
If a housing project has been abandoned, the buyer’s primary concern is no longer whether they can retain the property they purchased, but rather whether they can terminate the purchase contract and recover their payments. At this stage, since the developer may also owe outstanding payments for construction costs, financing, and other liabilities, it becomes necessary to determine whether the buyer’s claim for the return of principal should be accorded priority in the overall debt‑repayment process.
1. Basic Principle
Article 3 of the Supreme People’s Court’s Reply on the Protection of Rights and Interests of Consumers of Commodity Housing (Fa Shi [2023] No. 1) provides that, where a house cannot be delivered and there is no realistic possibility of delivery, if a consumer of commodity housing asserts that its right to claim a refund of the purchase price should take priority over the priority right to payment for construction project costs, mortgage rights, and other creditors’ claims, the people’s court shall uphold such claim.
Article 12 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on the Application of Law in Adjudicating Cases Involving Objections to Enforcement further provides that, where an enforcement court has frozen the escrow account for pre-sale funds of a real estate development enterprise, if a third party, on the ground that it has already paid the purchase price into that account and that the house sale contract has been terminated, brings an action objecting to the enforcement and requests that the corresponding purchase‑price funds be excluded from compulsory execution and disbursed to it, the people’s court shall grant such request if the grounds are established.
Where the executing court enforces, by way of compulsory execution, the buildings of a real estate development enterprise and the land-use rights for the construction land occupied by such buildings, and where, pursuant to items (1) and (3) of paragraph 1 of the preceding article, a consumer purchaser of commercial housing—whose property cannot be delivered and whose failure to deliver may result in the termination of the house sale contract—files an objection to enforcement seeking to exclude the corresponding portion of the proceeds from the sale of the buildings and the associated land-use rights, and requests that such proceeds be disbursed directly to that purchaser, the people’s court shall grant such request.
Accordingly, if the homebuyer seeks to rescind the contract, their right to a refund of the purchase price may also enjoy priority. It should be noted that, The scope of the priority right to claim the return of the purchase price should be limited to the principal amount of the housing payment already made. , excluding other charges such as funds‑occupation fees or liquidated damages.
2. Core Premise – Criteria for Determining Non-Deliverability
According to the aforementioned provisions, the core prerequisite for a homebuyer’s request that the developer prioritize refunding the purchase price is “ The property cannot be delivered and there is no realistic possibility of delivery. “In practice, proving that a house has not been delivered is relatively straightforward: a consumer of commercial housing need only demonstrate that the developer failed to deliver the property on the date specified in the sales contract. By contrast, establishing that ‘there is no possibility of actual delivery’ is considerably more challenging and requires a higher standard of proof.”
When courts render a similar determination of “inability to deliver,” common considerations include: prolonged non‑delivery (typically involving delays of several years); the project showing no signs of resuming construction; the developer adopting a dismissive or evasive stance; the developer having entered bankruptcy or pre‑reorganization proceedings; the property having been placed under judicial enforcement; the project being beyond the possibility of further construction; and the property remaining unable to obtain ownership registration for an extended period. However, if a real estate project is still under construction but merely progressing slowly, claims by purchasers seeking refunds of their purchase price along with priority rights are generally unlikely to be upheld by the court.
3. The Implementation Path for the Priority Right to Recover Housing Purchase Payments
(1) Claims of Rights During the Litigation Phase
When a homebuyer files a lawsuit to rescind the contract and recover the purchase price, they may… The synchronization requirement confirms the priority of the right to claim a refund of the purchase price. With respect to the priority right of payment for construction project costs, mortgage rights, and other creditor’s rights. Of course, homebuyers may also file two separate lawsuits: first seeking contract rescission, and then, in subsequent proceedings, requesting a determination that the purchase price should be repaid with priority.
For example, in case No. (2024) Xin 01 Min Zhong 3233, the homebuyer filed a lawsuit seeking to rescind the contract, arguing that the property had not been completed and that the developer had engaged in pre‑sale activities… On the basis of this reasoning, the same case sought to have the priority of repayment of the purchase price confirmed. By contrast, in case No. (2023) Hu 03 Min Zhong 39, the homebuyer first brought an action seeking rescission of the house purchase contract and subsequently—within the bankruptcy proceedings—filed another suit to have its rights recognized as having priority.
Both of the aforementioned avenues were upheld by the court; of course, resolving the matter through a single lawsuit is undoubtedly more economical and convenient.
(2) Remedies for Rights in the Enforcement Phase
Execution Objection Procedure Article 28 of the Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by People’s Courts of Cases Involving Objections to and Reviews of Enforcement stipulates that consumers of commercial housing may file an objection to enforcement. In case No. (2024) Ji 0211 Zhi Yi 156, after the property in question had been subject to enforcement measures in another case, the purchaser, as a third party, filed an objection to enforcement, and the court ultimately recognized the purchaser’s priority right.
Procedure for Actions to Challenge Enforcement Article 12, paragraph 2 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on the Application of Law in Adjudicating Cases Involving Objections to Enforcement provides that, where a consumer of commercial housing is unable to take delivery of the property and such failure may result in the termination of the contract, the consumer may, in an action challenging enforcement, seek to exclude the property from compulsory execution and obtain priority in repayment.
Accordingly, even if a purchaser of commercial housing does not seek to have priority for the return of the purchase price when filing a lawsuit seeking contract rescission, such purchaser may still raise an objection in the enforcement proceedings or bring an action challenging the enforcement, requesting that the corresponding portion of the proceeds from the sale be excluded from execution and given priority in satisfaction.
Author Biography
.
Zhang Bingxu
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Lawyer
Bachelor of Laws from the School of Law, Tsinghua University; Master of Laws from Washington University in St. Louis. Previously worked at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing.
Business Areas:
The firm boasts extensive legal expertise in civil and commercial dispute resolution and real estate investment and financing. Its practice spans a wide array of matters, including investment‑financing disputes, corporate governance, residential property sales, construction projects, and property management services. Additionally, the firm has provided specialized legal advisory services for outbound investments undertaken by several leading domestic real estate developers and insurance‑investment institutions.
.
Han Meijun
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University and Master of Civil Procedure Law from Tsinghua University. Previously worked at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing, and in 2025 was awarded the “Rising Star Lawyer Award” at the 10th Guike Annual Conference.
With more than seven years of experience in civil and commercial dispute resolution, he has represented clients in dozens of complex, high‑profile litigation and arbitration matters. The disputes he has handled encompass a wide range of issues, including equity transfer disputes, earn‑out agreement disputes, private equity fund and trust contract disputes, guarantee contract disputes, private lending disputes, challenges to the validity of corporate resolutions, and trade secret infringement disputes. These cases have been heard before such judicial bodies as the Supreme People’s Court, the higher people’s courts across China, the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission, and the Beijing Arbitration Commission. He excels at crafting comprehensive, systematic dispute‑resolution strategies for his clients—spanning front‑end transaction‑risk assessments and the design of commercial negotiation frameworks, through pre‑litigation evidence‑chain consolidation and preservation‑measure planning, to courtroom advocacy and enforcement‑driven recovery. By providing end‑to‑end, one‑stop services, he helps clients navigate intricate legal disputes, stand out in competitive environments, and achieve a seamless alignment between their business objectives and legal imperatives.
In addition to civil and commercial disputes, the firm also focuses on the cultural and entertainment sectors, specializing in music‑related and film‑and‑television investment disputes. With extensive experience in compliance and crisis communications, it provides end-to-end risk management and rights‑protection solutions for leading platforms, talent agencies, and public figures.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12

