
Attorney Wang Jun, director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, was invited to attend the event and delivered a speech on the topic “Exploring the Path of Challenging Fund‑Analysis Expert Opinions Through the Lens of Accounting and Electronic Data Forensic Examination.” Attorney Wang Jun conducted an in-depth analysis of fund‑analysis expert opinions, which simultaneously exhibit the characteristics of both accounting expertise and electronic‑data forensics, highlighting three key features. He further elaborated on strategies for challenging such evidence from multiple angles—including the legality of the commissioning procedure, the integrity of electronic‑data linkages, and the reasoning underlying the accounting analysis—thereby providing criminal defense counsel with clear guidance and practical methods for effectively conducting evidentiary challenges in the era of “fund analysis as evidence.”

Wang Jun Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Today, my presentation is titled “Employing the Analytical Frameworks of Accounting and Digital Forensics to Explore Paths for Challenging and Verifying Financial Analysis Opinions.” I have been practicing criminal defense for over a decade, and in recent years I have also studied Professor Liu Pinxin’s approach to handling cases involving digital evidence, gaining valuable insights along the way. I would like to take this opportunity to share these reflections with you.
I will elaborate from three perspectives, covering a total of nine key points.
The Necessity of Having a Financial Analysis and Expert Opinion
First, I contend that financial analysis and forensic opinions—comprising both expert reports and examination findings—exhibit characteristics of both accounting expertise and electronic data forensics. On this basis, The necessity of the fund‑analysis appraisal opinion is primarily reflected in the following three aspects.
First, the computational power of traditional accounting appraisal is no longer sufficient. Today, we live in an era of massive electronic data, and the traditional manual methods of accounting calculation and auditing can no longer keep pace with the times. Moreover, the conclusions reached by accounting and auditing examinations often remain confined to superficial aspects such as monetary amounts, transaction flows, and the identities of those involved. However, penetrating these surface-level details to uncover the underlying truth—tracing the ultimate destination and ownership of funds—lies beyond the capabilities of conventional accounting expertise.
Second, financial data possess the form of electronic evidence and are subject to specific evidentiary requirements. Financial data are predominantly in electronic form—such as bank statements and transfer records—and are therefore presented as digital evidence. The collection and authentication of such electronic data are subject to specific requirements, as set forth in documents like the “Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Collection, Extraction, and Examination and Adjudication of Electronic Data in Criminal Cases” issued jointly by the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, and the Ministry of Public Security. Failure to comply with these regulations may directly undermine the authenticity of the data and the admissibility of related evidence and expert opinions. Precisely because of these unique characteristics, it is necessary to establish electronic data examination as a distinct category of forensic expertise.
Third, the need for evidence conversion by public security organs. Financial analysis and forensic examination can trace the flow of funds to reveal underlying interpersonal relationships. Take pyramid‑scheme cases as an example: funds move from one person to another, often passing through several layers, a pattern closely tied to the scheme’s hierarchical structure and headcount. The ultimate goal of mapping fund flows and identifying related individuals is not merely to quantify numbers or sums; more importantly, it is to uncover the behavioral patterns behind the scheme and to identify all persons involved. When public security authorities initiate a case, they may initially have only one or two suspects; however, by applying a methodology that uses financial data to trace fund movements and link them to specific individuals, all participants can be brought to light and brought within the scope of prosecution. Without bringing such behind‑the‑scenes investigative work into the open, it cannot serve as a basis for pursuing other implicated parties.
Characteristics of Financial Analysis and Expert Opinions
1. Financial analysis is a tool, not an end in itself.
Financial analysis is merely a tool. As noted above, its fundamental purpose is to investigate and establish the modus operandi of criminal activities, identify the individuals involved, and clarify the relationships among them.
2. Prioritization of the role of expert opinions
In the past, traditional forensic opinions typically came into play at the later stages of an investigation. For example, once police investigations had progressed to a certain point and needed to determine issues such as the nature of injuries or the extent of losses, they would commission expert assessments to evaluate the consequences of the criminal conduct. By contrast, financial‑analysis forensic examinations are now increasingly conducted earlier—often during the preliminary investigative phase, even before a case is formally filed—to provide leads and support the investigation. Moreover, the forensic examination process may overlap with and proceed in tandem with the investigative process.
3. The process of financial analysis and appraisal is dynamic.
Fund‑flow analysis and forensic examination is an iterative process of trial and error and verification. Taking pyramid‑scheme cases as an example, in the past, accounting‑based forensic assessments might have been limited to determining the total amount of funds and the number of participants. Today, however, fund‑flow analysis serves as a tool to support investigative efforts: once the flow of funds is traced to a specific individual, the public security authorities will investigate and verify whether that person is suspected of involvement. If no suspicion arises, the line of inquiry is abandoned; if suspicion does exist, the investigation proceeds along that same track. The “Regulations on Procedures for Fund‑Flow Analysis and Forensic Examination by Public Security Organs (Trial Implementation)” explicitly stipulates that parties must be notified when a forensic opinion is used as evidence. However, not all fund‑flow analysis opinions ultimately serve as evidence: only those deemed valid are admitted as evidence, while invalid ones are excluded.
Review Pathway for Financial Analysis and Expert Opinions
Because the categories of forensic expertise are limited to forensic medicine, physical evidence examination, audio‑visual materials analysis, and environmental damage assessment, while financial‑analysis expertise currently cannot be readily classified as either forensic or industry‑specific, it does not necessarily fall fully within the scope of the General Provisions on Forensic Examination Procedures. Nevertheless, according to the Regulations, financial‑analysis expertise shares the same procedural requirements as those set forth in the General Provisions—namely, with respect to commissioning formalities, sample‑submission criteria, signatures of the expert, and institutional seals. In addition to drawing on the established review frameworks applicable to existing forensic‑expertise categories, given that opinions in financial‑analysis expertise combine features of both accounting appraisal and electronic‑data examination, it may be worthwhile to explore avenues for challenging such opinions by applying the review methodologies traditionally employed in accounting and electronic‑data appraisal.
1. From the perspective of forensic accounting review, does the fund analysis method possess scientific validity?
Scientific rigor encompasses both normativity and verifiability. In terms of normativity, although court rules clearly outline procedures for extracting, cleansing, and validating financial data, the expert opinion merely presents a written workflow, leaving us lawyers unable to conduct a substantive review of the testing methods. Moreover, determining how to carry out such a review lies beyond our capabilities. At present, when conducting financial analysis on massive datasets, human resources are limited; in addition to leveraging big data, we also rely on algorithms and models. However, terms like “algorithm” and “model” make us particularly cautious, as the proliferation of artificial‑intelligence software and products in recent years has sparked considerable controversy and criticism. Take AI algorithms as an example: the underlying principles are often highly complex, and even the engineers who design them may not be able to articulate with clarity the specific mechanisms at play during actual operation. Furthermore, when an AI system arrives at a particular conclusion, its scientific soundness and reasonableness cannot be guaranteed with absolute certainty. For instance, in one case, the expert set a threshold of 0.2 as a parameter and used it to filter other data. When asked about the origin of this parameter and the calculation method, the expert replied that he had no practical experience and simply considered 0.2 to be reasonable. Thus, the entire process resembles a series of hypotheses and inferences, yet its reliability and its ability to withstand scrutiny and verification remain highly questionable.
2. Examining the Issue of Data Sources from the Perspective of Analytical Reasoning in Electronic Data Forensics
The Regulations stipulate that public security organs may conduct forensic analysis and identification of financial data, and that the Commission for Discipline Inspection, the procuratorate, and the courts may also commission such examinations when necessary. The prerequisite for this type of commissioned appraisal is that the procuratorate, the court, or the Commission for Discipline Inspection has already obtained the electronic evidence relevant to the case; only then can they entrust an internal forensic institution within the public security system to carry out the examination—this arrangement poses no issue. In practice, it is understood that the Ministry of Public Security has established a “Platform for Tracing and Controlling Funds Involved in Illegal and Criminal Activities,” which is linked to the databases of various financial institutions, thereby facilitating investigations and case handling by the police. For example, when a sum of money is deposited into a bank account under Zhang San’s name, conventional accounting‑based assessments often stop there, concluding that Zhang San is the recipient. However, by leveraging big‑data analytics, investigators can penetrate this surface level and uncover multiple subsequent fund transfers between that account and another account registered under Li Si’s real name. Once such linkages crystallize into a stable pattern, it becomes compelling evidence that Zhang San’s account is, in fact, controlled by Li Si—and that even upstream funds ultimately converge on Li Si’s account. This, then, underscores the critical importance of big‑data analysis of fund‑transfer records: it no longer confines itself to the relationship between the recipient and the funds themselves, but instead enables investigators to unravel the intricate web of connections underlying those transactions.
This clearly underscores the importance of the illicit‑funds tracing and control platform: on the one hand, it can pinpoint the ultimate destination of funds; on the other, during investigations, public security authorities can seamlessly upload their collected data to the platform for cross‑checking, thereby facilitating case handling and intelligence gathering. A related question is this: if the supervisory commission, the procuratorate, or the courts need to rely on this “illicit‑funds tracing and control platform” when commissioning forensic examinations, how should the procedural interfaces be coordinated? And how can the issue of the legality of data sources be resolved?
3. Gain a moderate understanding of the thought processes involved in handling cases involving electronic evidence, and leverage the expertise of expert witnesses.
As previously noted, artificial intelligence also faces numerous challenges, including algorithmic bias, hallucinations, and a lack of transparency—issues that often lie beyond the scope of lawyers’ expertise. In such cases, lawyers typically turn to experts for assistance. However, engaging experts in turn presents its own set of difficulties.
First is the issue of expert qualification accreditation. At present, experts in the field lack formal qualifications as forensic data analysts, and the criteria for court‑recognized expert witnesses remain unclear. A few years ago, while handling a case involving the infringement of citizens’ personal information, I sought out an expert who had served in communications‑security roles at the G20 Communications Summit and received numerous national honors to act as a witness. I submitted this expert’s certificates of recognition to the court, but they were not accepted; the court insisted that experts must hold forensic‑expert credentials. However, the law does not explicitly require such credentials, and this requirement is largely a matter of individual judicial discretion. This stipulation could impede our ability to engage qualified expert witnesses.
Secondly, there is the issue of selecting the type of expert. Although lawyers may not be technically proficient, they must understand the mindset underlying the handling of technical or electronic evidence in legal proceedings. They need to know which issues can be referred to experts and in which areas experts can provide expert testimony, verification, or technical analysis; only then can they match cases with the appropriate specialists. Otherwise, for instance, if they lack even a basic grasp of such fundamental matters as whether ink‑and‑seal handwriting analysis can determine the time of writing or how it differs from the identification of the sequence of ink and seal impressions, their work will be difficult to carry out.
Finally, there is the question of how experts can play their role. Take the retrieval of evidentiary materials as an example: the law does not explicitly delineate lawyers’ rights in this regard, yet such materials are indispensable to expert opinions. Based on my successful experience in obtaining these materials during litigation, a lawyer can only secure their production if they raise sufficiently compelling challenges to the expert opinion—persuading the judge that, although retrieving the materials may increase the judge’s workload, it could nonetheless affect the conclusions of the expert report. Otherwise, the judge is unlikely to grant permission, and the expert will have little opportunity to contribute meaningfully.
Author Biography
.
Wang Jun
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Founding Partner
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, Director of the Management Committee, and founding partner; holds undergraduate and master’s degrees from Huazhong University of Science and Technology. Member of the Criminal Procedure Law Specialized Committee and the Women Lawyers’ Working Committee of the 12th Beijing Lawyers Association; contracted author for Peking University Law Information Network; senior researcher at the Southern Finance Legal Research Institute; and public‑interest ambassador against telecom and online fraud. Has published numerous professional articles in leading journals such as People’s Procuratorate and China Lawyers. A dual‑certified lawyer—Data Protection Officer (DPO) with the International Information Science Examination Institute (EXIN) and Data Protection Officer under China’s Personal Information Protection Law (DPOPIPL)—and an SGS‑certified internal auditor for ISO/IEC 42001:2023 Artificial Intelligence Management Systems.
He has successfully defended numerous criminal cases resulting in acquittals and possesses extensive practical experience in handling criminal–civil intersection cases and defending against property‑related penalties. He is particularly adept at representing clients in matters involving official misconduct, economic crimes, and cybercrime, with a wealth of hands‑on expertise, especially in the examination and analysis of electronic evidence.
Honors and Awards:
Fiscal Year 2025
Shortlisted for the ALB Legal Awards’ “NARA Annual Managing Partner Award”
LEGALBAND Client Choice: Top 15 Female Lawyers in China
Top 40 Chinese Legal Talents of GCP
GRCD China’s Lawyer of the Year (Female)
Fiscal Year 2024
Law New Agency’s Annual Power List: “Top 100 Outstanding Partners of the Year 2024”
China Business Law Journal “The A-List Legal Elite” award has once again recognized [the entity] as a “The Visionaries” leader.
The “Annual Managing Partner” award at the Guike Annual Conference.
LexisNexis 2024 “Under 40 Elite” Greater China List
LEGALBAND Client Choice “Top 15 Rising Partners List”
Fiscal Year 2023
China Business Law Journal “The A-List Legal Elite” award has selected [name] as a “The Visionaries” leader.
The 8th Guike Annual Conference “A Breath of Fresh Air – Most Promising Growth Award”
Fiscal Year 2021
Awarded the “Gold Medal Lawyer” in the criminal defense category at the 21st Century Southern Financial and Legal Research Institute’s Gold Medal Lawyer Selection.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12
