedural irregularity.


 

Two


 

Existing problems: One issue requires close attention—shortcomings in property rights remain pronounced.


 

(1) A new paragraph 3 has been added to Article 199, leaving unlimited discretion “outside the courtroom.”

Article 199 of the draft adds a new paragraph 3: “Outside the courtroom, anyone who disrupts the order of the people’s courts by gathering a crowd to make a disturbance or by insulting, defaming, threatening, or assaulting judicial personnel or parties to litigation shall be promptly stopped by judicial police; if the conduct constitutes a public security violation, administrative penalties shall be imposed; if it constitutes a crime, criminal liability shall be pursued.”


 


 

There are three issues:

First, space is boundless, “Outside the courthouse” and “the order of work of the people’s courts” are both undefined, allowing judicial police to extend their on-site authority beyond the courthouse walls;

Second, behavior knows no bounds, “and other means” serve as a catch-all provision, while “insulting or defaming” are subjective evaluative qualifiers. When lawyers publicly criticize procedural violations, and when the parties’ families or members of the public observing the proceedings raise legitimate, open questions about judicial injustice, such expressions can easily be lumped into this category, triggering a chilling effect.

Third, there is no remedy available through the procedure, The court alone determines, intervenes to stop, and decides the consequences; who defines “disruption”? The court. Who enforces the intervention? The court’s judicial police. To what extent is intervention permitted? There are no provisions on the principle of proportionality, no conditions for forcible removal, no limits on the use of police equipment, no requirements for official records, and no channels for reconsideration or appeal.

    

     (2) Property Involved in the Case: Incorporating current practices and norms into law does not necessarily represent progress in the system.

Articles 141 through 144 of the draft do indeed introduce numerous provisions regarding property: they require strict differentiation of property types, regulate the scope of measures that may be taken, and mandate that public security organs at the location of the property be notified when seizure, detention, or freezing is carried out in a different jurisdiction.

A new special chapter on the disposition of property involved in a case has been added. Article 258 provides that such property shall be kept in centralized custody and may be disposed of in advance; it may not be used for personal purposes, returned or returned in disguised form to the investigating authorities, or linked to the funding of investigative work. Public security organs and procuratorial organs shall submit specific recommendations for handling; courts shall conduct court investigations and debates on the factual evidence concerning the property involved; and after conviction and sentencing, the same adjudicating panel may continue to hear and dispose of the matter.

Overall, these provisions consolidate existing judicial interpretations and regulations while introducing some localized refinements, but they do not address the structural issues. “Prioritizing people over things” The longstanding problem persists: property proceedings remain subordinate to person‑based prosecution procedures; there is no independent action in rem, no separate adjudicative forum, and disputes over ownership are still overwhelmingly deferred until the enforcement stage.

Most importantly, two key issues remain unresolved:

1. The protection of property rights for third parties and interested parties remains severely inadequate.

Although the draft stipulates that when an interested party raises an objection, the public security organs, the procuratorate, and the people’s courts shall verify the matter, solicit opinions, and handle it in accordance with the law; if necessary, the court may notify the interested party to appear in court. However, “may” notify the court to appear is not “shall.” . Whether to appear in court is at the court’s discretion; furthermore, throughout the document, interested parties and their counsel are not granted the right to inspect the case file.

For a third party to claim that seized property belongs to them, they must first know on what grounds the investigating authority determined the property to be subject to seizure and which evidence was relied upon. If a third party retains counsel as their litigation representative but the lawyer is not allowed to inspect the case file, they cannot formulate objections grounded in factual evidence and must instead draft submissions based solely on the party’s statements, placing them at an inherent disadvantage. Granting only the right to participate while denying access to the case file significantly undermines the protection of property rights for interested parties.

2. The issue of custodianship for enterprises involved in the case was not addressed at all.

In practice, placing enterprises involved in cases under custodial management has become a frequently employed measure in cases involving organized crime and serious economic offenses. In nature, it amounts to a disguised form of coercive measure, exerting far greater interference than seizure, impoundment, or freezing of assets. The current legal basis consists solely of normative documents issued by the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, and two other ministries, with no binding provisions in higher-level laws.

This frequently occurs in practice, The case is still in the investigation and prosecution review stages; no trial has yet been held, and the court has not rendered any final judgment, yet trusteeship over the enterprises involved has already been initiated. Even if the company’s original legal representative and management team remain capable of running the business normally and are willing to operate in compliance, they are nonetheless subjected to a forced, comprehensive takeover. As a result, the company’s operational rights, control, and financial decision-making authority are all transferred to the custodial institution, effectively amounting to an early dispossession of the company’s operating interests. However, there are no legal rules governing the conditions for initiating receivership, the hearing procedures, the scope of receivership, the duration of receivership, the rights and obligations of the receiver, remedies for objections, oversight mechanisms, or avenues for damages.

I note that the draft adds Article 144-5, which explicitly provides: “With respect to seized or detained property involved in a case, including production and business assets such as factory buildings and machinery, provided that normal litigation proceedings are ensured, The relevant parties may be permitted to continue making reasonable use. , and take the necessary measures to preserve value and ensure safekeeping.”

In my view, from a legislative standpoint, this provision effectively negates the statutory basis for the “custody” of an enterprise’s operational assets in judicial practice. In accordance with the fundamental principle that public authority may not act unless expressly authorized by law, any so‑called “custody” that falls outside the scope of seizure, impoundment, freezing, or legally mandated preservation of value constitutes an unlawful expansion of power and lacks legal validity. However, “allowing continued use” is merely permissive, not mandatory; moreover, no retroactive corrective mechanism or compensation avenue exists for custody arrangements already implemented. The regulatory gap remains too wide.

(3) One step remains in the review of the necessity of detention.

Article 95 of the draft represents progress in reviewing the necessity of detention, stipulating that the People’s Procuratorate shall conduct periodic reviews of such necessity. It further provides that “opinions may be solicited from investigators, parties, defense counsel, and others”; however, how “periodic” review is to be carried out, who may initiate it, and what consequences arise from failure to initiate remain to be specified. Otherwise, the provision may still amount to a situation where regulations exist but accountability is lacking.

Three


 

A Few Suggestions on the Revised Draft

First, It is strongly recommended that the newly added Article 199, paragraph 3, be deleted.   Without leaving the open-ended discretion of “outside the court” . Where there is indeed violent obstruction, such matters should be handled under the Law on Public Security Administration Penalties, the Criminal Law, and the statutory duties of judicial police; there is no need to establish a separate set of rules without clear boundaries in the Criminal Procedure Law. This provision is highly likely to produce a chilling effect and severely suppress external oversight channels, The harm far outweighs the benefit.

Second, enshrine the right of third parties and interested parties to inspect case files. The third party’s counsel should have the right to inspect the case files regarding the basis for identifying the property involved and the evidentiary materials. If an interested party raises an objection and it is necessary for them to appear in court, It should be changed from “may notify” to “shall notify.” , at the very least, clearly define the circumstances under which a party must appear in court. If only the right to participate is granted without the right to inspect case files, it will be difficult for property-related objections to be supported by factual grounds.

Third, establish legal boundaries for the administration of enterprises involved in cases. 。 Clearly define escrow as a measure distinct from seizure, impoundment, and freezing; where escrow is indeed necessary, specify the triggering conditions, hearing procedures, scope of escrow, duration, rights and obligations of the escrow holder, remedies for objections, oversight mechanisms, and avenues for compensation for damages. For unlawful escrow that has already occurred, establish channels for correction and compensation. The phrase “may continue to be used” in Article 144‑5 should be further clarified as principled authorization, accompanied by rules ensuring preservation of value.

Fourth, strengthen the supporting rules for the residential surveillance exception and the review of the necessity of detention. For residential surveillance retained for crimes endangering national security and terrorist activities, judicial interpretations and procuratorial oversight must prevent the practice of “using the pretext of endangering national security to impose de facto residential surveillance”; the periodic review of the necessity of detention must clearly define the triggers for initiation, the methods of review, and the consequences of failing to conduct a review, and during such periodic reviews, The views of the parties and their counsel should be heard, rather than merely “may” be heard as stipulated in the current draft; the word “may” should be replaced with “shall.”

Conclusion

Amending the law is never achieved overnight. The draft takes a step forward on issues such as the right to defense and restrictions on residential surveillance, which deserves recognition; yet the legislation still leaves certain matters unresolved, reflecting a prudent approach. Such gaps do not amount to laissez-faire; controversial issues must ultimately be refined through practical application: non-negotiable red lines must be clear, and remedies must be effectively provided. Progress in the rule of law rarely occurs in a single stroke; rather, it requires that each advance be subject to scrutiny and capable of correction.  


 


 


 

Attorney Profile

.

Cheng Xiaolu

Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Chairman of the Partners’ Meeting

Director of the Criminal, Civil and Administrative Law Research Base at China University of Political Science and Law’s School of Criminal Justice and Xinglai Law Firm, and holds a Ph.D. in Law from Renmin University of China. Former senior partner at Deheng Law Firm in Beijing. Research fellow at the Institute of Legal Practice of Renmin University of China; member of the Criminal Law Committee of the 10th National Bar Association; special supervisory lawyer for detention centers under the Ministry of Public Security; deputy director of the Criminal Procedure Committee of the Beijing Lawyers Association; deputy director of the Professional Committee on Judicial Credibility of the Beijing Credit Society; adjunct practical mentor in criminal defense at Peking University, Renmin University of China, Shandong University, and other institutions; off-campus practice (practical) mentor for doctoral professional degree graduate students at China University of Political Science and Law; lawyer listed in the Beijing Lawyers Association’s talent pool for foreign-related legal work—covering transnational crime, fugitive apprehension and asset recovery, and international trade; and expert advisor to the Zhuhai Enterprise Compliance Promotion Association. Previously served for many years in the procuratorial organs of Beijing, where he was honored as an Outstanding Prosecutor of Beijing and one of the Top Ten Research Experts. He has published more than 50 professional articles in national-level journals such as the Chinese Journal of Criminal Law and the Journal of the National Procurators College, and his research achievements have received the First Prize in the National Competition for Applied Prosecutorial Theory Articles.


 

With over twenty-one years of extensive experience in criminal justice practice, he excels at defending and representing clients in major, complex, and challenging criminal cases. Leading his team, he has successfully handled a series of high-profile, impactful matters involving economic crimes, organized crime, official misconduct, and cases at the intersection of criminal and civil law. Renowned for his exceptional expertise and meticulous advocacy style, he has earned widespread acclaim from his clients. He also provides specialized criminal legal services to numerous central state-owned enterprises, listed companies, and private firms, achieving favorable outcomes.


 

Selected for Chambers’ “Greater China Legal Guide” in the Dispute Resolution category; listed on ALB China Law Awards’ “Dispute Resolution Lawyer of the Year” list; recognized by the Hurun Zhi Bang as a Highly Recommended Lawyer in Greater China for Commercial Crime and Criminal Defense, and awarded the “Outstanding Impact Award” under the Outstanding Legal Services Awards; featured on LEGALBAND’s Top Lawyers in China ranking in the White-Collar and Commercial Crime category; named to LegalOne’s list of Outstanding Legal Teams in China and among Client‑Trusted Lawyers; ranked among the Top 15 Female Lawyers in North China; and recipient of numerous other honors.


 

※ Source: WeChat official account of Beijing criminal lawyer specializing in corporate matters, Attorney Cheng

Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996

Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province

Contact number: 027-82288828
 

Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Block E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
 

Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916
 


 

Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license