On the afternoon of December 28, 2025, The 20th “Top Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum At China University of Political Science and Law Conference Room 0111, Comprehensive Library Building, Haidian Campus Successfully held, special symposium “ The Coordination Between the Two Laws and Defense in Official Crime Cases under the “Three Transformations” Framework (Standardization, Rule of Law, and Regularization) ”。
This forum is hosted by The “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum in Beijing, co-hosted by the Institute of Evidence Science at China University of Political Science and Law, with support from Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm. The guests attending this forum included the initiators of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” forum: Yang Kuangsheng, Director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm; Xu Lanting, Attorney at Beijing Junyong Law Firm; Qian Lieyang, Director of Beijing Zihua Law Firm; Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm; Wang Zhaofeng, Director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm; Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm; Mao Lixin, Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm; Zhu Yonghui, Director of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm; and Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, and Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Yingke Law Firm, also attended the meeting and participated in the discussions.
This forum also invited Professor Liu Yanhong, Vice President of China University of Political Science and Law, to deliver the opening address, and invited… Professor Zhang Zhong, Vice Dean of the Institute of Evidence Science at China University of Political Science and Law and doctoral supervisor; Professor Li Fenfei, a dual‑appointed professor at the School of Law and the School of Discipline Inspection and Supervision of Renmin University of China, as well as a doctoral supervisor; and Associate Professor Fang Baoguo of the Institute of Evidence Science at China University of Political Science and Law served as commentators and moderators. This forum is supported by institutions including Fazhi Net, China.org.cn, and Lüshi Weiyán, with participants from… More than seventy experts, scholars, lawyers, and seasoned professionals from law schools, the legal profession, and industry media attended the event in person. The forum was simultaneously livestreamed in a hybrid online–offline format, drawing widespread attention from the legal academia, the bar, judicial authorities, and the media; online viewership reached 9,000 in real time.
✦
Opening
✦
The forum officially commenced at 2:30 p.m. The opening ceremony was chaired by Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Secretary-General of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum. Attorney Cheng Xiaolu pointed out that, This year’s forum, themed “The Coordination Between the Criminal and Administrative Laws and Defense in Cases of Official Crimes under the ‘Three‑Modernizations’ Framework,” carries distinct contemporary significance and practical value. The 20th National Congress of the Communist Party of China and the Fourth Plenary Session of the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection underscored the need to advance the standardization, rule of law, and institutionalization of discipline inspection and supervision work. This year not only marks a deepening phase in the implementation of the “three modernizations” but also sees the official entry into force of the newly revised Supervision Law. The new law introduces significant adjustments to coercive measures, detention periods, and avenues for redress of rights, while also enshrining principles such as “equal rights and responsibilities,” “protection of rights,” and “minimizing the impact of investigations on the normal operations of enterprises.” These developments signal that supervisory work has been brought firmly within the framework of the rule of law, presenting both new opportunities and challenges for criminal defense. Against the backdrop of the current “three‑pronged transformation,” what substantive, procedural, and evidentiary challenges do defenses in cases of official misconduct face, and how can lawyers, within the framework of the new legal regime, expand their roles and perform their duties effectively? These are the central issues and the underlying significance of this year’s forum.
The forum opened with a welcoming address by Professor Liu Yanhong, Vice President of China University of Political Science and Law. Professor Liu extended warm congratulations and high praise for the continued successful organization of the “Ten‑Person Criminal Defense Forum” and for its growing academic reputation. Referring to the forum’s thematic focus, she noted that defense in cases of official misconduct has long been a vital component of criminal defense practice, posing significant challenges to lawyers’ professional skills and strategic acumen. In response, the legal community has actively explored innovative approaches and distilled valuable experience, developing a well‑established set of defense strategies. Overall, the trend in defending against official‑duty crimes is positive. As the country’s rule‑of‑law agenda advances—particularly within the context of the “three modernizations”—the mechanisms linking the two laws are becoming increasingly refined, bringing a steady stream of favorable developments for such defenses. This forum brings together leading criminal defense practitioners and distinguished scholars to engage in timely, expert discussions, which will have far‑reaching implications for advancing effective advocacy in this field. Finally, Professor Liu Yanhong expressed her best wishes for the forum’s complete success.
✦
First half
✦
Fang Baoguo
The first half of the forum was hosted by Fang Baoguo, Associate Professor at the Institute of Evidence Science, China University of Political Science and Law Serve as the host.
Director of the Management Committee, Beijing Dongwei Law Firm Attorney Mao Hongtao focused on “ Three transformations Effective Defense in Second-Instance Proceedings for Official Crimes under the Given Context 》 It puts forward the following four propositions: First, establish a foundation of entrustment through mutual selection. When accepting a case, conduct a prudent assessment—begin by reviewing the first-instance judgment; if there is room for defense, thoroughly examine the entire case file—and reach a shared objective with the client, refraining from making any guarantees about the outcome. Second, secure procedural rights through absolute trust. When the court urges the submission of written submissions or seeks to proceed with an in‑court review, rely on the client’s explicit authorization and, in accordance with the law, steadfastly uphold the procedural position that “a hearing must be held whenever new evidence emerges.” Third, open up the factual battleground by proactively gathering evidence. Boldly and skillfully challenge the charges by obtaining various types of evidence—particularly objective evidence—and ensure compliance in evidence‑gathering through the presence of two witnesses and comprehensive audio‑visual recording throughout the process. Fourth, build consensus on the case through professional engagement. By engaging in rational, sustained, and constructive communication with the courts and the procuratorate regarding new evidence and legal arguments, persuade the prosecution to accept the defense’s perspective, thereby laying the groundwork for consensus that may lead to a favorable retrial. In line with the “three‑fold standardization” requirements set forth at the Fourth Plenary Session of the 20th Central Commission for Discipline Inspection, these practices embody standardized review procedures, the rule‑of‑law‑based protection of rights, and formalized operational protocols, thus advancing, on a case‑by‑case basis, the ecosystem governing the handling of official‑duty crime cases toward greater fairness and stronger safeguards for individual rights.
Lawyer Yang Kuangsheng, director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, delivered a keynote address titled “Standards for Examining Evidence in Official Crime Cases and Evidence-Based Defense.” He argued that the linkage between the two laws—namely, the supervisory commission’s investigative procedures and the criminal procedure—hinges on evidence, which is the linchpin of this interface. Lawyer Yang elaborated on four key points: First, he emphasized that the core of aligning the two legal frameworks lies in upholding uniform evidentiary standards. Since evidentiary standards remain consistent across different stages of criminal proceedings, they should likewise be consistent between official‑crime cases and other criminal cases. Second, verbal evidence in official‑crime cases must be subject to rigorous scrutiny. Because such evidence is typically gathered prior to the initiation of criminal proceedings—and in many cases relies predominantly on testimonial evidence—it is difficult to ensure its legality and authenticity merely by relying on superficial corroboration among these statements. Therefore, it is imperative to make full use of legally authorized methods to conduct stringent review; this constitutes an indispensable tool for lawyers seeking to mount effective evidence‑based defenses. Third, Should be given high priority. The current situation is characterized by a lack of effective mechanisms for reviewing testimonial evidence in cases of official misconduct, as well as significant difficulties in enabling defense counsel to mount a robust evidentiary defense. He argues that, in many cases, both lawyers and defendants raise serious challenges to the legality and authenticity of evidence, yet prosecutors and judges rely on overly narrow review procedures. They often conclude that the evidence is lawful and authentic simply because it was obtained in accordance with the law and corroborated by other evidence. Moreover, they frequently deny numerous motions filed by defense counsel. In light of these issues, Attorney Yang Kuangsheng contends that efforts to scrutinize evidence must be intensified to facilitate effective evidentiary advocacy by defense attorneys. To this end, he puts forward specific recommendations, including requiring witnesses to appear in court, permitting access to simultaneous audio‑video recordings, mandating investigators to testify and explain the circumstances, and empowering defense counsel to conduct their own investigations and gather evidence.
Attorney Xu Lanting of Beijing Junyong Law Firm delivered a presentation titled “Key Defense Points in Bribery Cases Involving Lending and Interest‑Taking.” Drawing on his experience with numerous cases he has handled, he thoroughly examined the central points of contention and the most challenging aspects of such matters. He emphasized that distinguishing between ordinary private lending and bribery disguised as lending hinges on assessing whether the borrower has a genuine need for funds, whether the parties are on equal footing, whether the agreed‑upon interest rate deviates significantly from prevailing market rates, and whether a relationship of official authority or control exists. The essence of “quid pro quo” transactions is the cornerstone for establishing the crime of bribery; absent this characteristic, a straightforward conviction is unwarranted. Addressing the typical evidentiary landscape—characterized by “one‑on‑one” testimony and the predominance of verbal evidence—Attorney Xu proposed three key avenues for defense: rigorously verifying the authenticity of the alleged funding need, meticulously identifying and comparing inconsistencies in the evidence, and convincingly demonstrating the reasonableness of the interest charged. He argued that, in defending such cases, it is essential to uphold the principle of unity between subjective and objective elements and to adhere to the presumption of innocence, thereby achieving an effective defense.
Attorney Qian Lieyang, director of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “Challenges to Evidence in Official-Crime Cases and Legal Analysis.” He… He pointed out that “the linkage between the two laws under the backdrop of the ‘three modernizations’” directly addresses the pain points of criminal defense, but its positioning and scope of application still require clarification. He Raise key questions: Is the “Three Transformations” ultimately an internal checks-and-balances mechanism within the discipline inspection system, or a quantifiable standard for external oversight? He particularly… It is crucial to examine whether the procuratorial organs’ oversight of cases handled by the supervisory authorities can be effectively implemented. He pointed out that the Criminal Procedure Law grants the procuratorate powers of supervision, such as excluding illegally obtained evidence and applying the principle of “in dubio pro reo.” However, when confronted with the supervisory authorities, whether these mechanisms can function equally remains a question that continues to be debated in practice. Particular attention should be paid to the differences between the opinion on prosecution and the indictment, as they reveal whether the procuratorial organs are truly fulfilling their supervisory duties in accordance with the law.
Attorney Qian Lieyang A typical case was shared: In traditional bribery cases, the prevailing mindset that “a business owner issues a promissory note to an official—formally a loan but in reality a bribe”—is widespread. However… In this case, the loan agreement entered into between an official and a businessman was, in fact, a joint investment arrangement, supported by evidence such as real‑estate mortgages and profit‑sharing provisions. The objective facts indicate that it constituted commercial cooperation rather than a quid pro quo involving power and money. Nevertheless, even with ample evidence, the procuratorial organ’s response remained somewhat reluctant, struggling to conduct a thorough legal analysis of the matter. In light of this, he emphasized that the critical intersection of the “three‑modernizations” initiative and the linkage between the Criminal Law and the Supervision Law lies within the procuratorate. The procuratorial organs must accurately grasp the essence of the three‑modernizations and fully implement the requirements for aligning the two laws; just as they handle criminal investigation cases, they should, in accordance with the law, overturn, rescind, or dismiss for lack of sufficient evidence those cases handled by the discipline inspection commissions, thereby truly achieving a rule‑of‑law‑based system of checks and balances on power.
Chairman of the Partners’ Meeting, Beijing Starrise Law Firm Attorney Cheng Xiaolu’s presentation was titled “ The Scope of Criminal Lawyers’ Participation and the Expansion of Their Functions in the Context of Amendments to the Supervision Law She pointed out that current defense strategies in cases of official misconduct face several pressing issues: first, defendants frequently retract their confessions after referral to the judiciary; second, the exclusionary rule is often rendered ineffective, rendering procedural defenses largely symbolic; third, external interference in retained‑defense arrangements and “placeholder” defense tactics are particularly pronounced; and fourth, separate case handling based on whether a defendant pleads guilty or not undermines the adversarial examination of evidence. The root causes include the closed nature of investigative procedures and the lack of external oversight, the weakening of the independent judgment of prosecutors and judges through hierarchical reporting mechanisms, and the real‑world professional risks that deter judicial personnel from exercising proper checks and balances. The enactment of the new Supervision Law presents both challenges—stemming from the expansion of powers—and opportunities for advancing the rule of law. Lawyers should proactively invoke the rights‑protection provisions of the new law to achieve a substantive broadening of their functions and play an active role in the process of legal reform. Specifically: first, preventive measures—providing legal training to public officials and entrepreneurs and emphasizing the importance of backing up and preserving critical documents; second, during the investigation phase—although direct access to clients is restricted, lawyers may offer legal advice to family members, assist in applying for changes to coercive measures, guide relatives in responding prudently to demands for restitution, represent clients in filing appeals in accordance with the law, and serve as agents for the disposition of assets involved in the case; and third, once the matter enters judicial proceedings, maintain comprehensive defense on both substantive and procedural grounds, actively filing all appropriate applications without hesitation, and safeguarding clients’ rights through channels such as complaints and appeals, while also exploring oversight via the system of specially appointed supervisors.
The halftime commentator is Professor Zhang Zhong, Vice Dean of the Institute of Evidence Science at China University of Political Science and Law and doctoral supervisor. He first… From case‑handling techniques and evidence review to the application of law and business development, he provided a comprehensive summary of the invaluable experience shared by the first five speakers in defending against official‑duty crimes. He then went on to point out… Evidence-based defense has become the new norm in criminal defense. Particular attention should be paid to the following aspects: the admissibility and probative value of evidence in the course of oversight proceedings; the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence; the appearance of investigators in court; the issue of identity of evidence; the examination and cross-examination of expert opinions; and… How to leverage the assistance of expert witnesses Question. Finally, Professor Zhang Zhong concluded, Defense counsel should not confine themselves to passive advocacy; rather, they ought to proactively construct an evidence‑centric defense strategy, leveraging rigorous evidentiary analysis to advance a substantive adjudication of the case and thereby achieve effective representation.
✦
Second half
✦
The second half of the forum was moderated by Attorney Wang Bo, an attorney at Beijing Shangquan Law Firm and the secretary of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum.
The first speaker in the second half of the forum was Liu Weidong, director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm, whose presentation was titled “The Determination of ‘Agreement-Based’ Bribery Should Adhere Strictly to Evidentiary Standards.” Director Liu Weidong, focusing on agreed‑upon bribery cases, outlined defense strategies from two key perspectives. First, he emphasized a fact‑ and evidence‑based approach to defense, which includes: 1. Whether there are circumstances warranting the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence; 2. Whether the verbal evidence is internally inconsistent; 3. In cases involving separate-filed proceedings, is there a situation where the related case files are incomplete or insufficient? 4. Whether the agreement is manifestly unreasonable or contrary to common sense and practice; 5. The defense has filed a motion to subpoena the audio recording to establish whether there was a situation in which the defendant read from or wrote by rote after memorizing the text; 6. “Deceptive‑leadership” agreements and “no one takes them seriously” agreements should be used with caution as bases for conviction; 7. An agreement with a specific related party should be defended not only on the basis of whether the party was “aware,” but also on the basis of whether the party “directed” or “instigated” the conduct; 8. Defending from the perspective of whether there is reasonable suspicion of profit-driven law enforcement.
Second, defense from the perspective of legal application, including: 1. On the premise that both the aforementioned facts and evidence can be established, the criminal form of “contractual‑type” bribery should be characterized as preparatory conduct rather than attempted crime; 2. The view in judicial practice that “custodial” bribery should be classified as attempted crime ought to be corrected.
Finally, he put forward two specific recommendations for judicial practice. First, With respect to convictions for “agreement‑based” bribery, the court should mitigate or exempt the punishment; where evidence already existed prior to the offense indicating that payment was impossible, prosecution should not proceed. Second, Investigating officers should abandon the presumption of guilt and prevent the trend toward the overexpansion of contractual bribery cases in judicial practice.
The topic of Attorney Wang Zhaofeng, director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, was “…” Expression of Defense Arguments in the Context of “Three Transformations” ». He pointed out, The realization of the “three‑pronged” development goals in disciplinary inspection and supervision requires both self‑discipline on the part of supervisory authorities and external oversight, including from the legal profession. For lawyers to effectively advance this “three‑pronged” agenda, they must be afforded ample opportunity to articulate their defense arguments throughout the handling of official‑duty crimes. In practice, however, during the stage of supervisory investigation, lawyers are unable to intervene, leaving the procedural and substantive rights of those under investigation inadequately protected in a timely manner. Similarly, at the review‑prosecution and trial stages, on the one hand, supervisory organs continue to wield comprehensive, end‑to‑end supervisory authority, wielding significant influence over the trajectory and outcome of cases; on the other hand, lawyers remain barred from directly conveying their views to these organs, thereby undermining the achievement of impartiality in case adjudication.
To this end, Attorney Wang Zhaofeng recommends the following: 1. During the supervisory commission’s investigation phase, lawyers should be permitted, in their capacity as family representatives, to submit evidence favorable to the person under investigation to the supervisory authority, file motions for recusal, raise objections to jurisdiction, request changes to coercive measures, and present preliminary legal opinions. 2. A new provision should be introduced stipulating that, as necessary, prior to transferring a case for review and prosecution after the conclusion of the supervisory investigation, the views of counsel must be sought. At the review-and-prosecution stage, depending on the circumstances, supervisory investigators should be invited to participate in evidence disclosure and case hearings. At the trial stage, it should be mandated that, in cases where the defendant pleads not guilty or where counsel advances an acquittal defense, the supervisory authority shall dispatch personnel to observe the proceedings. 3. It should be stipulated that, whether at the procuratorial or judicial level, when reporting to or consulting with the supervisory authority on a case, written defense submissions by counsel must be submitted concurrently. In sum, lawyers should be regarded as a constructive force in advancing the “three‑pronged” development of the supervisory system; mechanisms should be refined to encourage greater lawyer participation in the handling of official‑duty crimes, thereby accelerating the achievement of the objectives of this “three‑pronged” reform.
Lawyer Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, spoke on the topic of “ The Issue of Remedies for Non-Official Personnel When Under Investigation Under the title “...,” he shared his views on the issue of remedies available to non‑public officials when they are subject to investigation. Zhao Attorney Yun Heng It is argued that the number of entrepreneurs and other non‑public officials currently under investigation by supervisory authorities continues to rise, yet their right to legal defense remains inadequately protected in such cases. This issue should be addressed from three perspectives. First, non‑public officials are entitled to full rights of defense, and depriving them of this right lacks legitimate legal justification. This is because non‑public officials are not subject to oversight by the supervisory authorities, and thus there is no basis for applying standard disciplinary or Party‑discipline measures. Non-public officials First, being placed under residential surveillance inherently entails criminal prosecution, and those subject to such prosecution naturally enjoy the full right to defense. Second, where there is a right, there must be redress; a transitional mechanism should be established without delay, beginning with limited advocacy by lawyers, to assist persons under investigation in applying for changes to coercive measures, offering substantive defense arguments, and safeguarding their lawful property. Third, leveraging the “three‑modernizations” framework, we should intensify research on the theoretical and institutional design of the right to defense for persons under investigation, so that human rights protection can make further progress through the comprehensive and effective alignment of the two laws.
Lawyer Mao Lixin, director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “Examination and Challenge of the Authenticity of Verbal Evidence in Official Crime Cases.” He began by emphasizing that the “three modernizations” are not only requirements for disciplinary inspection and supervision work but also for anti-corruption efforts, representing a long-term task. From the perspective of evidence review, verifying the authenticity of evidence and distinguishing truth from falsehood is of paramount importance in preventing wrongful convictions. At the legislative level of criminal procedure, he proposed establishing the principle of voluntariness in confessions, excluding any non‑voluntary statements; and instituting a rule excluding hearsay evidence, under which witnesses must appear in court to testify and undergo cross-examination by both the prosecution and the defense whenever either side disputes the verbatim record of their testimony. On the technical front of defense, he shared methods for scrutinizing and challenging the authenticity of verbal evidence: first, examining the process by which such evidence was obtained—by comparing interrogation audio and video recordings with written transcripts to identify inconsistencies or “synchronous fluctuations” caused by inducement or leading questions; second, subjecting corroborating evidence to critical scrutiny, assessing whether it is admissible, originates independently, and exhibits no substantial discrepancies; third, applying common sense, everyday logic, and empirical reasoning—for evidence that appears mutually corroborative but defies common sense and logical consistency, the conclusion can only be “both false,” not “both true”; and fourth, drawing on the “anchoring narrative method” to conduct a holistic analysis of the entire case, whereby core facts such as bribery and acceptance of bribes must be anchored in a series of prerequisite and foundational facts—including the motive for bribery, the source of funds, and the destination of those funds—and if these prerequisites and foundations lack evidentiary support, the core facts will be difficult to sustain.
Attorney Zhu Yonghui, director of the Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, has put forward a systematic reflection and a gradual reform proposal regarding whether simultaneous audio‑video recording of interrogations can replace interrogation transcripts as evidence. He points out that contemporary criminal proceedings rely heavily on interrogation transcripts, which are, in fact, “secondary evidence” prone to information loss and distortion, making it difficult to fully and objectively capture the original substance of the interrogation and thus conflicting with the fundamental goal of judicial proceedings to pursue “objective truth.” By contrast, simultaneous audio‑video recording of interrogations can comprehensively, intuitively, and continuously document the entire process, capturing every detail—verbal content, tone, facial expressions, and more—and offers distinct advantages in safeguarding the voluntariness of statements, preventing unlawful evidence‑gathering, and reconstructing the facts, thereby warranting its status as a more reliable form of evidence. Nevertheless, its implementation faces practical obstacles: legally, its evidentiary standing remains unclear, and in practice it is often excluded from independent admission and examination; moreover, in day-to-day application, challenges such as time‑consuming access and relatively high storage costs persist.
In this regard, Attorney Zhu Yonghui argues that the issue can be addressed from three perspectives: First, at the legislative level, the independent evidentiary status of simultaneous audio‑video recordings during interrogations should be clearly established, enabling their lawful admission and use as a basis for adjudication. Second, during a transitional period, a rule should be instituted granting such recordings priority over written transcripts—meaning that, in cases of conflict between the two, the recording shall prevail—thereby incentivizing standardized evidence‑gathering practices. Ultimately, the long-term goal is to advance both legislative reform and a shift in practice, gradually making simultaneous audio‑video recordings the primary means of securing verbal evidence, thereby reducing or even replacing written transcripts and ensuring that courtroom proceedings are grounded in more objective and comprehensive original materials. This vision seeks to enhance judicial fairness at the very source of evidence and represents an important step toward a more rigorous and transparent criminal justice system.
Attorney Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Yingke Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “Procedural and Substantive Issues under the Expanded Application of the Crime of Unexplained Huge Wealth.” Attorney Zhao pointed out that this offense was first codified in a separate criminal statute in 1988 and incorporated into the Criminal Code in 1997. In 2009, Amendment VII to the Criminal Code raised the maximum statutory penalty from five to ten years’ imprisonment. Overall, the crime is characterized by four key features: a small number of cases, a long time span, a light burden of proof for the prosecution, and a heavy obligation on the defendant to provide explanations. From a legislative perspective, the criminalization based on the inability to account for the lawful origin of wealth essentially relies on a logic of presuming illegality, reflecting a utilitarian value orientation that conflicts with the principles of presumption of innocence and the benefit of the doubt. Citing a case he personally handled—where the period from arrest to trial was less than two months—Attorney Zhao emphasized that proving this offense is complex and requires affording the defendant’s family members sufficient time to verify their income and expenditures, which constitutes a fundamental safeguard of the right to defense. Furthermore, the People’s Procuratorate and the People’s Courts must reserve adequate time for review and preparation of the case, thereby demonstrating due diligence and ensuring “justice that can be seen.” With regard to the standards for conviction, it is essential to avoid common misconceptions and clearly distinguish between the burden of proof and the standard of proof. The crime of unexplained huge wealth does not constitute a case of reversed burden of proof; the objective accuracy of the discrepancy between assets and income remains the responsibility of the public prosecutor. If the factual basis underlying the alleged shortfall is unclear or the evidence is insufficient, the adverse consequences of the charge should fall on the prosecution, rather than shifting the burden of explaining the source onto the defendant. Looking ahead, efforts should be strengthened to standardize investigations into this offense and to rigorously uphold the evidentiary standard of “beyond a reasonable doubt.”
In the final segment of the conference, Professor Li Fenfei, a jointly appointed professor at the Law School and the Institute of Discipline Inspection and Supervision of Renmin University of China, as well as a doctoral supervisor, provided commentary on the speakers who presented in the second half of the session. Professor Li first commended the forum’s theoretical and practical significance, noting that the key issues highlighted by the speakers—drawn from their experience in case handling—were both incisive and well‑grounded. He emphasized that the cornerstone of the “three‑pronged” development of supervisory work is the rule of law, and that lawyers can play a constructive role in this process; moreover, certain misconceptions about the legal profession still require clarification.
Against the backdrop of the fourth amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law, Professor Li Fenfei argues that the revision should seek to enhance the coordination and checks-and-balances among legal institutions in the following ways: First, refine the mechanism of mutual cooperation and restraint, ensuring that the inter‑agency arrangements are effectively implemented. In particular, it is necessary to address the persistent imbalance in practice—where cooperation is ample but oversight remains inadequate. To this end, the next amendment could further elaborate the principle of mutual cooperation and restraint among the three principal organs; for instance, by extending this framework to include the supervisory authorities, thereby establishing a four‑organ system of coordinated oversight and checks. Second, improve the procuratorial‑investigative system by clearly defining the conditions, modalities, timing, and feedback mechanisms for early intervention, enabling the procuratorate to participate in the supervisory authorities’ criminal investigations, gain real‑time insight into the entire investigative process, and provide constructive recommendations to the supervisory body. Third, strengthen the procuratorate’s power of independent investigation. Fourth, refine the specific application of the lenient treatment system for those who plead guilty and accept punishment during the supervisory investigation stage. Fifth, enhance the evidence‑linkage mechanism by introducing provisions that allow evidence collected by the supervisory authorities in the course of investigating official misconduct to be admissible in subsequent criminal proceedings.
Professor Li Fenfei concluded by noting that the interface between the Supervision Law and the Criminal Procedure Law remains a major issue requiring ongoing attention. However, the law‑making process should proceed with due caution to avoid proposing overly radical amendments; it may be advisable to prioritize incorporating provisions supported by practical experience into the legislative revision.
The 20th “Top Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum After four hours, the event concluded successfully. This forum brought together practitioners and academics to engage in in-depth discussions on the key and challenging issues in defending against official‑duty crimes, offering valuable insights for overcoming the difficulties in aligning the two legal frameworks and for elevating the quality of such defense. It also holds significant positive implications for advancing the rule of law in criminal justice. Thank you to all the experts and scholars for their insightful presentations and clarifications. We look forward to the next gathering of the “Ten Criminal Defense Experts” Forum!
Introduction to the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum
“The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, It was jointly initiated and established in early 2018 by ten criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. The initiators include: Yang Kuangsheng of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, Xu Lanting of Beijing Junyong Law Firm, Qian Lieyang of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, Hao Chunli of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm, Liu Weidong of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm, Wang Zhaofeng of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, Zhao Yunheng of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, Mao Lixin of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, Zhu Yonghui of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, Beijing… Dongwei Law Firm Mao Hongtao and nine other criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, serves as the Forum’s Secretary-General, while Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Management Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm, holds the position of Deputy Secretary-General.
The purpose of establishing this forum is: Jointly examine cutting-edge issues in criminal defense, advance the professionalization and standardization of criminal advocacy, promote a rational and reasoned culture of criminal defense, foster a harmonious and mutually reinforcing criminal-defense ecosystem, and contribute modest yet meaningful efforts to the development of criminal defense and the rule of law in China.
Since the establishment of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, it has successively convened discussions on topics including: “Criminal Defense in the Context of the Implementation of the Supervision Law”; “The Draft Amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law”; “The Impact of the Integration of Arrest and Prosecution on Criminal Defense”; “The Current Situation of Difficult Access to Clients and the Protection of Lawyers’ Defense Rights”; “Protection of Property Rights of Private Entrepreneurs Involved in Criminal Cases”; “An Interpretation of the ‘Four Opinions’ on Cases Involving the Campaign Against Organized Crime and Evil Forces”; “Practical Issues in Defending Financial‑Related Crimes”; “The Application of Evidence Rules in Criminal Defense”; “The Relationship Among Prosecution, Defense, and Adjudication in Cases Involving Plea Bargaining and Acceptance of Punishment”; and “The Implications and Changes Brought by the Interpretation of the New Criminal Procedure Law for Criminal Defense.” “The 11th ‘Ten-Person Forum on Criminal Defense’ and Symposium on Lawyers’ Participation in Corporate Compliance” “Implementation of the Legal Aid Law and Criminal Defense” “Defense in Fraud Crimes” “The Necessity of Holding Criminal Second-Instance Trials and Ways to Improve Them” “Prevention and Correction of Wrongful Cases Involving Enterprises, Along with Mechanisms for Appeals and Retrials” “Challenges and Strategies in Defending Against Financial and Securities‑Related Crimes” “Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law and the Improvement of the Defense System” “Evidence-Based Defense Practice: Principles and Methods” “Reflections on and Improvements to the Current Relationship Between Defense and Trial” The Coordination Between the Two Laws and Defense in Official Crime Cases under the “Three Transformations” Framework (Standardization, Rule of Law, and Regularization) ” It has organized twenty specialized forums on topical and cutting-edge issues in the field of criminal justice. Each forum invites experts from legislative and judicial bodies, criminal law scholars, renowned defense attorneys, and stakeholders across various sectors who are concerned with criminal defense, to offer multifaceted perspectives on the practice of criminal defense, examine related legislative and practical issues, and advance the rule of law in criminal matters, thereby generating a positive social impact.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee
Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12