

As China’s rule-of-law development continues to deepen and the business environment keeps improving, corporate-related official‑crime cases in judicial practice are exhibiting distinct new trends and challenges. To explore cutting-edge theoretical and practical issues in this field and jointly enhance lawyers’ professional capabilities, on September 13, 2025, a conference co‑hosted by the Zhengzhou Lawyers Association, the “Criminal Defense Twenty‑Person Forum” team, and other organizations will be held. “Criminal Defense Twenty-Person Forum • Public Welfare Event – Zhengzhou Station, and the Central China Criminal Defense Forum on Protecting Enterprises” It was successfully held in Zhengzhou. The forum brought together numerous experts from the national judiciary, the legal profession, and academia, who engaged in multi‑level, high‑caliber discussions on topics such as corporate criminal risk prevention and control, and new developments in defense representation involving businesses.

During the forum’s special session on “New Trends and Strategies in Corporate‑Related Official Crime Cases,” Attorney Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and initiator of the “Criminal Defense Twenty‑Person Forum,” delivered a keynote address, drawing on his extensive professional experience and keen industry insights. Attorney Zhao, focusing on two main strands—bribery cases and corporate anti-corruption matters—provides a thorough analysis of the latest developments in these two categories, examining their evolving trends in terms of caseloads, distinctive features, defense challenges, and strategic options within the current dual context of policy and judicial practice. Ranging from broad macro‑trends to granular case‑by‑case nuances, he not only elucidates the legal and policy rationale underlying the “gap between initiation of proceedings and prosecution” in bribery cases but also highlights the hallmark characteristics of internal corporate anti‑corruption matters—simple charges coupled with complex factual circumstances. Furthermore, he advances a “comprehensive defense” strategy centered on resolving deep‑seated conflicts, offering lawyers forward‑looking, highly practical guidance for mounting effective defenses in intricate corporate‑related official‑duty crime cases.
The following is compiled from Attorney Zhao Yunheng’s remarks at the forum, for the benefit of our readers.

Zhao Yunheng
Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Founder of the “Twenty Criminal Defense Lawyers Forum”
Bribery-related cases
(1) Rising Case Volume: The Clash Between Policy and Reality
According to news reports, in 2024, the total number of criminal cases filed in China declined by 25.7%. This figure unequivocally underscores the remarkable achievements China has made in public security management, further cementing its status as one of the safest countries in the world.
However, in this asymmetric environment, there is always a segment of the population that remains vulnerable—namely, those involved in official‑related crimes: both the bribe-givers and the bribe-takers, who can be regarded as the current high‑risk group. According to the latest data, in the first half of 2025, disciplinary inspection and supervision authorities nationwide initiated investigations into 16,000 individuals suspected of bribery and referred 1,990 of them to the procuratorial organs, a trend that has been steadily rising in recent years. This indicates that, as anti-corruption efforts continue to advance and the number of officials brought down increases, numerous entrepreneurs linked to these officials are also being placed under investigation, leading to a steady rise in the number of bribery cases.
Behind this upward trend lie complex policy and practical factors. On the one hand, China has consistently maintained a high-pressure stance against corruption, steadily intensifying penalties for bribery—particularly in key sectors such as finance, state-owned enterprises, and energy—while continuously deepening and expanding anti-corruption efforts. As a result, an increasing number of both new and longstanding bribery cases have come to light.
On the other hand, disparities in the practical implementation of criminal policy have also influenced case volumes. Although China has vigorously promoted the protection of the private sector and the development of the private economy, emphasizing safeguards for private entrepreneurs, public security organs—as government agencies—are tasked with ensuring the immediate and effective execution of criminal policies, enabling swift implementation. For instance, the once‑widespread practice of “deep‑sea fishing” has significantly declined following the intensive rollout of a series of central and local policies and reform measures; some cases even represent backlogs. However, the supervisory authorities differ from public security organs in their priorities and mandates. As political bodies, they shoulder unique responsibilities and missions in anti-corruption efforts, which means that—even against the backdrop of protecting the private sector—their enforcement against bribery-related offenses remains unwavering. Consequently, under what appears to be a contradictory policy environment, the number of bribery cases continues to rise, and news reports frequently highlight the detention of listed‑company executives by supervisory commissions.
(II) The Gap Between Filing a Case and Prosecution: Legal Framework and Practical Implementation
In bribery cases, a striking phenomenon is the substantial gap between the number of cases filed and the number of prosecutions. Each year, the number of bribery cases initiated can be as high as nearly 20,000, yet the number of individuals actually prosecuted accounts for only about one-eighth of those cases.
The emergence of this phenomenon is closely linked to a variety of factors.
First, from the perspective of legal classification, Article 15 of the Supervision Law stipulates that the subjects of supervision are primarily public officials. Private-sector entrepreneurs, as they are not public officials, do not fall within the scope of supervision and are typically treated as persons involved in the case, assisting and cooperating with the investigation. This places private-sector entrepreneurs in a position where prosecution may or may not be pursued, thereby affording considerable flexibility in the handling of cases.
Secondly, in cases of official misconduct, the supervisory authorities’ application of the “four forms” of handling is a key factor contributing to the gap between case initiation and prosecution. Under this framework, the first three forms account for over 90 percent of all cases, while only 5 to 6 percent proceed to criminal prosecution. By contrast, private-sector entrepreneurs are not subject to oversight by the supervisory authorities; once detained, they typically face only criminal prosecution. However, given their unique position in such cases—and the need for supervisory bodies to weigh multiple considerations during investigations, including leveraging entrepreneurs as key witnesses to corroborate evidence of official crimes, safeguarding the survival and development of implicated enterprises and their employees, and encouraging voluntary restitution—some cases are resolved at the stage of investigation by the supervisory commission or review by the procuratorial organs, without advancing to the prosecution phase.
Incidentally, I have previously proposed at other conferences that scholars and experts be invited to examine a legal‑theoretical issue: whether lawyers are entitled to intervene during the investigation phase conducted by the supervisory commissions in cases involving private‑sector entrepreneurs. This is because supervisory authorities handle cases according to the “four forms of handling,” with outcomes bifurcated upon closure—many matters are addressed solely through disciplinary measures, without necessarily proceeding to criminal proceedings. This has been cited as a rationale for barring lawyers from participating in such defenses. However, private‑sector entrepreneurs are not public officials and thus fall outside the scope of supervisory jurisdiction; consequently, the “four forms” do not apply to them. Once an individual is placed under detention, there remains only one possible outcome: criminal prosecution. From a theoretical standpoint, does this not make it all the more imperative to safeguard the right to defense for those subject to criminal prosecution? Therefore, it is essential to promptly study the distinct legal rights of public officials and non‑public officials who cooperate with investigations, and to translate these findings into legislative reforms without delay.
Third, the standards for prosecuting bribery offenses also give rise to discrepancies between case initiation and prosecution. At present, the threshold for establishing the crime of accepting bribes is relatively broad: public officials who accept money or property can generally be convicted. By contrast, the determination of the crime of offering bribes is more complex. In addition to circumstances where prosecution may be waived, the law requires that the briber act with the intent to obtain an improper benefit. Yet in practice, the definition and assessment of “obtaining an improper benefit” often remain contentious, which in turn makes it difficult for some bribery cases to meet the criteria for prosecution.
(3) Expanding the Scope of Defense: Grasping Key Points
Given the aforementioned characteristics of bribery-related cases, the scope for defense is steadily expanding. During the defense process, one can address multiple key issues.
First, the policy context. As the state has placed increasing emphasis on the private sector, a series of policies aimed at safeguarding its development have been introduced, including the Law on the Promotion of the Private Economy and the Opinions on Promoting the Growth and Strengthening of the Private Sector issued by the CPC Central Committee and the State Council. These policies carry significant guiding weight in judicial practice, enabling defense counsel to leverage them effectively to secure favorable outcomes for their clients.
Second, the legal circumstances. There are differences in the handling of bribery and acceptance-of-bribery cases; the law tends to be more lenient toward acts of bribery. If the party concerned cooperates fully, voluntarily discloses the facts, and promptly returns any illicit gains, such factors will be taken into account during sentencing, thereby affording a degree of leeway for the defense.
Third, a company’s genuine operational difficulties may also serve as an important mitigating factor. In the current environment of economic downturn, enterprises face numerous challenges to their survival and development. For certain companies involved in legal proceedings, if their financial distress has a significant impact on local economic growth, judicial authorities typically take this into account during the investigation. For example, in a case we handled in a particular city involving the detention of a private‑sector entrepreneur, although lawyers were unable to intervene directly as defense counsel, they guided the family in drafting and submitting a request for a suspension of investigation, thoroughly outlining the enterprise’s hardships and its critical role in the local economy. This approach earned the understanding and approval of the supervisory commission staff, leading to a shift in their attitude toward both the family and the company. They explicitly stated that they would conclude the investigation promptly and, throughout the process, ensure effective communication between the entrepreneur and the company while supporting the firm’s stable development.
Internal anti-corruption cases within enterprises
(1) Surge in Case Volume: A Crackdown Driven by Policy Measures
In recent years, the state has steadily strengthened its protection of corporate property rights and has taken increasingly stringent measures to crack down on infringements. The introduction of relevant policies has provided clear guidance and robust support for combating internal corporate corruption. Today, anti‑fraud efforts are in full swing, with major enterprises actively addressing this issue by bolstering their internal controls, retaining legal counsel—particularly attorneys with experience in public security, procuratorial, and judicial agencies—to conduct internal investigations, interviews, and prosecutions. Likewise, external lawyers can also mount a defense on behalf of suspects. Beyond companies’ own anti‑fraud initiatives, public security authorities have been implementing these measures with great vigor; from the central level down to local jurisdictions, they are conducting comprehensive sweeps, including retroactive reviews of long‑pending or closed cases involving businesses—rectifying instances where cases should have been filed but were not, or where they were improperly initiated. In Zhejiang Province, during the “Guardian 2024” special campaign launched in 2024, authorities solved 1,298 cases of internal corporate corruption, apprehended 1,997 suspects, and recovered more than RMB 920 million in losses, achieving an overall rate of asset recovery and loss mitigation exceeding 50%. We must stay abreast of such policies and targeted campaigns and proactively apply them in our practice.
(II) The Complex Facts Behind Simple Charges
In internal anti‑fraud cases within enterprises, a notable feature is that the types of cases are relatively straightforward, yet the factual circumstances are often quite complex. According to publicly available data, the charges in such cases predominantly fall into several common categories: embezzlement by an official accounts for the largest share of all cases, misappropriation of funds is also fairly prevalent and frequently overlaps with embezzlement, and bribery by non‑state functionaries occurs from time to time.
However, behind these seemingly straightforward charges lie highly complex factual circumstances that directly affect the evidentiary chain and legal relationships. On the one hand, in today’s era of rapid internet‑technology advancement, electronic data and electronic payment and settlement systems have become ubiquitous. Criminal methods are no longer limited to traditional tactics such as simple tampering with documents or misappropriating funds; perpetrators often employ sophisticated technical tools and intricate transaction schemes, rendering internal corporate fraud increasingly concealed and convoluted.
On the other hand, internal corporate disputes—such as equity conflicts, investment‑related disagreements, and labor‑law issues—further complicate the factual circumstances of cases. In some instances, the parties involved are entangled in intricate webs of interest; for example, when bonuses that should have been paid to employees are withheld, and the employees subsequently appropriate them through various means. In such situations, is this form of self‑help a typical tort, or does it constitute embezzlement in the course of one’s duties? As these types of internal disputes become increasingly common, case‑specific analysis must carefully account for the complex interplay of both internal and external factors.
(3) Defense Strategy: “Grand Advocacy”
In internal anti-corruption cases within enterprises, an effective defense strategy is of paramount importance. Here, I would like to reiterate my long‑standing advocacy for a “big‑picture” approach to defense: by stepping back from the case itself and examining it from a broader, macro perspective, we can uncover the underlying systemic factors and address the root causes of the issue.
For example, in a recent embezzlement case I handled in a certain city, although the matter was relatively straightforward, the company involved wielded significant influence locally and made a substantial contribution to the local fiscal revenue. Consequently, the court inevitably sought the company’s input, resulting in an exceptionally protracted trial. The defendant has been in custody for two and a half years, with the proceedings spanning four court hearings and five rounds of supplementary investigations, yet the case remains unresolved. This case vividly illustrates that, when dealing with internal anti-corruption matters within enterprises, the company’s clout often exerts a decisive impact on the outcome. Unless the accused is entirely without fault and can mount a robust defense of innocence, in most cases there will be some degree of culpability. Under such circumstances, it is generally advisable to engage in constructive dialogue with the company’s leadership, aiming to resolve the dispute amicably.
In many similar cases, the root of the conflict often lies in personal disputes or clashes of economic interests between the parties involved and the company’s management. For instance, in the case where Elon Musk sued a Chinese engineer, the dispute erupted when the scientist took the company’s funds and core code to join a competitor, triggering a fierce confrontation between the enterprise and the individual. In such situations, if the underlying tensions between the company and the party concerned cannot be resolved at their source, even a defense attorney’s robust legal arguments may prove insufficient. Once the matter enters criminal proceedings, it signals that the judicial authorities have, to some extent, endorsed the company’s criminal complaint, thereby increasing the difficulty of the defense and ultimately placing the party at a disadvantage.
That concludes my remarks. Since today’s topic is strategy rather than methodology, I can only offer a high-level overview for your reference. Thank you!
Attorney Profile
.
Zhao Yunheng
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Honorary Director
Doctor of Law from Peking University. Director of the Chinese Society of Criminal Procedure, Special Supervisory Counselor for Lawyers at Detention Centers nationwide under the Ministry of Public Security, Part-time Master’s Supervisor at the School of Law, Peking University, Vice President of the Peking University Financial Alumni Association, Part-time Professor at the School of Law, China University of Political Science and Law, and Off-Campus Graduate Mentor at the School of Law, Beijing Foreign Studies University. Member of the Criminal Law Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association in its 8th and 9th terms; Deputy Director of the Corporate Compliance Law Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association in its 10th term; Legal Expert with the Beijing Municipal Commission of Planning and Natural Resources; and Member of the Corporate Compliance Working Committee of the All-China Federation of Enterprises.
His primary practice areas are criminal litigation and the prevention and response to corporate criminal legal crises. He has handled numerous high-profile criminal cases in China, with particular expertise in cases involving official misconduct and economic crimes. His bilingual Chinese–English book, “The Great Defense: My Story of Criminal Defense,” has been published both domestically and internationally. He pioneered the concept of “Great Defense,” skillfully employing broad thinking and a holistic perspective to transcend the confines of individual cases, leveraging comprehensive strategies in his advocacy. With extensive experience in litigating complex and challenging cases of official misconduct and economic crime, he demonstrates masterful application of legal techniques and excels at navigating intricate social and legal relationships.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12
