CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

On the afternoon of March 26, 2026, The 21st “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum At Beijing Shangquan Law Firm Successfully held, special symposium “ Examination and Cross-Examination of Oral Evidence ”。



This forum is hosted by The forum was hosted by the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” of Beijing and co-organized by Beijing Shangquan Law Firm. The guests attending this forum include the initiators of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum: Yang Kuangsheng, Director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm; Xu Lanting, Honorary Director of Beijing Junyong Law Firm; Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm; Wang Zhaofeng, Director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm; Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm; Mao Lixin, Honorary Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm; Zhu Yonghui, Director of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm; and Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, and Chang Xiao, an attorney at Beijing Zihua Law Firm, attended the meeting and participated in the seminar.


This forum also invited Professor Zhang Baosheng, former Vice President of China University of Political Science and Law, Honorary Dean of the Institute of Evidence Science, Co-Director of the Collaborative Innovation Center for Judicial Civilization, and a professor and doctoral supervisor, as well as Professor Liu Jihua, Director of the Department of Procedural Law at the School of Law of Renmin University of China, and a professor and doctoral supervisor, to serve as commentators. Yang Dakang, the host of the legal self-media platform “Dakang’s Living Room,” served as the moderator. From More than sixty experts, scholars, lawyers, and seasoned professionals from law schools and the legal community attended the event in person. The forum was simultaneously livestreamed in a hybrid online–offline format, drawing widespread attention from the legal academia, the bar, judicial authorities, and the media; nearly 5,000 viewers tuned in live online.


✦

Opening

✦

Cheng Xiaolu

The forum officially commenced at 1:30 p.m. The opening ceremony was chaired by Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Secretary-General of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum. Attorney Cheng Xiaolu pointed out that, This year’s forum Coinciding with the 20th anniversary of Shangquan Law Firm, this occasion holds special commemorative significance. This year marks the ninth anniversary of the establishment of the Ten‑Person Criminal Defense Forum. After nine years—a full cycle—the forum has returned to Shangquan Law Firm, the venue of its inaugural session. This is both a return to our original aspirations and the launch of a new journey. Over the past nine years, “The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” The forum has consistently upheld the principles of innovation, pragmatism, rationality, and continuous improvement, focusing on the pressing issues, challenging problems, and persistent pain points in criminal justice practice, thereby offering thoughtful insights that are both insightful and grounded in real‑world experience. Attorney Cheng Xiaolu pointed out that, This forum focuses on “The Examination and Cross-Examination of Oral Evidence.” ” This topic, seemingly traditional yet perpetually relevant, underscores the central role of testimonial evidence in criminal proceedings. However, due to its inherent subjectivity, volatility, and malleability, it serves both as a window into the truth of a case and as a potential catalyst for miscarriages of justice. Against the backdrop of the ongoing substantive transformation of courtroom trials and the deepening application of evidentiary adjudication principles, the challenge of penetrating the opacity of testimonial evidence—accurately assessing its “three characteristics,” and employing procedural rules, empirical norms, and logical reasoning to conduct effective cross-examination—directly determines the success of effective defense and the realization of judicial fairness. This issue warrants thorough, rational, and systematic reflection within the legal profession, which is precisely the focus and significance of this year’s forum.


Gao Wenlong

The forum opened with a welcoming address by Gao Wenlong, Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm. Director Gao first extended, on behalf of Shangquan, a warm welcome to all the distinguished guests. He then traced the origins of the Criminal Defense Ten‑Person Forum and its close ties with Shangquan, noting that the Forum “dares to speak, can speak, and knows how to speak,” consistently providing lawyers with opportunities and a platform to engage in the building of the rule of law and advance legal progress—values that align closely with Shangquan’s own philosophy. This year marks the 20th anniversary of Shangquan’s founding; over the past two decades, the firm has steadfastly pursued standardization, refinement, and scholarly rigor in criminal defense, striving to achieve an even higher level of professional excellence. Director Gao went on to announce that, to commemorate its 20th anniversary, Shangquan will host a series of events, inviting all to join. Shangquan stands ready to work alongside all legal colleagues, including the Criminal Defense Ten‑Person Forum, to contribute to every incremental step forward in China’s criminal rule of law. In closing, Director Gao expressed his best wishes for the complete success of this forum.


✦

First half

✦

Wang Bo

The first half of the forum was chaired by Attorney Wang Bo, a partner at Beijing Shangquan Law Firm and secretary of the Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers Forum. Serve as the host.


Yang Kuangsheng

The first speaker in the first half of the forum was Attorney Yang Kuangsheng, director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, who delivered a keynote address on “Review Procedures and Strategies for Overcoming Challenges in Verbal Evidence in Criminal Defense.” Attorney Yang argued that evidence serves as the foundation for establishing the facts of a case, and that the examination of evidence is the most critical task in criminal proceedings. He noted that current judicial practice faces numerous issues in evidence review that urgently require resolution. To address these challenges, he advanced four fundamental propositions. First, Attorney Yang maintained that verbal evidence must be subjected to comprehensive, rigorous scrutiny through a variety of measures; the practice of relying solely on corroboration among verbal statements should be abandoned. This approach is both an intrinsic requirement stemming from the unique characteristics of verbal evidence in criminal proceedings and an objective necessity dictated by the current state of its admissibility. Second, he contended that many of the measures prescribed in the Criminal Procedure Law should be employed as tools for reviewing verbal evidence. He urged prosecutors and judges to proactively fulfill their duties, adopting diverse methods to strengthen the examination of such evidence. Third, Attorney Yang emphasized that defense counsel should vigorously seek to utilize review measures that require authorization or cooperation from the investigating authorities—such as requesting witnesses to appear in court or applying to access audio‑visual recordings—and that the procuratorial organs and the courts should provide full support. Finally, he stressed that lawyers should make full and effective use of those measures they can independently employ, such as meeting with clients to verify evidence and conducting investigations to gather proof, ensuring that defense counsel are both capable of and adept at deploying these tools. In addition, Attorney Yang put forward several recommendations, calling for legislative and institutional improvements in the review of verbal evidence as part of ongoing reforms to the Criminal Procedure Law and the broader judicial system.


Always smile

Attorney Chang Xiao of Beijing Zihua Law Firm delivered a keynote address on behalf of Attorney Qian Lieyang, the director of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, titled “Procedural Reflections on a Defendant’s In‑Court Reversal of Plea.” The presentation pointed out that, in judicial practice, a persistent phenomenon has long existed: after a defendant makes a guilty plea during the investigation phase and subsequently retracts it in court, prosecutors often suppress such a reversal on the grounds of “poor attitude toward admitting guilt,” while the court relies on the signed pretrial interrogation record as the basis for conviction. This practice—focusing on reviewing case files rather than examining the defendant in person—fundamentally conflicts with the requirement of substantive courtroom proceedings.


Attorney Chang Xiao conducts an analysis from three perspectives: the legal efficacy of pretrial statements, extraterritorial rules governing such statements, and domestic interpretive approaches. In terms of legal characterization, pretrial statements are confessions obtained during the investigative phase and serve as the basis for the public prosecution authority’s review and decision to prosecute; they do not constitute evidence for conviction in court. Treating pretrial statements as the primary basis for conviction introduces an additional hurdle to the court’s efforts to ascertain the factual truth. Accordingly, pretrial statements should be classified as evidence supporting the public prosecution, while, in principle, evidence used for conviction ought to be limited to on‑the‑spot admissions made in court, thereby aligning with the requirement of substantive courtroom proceedings.


With regard to extraterritorial experience, in both common law jurisdictions and civil law systems such as Germany and Japan, the evidentiary status of pretrial statements is subject to strict limitations. In common law systems, the authenticity of oral evidence is scrutinized through cross-examination, and pretrial statements are generally excluded. Under Article 250 of the German Code of Criminal Procedure, the “principle of personal examination” is enshrined, prohibiting the reading of interrogation transcripts in lieu of on‑court questioning; accordingly, pretrial statements are, in principle, deemed inadmissible as evidence.


With respect to China’s current legal framework, Attorney Chang Xiao cited Article 83 of the Interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law, noting that the admission of pretrial statements requires the simultaneous fulfillment of two conditions: “the reason for retracting the statement cannot be reasonably explained” and “the pretrial statement is corroborated by other evidence.” Moreover, the law stipulates that such statements may be admitted, rather than must be admitted. The speaker argued that the legislative intent behind this judicial interpretation adopts a cautious approach toward the admissibility of pretrial records in cases of recantation, thereby preserving legal room for defense counsel. However, in practice, some judicial authorities have yet to fully translate this provision into consistent interpretation and application.


Liu Weidong

The speech titled “…” was delivered by Attorney Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm. How to Successfully Exclude Illegally Obtained Testimonial Evidence: Examples from Several Real Cases I Have Handled 》. Director Liu Weidong first presented seven cases in which he successfully excluded illegally obtained testimonial evidence, and summarized the key strategies for excluding such evidence at each stage of the proceedings: obtaining hospital medical records and detention center intake schedules; requesting witnesses to appear in court; retrieving favorable statements that had not been produced; reviewing and copying synchronized audio‑video recordings; and conducting cross‑examination during trial. Through these cases, Director Liu Weidong shared insights on testimonial evidence. Three insights regarding the types of non‑infringement defenses, the timeframes for asserting such defenses, and how to do so. Finally, Director Liu Weidong put forward three recommendations regarding the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence: First, evidence that has already been excluded at the first-instance stage should be removed from the case file at the second instance and should no longer be subject to review; second, he suggested that the Supreme People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate publicly disclose the number of such exclusions in their annual work reports, thereby encouraging the emergence of more cases involving the exclusion of illegal evidence; and third, he recommended that the legal profession organize more seminars on the theory and practice of excluding illegally obtained evidence, pooling collective wisdom to produce a greater number of landmark cases in this area.


Xu Lanting

Attorney Xu Lanting, Honorary Director of Beijing Junyong Law Firm He delivered a presentation titled “Methods and Techniques for Examining Verbal Evidence—From the Perspective of Bribery Cases.” He pointed out that bribery cases are highly concealed, with relatively limited objective evidence, making verbal testimony the focal point of both case substantiation and courtroom cross-examination. However, “consistent confessions” do not automatically equate to “clear facts,” nor does “abundant testimony” necessarily mean that “the evidence is solid and sufficient.” Drawing on his practical experience, Attorney Xu outlined a systematic approach to reviewing and challenging verbal evidence, examining whether the confession‑forming process was complete, whether the actor and method were lawful, whether the content could withstand scrutiny under rules of experience and corroborating objective evidence, and whether simultaneous audio‑video recording and any recantations revealed procedural or factual issues. He emphasized the need to integrate procedural review, content comparison, and objective verification, so as to prevent substituting superficial consistency for factual determination and to uphold the principles of evidentiary adjudication and stringent standards of proof.


Wang Zhaofeng

The title of the speech delivered by Wang Zhaofeng, director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, was “…” The Underlying Logic of the Examination and Cross-Examination of Verbal Evidence ». Attorney Wang Zhaofeng argues that verbal evidence attracts particular attention because, in practice, such evidence is often found to be unlawful or unreliable, yet it is frequently admitted—making it one of the key factors contributing to wrongful convictions. To scrutinize and challenge verbal evidence, it is essential to understand its forms and distinctive characteristics. In… In terms of form, verbal evidence can be categorized into on‑scene statements, contemporaneous audio‑video recordings, and written transcripts, with the amount of information and reliability decreasing in that order. Verbal evidence is also characterized by subjectivity and volatility; therefore, it must be scrutinized and challenged from multiple angles, including the identity of the evidence‑providing party, the entity conducting the collection, the circumstances of collection, and the methods employed. Attorney Wang Zhaofeng further recommends that future legislation establish a system mandating the presence of defense counsel during investigative and inquiry proceedings; in the interim, the evidentiary status of audio‑video recordings should be clearly defined and subjected to examination and cross‑examination; moreover, courts should work to increase the rate at which witnesses appear in court, among other measures.


Liu Plan

Upper half of the forum The commentator for the event is Professor Liu Jihua, Director of the Litigation Law Teaching and Research Section at the School of Law of Renmin University of China and a doctoral supervisor. He… It is believed that the forum’s agenda closely addresses the cutting-edge challenges and hot topics in criminal defense, offering not only valuable insights for professional discourse but also serving as an important reference for legislative drafting, legal amendment, and judicial reform. Professor Liu Jihua points out that verbal evidence is of paramount importance in criminal trials, yet its subjective nature and susceptibility to change pose significant risks to fact-finding. He argues that many of the challenges lawyers currently face in practice—such as low rates of witness attendance—stem from gaps in the legislative framework, and that discussions of these issues should move beyond the confines of judicial practice. Technical level Rise to be against An Analysis of the Legislative Origins 。


Subsequently, Professor Liu Jihua, by comparing foreign systems governing witness testimony in court, pointed out that… China’s Criminal Procedure Law “emphasizes investigation while downplaying trial.” ” structural issues. He pointed out that the current legislative framework imposes institutional barriers to witness testimony in court: Article 192 of the Criminal Procedure Law vests the decision on whether a witness shall appear in court at the discretion of the court, resulting in frequent denials of defense counsel’s requests to summon witnesses and rendering courtroom proceedings largely formalistic. He proposed drawing on the legislative experience of civil law jurisdictions by enshrining the right of defendants and their defense counsel to call witnesses as a matter of principle, rather than leaving it to the judge’s discretion, and thereby advancing the establishment of a compulsory witness‑appearance regime in ordinary‑procedure cases.


Professor Liu Jihua concluded by emphasizing that lawyers are a vital force in the criminal justice system; without effective legal representation, judicial fairness cannot be achieved. He called on both the academic and practitioner communities to work together to advance legislative reform. Only by addressing fundamental issues—such as witness testimony in court—through legislation can the trial process fully fulfill its role and enable the litigation‑system reform centered on adjudication.


✦

Second half

✦

Yang Dakang

The second half of the forum was moderated by Yang Dakang, the founder of the legal self-media platform “Dakang Parlor.”


Zhao Yunheng

The first speaker in the second half of the forum was Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, who presented on “The Impact of Defense‑Initiated Evidence Collection on the Cross‑Examination of Prosecution Witnesses’ Testimonies.” Director Zhao argued that when confronting the prosecution’s transcripts of testimonial evidence—such as witness statements—merely pointing out discrepancies, identifying loopholes, or consulting corroborating recordings is far from sufficient to challenge their legality and authenticity. Rather, where conditions permit, lawyers must proactively conduct independent investigations and gather evidence to address the common issues of selective and one‑sided testimony, contradictory statements, and false testimony.


Director Zhao Yunheng believes that evidence collection must both mitigate professional risks and remain objective and effective, and can be conducted through three approaches: first, taking witness statements accompanied by continuous audio recording; second, conducting on-site visits and recording video at the scene; and third, issuing a formal inquiry letter to the witness, requesting clarification and the submission of any new evidence. Following evidence collection, the prosecution’s witness statements may have the following implications: they may prompt the panel of judges to raise doubts, leading to further investigation by the court or the prosecution; the court may summon the witness to appear in court for cross-examination; or the panel of judges may directly reject the prosecution’s witness statements, refusing to rely on them as the basis for a verdict.

                                                   

Mao Lixin

Lawyer Mao Lixin, Honorary Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “From ‘Three Characteristics’ to ‘Two Forces’: A Progressive Review Method for Verbal Evidence.” He began by pointing out that, given the fact that verbal evidence often constitutes the largest portion of the prosecution’s evidentiary framework, presents the most pressing challenges, and is the most difficult to challenge—while simultaneously exhibiting direct probative value yet questionable informational reliability—it must undergo comprehensive review and thorough cross-examination before it can serve as the basis for a verdict. The examination and cross‑examination of verbal evidence should proceed along the lines of the evidence’s “three characteristics”—legality, relevance, and authenticity—and the myriad elements associated with each; however, the ultimate conclusions and evidentiary opinions must ultimately be grounded in the “two forces”—evidentiary admissibility and probative value. The progressive review process unfolds as follows: first, assess the relevance of the evidence; if it is irrelevant, it is not admissible as evidence. Next, evaluate its admissibility; any evidence that, under the law, must be excluded may not proceed to courtroom examination. Thereafter, scrutinize the evidence’s authenticity and credibility; only evidence verified as true may be used as the basis for a judgment. Finally, leveraging such admissible evidence, construct an evidentiary chain and system, and arrive at the factual findings of the case through logical reasoning. This is a complex procedure that takes the “three characteristics” as its starting point and culminates in the “two forces,” seeking to separate the genuine from the spurious and retain the essential while discarding the superfluous. Moreover, the review and cross‑examination of verbal evidence may be conducted comprehensively through methods such as examining contemporaneous audio‑visual recordings, conducting proactive investigations and evidence collection, requesting witnesses to appear in court, and engaging in cross‑examination.


Zhu Yonghui

Attorney Zhu Yonghui, director of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, delivered a presentation on the topic “How to Use Simultaneous Audio and Video Recordings to Challenge Verbal Evidence.” He provided a legal analysis and practical insights across five key areas: the nature and functional role of such recordings; the statutory circumstances mandating their use; the legal consequences of missing recordings or inconsistencies between recordings and written transcripts; the authority of lawyers, prosecutors, and judicial organs to obtain these recordings; and strategies for leveraging recordings to scrutinize and challenge written records. Attorney Zhu emphasized that simultaneous audio‑video recordings are indispensable for establishing both the legality of investigative procedures and the authenticity of recorded statements. Accordingly, Chinese law imposes recording requirements on the investigative activities of public security organs and procuratorates, as well as on the inquiry processes conducted by supervisory authorities. Moreover, judicial interpretations explicitly stipulate that, in cases where there is a material discrepancy between the transcript and the recording, the audio‑video record shall prevail—providing a clear legal basis for defense counsel to challenge verbal evidence by cross‑checking against the recordings. Attorney Zhu acknowledged that lawyers currently face a dual challenge in accessing these recordings: stringent legal provisions coupled with practical obstacles. The regulations governing the inspection and copying of such recordings are particularly burdensome for attorneys, underscoring the need for legislative refinement in the future. He further noted that, when employing recordings to challenge verbal evidence, practitioners should focus on two primary objectives: excluding illegally obtained statements and mitigating the probative value of statements tainted by procedural defects. A comprehensive review should be conducted from the perspectives of formal legality and substantive truthfulness, with particular attention paid to meticulously and rigorously conducting a reverse‑engineering analysis of the mandatory norms set forth in laws and judicial interpretations. Only through such a thorough and systematic approach can effective challenges to verbal evidence be mounted.


Mao Hongtao

Lawyer Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm, delivered a presentation titled “Three Dimensions of Verbal Evidence Review—Illustrated by Three Real-World Cases.” Drawing on cases he personally handled, he emphasized that the examination of verbal evidence encompasses legal, factual, and psychological dimensions, and that effective advocacy requires addressing these issues from procedural, objective, and logical perspectives.


First, from the procedural perspective, the key lies in the application of the exclusionary rule for illegally obtained evidence. Take, for example, a case involving a senior executive of a state-owned enterprise accused of embezzlement, bribery, and accepting bribes: when there are suspicions of unlawful evidence‑gathering practices such as torture or coercive interrogation, the defense counsel should promptly identify such violations and, in accordance with the law, move to exclude the illegally obtained evidence. Upholding the bottom line of procedural justice is the primary prerequisite for effective advocacy.


Second, the objective dimension centers on verifying the authenticity of testimonial evidence through objective proof. Taking the case of a private entrepreneur suspected of bribery as an example, when testimonial evidence appears seamless and irrefutable, the defense counsel should proactively transcend the limitations of such testimony and diligently obtain objective evidence, such as financial records and bank transaction statements. If objective evidence conflicts with testimonial evidence, the objective evidence shall prevail.


Third, from the perspective of logic, the key lies in assessing the admissibility of evidence based on common sense and ordinary reasoning. When there are neither procedural defects nor objective corroborating evidence, defense counsel should rely on logic, common sense, and an understanding of human nature to conduct their review. Take, for example, a case involving a female entrepreneur accused of accepting bribes, leveraging influence to solicit bribes, and corporate bribery: false statements often cannot withstand scrutiny by common sense, and fabricated narratives inevitably reveal inconsistencies when subjected to logical inquiry. Whenever testimonial evidence contradicts basic everyday常识, its authenticity should be viewed with heightened caution.


Attorney Mao Hongtao concluded by emphasizing that effective advocacy requires both a keen focus on testimonial evidence and the ability to step back and scrutinize such evidence critically. At the same time, defense counsel must possess the courage and competence to conduct thorough investigations and gather evidence. Only in this way can one wield the three “keys” of procedure, objectivity, and logic to navigate the labyrinth of testimonial evidence and secure a just outcome.


Cheng Xiaolu

Chairman of the Partners’ Meeting, Beijing Starrise Law Firm Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, drawing on cases she has personally handled, analyzes the challenges of excluding illegally obtained verbal evidence in bribery cases and the corresponding strategies from four perspectives: First, the “inherent flaws” and “man-made risks” of testimonial evidence. Bribery cases rely excessively on verbal testimony, which is prone to fabrication; record‑keeping and transfer are often selective; and “corroboration” between statements does not necessarily reflect the truth. Even seemingly consistent confessions frequently lack objective corroboration and cannot withstand scrutiny of their details. Second, typical patterns of unlawful evidence‑gathering. Investigative authorities frequently threaten the safety of family members, combine deception with inducements, make arbitrary promises of favorable sentencing, and even retroactively sign or tamper with official records. Third, practical challenges in excluding illegally obtained evidence. Taking the first‑instance judgment in the bribery case involving Defendant Huang as an example, the court shifted the burden of proof to the defense, used “signed confirmation” as rebuttal to demonstrate legality, and declined to subpoena crucial audio‑visual recordings on the grounds that they were unnecessary. Fourth, avoid passive cross‑examination; take proactive measures instead. During meetings, precisely document leads indicating unlawful evidence‑gathering; lawfully and boldly conduct investigations and collect evidence from key witnesses; file targeted applications to obtain synchronized recordings from critical time periods; request that investigators appear in court; scrutinize testimonial evidence for internal contradictions; apply rules of experience to assess reasonableness; and, if reasonable doubts about the legality of unlawfully obtained evidence persist, insist on ruling such evidence inadmissible. By deploying this comprehensive set of strategies, we can compel judicial authorities to fulfill their statutory duty of review.


Zhang Baosheng

In the final segment of the conference, Professor Zhang Baosheng, former Vice President of China University of Political Science and Law, Honorary Dean of the Institute of Evidence Science, Co-Director of the Collaborative Innovation Center for Judicial Civilization, and doctoral supervisor, Provide commentary on the speakers from the second half. Professor Zhang Baosheng began by summarizing the key points of each speaker’s remarks, affirming the practical significance of the seminar’s theme, and emphasizing that evidence analysis and reasoning are fundamental skills for lawyers, with cross-examination occupying a central role in criminal defense. Focusing on the topic of cross-examination, Professor Zhang Baosheng emphasized four key aspects: first, the prerequisite for cross-examination is to heighten awareness of the importance of witness testimony in court and, from the perspective of human rights protection, to advance the effective implementation of the right to cross-examine. Second, the scope of evidentiary challenge should shift from “two forces” to the four dimensions of credibility; third, with respect to methods of evidentiary challenge—cross-examination and confrontation—the right of the defendant to confront witnesses must be given greater weight. Fourth, emphasis should be placed on challenging the evidentiary process; the focus ought to shift from static analysis of evidence to dynamic reasoning, with inductive inference and common social knowledge employed to support the proof.


Professor Zhang Baosheng further pointed out that contemporary criminal proceedings suffer from an overreliance on corroboration, and recommended replacing the concepts of “corroboration” and “evidence chain” with “proof” and “chains of reasoning,” thereby advancing the scientific and rational transformation of evidence analysis. Drawing on specific cases, he also examined issues related to the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence, the video recording of interrogation transcripts, and the admissibility of physical evidence, calling for strengthened institutional refinement of evidentiary rules in the course of revising the Criminal Procedure Law. Professor Zhang Baosheng concluded by emphasizing that evidence law is a vital cornerstone of the rule of law, and that in the future, greater attention should be given to both the theory and practice of evidentiary reasoning, thereby advancing criminal justice.


The 21st “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum After four and a half hours, the event concluded successfully. This forum brought together practitioners and academics to engage in in-depth discussions on the examination and cross-examination of testimonial evidence, as well as related pressing and challenging issues. It put forward constructive recommendations for revising the statutory provisions in the Criminal Procedure Law pertaining to the review of testimonial evidence and the appearance of witnesses in court, thereby contributing positively to the advancement of criminal justice reform. We extend our gratitude to all the experts and scholars for their insightful presentations and clarifications, and look forward to the next gathering of the “Ten Criminal Defense Experts” Forum!


Introduction to the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum

“The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, It was jointly initiated and established in early 2018 by ten criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. The initiators include: Yang Kuangsheng of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, Xu Lanting of Beijing Junyong Law Firm, Qian Lieyang of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, Hao Chunli of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm, Liu Weidong of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm, Wang Zhaofeng of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, Zhao Yunheng of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, Mao Lixin of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, Zhu Yonghui of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, Beijing… Dongwei Law Firm Mao Hongtao and nine other criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, serves as the Forum’s Secretary-General, while Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Management Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm, holds the position of Deputy Secretary-General.


The purpose of establishing this forum is: Jointly examine cutting-edge issues in criminal defense, advance the professionalization and standardization of criminal advocacy, promote a rational and reasoned culture of criminal defense, foster a harmonious and mutually reinforcing ecosystem for criminal defense, and contribute modest yet meaningful efforts to the development of criminal defense and the rule of law in China.


Since the establishment of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, it has organized twenty-one specialized forums addressing a range of pressing and cutting-edge issues in criminal justice, including: “Criminal Defense in the Context of the Implementation of the Supervision Law”; “The Draft Amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law”; “The Impact of the Integration of Arrest and Prosecution on Criminal Defense”; “The Current Situation of Difficult Access to Meetings and the Protection of Lawyers’ Defense Rights”; “Protection of Property Rights of Private Entrepreneurs Involved in Criminal Cases”; “An Interpretation of the ‘Four Opinions’ on Cases Involving the Campaign Against Organized Crime and Evil Forces”; “Practical Approaches to Defending Financial‑Related Crimes”; “The Application of Evidence Rules in Criminal Defense”; “The Relationship Among Prosecution, Defense, and Adjudication in Cases Involving Plea Bargaining and Acceptance of Punishment”; “The Implications and Changes Brought by the New Interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law for Criminal Defense”; “The 11th ‘Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers’ Forum and the Symposium on Lawyers’ Participation in Corporate Compliance”; “Implementation of the Legal Aid Law and Its Implications for Criminal Defense”; “Defense in Fraud Cases”; “The Necessity and Improvements of Oral Hearings in Second‑Instance Criminal Trials”; “Prevention and Correction of Wrongful or Miscarried Cases Involving Enterprises, along with Mechanisms for Appeals and Retrials”; “Challenges and Strategies in Defending Financial and Securities‑Related Crimes”; “Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law and the Enhancement of the Defense System”; “Evidence‑Based Defense: Principles and Methods”; “Reflections on and Improvements to the Contemporary Relationship Between Prosecution and Defense”; “The Coordination of Two Laws and the Defense of Official‑Duty Crimes in the Context of the ‘Three Transformations’—Standardization, Rule of Law, and Regularization”; and “Examination and Cross‑Examination of Verbal Evidence.” Each forum has brought together experts from legislative and judicial bodies, scholars of criminal law, prominent criminal defense attorneys, and stakeholders concerned with criminal defense, offering multidimensional analyses and critical assessments of criminal defense practice, exploring both legislative and practical issues, and contributing to the advancement of criminal rule of law, thereby generating significant positive social impact.



Layout: Wang Xin

Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building



Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province


Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license