Recently, Director Wang Jun of Beijing Starrise Law Firm was invited by the Institute of Evidence Science at China University of Political Science and Law to serve as a lecturer for the course “Criminal Defense and Representation Practice.” She delivered a specialized presentation that seamlessly integrated theory with practice, titled “From a Humanities Background to a Scientific One: A Shift in Thinking in Electronic Evidence Defense,” which elicited an enthusiastic response from both faculty and students.
Director Wang Jun began by noting that the professionalization of the legal profession has become an inevitable trend. In cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, and Shenzhen, lawyers’ areas of expertise are becoming increasingly distinct, and the industry is shifting from traditional practice‑area categorization toward sector‑specific specialization and further subdivision within those fields. Electronic evidence has emerged as a key niche within criminal defense. At the same time, multidisciplinary competencies have become essential; even humanities graduates must combine quantitative reasoning with technical thinking to excel in the field of electronic evidence.
The outcomes of effective defense are diverse and extend beyond mere acquittals by the court. Cases dismissed during the investigation phase, release on bail pending trial, non-prosecution decisions at the review-and-prosecution stage, as well as suspended sentences and actual sentencing with full restitution, all constitute meaningful results. However, in practice, the rate of acquittals remains extremely low, owing to the considerable difficulty of persuading multiple stakeholders and the potential for internal accountability. Director Wang Jun particularly underscores the critical importance of the “golden 37-day rescue period” in criminal proceedings; this phase represents a pivotal juncture between guilt and innocence, making it essential to advance defense efforts proactively. Furthermore, defense strategies should be broadened to encompass property‑related defenses and to leverage expert witnesses and the examination of electronic evidence, thereby bolstering the defense; the preservation and scrutiny of electronic evidence have become pivotal tools.
Taking the case of operating an illegal casino as an example, Director Wang Jun provided a detailed explanation of the investigative approach—starting with identifying anomalies, then delving deeply to verify the legality of evidence collection. From uncovering jurisdictional irregularities tied to timing and location, to mining backend data for clues of procedural violations by investigative authorities, to detecting signs of falsification in forensic samples and expert reports, and finally to invoking procedural invalidity to request recusal of relevant personnel, the presentation unfolded in a step-by-step manner, laying out a comprehensive defense‑logic chain. Regarding the extraction, preservation, and retrieval of electronic evidence, image‑based copying serves as the core method for ensuring evidentiary integrity, safeguarding the four essential attributes of electronic data. The procurement of forensic samples must be grounded in reasonable suspicion specific to the case to persuade the court. Attention should also be paid to the preservation inventory, the source of the evidence, and the form of its preservation, with hash values employed to validate the authenticity of the data.
Different stakeholders each have distinct responsibilities in the review and application of electronic evidence. Lawyers must proactively conduct reviews, meticulously craft expert‑witness requests, and cultivate a foundational technical mindset. While blockchain‑based evidence preservation at Internet courts offers both advantages and limitations, it should be supplemented with forensic techniques to verify the integrity of the original data. Expert assistants, leveraging specialized tools for analysis, can help address lawyers’ technical shortcomings; meanwhile, lawyers should serve as effective intermediaries, ensuring that expert opinions are deployed to their fullest potential.
The authentication of electronic evidence revolves around its authenticity, legality, and relevance. Legality must be corroborated by both authenticity and relevance to exclude illegally obtained evidence; authenticity is closely linked to integrity, with the primary safeguards being the original storage medium, hash‑value verification, and the reproducibility of the extraction process; relevance is a key focus for the courts, requiring proof of the connection between persons and devices, as well as between devices and data, thereby establishing a closed loop through objective parameters.
Through cases involving the infringement of citizens’ personal information, embezzlement, Software copyright cases Through the analysis of several landmark cases, Director Wang Jun demonstrated the practical application of electronic‑evidence‑based defense across different types of criminal proceedings. In a case involving the infringement of citizens’ personal information, she successfully challenged the core expert opinion by mounting a dual‑pronged challenge—both procedurally and substantively. In a corruption case, she reconstructed the flow of funds using electronic evidence, thereby mitigating the severity of the sentence; in… Software copyright cases In this context, three-dimensional verification requirements are proposed, and open-source code is excluded.
During the three-hour lecture, Director Wang Jun not only provided an in-depth exposition of specialized knowledge but also engaged actively with the audience through questions and answers, guiding them to deepen their understanding through critical reflection. The session was rich in content and illustrated with vivid real-world examples, opening up a fresh perspective on the defense of electronic evidence for the students.
This session not only helped students at the Law University establish a systematic framework for understanding electronic‑evidence‑based defense, but also, through the analysis of real cases and the sharing of practical experience, enabled them to gain a more intuitive grasp of the logic underlying the application of electronic evidence in judicial practice, thereby achieving a genuine integration of academic theory and bar‑firm practice. Beijing Starrise Law Firm will continue to organize such knowledge‑sharing events, fostering legal talent and contributing its professional expertise to the advancement of the rule of law.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee
Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12