
Since the real estate market entered a downturn, many developers have run into severe operational difficulties, leading to project stoppages and delays in property delivery. Even though buyers have signed purchase contracts and paid part of the purchase price, the properties either remain undelivered or have yet to obtain property ownership certificates. At this point, if it is discovered that the developer is facing financial distress and has been sued by creditors or construction contractors, the question arises: Could a home for which full payment has already been made be subject to seizure? Might it be seized to satisfy the developer’s debts? This article provides a professional analysis of these issues.
Given that in practice there may be various complex scenarios—such as projects left unfinished, developers’ bankruptcy, or debt-for‑property settlements—the article will analyze these situations separately and will be published in a multi‑part series.
1. Basic Principle of Priority of Rights
Based on the principle of protecting homebuyers’ right of residence, when a developer incurs other debts, the Supreme People’s Court’s judicial interpretation grants homebuyers who meet certain conditions a priority right: their real property rights in the purchased housing shall remain unaffected by the developer’s other liabilities.

Common liabilities of developers include unpaid construction payments, financial borrowings, intercompany or private loans, and other debts arising from business operations. In general, The priority of claims against the developer is as follows: construction project payment lien > mortgage right (subject to registration) > ordinary creditor’s rights. Meanwhile, the status of homebuyers’ rights within this priority-ranking system is as follows:
(1) Priority Rights of Ordinary Homebuyers
Article 29 of the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by People’s Courts of Cases Involving Objections to and Reviews of Enforcement stipulates that, in the enforcement of monetary claims, if a purchaser raises an objection to a commercial residential property registered under the name of the real estate development enterprise subject to enforcement, and the objection meets the following conditions and the purchaser’s rights are sufficient to preclude enforcement, the people’s court shall uphold the objection: (1) A lawful and valid written sales contract was entered into prior to the seizure by the people’s court; (2) The purchased residential property is intended for residential use and the purchaser does not own any other residential property; (3) The price paid exceeds fifty percent of the total contract price.
This provision further clarifies. A purchaser who meets the aforementioned conditions is entitled to file an objection to enforcement with respect to the commercial housing it has purchased, thereby seeking to exclude such enforcement; in other words, it may enjoy priority over ordinary creditors’ claims, but remains subordinate to the priority rights of construction‑project payments and mortgage rights.
(2) The Super-Priority Right of Consumers of Commodity Housing
Article 2 of the Supreme People’s Court’s Reply on the Protection of Rights and Interests of Consumers Purchasing Commodity Housing (Fa Shi [2023] No. 1) provides that if a consumer purchasing commodity housing for residential purposes has paid the full purchase price and asserts that their right to demand delivery of the property should take priority over the priority right to payment for construction project costs, mortgage rights, and other creditors’ claims, the people’s court shall uphold such claim. Where a consumer has paid only part of the purchase price but, prior to the conclusion of the first-instance court debate, has actually paid the remaining balance, the provisions of the preceding paragraph shall apply. This provision establishes a “super-priority” for consumers of commodity housing, namely: A purchaser who meets the aforementioned conditions not only has the right to exclude third-party enforcement against the property and to demand the return of the purchase price, but also enjoys priority over construction‑payment claims and mortgage liens.

2. Judicial Definition of Core Concepts
The aforementioned provisions introduce several concepts: “consumers of commercial housing,” “for the purpose of residential use,” “where the price paid exceeds fifty percent of the total contract price,” and “where the full purchase price has been paid.” In light of relevant judicial interpretations and case law, these concepts are understood as follows:

(1) Consumers of Commodity Housing
From the perspective of legal capacity, the status of a consumer should be defined as Natural person . Legal persons and other organizations are generally not included within the scope of consumers. The rationale is that the homebuyer’s super‑priority right is a special provision designed to protect the homebuyer’s right to subsistence and should not be arbitrarily extended in its application.
(2) More than half of the payment has been made.
According to Article 125 of the “Minutes of the National Courts’ Conference on Civil and Commercial Trial Work,” where “the price already paid exceeds fifty percent of the total contract price,” if the consumer purchasing a commercial residential property has paid an amount… Close to fifty percent Moreover, where the remaining purchase price has been paid to the applicant for enforcement in accordance with the contract, or has been remitted for enforcement as required by the people’s court, this may be construed as being consistent with the spirit of the relevant provision.
(3) For residential purposes
For the purpose of residence, it means that the purchase of a home is directly intended to meet one’s living and housing needs, rather than for business or investment purposes. Therefore, Non-residential properties such as shops and commercial premises are not applicable. Situations “for the purpose of residence.”
(4) Understanding of “no other housing”
According to Article 125 of the Minutes of the National Courts’ Conference on Civil and Commercial Trial Work, where the buyer does not own any other residential property, it may be construed that, within the same prefecture-level or county-level city as the property at issue, the consumer of commercial housing does not possess any residential property. Even if the consumer already owns one residential unit, if the newly purchased property, in terms of area, still suffices to meet basic housing needs, the same determination may likewise be made.
In case No. (2023) Liao 04 Min Zhong 72, the court held that the term “buyer” should be interpreted broadly, encompassing not only the buyer himself or herself but also the spouse who is subject to the regime of joint marital property and any minor children. As long as one of these three parties owns a residence, it may be deemed that residential housing already exists.
Thus, it can be seen that the so‑called “no other housing” should refer to… The entire household does not own any other housing within the same city, or the existing housing fails to meet the household’s basic living needs. 。
(5) Reference for Parking Space Usage
Although the Supreme People’s Court’s Reply on the Protection of Rights and Interests of Commodity Housing Consumers stipulates that the subject of super-priority is the commodity housing purchased by consumer‑buyers, judicial practice has encountered situations where… Parking spaces are equally applicable. The relevant precedent.
For example, in the Supreme People’s Court case No. (2022) Sup. Ct. Min. Zhong No. 86, the Supreme Court held that the parking space purchased together with the residential unit constitutes an essential ancillary facility for the purchaser’s daily life and has been used continuously since its acquisition to park vehicles. Accordingly, the parking space may be deemed to possess the attribute of a necessary residential right that is specially protected under Article 29 of the Supreme People’s Court’s Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by People’s Courts of Cases Involving Objections to and Reviews of Enforcement Measures.
(6) Reference applicability for mixed-use commercial-residential properties
In case No. (2023) Hu 7101 Min Chu 148, the court held that, where a commercial‑residential property is designated for office use but in practice also serves a residential function, a comprehensive determination should be made based on the actual circumstances, taking into account whether the building’s design itself meets the requirements of everyday living, as well as prevailing transaction practices and common sense. Accordingly, if… A commercial-residential property is actually used for residential purposes. Yes, there is still room for special protection.
(7) Debt-for-property settlement does not constitute a purpose of residence.
In Case No. Xiang 1202 Zhi Yi 54 (2023), the court held that, since the transferee under a debt‑for‑property agreement executed the relevant house purchase contract for the purpose of settling the debt rather than for residential use, such transferee is not entitled to the super‑priority right afforded to consumers of commercial housing.
(8) A transfer with a guarantee does not constitute an arrangement for residential purposes.
In Case No. (2020) Sup. Ct. Min Shen 5847, the Supreme People’s Court held that the true intention of the judgment debtor and the third party in the house sale was not to transfer ownership of the property; rather, the sale was fictitious, with a non‑typical security arrangement—namely, a transfer‑of‑ownership‑as‑security—being the actual purpose. Accordingly, the purchaser was not a bona fide buyer and did not qualify as a consumer‑buyer, and thus was not entitled to the super‑priority rights accorded to consumers of commercial housing.
Author Biography
.
Zhang Bingxu
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Lawyer
Bachelor of Laws from the School of Law, Tsinghua University; Master of Laws from Washington University in St. Louis. Previously worked at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing.
Business Areas:
The firm boasts extensive legal expertise in civil and commercial dispute resolution and real estate investment and financing. Its practice spans a wide array of matters, including investment‑financing disputes, corporate governance, residential property sales, construction projects, and property management services. Additionally, the firm has provided specialized legal advisory services for outbound investments undertaken by numerous leading domestic real estate and insurance‑investment enterprises.
.
Han Meijun
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University; Master of Civil Procedure Law from Tsinghua University. Previously worked at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing and, in 2025, was awarded the “Rising Star Lawyer Award” at the 10th Guike Annual Conference.
With over seven years of experience in civil and commercial dispute resolution, he has represented clients in dozens of complex, high‑profile litigation and arbitration matters. The disputes he has handled encompass a wide range of issues, including equity transfer disputes, earn‑out agreement disputes, private equity and trust contract disputes, guarantee contract disputes, private lending disputes, challenges to the validity of corporate resolutions, and trade secret infringement disputes. These cases have been heard before such judicial bodies as the Supreme People’s Court, the higher people’s courts across China, the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission, and the Beijing Arbitration Commission. He excels at crafting comprehensive, systematic dispute‑resolution strategies for his clients—spanning front‑end transaction‑risk assessments and the design of commercial negotiation frameworks, through pre‑litigation evidence‑chain consolidation and preservation‑measure planning, to courtroom advocacy and enforcement‑driven recovery. By providing end‑to‑end, one‑stop services, he helps clients stand out in intricate legal disputes and achieve a seamless alignment between their business objectives and legal interests.
In addition to civil and commercial disputes, the firm also focuses on the cultural and entertainment sectors, specializing in music‑related and film‑and‑television investment disputes. With extensive experience in compliance and crisis communications, it provides end-to-end risk management and rights‑protection solutions for leading platforms, talent agencies, and public figures.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12

