
Practical Approaches to Managing Corporate Criminal Risks
Xu Rui
Star Lai Law Firm
Partner
xurui@xinglailaw.com
Ma Xueyan
Star Lai Law Firm
Lawyer
maxueyan@xinglailaw.com
Subject to
Changes in the economic environment and financial pressures have led to a sustained increase in corporate financing needs. Some unscrupulous actors exploit the guise of financing partnerships to perpetrate fraud, while “loan‑trapping” schemes among businesses are increasingly evolving into systemic criminal offenses. This paper aims to help enterprises swiftly identify risk traps and offer practical strategies to safeguard their legitimate rights and interests.
Legal Lending vs. Loan Scams
In judicial practice, although inter‑enterprise lending is a form of private lending, accurately distinguishing between lawful inter‑enterprise loans and the unlawful “routine loan” scheme is crucial for determining whether a matter constitutes a civil dispute or a criminal offense. The most fundamental difference between the two lies in whether the actor subjectively harbors the intent to unlawfully appropriate the other party’s property. In legitimate private lending, the lender’s purpose is to recover the principal on schedule and earn interest; by contrast, perpetrators of “routine loan” schemes, from the outset, seek to illegally seize all or part of the borrower enterprise’s assets through pre‑designed traps and fraudulent tactics.
Under a genuine private lending agreement, the lender and borrower enter into a loan contract on an equal and voluntary basis, with clear terms. Although the agreed-upon interest rates and liquidated damages may be adjusted if deemed excessive, the contract as a whole reflects the parties’ true mutual intent to lend and borrow. By contrast, the contracts used in “routine loan” schemes are tools for perpetrating fraud. Perpetrators often exploit their superior position to induce enterprises to sign “yin‑yang contracts,” fictitious procurement agreements, or sham guarantee contracts that involve material misunderstandings or manifest unfairness. They then fabricate transactional contexts and forge bank statements, creating the appearance of legitimate lending to gather evidence for subsequent “rights‑protection” maneuvers.
In the context of “loan‑sharking schemes,” perpetrators deliberately and intentionally engineer defaults. For example, they may go out of contact on the repayment due date, demand that borrowers repay in cash, impose unreasonable repayment deadlines and obstacles, or unilaterally declare the borrower in default—all to trigger the contract’s steep penalties and liquidated damages clauses, thereby inflating the debt. Subsequently, their collection tactics often amount to coercion. A particularly salient feature is that they frequently present the meticulously fabricated loan agreements, bank statements, and other documents as a comprehensive evidentiary chain, promptly filing civil lawsuits in an attempt to leverage the judicial process to legitimize their unlawful claims. If the court examines only the superficial authenticity of a single contract in isolation, without assessing the conduct as a whole, it can easily be misled and grant the plaintiff’s claims. Moreover, they employ “soft‑violence” tactics—such as harassment, stalking, and physical blockades—to exert dual psychological and legal pressure on business owners, ultimately forcing them to capitulate.
Preventive Measures and Post-Event Rights Protection
In the face of the systemic risk posed by “routine loan” schemes, companies must establish a comprehensive defense framework that encompasses both proactive prevention and post‑incident response. During the preventive phase, it is essential to put in place a rigorous financing management system that exercises end‑to‑end oversight over financing decisions, partner selection, and contract review. In practice, criminal “routine loan” rings exploit borrowers’ lax due diligence by fabricating legal façades—such as drafting promissory notes far exceeding the principal amount or entering into fictitious procurement contracts. Accordingly, when choosing financing partners, companies should, beyond standard checks of business registration information, conduct thorough investigations into shareholders’ backgrounds, related‑entity networks, and litigation histories, while remaining particularly wary of lenders with short registration periods but unusually strong financial resources.
In the specific transaction process, the standardization of fund management is of paramount importance. Enterprises must conduct fund transfers exclusively through corporate‑to‑corporate accounts, ensuring that every payment is supported by complete and traceable bank records. In exceptional circumstances where cash transactions are unavoidable, evidence should be rigorously documented through multiple channels—such as dual‑person witnessing and continuous audio‑video recording—and the nature of the funds must be accurately specified on receipts and supporting documents. With regard to contract management, a standardized review procedure must be established, with dedicated review checkpoints for key provisions such as interest calculation methods and the conditions triggering liability for breach of contract. Standardized contracts and blank promissory notes are particularly prone to being exploited as a legal façade for subsequent fraudulent litigation; therefore, any blank clauses in a contract must be fully completed prior to signing, leaving no room for post‑hoc supplementation.
When a company detects that it may be caught in a “loan‑trap” scheme, it should promptly activate its rights‑protection mechanism. The first step is to immediately cease the practice of “using new loans to repay old ones,” thereby preventing the debt from spiraling out of control. At the same time, the company must systematically gather and preserve a comprehensive set of evidentiary materials, including contractual documents, bank statements, and all relevant communication records. In Guiding Case No. 87 of the Supreme People’s Procuratorate—the “Li Weijun et al. False Litigation Case Involving ‘Loan‑Trap’ Schemes”—the procuratorial authorities reviewed hundreds of civil litigation records and identified a pattern: the promissory notes were all standardized contracts, and most cases had been decided by default. Through coordinated criminal–civil supervision, they ultimately overturned the original judgments in 50 cases involving false litigation, effectively severing the criminal syndicate’s illicit profit‑making channels through the judicial system. This underscores the critical importance of preserving evidence and highlights that, when choosing a course of action, companies should abandon the habitual mindset of passively responding to civil litigation and instead proactively pursue criminal charges.
“Loan‑sharking schemes” have, in essence, transcended the scope of ordinary civil disputes arising from private lending, constituting a criminal offense that uses lending as a façade while concealing fraud at its core. These schemes exhibit a highly sophisticated and systematic modus operandi, employing a series of interlocking deceptive steps to ultimately achieve the unlawful appropriation of the victimized enterprise’s assets. As the financial landscape grows increasingly complex, such criminal patterns have spawned new variants, with methods becoming ever more concealed and professionally engineered. Once ensnared in these traps, enterprises face not only temporary economic losses but also an existential threat that jeopardizes their very survival. Accordingly, when confronted with such risks, companies should abandon conventional approaches to dispute resolution and promptly seek expert legal counsel with experience in cross‑border criminal–civil cases. Through meticulous legal analysis and well‑crafted litigation strategies, they can effectively safeguard their legitimate rights and interests and avoid falling into irreparable operational difficulties.
This article was published in the November 2025 issue of China Business Law, under the original title: “Characteristics and Countermeasures of ‘Ponzi Lending’ Among Enterprises” 。
Author Biography
.
Xu Rui
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Partner at Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Director of the Corporate Appeals Practice Center; holds an LL.M. from Wuhan University. In 2025, he was named GRCD China’s Young Lawyer of the Year and received both the “Crown” Rising Star Lawyer Award and the Classic Case Award at the 10th Guike Annual Conference. He specializes in commercial dispute resolution, corporate legal services, high‑profile criminal defense, and corporate compliance, having amassed extensive practical experience across these areas. He has successfully secured substantial recoveries for his clients through retrial proceedings and three‑level review procedures. His primary practice areas include major commercial disputes, criminal defense, financial loan disputes, corporate matters, and complex asset preservation and enforcement. He excels at providing sophisticated civil and commercial legal advice, corporate legal services, and criminal defense in highly complex and challenging cases, with a proven track record in commercial disputes, corporate litigation, criminal defense, financial disputes, and asset preservation and enforcement.
.
Ma Xueyan
Lawyer at Beijing Starrise Law Firm
An attorney at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, holding a Bachelor of Laws degree from China University of Political Science and Law and a Master of Laws degree from the University of Edinburgh. The firm provides clients with specialized legal services in civil and commercial matters, criminal law, corporate legal risk management, and compliance. Its principal practice areas include civil and commercial dispute resolution, criminal defense, intellectual property, corporate compliance, and corporate legal risk management.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12



