CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

Against the backdrop of comprehensively advancing law-based governance, and in order to thoroughly implement the arrangements set forth at the Third and Fourth Plenary Sessions of the 20th CPC Central Committee regarding the improvement of the system for ensuring seamless coordination between administrative and criminal penalties, on December 13, 2025, the School of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, in collaboration with the Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Institute of China University of Political Science and Law, the Integrated Research Base for Civil, Criminal, and Administrative Law of Xinglai Law Firm, Beijing Starrise Law Firm, and the Guangdong Institute of Rule of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, will host… “Seminar on Reforming and Improving the Mechanism for Linking Administrative Law Enforcement with Criminal Justice” It was successfully held in Guangzhou.



The conference conducted an in-depth discussion on the key and challenging issues encountered in the operation of the mechanism for coordinating administrative law enforcement with criminal justice, providing theoretical underpinnings and practical guidance to address the operational difficulties in achieving two-way coordination between these two spheres.


More than 120 experts and scholars, representatives from practical agencies, and faculty and students from the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, the Guangdong Provincial People’s Procuratorate, the Zhuhai Municipal People’s Procuratorate of Guangdong Province, the Baiyun District People’s Procuratorate of Guangzhou, Renmin University of China, China University of Political Science and Law, the People’s Public Security University of China, Guangzhou University, Anhui University, the Guangdong Police College, Beijing Starrise Law Firm, and other institutions gathered to discuss innovative developments in the two-way coordination mechanism between administrative and criminal enforcement.


Opening Ceremony



The opening ceremony of the seminar was chaired by Professor Gao Jingfeng of the School of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade. Ge Xiaoyue, Deputy Secretary of the Party Committee of the university; Sun Maoli, a member of the 14th National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference and former member of the Party Leadership Group and Vice Minister of the Ministry of Public Security; and Sun Qian, Director of the Advisory Committee of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate and former member of its Party Leadership Group and Vice Procurator-General, attended the ceremony and delivered remarks.



Ge Xiaoyue, Deputy Secretary of the Party Committee of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, on behalf of the university, extended a warm welcome and expressed her gratitude to all the leaders, experts, scholars, and distinguished guests in attendance. She pointed out that, as China enters a new stage of building a country under the rule of law, the mechanism for coordinating administrative and criminal enforcement is directly linked to the effectiveness of national governance and the public’s sense of fairness and justice. Since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, related reforms have continued to deepen; however, numerous challenges remain in practice. This symposium focuses on key issues and holds significant importance for advancing institutional and theoretical innovation and for modernizing China’s governance system and governance capacity. She emphasized that hosting this symposium is both an honor and a responsibility. Marking the university’s 60th anniversary as a fresh starting point, the institution will continue to pool high-quality resources, build high-level platforms, and work hand in hand with all sectors to contribute the “GDUFS Approach” to the further improvement of the socialist rule-of-law system with Chinese characteristics. She also extended her best wishes for the symposium to yield fruitful outcomes.



Sun Maoli, a member of the 14th National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference and former member of the Party Leadership Group and Vice Minister of the Ministry of Public Security, pointed out that the theme of this seminar is both theoretically and practically significant. At present, China’s crime landscape has undergone marked changes: traditional crimes are on the decline, while administrative and statutory offenses have increasingly become the focus of governance. There is an urgent need for coordinated efforts between administrative oversight and criminal justice to prevent such offenses and prosecute them in accordance with the law. Drawing on his experience in public security work, he put forward three key observations: first, administrative regulatory authorities must strengthen their capacity to analyze and refer criminal leads; second, the public security, procuratorial, and judicial organs should enhance coordination and communication with administrative regulators and provide timely feedback on recommendations, thereby bolstering front‑end regulatory effectiveness; and third, complementary measures to ensure seamless linkage between administrative and criminal proceedings should be refined, enabling mutual support in technology, resources, and capabilities to address challenges such as high appraisal costs and heavy reliance on specialized expertise. By forging synergy between administrative enforcement and criminal justice, we can further enhance governance efficiency.



Sun Qian, Director of the Advisory Committee of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, former member of the Party Leadership Group, and former Vice Procurator-General, stated that this seminar, which focuses on the mechanism for coordinating administrative and criminal enforcement, represents an important step in implementing Xi Jinping’s thought on the rule of law and responding to the national strategy of comprehensively advancing law-based governance. Drawing on his many years of experience in procuratorial work, he shared three key insights: First, the evolution of the administrative–criminal coordination mechanism reflects the development of China’s social governance and legal system, having shifted from the one-way linkage—aimed at preventing “substituting fines for criminal penalties”—in the early stages of reform and opening-up, to a two-way alignment between administrative and criminal sanctions. In line with the principle of penal restraint enshrined in the Criminal Law, it has also streamlined procedures for referring cases back from criminal prosecution to administrative penalties. Second, it is essential to clearly delineate the powers and responsibilities of administrative and judicial authorities, ensuring that criminal offenses are not dismissed solely through administrative measures while also guaranteeing appropriate handling of minor violations. Third, attention must be paid to issues such as the failure to transfer serious crimes in accordance with the law, inconsistencies in criteria for distinguishing between crime and non‑crime, and disruptions in the coordination between prosecutorial and administrative powers. Addressing these challenges requires sustained, concerted efforts by both the academic and practical communities.


Keynote Address


  • Several Key Issues in the Mechanism for Linking Administrative Law Enforcement with Criminal Justice



The keynote session was chaired by Professor Zhou Xin of the School of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade. Professor Chen Weidong, Wu Yuzhang Distinguished Professor at Renmin University of China and Executive Vice President of the Chinese Society for Criminal Procedure, Professor Xiong Qiuhong, Dean of the Institute of Procedural Law at China University of Political Science and Law and Vice President and Secretary-General of the Chinese Society for Criminal Procedure, Deputy Director Wu Qiaobin of the Legal Policy Research Office of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, and Professor Yang Zhikun, Vice Dean of the Guangdong Institute for the Rule of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade, each delivered a keynote address on the theme “Several Important Issues in the Mechanism Linking Administrative Enforcement with Criminal Justice.”



Professor Chen Weidong, Wu Yuzhang Distinguished Professor at Renmin University of China and Executive Vice President of the Chinese Society of Criminal Procedure Law, points out that the coordination between administrative and criminal enforcement is a key yet challenging issue in the rule-of-law construction. Since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, progress has been made; however, in practice, problems persist, including cases being left untransferred or difficult to transfer, alongside an overemphasis on pursuing criminal liability, with the resulting mechanism often operating in a vacuum. The coordination between administrative and criminal enforcement faces five major challenges: an incomplete normative framework, inefficient procedural operations, inadequate rules of evidence, barriers to information sharing, and the need to strengthen procuratorial oversight. To address these issues, improvements should be pursued across five dimensions: first, by refining the normative system, strengthening top-level design, and issuing unified documents to resolve conflicts; second, by streamlining procedural workflows, clarifying transfer criteria, and establishing a checklist system to standardize reverse‑linkage procedures; third, by perfecting evidentiary rules, adhering to the principle of limited transfer, and clearly defining the scope and standards for evidence conversion; fourth, by enhancing information sharing, coordinating the joint development of platforms, and instituting end-to-end data‑security mechanisms; and fifth, by optimizing procuratorial supervision—expanding its scope, improving its effectiveness, and leveraging digital prosecution to achieve precision‑based oversight.



Professor Xiong Qiuhong, Dean of the Institute of Litigation Studies at China University of Political Science and Law and Vice President and Secretary-General of the Chinese Society for Criminal Procedure, points out that, at the normative level, China’s system of coordination between administrative and criminal proceedings has progressed from the 2001 State Council document that first introduced the concept of “administrative–criminal coordination” and stipulated “positive coordination,” to the 2018 amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law, which added provisions on “reverse coordination,” thereby entering a new stage of normative development characterized by “two-way emphasis.” At the theoretical level, while upholding the foundational “dual‑system” framework of administrative and criminal sanctions, it is advisable to supplement this with a “unified integration theory” to address the growing trend toward blurred boundaries between administrative and criminal jurisdictions, driven by the expanding scope of administrative offenses and crimes. At the operational level, drawing on German experience, a mechanism for administrative–criminal coordination could be designed with the goals of ensuring accurate legal application, procedural integrity, and a balance between judicial fairness and efficiency; under the principle of criminal priority, both criminal offenses and administrative violations would undergo dual review. With regard to the transition from criminal proceedings to administrative‑violation procedures, issues of administrative–criminal coordination should be addressed by distinguishing among different stages of litigation and varying case circumstances. Conversely, when shifting from administrative‑violation procedures to criminal proceedings, such coordination should be governed by whether the administrative authority has already imposed an administrative penalty, with further refinements made to mechanisms for transferring leads, converting evidence, and providing feedback, so as to foster efficient collaboration between administrative enforcement agencies and criminal prosecution authorities.



Deputy Director Wu Qiaobin of the Legal and Policy Research Office of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate pointed out that the relationships between administrative and criminal law, between administrative enforcement and criminal justice, and between administrative liability and criminal liability are both complex and reflective of contemporary realities, underscoring the significant value of studying mechanisms for coordinating administrative and criminal proceedings. As the structure of criminal offenses evolves, the traditional “administrative‑to‑criminal” forward linkage can no longer meet the demands of an era characterized by administrative offenses, leaving gaps where neither criminal sanctions nor administrative penalties are imposed. Consequently, establishing a reverse linkage between administrative and criminal procedures has become particularly necessary; its core lies in referring to the competent authorities those acts that do not give rise to criminal liability but nonetheless entail administrative responsibility, in accordance with the principle that “exemption from criminal punishment does not equate to exemption from administrative sanction.” While the current institutional framework has been steadily refined and has yielded practical results, challenges remain, including gaps in substantive norms, bottlenecks in procedural implementation, and insufficiently robust oversight mechanisms. He recommended adopting the guiding principle of “balancing crime control with governance,” upholding principles such as independent determination and comprehensive evaluation, and continuously enhancing the quality and efficiency of reverse administrative‑criminal coordination through the standardization of penalty criteria, the streamlining of coordination procedures, the strengthening of technological support, and the deepening of collaborative linkages.



Professor Yang Zhikun, Vice Dean of the Guangdong Institute for Rule of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade, points out that the coordination between administrative enforcement and criminal justice is not merely a procedural or case‑by‑case transfer issue. Rather, it should be understood within the broader constitutional framework of the division and collaboration of state powers. Administrative enforcement and criminal justice each assume distinct functions in addressing different types of unlawful conduct; this arrangement both reflects specialized division of labor and efficiency, while also requiring coordinated linkage to safeguard the unity of the legal order and the integration of the governance system. As the organ responsible for legal supervision, the procuratorial organs should play a pivotal role in this coordination mechanism, promoting cross‑departmental collaborative operations through platform development and process optimization. At the substantive level, they must distinguish between homogeneous and heterogeneous regulatory regimes: for homogeneous areas, they should ensure substantive “linkage” in the handling of unlawful conduct, whereas for heterogeneous areas, they should emphasize coordination guided by the principle of proportionality, thereby preventing situations in practice where responsibility becomes disjointed or penalties are applied in reverse order. Ultimately, through typological and contextualized decision‑making, effective coordination between administrative enforcement and criminal justice can be achieved.


Theme Report, Unit 1


  • Reform and Improvement of the Positive Coordination Mechanism between Administrative Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice


This symposium featured two thematic sessions. The first session, titled “Reform and Improvement of the Mechanism for Positive Coordination Between Administrative Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice,” was chaired by Wu Qiaobin, Deputy Director of the Legal and Policy Research Office of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate.



Ye ZuHuai, a member of the Party Leadership Group and Deputy Chief Prosecutor of the People’s Procuratorate of Zhuhai City, Guangdong Province; Zhang Zetao, a professor at the School of Law of Guangzhou University; Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Director of the Integrated Research Base for Civil–Criminal–Administrative Law at the Institute of Criminal Law and Justice of China University of Political Science and Law and Xinglai Law Firm; Yang Fan, a professor at the School of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and International Trade; Li Ce, a lecturer at the School of Law of the People’s Public Security University of China; and Zhi Jiayi, a lecturer at the School of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and International Trade, each delivered a keynote report. Chen Kexiang, Associate Professor and Director of the Institute for Regional Rule of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and International Trade, then engaged in a panel discussion.



Ye Zuhuai, Deputy Chief Prosecutor and member of the Party Leadership Group of the People’s Procuratorate of Zhuhai City, Guangdong Province, stated that Zhuhai has been a pioneer in the “linkage between administrative and criminal law”: in 2012, it established the province’s first city‑district–level networked information‑sharing platform for this linkage. Moreover, the Regulations on the Coordination between Administrative Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice in the Zhuhai Special Economic Zone represent the nation’s first local regulation systematically standardizing such coordination, with demonstrably positive practical results. Nevertheless, current efforts to advance this linkage still face challenges, including insufficient legislative support, inconsistent standards for case referrals, and low data‑conversion rates on the platform. To further deepen this work, three key approaches can be pursued: first, upgrade the platform to break down information silos; second, refine guiding standards to enhance the quality and effectiveness of coordination; and third, strengthen legislative provisions to bolster the rigidity of oversight.



Professor Zhang Zetao of the School of Law at Guangzhou University argues that the traditional unidirectional coordination model focuses solely on the linear referral of cases from administrative authorities to judicial organs, while neglecting subsequent administrative oversight and follow-up after criminal proceedings. This approach fails to establish a governance feedback loop integrating “punishment and prevention,” resulting in the coexistence of “using fines in lieu of criminal penalties” and “using criminal penalties in lieu of fines,” inadequate mechanisms for converting evidence, and fragmented interagency collaboration. Guided by the theory of collaborative governance, a closed-loop system should be established—covering “clues of administrative violations, criminal case initiation and investigation, criminal adjudication, and administrative regulatory follow-up.” This would involve enacting unified legislation to clarify the powers and responsibilities of coordinating entities, define referral criteria and rules for evidence conversion, codify administrative oversight obligations arising after criminal proceedings, and develop cross‑departmental big‑data sharing platforms and regular joint‑meeting mechanisms. Furthermore, diverse stakeholders—including industry associations, social organizations, and public whistleblowers—should be engaged to foster a multi‑stakeholder governance framework involving government, the judiciary, and civil society. Finally, such coordination efforts should be integrated into performance‑evaluation and accountability systems, thereby achieving comprehensive, end‑to‑end governance of both administrative violations and criminal offenses.



Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, used the high-profile Changchun vaccine case as a case study to examine the conflicts and potential resolutions in the practical implementation of the mechanism for coordinating criminal and administrative proceedings. She pointed out that, following the initiation of criminal proceedings, an administrative authority unilaterally imposed the maximum administrative fine of RMB 9.1 billion—does this contravene the principle of “criminal proceedings take precedence”? Behind this issue lies a profound tension between “efficiency” and “procedural justice,” and it serves as a quintessential illustration of the blurred boundaries of power in the coordination between criminal and administrative enforcement. This case highlights two key problems: first, the criteria and timing for initiating criminal investigations may be influenced by public opinion and other factors; second, the overlap between administrative penalties and criminal prosecution not only blurs the line between administrative and judicial authority but also risks giving rise to “double jeopardy,” thereby inflicting irreversible harm on the rights and interests of businesses. Attorney Cheng emphasized that stringent punishment of unlawful conduct must rest on a solid foundation of procedural rule of law. She called for the establishment of a well‑defined institutional framework with clear delineations of powers and responsibilities and seamless coordination: once administrative enforcement agencies refer a case to the judiciary, they should respect the primacy of judicial proceedings and, only after the criminal process has concluded, decide in accordance with the law whether and how to impose supplementary administrative sanctions, such as disqualification penalties. Only by upholding both substantive and procedural justice can we ensure that every sanction is both robust and capable of withstanding scrutiny under law and history.



Professor Yang Fan of the School of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade argues that it is necessary to further reflect on the absolute efficacy of referring cases to the judicial authorities and on the necessity of timely referral. At present, the criteria for determining whether a case involves criminal conduct remain unclear and require further clarification; moreover, even after a case is referred, the judicial authorities still rely on the administrative agency’s expert judgment, and terminating an administrative investigation may not facilitate the judiciary’s comprehensive understanding of the facts. In addition, given the inherent independence of administrative enforcement, whether a decision by the judicial authorities not to prosecute necessarily compels the administrative agency to issue an administrative penalty remains a matter for debate.



Lecturer Li Ce of the School of Law at the People’s Public Security University of China stated that the traditional case‑transfer paradigm is passive, retrospective, and fragmented, making it ill‑suited to the demands of addressing emerging forms of crime and preventing risks. To address this, we should adopt the principle of risk prevention as a core theoretical framework, shifting the linkage between administrative and criminal enforcement from post‑event accountability to proactive prevention. This can be achieved by standardizing risk early warning systems, implementing tiered, coordinated interventions, and establishing closed‑loop optimization mechanisms; leveraging real‑world big data and AI‑driven self‑learning to continuously refine risk models. At the same time, local practices should be elevated into national legislation, fully harnessing the role of digital technologies in preventing illegal and criminal activities. Such efforts will enable a paradigmatic leap in the exercise of public authority—from “case handling” to “risk prevention”—thereby providing foundational technological support for the modernization of the rule of law.



Zhi Jia, a lecturer at the School of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, notes that the current standard for referring cases—“where there is reasonable suspicion of criminal conduct and criminal liability must be pursued in accordance with the law”—poses significant challenges for frontline administrative law enforcement officers. Drawing on the intellectual property field’s approach, which allows referral upon “reasonable suspicion of crime,” a “lenient entry, strict exit” model could be adopted to both prevent substituting fines for criminal penalties and leverage the specialized investigative strengths of public security organs. At the same time, legislation should grant administrative agencies discretion to handle minor cases and to dismiss charges where appropriate, clearly defining the boundaries of such powers and the applicable procedures. Furthermore, prosecutorial oversight should be strengthened throughout the entire process of case referral and initiation of proceedings, the joint conference system should be improved, and the scope of transferring case‑related assets and evidence should be expanded, thereby achieving mutual complementarity and standardized harmonization between administrative and criminal evidentiary rules.



Associate Professor Chen Kexiang, Director of the Institute for Regional Rule of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and Foreign Trade, points out that the core issues in the coordination between administrative and criminal enforcement are “what should be referred” and “how it should be referred.” From the perspective of substantive standards, the low hierarchical status of relevant regulations makes it difficult to achieve seamless alignment; therefore, higher‑level legislation is needed to establish criteria that both administrative agencies and procuratorial organs can jointly enforce. This requires not only advancing the clarification of substantive standards but also further refining them through sector‑specific approaches. In terms of procedural design, cooperative governance models such as joint meetings and co‑located offices should employ scenario‑based frameworks to delineate the respective jurisdictions of different authorities, thereby preventing the overreach of one agency’s powers in the name of coordination. As for technological applications, the challenge of information sharing in administrative–criminal coordination—characterized by “platforms without actual sharing”—stems primarily from unclear legislative authority. To address this, it is necessary to more clearly define the entities, scope, and responsibilities involved in data sharing, so as to unlock the full potential of these platforms and solidify the technical foundation for two‑way coordination between administrative and criminal enforcement.


Theme Report, Unit 2


  • Reform and Improvement of the Reverse Coordination Mechanism Between Administrative Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice


The thematic report of the second session, titled “Reform and Improvement of the Mechanism for Bidirectional Coordination Between Administrative Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice,” was chaired by Wang Jun, Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Executive Director of the Integrated Civil–Criminal–Administrative Research Base jointly established by the School of Criminal Law and the Xinglai Law Firm at China University of Political Science and Law.



Professor Liu Jihua of the Law School at Renmin University of China, Professor Yuan Yi of the Institute of Comparative Law at China University of Political Science and Law, Deputy Director Xiao Yajing of the Second Prosecution Department of the Baiyun District People’s Procuratorate in Guangzhou, Lecturer Zheng Lizhou of the Law School at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and International Trade, and doctoral candidate Tian Yuan of the same law school each delivered a keynote report. Associate Professor Xia Wei of the School of Criminal Justice at China University of Political Science and Law and Lecturer Liu Tiantian of the School of Law at Anhui University engaged in a panel discussion.



Professor Liu Jihua of the Law School at Renmin University of China stated that the two-way linkage between administrative and criminal proceedings is a new issue receiving high attention from the central authorities, involving comprehensive coordination between administrative enforcement and criminal justice. This mechanism requires that individuals who commit administrative violations that also constitute criminal offenses be held accountable under both administrative and criminal law, thereby preventing one-sided attribution of responsibility. He pointed out that, in practice, some cases—though lacking victims and already constituting criminal offenses—are not referred to public security organs, which hinders the initiation of public prosecution. Even after the procuratorial organ forwards such cases back to the administrative authority, it should continue to assume responsibility for issuing prosecutorial recommendations and for ongoing follow-up on the outcomes. Furthermore, he examined issues such as the exclusion of court‑issued convictions resulting in exemption from punishment from the scope of reverse linkage, as well as the lack of guidance through typical cases, and recommended that the relevant departments jointly draft pertinent documents.



Professor Yuan Yi of the School of Comparative Law at China University of Political Science and Law stated that the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation shares a similar structure with China’s Criminal Procedure Law, and its legislative feature of fixed statutory provisions can offer valuable insights for revising China’s criminal procedure law. Furthermore, Russian law contains two provisions relevant to the reverse‑linkage mechanism: first, Russia has introduced a new chapter stipulating that, in cases where criminal liability is waived, a procedural fine may be imposed—aligning with the direction of reverse linkage; second, when a minor is not subject to criminal liability, the case is instead handled through administrative coercive measures, which encompass three categories—educational and rehabilitative measures, compulsory educational and rehabilitative measures, and closed‑type specialized educational institutions—each governed by detailed and highly targeted regulations. To ensure the effective implementation of reverse linkage, it is necessary to establish comprehensive legislative norms, with priority given to minors or other vulnerable groups, and to refine the applicable criteria accordingly.



Xiao Yajing, Deputy Director of the Second Prosecution Department of the People’s Procuratorate of Baiyun District, Guangzhou, stated that, in the implementation of the reverse‑linkage mechanism, challenges persist, including ambiguity regarding the entities responsible for transferring cases involving smuggling and tax offenses; inconsistent evidentiary standards; insufficient institutional rigidity; and a mismatch between penalties and the severity of violations. She recommended that, at the legislative level, substantive and procedural provisions governing reverse linkage be systematically coordinated. At the same time, she urged enhancing prosecutors’ expertise in cross‑disciplinary areas such as customs anti‑smuggling, financial and foreign‑exchange regulation, and cybercrime. On the front of collaborative governance, she proposed incorporating reverse linkage into the performance‑evaluation frameworks for rule‑of‑law development and public‑security initiatives, thereby addressing the current overreliance on unilateral impetus from the procuratorial organs and advancing the transition from case‑by‑case handling to systemic governance and broader social governance.



Lecturer Zheng Lizhou of the School of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies and International Trade stated that the mechanism for reverse coordination between criminal and administrative procedures in the handling of case‑related property reflects the hierarchical relationship between criminal and administrative liability, emphasizing the realization of efficiency. In judicial practice, barriers persist between criminal justice and administrative enforcement in areas such as information sharing, standardization, and the delineation of responsibilities, while the parties’ procedural participation rights remain unclear. To improve the relevant reverse coordination mechanisms, it is necessary to establish an information‑sharing platform, refine the “enforcement–judiciary” collaborative framework, and safeguard the parties’ rights to be informed, to express their views, and to seek procedural remedies, while also ensuring the consistent application of the principle of proportionality across both administrative and criminal law.



Dr. Tian Yuan, a doctoral candidate at the School of Law of Guangdong University of Foreign Studies, points out that under China’s dual-track sanctioning model of “administrative plus criminal,” the decision not to pursue criminal liability does not extinguish the administrative illegality. Moreover, the expansion of minor offenses has further widened the institutional vacuum of “no punishment without criminal liability,” making reverse coordination between administrative and criminal proceedings an imperative for closing gaps in the governance chain. She argues that the current mechanism for such reverse coordination faces three core challenges: first, gaps in legal norms, blurred boundaries between administrative and criminal enforcement, and blind spots in the application of relevant systems; second, an imbalance in penalties, with insufficient orderly alignment in the severity of sanctions, leading to the phenomenon of “reverse inversion” between administrative and criminal penalties; and third, procedural bottlenecks—difficulties in identifying the transferring authority, inadequate evidence‑linkage mechanisms, and a lack of standardized procedures—resulting in the ineffective implementation of administrative sanctions. To address these issues, coordinated improvements are needed on both substantive and procedural levels: substantively, it is essential to clarify criteria for distinguishing between administrative and criminal matters, fill gaps in administrative penalty provisions, and apply the principle of proportionality to ensure appropriate matching of sanction intensities; procedurally, clear rules should be established regarding the initiating authorities and jurisdiction, unified standards for evidence conversion should be adopted, the scope of case‑transfer referrals should be standardized, and feedback processes should be optimized, thereby achieving effective integration between administrative enforcement and criminal justice.



Xia Wei, an associate professor at the School of Criminal Justice of China University of Political Science and Law, stated that reverse linkage not only serves a accountability function but also embodies a corrective value: administrative agencies may impose improper penalties due to evidentiary defects or erroneous findings; upon identifying such issues during criminal review, judicial authorities should, through the reverse‑linkage mechanism, urge the administrative agency to reinvestigate and either rescind or modify the original penalty decision. He recommends that legislation explicitly define the procuratorial organs’ power to initiate corrective measures, as well as the administrative agencies’ obligation and time limits for re‑processing. By doing so, reverse linkage could be expanded from a mere “tool for accountability” into a composite institutional framework integrating diversified governance and rights protection—thereby safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of the parties involved, enhancing the standardization of administrative law enforcement, and realizing the rule-of-law objective of “correcting all errors while ensuring that those who evade punishment are held accountable.”



Liu Tiantian, a lecturer at the School of Law of Anhui University, stated that in 2024, procuratorial organs nationwide issued administrative penalty recommendations to 162,000 individuals who were not prosecuted, accounting for 40% of all non-prosecution cases. In Ningxia and other regions, administrative agencies responded with penalties in nearly 90% of these cases, effectively addressing the issue of “no criminal liability, no punishment.” However, the criteria for determining punishability still lack uniform standards, rules on evidence conversion vary, and the depth of technological empowerment remains insufficient. She recommended emphasizing, at the conceptual level, the integration of “punishment commensurate with responsibility” with social governance; at the institutional level, advancing statutory procedures, unified standards, and standardized checklists for evidence conversion; and, at the innovation level, leveraging big data platforms to achieve end-to-end digitalization of prosecutorial recommendations—covering automatic generation, delivery, reminders, and performance evaluation—thereby strengthening the rigidity of oversight and ensuring that reverse coordination evolves from quantitative growth to qualitative improvement.


Closing Ceremony


The closing ceremony was chaired by Professor Zhou Xin of the School of Law at Guangdong University of Foreign Studies. Professor Gao Jingfeng of the same school delivered the concluding remarks of the symposium.



Professor Gao Jingfeng fully commended the success of this conference, noting that it showcased several notable highlights: First, the conference brought together a broad spectrum of participants, including experts and scholars from political and legal organs at all levels, as well as from academia and the practical field, resulting in vigorous exchanges of views that were both insightful and highly informative. Second, the discussions combined depth with breadth, delving into the core issue of the coordination between administrative and criminal enforcement while comprehensively addressing key dimensions such as substantive norms and procedural implementation, thus ensuring a systematic and holistic coverage. Third, the perspectives advanced were forward-looking, theoretically grounded, and practically applicable—addressing current challenges with targeted solutions while offering innovative ideas for long-term development. Fourth, the research adopted diverse and expansive analytical lenses, drawing on domestic law‑enforcement and judicial practices to distill valuable lessons, while also incorporating comparative studies of domestic and foreign legislative frameworks to broaden horizons, thereby providing important insights for future reforms of the administrative–criminal enforcement coordination mechanism and related research.



Subsequently, Professor Gao Jingfeng, drawing on the outcomes of the conference discussions, identified five key issues that warrant further in-depth examination: First, the nature of procuratorial oversight within the framework of positive criminal–administrative coordination—specifically, whether it falls under criminal case‑filing supervision or administrative procuratorial review, and the legislative compatibility of the relevant institutional norms. Second, the delineation of the boundaries between procuratorial power and administrative authority, with a particular focus on clarifying the legal effect of procuratorial opinions on administrative penalties issued by the procuratorate in the context of reverse coordination, thereby defining the scope of procuratorial powers. Third, the hierarchical status and applicable relationships between procuratorial opinions and procuratorial recommendations, requiring a clear articulation of their logical interplay in judicial practice. Fourth, the coordinated adaptation of reverse coordination with the system for sealing criminal records, including the sealing of relevant evidence after non‑prosecution, the alignment of transferred materials with sealing requirements, and the rules governing the sealing of administrative penalty records. Fifth, the standardized development of a digital platform for criminal–administrative coordination, necessitating adherence to the principle of “doing good,” clarification of the relationship between information‑platform construction and the principle of decentralization in information systems, upholding the principle of two‑way transparency in information management, and safeguarding citizens’ rights and freedoms.


Finally, Professor Gao Jingfeng expressed his gratitude to the university leadership for their strong support of this symposium, as well as to the leaders of political and legal organs at all levels, university scholars and experts, practitioners from relevant departments, young researchers, and graduate students who actively participated in the conference. He also extended his heartfelt thanks to the entire conference organizing team for their diligent efforts in ensuring the event’s successful execution. He emphasized that this symposium focused squarely on the core issues of reforming and improving the mechanism for coordinating administrative enforcement with criminal justice, effectively building broad consensus, sparking insightful exchanges, and offering practical recommendations, thereby yielding substantial results. He looked forward to colleagues taking this conference as an opportunity to further deepen theoretical research and practical exploration in related fields, working together to contribute greater wisdom and solid strength to refining China’s distinctive system of administrative–criminal coordination and advancing the rule of law in China.


Source: Chinese Law Review



Editor and Layout: Wang Xin

Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building


Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province

Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license