CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

When handling criminal cases, whether lawyers should independently conduct investigations and gather evidence remains a matter of debate in practice. Some lawyers contend that such independent efforts entail professional risks, leading them to adopt a highly cautious or even abstentionist stance. Others argue that evidence obtained through independent investigation is unlikely to be admitted, and thus they do not advocate for it either.


However, based on our experience in handling cases, when the right to conduct independent investigations and gather evidence is exercised in strict compliance with professional standards, cases typically yield favorable outcomes, and professional risks can be effectively mitigated.


I. The Necessity of Lawyers Conducting Investigations and Gathering Evidence


The primary purpose of criminal investigation is to establish an evidence framework oriented toward conviction. Once a public security organ initiates a case, it signifies that sufficient evidence for conviction has already been gathered. Thereafter, the core objective of investigative activities is to further collect and refine the evidentiary basis for conviction; in this process, investigative authorities generally do not proactively seek out evidence favorable to the suspect.


In particularly extreme cases, in some proceedings, the investigating and prosecuting authorities may even choose to conceal evidence supporting acquittal or mitigation of culpability. For instance, in a corporate bribery case we handled, the alleged facts included that, in 1998, a certain group company transferred equity interests to a public official free of charge and subsequently bribed the official through dividend payments. In response to this allegation, the defendant submitted that, in fact, the public official had contributed a property as capital in exchange for the equity interest, and that the property was later used by the group company to offset a debt owed to an electric utility; the defendant also provided relevant leads for gathering corroborating evidence.


Based on leads provided by the parties, during both the investigation and the review‑for‑prosecution stages, we collected and submitted objective evidence, including the Debt‑Settlement Agreement, cadastral maps of the property, photographs of the premises, and payment receipts showing that the property’s water charges were paid in the name of the power supply station. At the same time, we obtained testimony from a firsthand witness—the public official’s sister. During this process, we discovered that she had been questioned five times by investigators from the supervisory commission; however, her interrogation transcripts were conspicuously absent from the case file. Subsequently, we submitted the “Notice of Interrogation” as part of the evidence and requested the production of the five missing transcripts that had not been transferred with the case. Regrettably, these pieces of evidence were neither admitted nor ultimately forwarded to the court. During the trial phase, our legal team once again presented the collected evidence to the collegial panel and again sought the production of the five untransferred interrogation transcripts. Following repeated advocacy, after the second court hearing, the procuratorial organ handed over to the court five volumes designated as “confidential files,” whose contents unequivocally corroborated the fact—long maintained by our team—that shares had been settled through the transfer of real estate. Had no investigative efforts been undertaken, it would have been exceedingly difficult to shake the judge’s internal conviction, and the true facts of the case might well have been buried along with those five confidential volumes.


After a case has progressed through the investigation and prosecution review stages and entered the court‑trial phase, the evidentiary framework established by the investigative authorities typically becomes more robust. At this juncture, relying solely on traditional methods of cross‑examination and argumentative advocacy proves insufficient to challenge the existing evidentiary structure, thereby hindering the full and effective exercise of the defense counsel’s rights. Consequently, to dismantle the evidentiary system constructed by the investigative authorities under a presumption‑of‑guilt mindset, one effective approach is for defense counsel to fully exercise their right to conduct investigations and gather evidence, thereby reconstructing the evidentiary framework.


II. The Validity of Lawyers’ Evidence-Gathering Activities


(1)


Determine the direction of evidence collection.


As previously noted, the purpose of a lawyer’s fact-finding and evidence‑gathering is to dismantle the existing evidentiary framework and reconstruct one that favors the client; evidence, after all, serves the logic of proof. Accordingly, to determine the direction of evidence collection, it is essential to first gain a thorough understanding of the investigative authorities’ logic of proof and then identify points of leverage for breakthrough.


During the review-and-prosecution and court‑trial stages, defense counsel can gain a comprehensive understanding of the evidentiary logic and the evidence framework by reviewing the case file. The challenge, however, lies in the investigation phase—particularly during the review and approval of arrest—when lawyers are effectively navigating in a fog: they lack access to the case file, and their communications with investigators are often confined to procedural matters, making it difficult to reach the heart of the case. At such junctures, the ability to reconstruct the truth through diverse information channels directly determines the precision of the evidence‑gathering strategy.


While handling a case involving an alleged illegal fundraising scheme by a short‑video entrepreneurship platform, we encountered challenges due to the company’s innovative business model and its complex structure, which encompassed the platform itself, agents, and end users—none of whom the family members fully understood. Meanwhile, the internet was already flooded with numerous negative articles and short videos related to the case. To prepare for our initial meeting, we conducted online research and compiled a checklist of questions to verify with the client. However, although the client was a shareholder, they were only responsible for a limited portion of the business; thus, a single meeting could not provide a comprehensive picture of the entire operation. Consequently, we conducted interviews with more than twenty individuals, including employees from various departments and agents, ultimately gaining a thorough and detailed understanding of the company’s business model and establishing a clear roadmap for subsequent evidence‑gathering efforts.


(2)


Uncover and gather evidence leads


In general, the primary method for obtaining investigative leads is to communicate with the parties involved. This requires that, during our meetings, we not only listen to the parties’ explanations of the case but also actively seek out evidence that can substantiate those explanations. Moreover, this process often entails multiple rounds of interviews, repeated verification, and ongoing refinement.


In addition, to uncover further investigative leads, we engage with anyone who has knowledge of the facts of the case. In the aforementioned case involving an online short‑video startup suspected of illegal fundraising, during interviews with company employees, we sought to identify additional evidence and, where appropriate, requested that employees produce relevant documentation. Ultimately, we submitted to the procuratorial authorities a comprehensive array of evidence, including the company’s promotional PPTs, operational data, business plans, and externally executed cooperation agreements. We also consolidated and systematically organized information gathered from the parties involved and the employees, providing prosecutors with a detailed account of the company’s business philosophy, operating model, and evolutionary trajectory. As a result, the charge was successfully reclassified from fundraising fraud to the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits.


(3)


Evidence Collection Content and Presentation Format


The work of a defense attorney primarily involves both presentation and persuasion. When collecting and submitting evidence, it is equally important to consider how best to present that evidence so that the opposing party can accurately grasp the message we seek to convey, thereby achieving a persuasive effect. Consequently, the manner in which evidence is presented will vary from case to case.


1

Objective evidence


In general, the primary methods for collecting objective evidence include applying for access to government information, requesting a re‑examination, recording video, obtaining documentary evidence from third parties, and retrieving WeChat chat records. In addition, when submitting such evidence, it is essential to clearly state its source to facilitate verification by case-handling personnel of its legality and authenticity, thereby ensuring the validity of the evidence-gathering process.


Among the objective evidence, the issue of re‑examination merits particular discussion. In economic crimes and offenses involving electronic data, expert opinions are playing an increasingly pivotal role. Defense counsel typically seek to request a re‑examination; however, such requests are seldom granted in practice, which to some extent underscores that expert opinions are often relied upon as the basis for reaching a verdict. Accordingly, we recommend that, where circumstances permit, counsel may independently engage an appraisal institution to conduct a re‑examination.


For example, in a homicide case handled by Attorney Zhao Yunheng, the central issue was the cause of the victim’s death. The forensic opinion commissioned by the investigative authorities concluded that “the fracture fragments of the hyoid bone were irregularly aligned and exhibited hemorrhaging, consistent with antemortem injury,” ultimately reaching the finding that “mechanical asphyxia due to strangulation cannot be ruled out.” In response to the conclusiveness of this expert opinion, Attorney Zhao Yunheng retained a second expert to conduct an independent assessment, which determined that the original report “could not exclude the possibility that the hyoid fracture resulted from physiological separation.” Ultimately, the court of first instance acquitted the defendant, finding that the evidence did not meet the standard of excluding reasonable doubt.


Moreover, expert assistance is even more critical when it comes to forensic opinions on electronic data. In a case involving alleged illegal gambling through a certain communication app that I once handled, the prosecution alleged that the app’s groups were predominantly gambling‑related, with chess and card games, and that the operators had failed to implement blocking measures. However, since the app did not retain group chat logs, establishing that these groups were primarily gambling‑oriented became one of the central points of contention. The prosecution’s key evidence was a forensic report on electronic data: it classified groups whose red‑envelope messages contained keywords such as “room,” “table,” “water,” “lose,” or “win,” and whose total red‑envelope transactions exceeded RMB 50,000, as “priority groups,” and on that basis estimated the number of participants involved in gambling and the amount of illicit funds circulating within those groups. To challenge the probative value of this forensic opinion, we commissioned an independent electronic‑data expert to conduct a re‑examination and submitted a formal expert opinion addressing the methods and standards employed by the prosecution in preparing its report. Ultimately, that forensic opinion was successfully discredited.


Accordingly, for highly specialized evidence, re‑expertise conducted with the assistance of experts is more direct and effective than merely subjecting the expert opinion to formal challenges.


2

Verbal evidence


When collecting testimonial evidence, we typically obtain it in the form of a “Lawyer’s Investigation Record.” The evidentiary process primarily involves two aspects: (1) further elaboration on the content of the interrogation record; and (2) procedural facts.


With respect to the first aspect, the primary purpose of gathering evidence is to challenge the probative value of the witnesses’ interrogation records. In handling a case involving smuggled human hair, the central issue was whether the smuggled hair qualified as “combed human hair.” If it did, the offense should be classified as smuggling ordinary goods; if not, it should be classified as smuggling waste. However, in numerous interrogation records collected by the public security authorities, the witnesses all testified that the smuggled hair was “combed human hair.” In fact, “combed human hair” is distinct from everyday usage and constitutes a legal concept, specifically referring to human hair in which the roots are aligned with the roots and the ends with the ends. Accordingly, when we re‑interviewed these witnesses, rather than asking them to directly retract their earlier statements, we built upon those statements by further probing: How do they understand the meaning of “combed human hair”? Did the public security authorities explain the concept of “combed human hair” to them during the initial questioning? And had the smuggled hair undergone the specific processing required to achieve the “root‑to‑root, end‑to‑end” alignment characteristic of “combed hair” (a term used in the industry)? During this process, the witnesses indicated that the hair‑products industry does not use the term “combed human hair”; they assumed that any hair brushed with a comb automatically met that standard. Yet, for smuggled hair to become “combed hair”—that is, to achieve the precise root‑to‑root, end‑to‑end alignment—additional processing at a manufacturing facility is necessary. Through the lawyer’s investigative efforts, the evidentiary weight of the previously collected witness statements was effectively undermined. Ultimately, after the case was remanded for reconsideration, the charge was successfully reclassified as smuggling waste, and the defendant’s sentence was accordingly reduced.


With respect to procedural facts, the primary strategy is to challenge the admissibility of interrogation records by demonstrating that investigators engaged in unlawful evidence‑gathering. For example, in a case involving organized crime, we obtained testimony from multiple witnesses and uncovered numerous instances of illegal investigative conduct during the process. Some witnesses reported being questioned twice; during the second interview, investigators explicitly stated that their superiors were dissatisfied with the content of the first record and instructed the witnesses to cooperate fully, warning that failure to do so would result in their being taken to the public security bureau. Under such pressure, the witnesses ultimately signed records that did not accurately reflect their true statements. Furthermore, some witnesses were illiterate, yet investigators failed to read the records aloud for verification, leading them to sign without fully understanding the contents. Crucially, substantial discrepancies existed between the information recorded in the interrogation transcripts and the witnesses’ actual accounts. Accordingly, we recommend that, in such evidentiary proceedings, in addition to documenting the procedural irregularities committed by investigators, it is also essential to record the factual circumstances as understood by the witnesses themselves. Finally, we compiled dozens of witness statements, categorized them according to the specific unlawful acts of the investigators, and submitted them to the court, urging the tribunal to accord particular attention to the issue of evidentiary legality.

Author Biography

.

Li Kexuan

Beijing Starrise Law Firm

Lawyer


An attorney at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, holding a Bachelor of Laws degree from East China University of Political Science and Law and a Master of Laws degree from Southwest University of Political Science and Law. In 2024, he was named among the Top 30 Rising Stars in China’s legal profession by LEGALBAND. He has conducted in-depth research and accumulated substantial practical experience in areas such as corporate criminal compliance management, crime prevention, and the identification, mitigation, and response to corporate criminal legal risks. He has participated in numerous criminal defense cases involving corporations and entrepreneurs, covering such criminal fields as commercial bribery, economic crimes, financial and securities offenses, intellectual property crimes, tax offenses, and environmental crimes.


Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building



Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province



Layout: Wang Xin

Reviewed by: Management Committee

Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license