Since the 18th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, the Party Central Committee with Comrade Xi Jinping at its core has attached great importance to mediation work. General Secretary Xi Jinping has emphasized the need to uphold and develop the “Fengqiao Experience” for the new era, placing non-litigious dispute-resolution mechanisms at the forefront. Guided by Xi Jinping Thought on Socialism with Chinese Characteristics for a New Era, the people’s courts have thoroughly implemented Xi Jinping’s thought on the rule of law and carried out the important decisions adopted at the Fourth Plenary Session of the 20th CPC Central Committee—namely, “accelerating the development of a foreign-related rule-of-law system and capacity, and improving mechanisms such as international commercial mediation, arbitration, and litigation.” They have placed great emphasis on resolving disputes through mediation, using mediation to ease tensions and settle litigation, and leveraging mediation to end conflicts, while actively integrating the traditional Chinese cultural concept of “harmony and unity” into every stage and aspect of foreign-related commercial and maritime adjudication. To fully leverage the exemplary and guiding role of typical cases, the Supreme People’s Court has released the third batch of typical cases involving foreign-related commercial and maritime mediation. This batch covers a wide range of areas, including cross-border investment, equity transfers, sales contracts, ship management and operation, salvage at sea, and the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards, involving parties from countries such as South Korea, Italy, Denmark, Yemen, and Portugal. These cases vividly demonstrate how the people’s courts inherit and carry forward China’s fine traditional culture of “harmony,” practice and promote the “Fengqiao Experience” in the new era, and fulfill their judicial responsibilities in serving high‑level opening-up and safeguarding the high‑quality development of the marine economy. The typical cases in this batch exhibit the following key characteristics:
First, the principle of “harmony and unity” runs throughout, with efforts to resolve disputes and ensure stability in service of high-quality development. As an essential essence of China’s fine traditional culture, the “harmony and unity” ethos embodies profound principles of harmonious coexistence, win-win cooperation, and inclusive mutual support. Upholding this philosophy, the people’s courts adhere to equal protection, foster mutually beneficial outcomes, and facilitate the resolution of disputes, injecting new momentum into the settlement of international commercial disputes through their fair, efficient, convenient, and cost‑effective Eastern mediation practices. Case One concerns a dispute over capital contributions involving shareholders and directors from both China and South Korea. The people’s courts have consistently safeguarded the legitimate rights and interests of domestic and foreign parties on an equal footing, thoroughly examined the root causes of the conflict, and meticulously clarified the factual and legal relationships at issue. Leveraging a circuit‑trial mechanism, they resolved the dispute efficiently, comprehensively settling nearly a decade of cross‑border cooperation disputes in a single package—“one case closed, multiple cases resolved”—thereby achieving substantive resolution of international commercial disputes and continuously improving the rule‑of‑law‑based, internationally oriented business environment. Case Two involves a share‑transfer dispute between two Italian nationals. Both parties expressly chose Chinese courts to exercise jurisdiction and apply Chinese law. Respecting the parties’ autonomy of will, the people’s courts employed precise legal clarification to delineate the scope of the dispute and dynamic coordination to bring it to a close, ultimately facilitating a mediated settlement that addressed both legal and emotional concerns. This approach enabled the foreign parties to experience the wisdom and warmth of China’s judicial system, thereby significantly enhancing the international credibility and influence of China’s foreign‑related judicial system.
Second, leveraging professional expertise to guide mediation practice and seek the “optimal solution” for international commercial disputes. Resolving international commercial disputes through mediation often requires foreign‑related judges to accurately apply international treaties, customary international law, and foreign statutes, while relying on expert appraisals to clarify the facts and delineate the rights and obligations of all parties, thereby identifying the “optimal solution” that settles the dispute. Case Three involves the recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award: a Fujian‑based enterprise, due to quality issues in the supply of 500 tons of Peruvian crude fish oil, was ordered by the International Oil, Oilseed and Fat Association (FOSFA) to compensate a Danish company. The people’s court precisely applied the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (hereinafter referred to as the New York Convention), thoroughly examined English arbitration law, and actively facilitated a transition from “compulsory enforcement” to a mutually amicable settlement. Case Four concerns a Yemeni sales contract dispute. In this instance, the people’s court innovatively implemented a working mechanism that integrates “promotion, assessment, and appraisal” in parallel with “dual mediation,” using judicial expertise to establish objective factual findings. A Yemeni mediator fostered communication and bridged differences, while a Chinese mediator assessed risks and helped form realistic expectations. Balancing fairness and efficiency, the court enabled both parties to reach a mediated settlement and fully comply with its terms, thereby providing robust judicial support and safeguards for the high‑quality development of the free trade pilot zone.
Third, relying on the nationwide “one-network” system of the courts and… On the water A “one-stop” multi‑channel dispute resolution mechanism, powered by digital intelligence, safeguards the high‑quality development of the marine economy. 。 In view of the unique characteristics of maritime cases—namely, their connection to shipping and their cross‑jurisdictional nature—the Maritime Court has leveraged the achievements of smart court development to innovate maritime mediation methods, thereby accelerating dispute resolution at sea. Case Five involves a contractual dispute over ship management and operation. Adhering to the principle of “rapid data transmission and minimal vessel detention,” the Maritime Court utilized the national courts’ “One Network” system—the National Court Case Handling and Office Platform—to conduct mediation both online and offline in parallel, facilitating a settlement between the parties. Through the mobile office system, it promptly issued an order lifting the vessel’s arrest, successfully mediating the case while minimizing the adverse impact of the vessel’s detention on shipping operations. Within 24 hours, it completed a series of procedures—including coordinated vessel arrest, off‑site boarding, mutual settlement, and release of preservation measures—efficiently and conclusively resolving a complex international maritime dispute involving more than RMB 40 million, setting a new record for the swift resolution of such cases. Case Six concerns an international maritime salvage dispute that affects the legitimate rights and interests of Chinese and foreign parties as well as the international shipping order along the New Western Land‑Sea Corridor. Relying on an integrated, one‑stop multi‑party dispute‑resolution mechanism for waterborne matters, the Maritime Court collaborated with maritime authorities to establish a specialized mediation team, providing bilingual services to break down communication barriers. By harnessing the digital judicial resources of the “One Network, One Database” platform, it precisely identified the key legal issues at stake and ultimately facilitated a settlement: the Portuguese‑flagged vessel operator made a lump‑sum payment of the salvage fees, enabling a swift and substantive resolution of the dispute and providing strong support for the development of Hainan Free Trade Port as an international shipping hub.
Typical Cases of Foreign-related Commercial and Maritime Mediation—Third Batch
Table of Contents
Case One: Helping Chinese and foreign enterprises break free from constraints and “move forward,” comprehensively resolving cross-border cross-shareholding disputes.
— A dispute over capital contributions involving a South Korean health industry group, a Chinese health investment company, He Moumou, a Shanghai-based medical company, and other shareholders.
Case No. 2: The Italian parties mutually agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of a Chinese court, and the court, through “precise clarification combined with dynamic coordination,” efficiently resolved a shareholding dispute.
——Case of Equity Transfer Dispute between an Italian national, Mr. Ma and his daughter, and Mr. Lu
Case Three: Precisely ascertaining extraterritorial law to achieve an organic linkage between arbitration and mediation.
— Case of a Danish company and a Fujian-based enterprise applying for the recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award rendered by an international industry association
Case Four: Parallel Implementation of “Promotion, Evaluation, and Assessment,” with “Dual Mediation” Effectively Resolving Cross-Border Commercial Disputes
— Dispute over a sales contract between Yemeni businessman Mr. Ha and a Guangzhou-based company
Case Five: Leveraging the “One-Network” System, Two Courts Collaborate Around the Clock to Effectively Resolve International Maritime Disputes
— Case of Dispute over a Ship Management Contract between Ye, Chen, and a Hong Kong-based company
Case Six: Leveraging an on-water “one-stop” multi‑party dispute resolution mechanism to pool resources and support the development of Hainan Free Trade Port as an international shipping hub.
— Dispute over a maritime salvage contract between a Chinese salvage and wreck‑removal company and a Portuguese‑registered company
Case One
Helping Chinese and foreign enterprises break free from constraints and move forward, while comprehensively resolving cross-border cross‑shareholding disputes.
— A dispute over capital contributions involving a South Korean health industry group, a Chinese health investment company, He Moumou, a Shanghai-based medical company, and other shareholders.
[Basic Facts of the Case]
In 2016, a South Korean health‑industry group and a Chinese health‑investment company entered into an investment agreement to establish a subsidiary in China for developing the medical‑aesthetic sector. During the course of their cooperation, the South Korean group, relying on materials obtained through a shareholder‑right‑to‑information lawsuit, alleged that the Chinese company had withdrawn its capital contributions and filed suit seeking repayment of the misappropriated funds and compensation totaling RMB 310 million from the Chinese company, its affiliated entities, and the directors of its subsidiaries. The Chinese company countered that the transactions at issue constituted ordinary business dealings between enterprises and did not amount to withdrawal of capital contributions. Under the terms of the investment agreement, the two parties maintained a complex joint‑venture structure, including cross‑shareholdings and the joint establishment of project companies, and engaged in certain cooperative activities during an initial “honeymoon period.” However, diverging corporate philosophies soon gave rise to sharp disputes, bringing the collaboration to a standstill and creating a deadlock in corporate governance. To safeguard their respective interests, each party initiated multiple litigation and arbitration proceedings in both China and South Korea, covering matters such as disputes over entrusted management, shareholder‑right‑to‑information claims, and demands for the return of contributed capital.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
In view of the case’s complex legal relationships, numerous related proceedings, substantial subject matter at issue, and protracted duration, the International Commercial Court of the Supreme People’s Court leveraged its expertise and diversified dispute‑resolution capabilities to achieve a comprehensive, one‑stop settlement. First, by precisely identifying the parties’ claims, the court laid a solid foundation for mediation. Fully utilizing its mobile adjudication function, the collegiate panel convened an open hearing in Shanghai, inviting deputies to the National People’s Congress and academic experts to observe the proceedings. Expert assistants appeared in court to offer expert opinions on specialized issues, enabling the court to accurately distill the key points of contention and keenly recognize that all parties were reluctant to remain mired in endless litigation and incur unnecessary costs in investment and business operations. The court promptly provided legal explanations and reasoned analyses, highlighting existing risks and potential future disputes, thereby gaining the acceptance of both Chinese and foreign parties and establishing a strong basis for resolving the series of disputes involved through mediation. Second, upholding equal protection and fostering consensus, the court advanced the mediation process. It fully respected the wishes of all stakeholders, conducting impartial communication, coordination, and patient counseling. To facilitate mediation, the panel made multiple visits to the circuit court, organized face-to-face consultations among the parties, maintained ongoing telephone updates on progress, and worked tirelessly to identify the greatest common divisor of their interests, gradually building a shared understanding and reaching a mediated settlement. Third, by refining the terms of the agreement, the court helped ensure the substantive resolution of the disputes. To ensure the effective implementation of the mediation plan, the panel engaged in repeated discussions with the parties regarding the details, thoroughly deliberating on matters such as addressing exchange‑rate differentials arising from currency fluctuations while remaining compliant with the corporate laws of China and South Korea. Ultimately, the court formulated a mediation framework centered on the principle of restoring the status quo and dissolving cross‑border, cross‑shareholding relationships. All seven agreements previously entered into by the parties—covering framework cooperation, basic transaction terms, shareholder agreements, investment contracts, and others—were terminated, and other pending adversarial proceedings were likewise withdrawn. Thus, nearly a decade of transnational commercial disputes between the parties has been brought to a successful close.
[Typical Significance]
This case arose from a dispute over a cross-border, cross‑shareholding cooperation model between Chinese and Korean enterprises. The transaction structure is complex, and the outcome of this particular case is closely linked to the broader resolution of the overall dispute. The people’s courts have upheld the principle of equal protection of the legitimate rights and interests of both domestic and foreign parties, embodying the philosophy of “mutual trust and win‑win cooperation, harmony and shared progress.” By helping all parties clarify the substantive issues at stake and leveraging the circuit‑trial mechanism to give full effect to mediation as a means of resolving disputes, the court achieved a comprehensive settlement of nearly a decade of transnational cooperation disputes, effectively ensuring that “one case is resolved, multiple cases are extinguished.” This approach underscores the unique value of mediation in international dispute resolution, showcases the inclusiveness and wisdom of China’s rule‑of‑law culture to the international community, and has earned high praise from both domestic and foreign parties.
Case Two
The Italian parties mutually agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of a Chinese court, and the court, through “precise clarification plus dynamic coordination,” efficiently resolved the equity dispute.
——Case of Equity Transfer Dispute between an Italian national, Mr. Ma and his daughter, and Mr. Lu
[Basic Facts of the Case]
A certain catering company is a foreign-invested enterprise registered in Suzhou, Jiangsu Province. Its shareholders are Mr. Ma and his daughter, both Italian nationals, with a registered capital of EUR 50,000 and a subscribed capital contribution deadline of December 31, 2020. In June 2022, Mr. Ma and his daughter entered into an equity transfer agreement with another Italian national, Mr. Lu, under which they agreed to transfer all of the company’s equity for RMB 500,000. The agreement further stipulated that any disputes would be subject to the jurisdiction of the Suzhou People’s Court and governed by Chinese law. After assuming actual management, Mr. Lu discovered that the original shareholders had not yet made their capital contributions; accordingly, he personally supplemented the unpaid capital and, on this ground, refused to pay the equity transfer price. Mr. Ma and his daughter brought suit before the People’s Court, seeking a judgment ordering Mr. Lu to pay RMB 500,000 in equity transfer consideration together with liquidated damages. In turn, Mr. Lu filed a counterclaim, demanding that Mr. Ma and his daughter return the capital contributions they had made. The first-instance court ruled in favor of Mr. Ma and his daughter, dismissing Mr. Lu’s counterclaim. Dissatisfied with the decision, Mr. Lu appealed to the Intermediate People’s Court of Suzhou, Jiangsu Province.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
The International Commercial Tribunal of the Suzhou Intermediate People’s Court, with the goal of resolving disputes and bringing them to a close, has effectively employed a mediation model characterized by “precise clarification plus dynamic coordination” to facilitate the swift, efficient, and substantive resolution of conflicts. First, it respects party autonomy and fosters stable expectations for dispute resolution. The collegiate panel fully honored the foreign parties’ agreement to apply Chinese law, rigorously clarifying the legal relationships in accordance with the specific provisions of China’s Civil Code and Company Law, thereby ensuring that the parties’ expectations regarding dispute settlement remain stable through a professional, neutral, and impartial judicial approach. Second, it precisely identifies the points of contention and guides rational decision‑making. The panel comprehensively reviewed the facts of the case, distilled the key issues, and provided clear, targeted explanations. On the one hand, it explained to Mr. Ma and his daughter that their failure to disclose material defects in their capital contributions at the time of the equity transfer could trigger an adjustment to the transfer price; on the other hand, it clarified to Mr. Lu that, even if set‑off were established, any remaining unpaid balance would still be due and subject to liability for breach of contract. On this basis, the panel encouraged the parties to rationally assess litigation risks and gradually narrow their differences in interest. Third, it adheres to dynamic coordination to build consensus and facilitate settlement. Building on these precise clarifications, the panel engaged in multiple rounds of communication, actively facilitating dialogue and crafting a mediation plan that was both financially reasonable and practically feasible, under which Mr. Lu agreed to pay Ms. Ma and her daughter RMB 180,000 in installments as consideration for the equity transfer. On the day the mediation agreement was signed, Mr. Lu made the initial payment on the spot, thereby achieving a substantive resolution of the dispute.
[Typical Significance]
In this case, both parties are Italian nationals who jointly agreed to submit to the jurisdiction of Chinese courts and to be governed by Chinese law, thereby demonstrating their strong confidence in China’s rule-of-law environment and the impartiality of its judiciary. In adjudicating cross-border commercial disputes, the people’s courts have thoroughly implemented the “Fengqiao Experience” of the new era, resolving disputes through precise legal clarification and quelling conflicts via dynamic coordination, thus facilitating mediation agreements that are both feasible and enforceable. An外籍 party even presented a banner as a token of high appreciation for the Chinese courts, offering a practical model that can serve as a reference for further enhancing the international influence of China’s judicial system and for strengthening and improving the diversified mechanisms for resolving international commercial disputes.
Case Three
Accurately ascertaining foreign law to achieve an organic linkage between arbitration and mediation.
— Case of a Danish company and a Fujian-based enterprise applying for the recognition and enforcement of an arbitral award rendered by an international industry association
[Basic Facts of the Case]
In 2019, a Danish company entered into an agreement with a Fujian-based enterprise, under which the Fujian enterprise was to supply 500 tons of Peruvian crude fish oil to the Danish company. Subsequently, because the Fujian enterprise was unable to deliver goods that met the contractual specifications, it refunded the full amount paid by the Danish company. In 2020, citing the Fujian enterprise’s failure to perform its contractual obligations, the Danish company filed an arbitration request with the International Oil, Oilseed and Fat Association (FOSFA), as stipulated in the contract, seeking compensation for the difference in price and interest damages. In March 2023, the Association rendered an award in London, England, ordering the Fujian enterprise to pay the Danish company US$419,500 in liquidated damages plus interest, together with all arbitration costs. As the Fujian enterprise failed to comply with the award, in June 2024, the Danish company, pursuant to… According to The New York Convention , filed an application with the Intermediate People’s Court of Fuzhou City, Fujian Province, for the recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
A Fujian-based enterprise and a Danish company have maintained a long-standing cooperative relationship, with smooth economic and trade exchanges. However, the current dispute has not only left both parties facing the prospect of terminating their collaboration but has also resulted in the Fujian enterprise being placed on FOSFA’s list of untrustworthy entities, severely hampering its efforts to expand into overseas markets. To resolve this predicament, the People’s Court meticulously ascertained the applicable foreign law, accurately applied relevant international conventions, and skillfully integrated “Eastern wisdom,” employing a multi‑pronged approach to achieve a substantive settlement. First, by establishing credibility through professionalism, the court precisely identified and applied English law. As this case involved the recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award, it required the application of the New York Convention and the laws of the seat of arbitration—namely, England—to determine whether the arbitral proceedings were lawful and whether the award should be recognized and enforced. To this end, the parties engaged British legal experts to issue legal opinions on the UK’s Arbitration Act 1996 and the FOSFA Rules of Arbitration. In order to ensure an accurate understanding and application of these extraterritorial laws, the collegiate panel sought online advice from foreign legal experts, thereby clarifying the legality of the arbitral process. Second, by promoting convenience, the court leveraged online coordination to dismantle barriers to cross‑border legal comprehension. Adopting a hybrid “online plus offline” working mechanism, the Chinese and Danish parties participated in a cloud‑based hearing, during which they jointly and thoroughly examined the key points of convergence between the FOSFA Rules of Arbitration and the New York Convention, bridging gaps in cross‑border legal knowledge and laying the groundwork for mediation. Third, by pursuing a win‑win outcome, the court built a bridge from confrontation to cooperation. The collegiate panel clearly explained to the Danish company that “recognition of the award does not equate to compulsory litigation,” while actively conveying the Fujian enterprise’s sincere commitment to fulfilling its obligations. Impressed by the Chinese court’s professional rigor and the Fujian enterprise’s genuine goodwill, the Danish company agreed to reduce the compensation amount from over US$410,000 to just over US$280,000. The Fujian enterprise promptly paid the full settlement sum, whereupon the Danish company withdrew its application from the People’s Court. Consequently, the Fujian enterprise was removed from FOSFA’s “untrustworthy entities” list, and the cooperative relationship between the two parties was restored.
[Typical Significance]
This case concerns the recognition and enforcement of a foreign arbitral award. Guided by the judicial principle of resolving both the case and the underlying dispute, the people’s court has shifted its role from “procedural reviewer” to “dispute resolver,” proactively facilitating mediation between the parties. This not only helps domestic private enterprises restore their international reputation and move forward with greater agility but also effectively safeguards the legitimate rights and interests of the foreign party, achieving a balanced and mutually beneficial outcome. By adopting an approach that uses recognition to promote mediation, the court has guided the parties from compulsory enforcement toward amicable settlement, replacing confrontation with cooperation and ultimately delivering win‑win results. This case creatively integrates Eastern mediation wisdom with Western arbitration rules, forging a distinctive Chinese model for dispute resolution. It offers a new pathway for international commercial dispute settlement—lower in cost, more efficient, and better suited to preserving sound business relationships—thereby helping China establish itself as a preferred destination for resolving international commercial disputes.
Case Four
“Promotion, Evaluation, and Assessment” Operate in Parallel; “Dual Mediation” Effectively Resolves Cross-Border Commercial Disputes
— Dispute over a sales contract between Yemeni businessman Mr. Ha and a Guangzhou-based company
[Basic Facts of the Case]
In June 2022, a Yemeni businessman, surnamed Ha, placed an order with a Guangzhou-based company for a solid-tube ice-making machine valued at over US$250,000 and weighing 30 tons. The contract explicitly specified the brands and models of key components, such as the compressor, solenoid valves, and expansion valves, as well as core technical parameters including ice‑making specifications, production capacity, and energy consumption. Upon completion of manufacturing, Mr. Ha discovered during the acceptance inspection that certain component brands and models, along with operational parameters, did not conform to the contractual stipulations. He promptly refused to accept the equipment and demanded a refund. In response, the Guangzhou company maintained that the product complied with the contract and urged Mr. Ha to fulfill his obligations to make payment and take delivery, leading to a heated dispute. Mr. Ha filed a lawsuit with the People’s Court of the Nansha Area of the Guangdong Free Trade Zone, seeking termination of the sales contract, a judgment ordering the Guangzhou company to return double the deposit, refund all payments made, and compensate for related losses. The Guangzhou company counterclaimed, requesting continued performance of the contract and a judgment requiring Mr. Ha to pay the outstanding balance and bear liability for breach of contract.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
This case is a dispute over a sales contract involving Yemen, presenting multiple challenges—including cross-border transactions, the determination of specialized technical issues, and differences in legal perceptions between Chinese and foreign parties—making conflict resolution particularly difficult. In light of the specific circumstances of the case, the People’s Court of the Nansha Area of the Guangdong Pilot Free Trade Zone adopted an integrated dispute‑resolution model encompassing “promotion, evaluation, and appraisal,” and introduced a “dual‑mediation” mechanism to leverage professional judicial expertise in resolving the dispute. First, “appraisal” was used to clarify the facts and lay a solid foundation for mediation. With respect to specialized matters such as the specifications and technical parameters of ice‑making machine components, the court duly initiated a judicial appraisal procedure, commissioned a reputable expert institution to issue an authoritative opinion, and arranged for the appraisers to appear in court to undergo cross‑examination, thereby fully safeguarding both parties’ rights to challenge the evidence. By relying on impartial, expert opinions to establish the facts and delineate right from wrong, the court helped dispel the adversarial sentiments arising from differing factual understandings, thus creating a conducive environment for mediation. Second, “promotion” was employed to overcome barriers to cross‑border communication. A Yemeni mediator, well‑versed in the national conditions of both China and Yemen and with extensive experience in international trade, was appointed to facilitate dialogue in Arabic, meticulously explaining to the Yemeni party China’s judicial procedures and mediation rules, thereby addressing their misconceptions and concerns about the dispute‑resolution mechanisms. Third, “evaluation” was utilized to weigh the pros and cons and guide the parties toward rational mediation. Through evaluative mediation, the Chinese mediator, drawing on the case facts, applicable laws, and established trade practices, precisely calculated the litigation costs, performance risks, and actual losses associated with various dispute‑resolution options, producing a professional assessment that enabled both sides to comprehensively weigh the advantages and disadvantages and adjust their expectations accordingly, shifting from adversarial confrontation to cooperative negotiation. With coordinated efforts by Chinese and foreign mediators, the court convened multiple rounds of consultations, gradually narrowing the gaps between the parties. Ultimately, the parties voluntarily reached a mediated settlement and, on the day following the agreement’s signing, fully and proactively fulfilled all obligations, resulting in a substantive resolution of the dispute and achieving the favorable outcome of a case closed and the matter resolved.
[Typical Significance]
This case innovatively implements a working mechanism that integrates “promotion, evaluation, and appraisal” in parallel with the fusion of “dual mediation,” using expert appraisal to establish the facts, promotion to foster mutual understanding, and assessment to weigh pros and cons. This approach effectively addresses key challenges in cross-border commercial disputes—such as language barriers, cultural differences, difficulties in fact-finding, and significant expectation gaps—while, on the basis of respecting international commercial practices and the legitimate interests of both Chinese and foreign parties, achieving an organic integration of professional adjudication, cultural communication, and judicial safeguards. The case fully demonstrates the professionalism, openness, and practical effectiveness of China’s foreign-related commercial justice, significantly enhancing the confidence and recognition of overseas entities in China’s judicial system, continuously optimizing a market‑oriented, law‑based, and internationally aligned business environment, and providing robust judicial support and protection for the high‑quality development of the free trade pilot zones.
Case Five
By making effective use of the “One-Network” system, the two courts have collaborated around the clock to skillfully resolve cross-border maritime disputes.
— Case of Dispute over a Ship Management Contract between Ye, Chen, and a Hong Kong-based company
[Basic Facts of the Case]
Ye and Chen agreed that, in the name of a Hong Kong‑registered company, they would purchase a 150,000‑ton class foreign‑flagged oil tanker from an Italian company for operational purposes. However, since Chen effectively controlled the vessel, he refused to disclose its whereabouts or operational status to Ye and also declined to settle accounts. Consequently, Ye filed a lawsuit with the Xiamen Maritime Court, seeking the return of investment funds totaling over RMB 40 million, and applied for the court to immediately order the arrest of the vessel involved. Upon review, the Xiamen Maritime Court determined that the vessel was currently unloading at a port in Qingdao; should it complete unloading, depart, and exit Chinese territorial waters, subsequent proceedings and enforcement would encounter significant obstacles. In response, the court promptly initiated review procedures, issued a ruling authorizing the vessel’s arrest in accordance with the law, and coordinated online with the Qingdao Maritime Court and relevant authorities, including maritime and border inspection agencies, to swiftly carry out cross‑jurisdictional vessel arrest and facilitate mediation in the case.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
This case involves a substantial sum of money, complex international elements, and a foreign‑flagged vessel with a short window for entering port and discharging cargo, making ship detention particularly challenging. If the vessel were to remain detained due to the seizure, exorbitant demurrage costs would arise, severely undermining efforts to achieve a substantive resolution. Adopting a dispute‑resolution approach prioritizing mediation while using detention as a secondary measure, the Xiamen Maritime Court, within 24 hours and in coordinated collaboration with the Qingdao Maritime Court, successfully completed the sequence of “seizure–mediation–release,” setting a new record for the efficient handling of international maritime disputes by Chinese maritime courts. First, cross‑jurisdictional coordination and multi‑agency collaboration accelerated the seizure process. To ensure the vessel was seized before departure, the Xiamen Maritime Court promptly contacted the Qingdao Maritime Court, initiating cross‑regional judicial cooperation through online briefings on the case details and the need for detention. The two courts swiftly reached consensus on joint seizure, simultaneously coordinating with Qingdao Port’s border inspection, maritime authorities, and terminal operators to expedite procedures for boarding hazardous‑cargo vessels and jointly establishing a “green channel” for seizure, enabling boarding and detention during unloading breaks. Second, parallel dual‑track mediation—conducted back‑to‑back—reduced the parties’ dispute‑resolution costs. By advancing “remote seizure” alongside “remote mediation” in tandem, the adjudicating panel skillfully applied a back‑to‑back mediation strategy, engaging in multiple rounds of telephone and video communications with the parties located in Xiamen and Fuzhou, respectively. The panel thoroughly analyzed each side’s interests and risk exposures regarding core issues such as operational and managerial responsibilities and cost allocation. Through separate outreach and dynamic information exchange, the parties shifted from heated confrontation to rational negotiation. Third, leveraging digital technology and a unified online platform, the court achieved “zero delay” in releasing the vessel. The panel meticulously finalized terms related to the repayment amount, performance deadlines, and liability for breach, leading to the signing of a settlement agreement. To prevent costly port‑stay fees, the Xiamen Maritime Court issued an order lifting the seizure electronically via its case‑management system, simultaneously transmitting it to the Qingdao Maritime Court and relevant port authorities—including border control and maritime agencies—ensuring paperless processing and delivery within minutes. As a result, the massive vessel was able to depart freely, with no schedule delays attributable to this case. During the detention period, the panel patiently explained to the foreign crew the legal basis for the seizure and their associated rights and obligations; the crew transitioned from apprehension and resistance to understanding and cooperation, remarking, “We respect the decision of the Chinese courts, have witnessed the professionalism of Chinese judges, and admire the efficiency of China’s judicial system.” In handling this international maritime dispute, judicial warmth and efficiency complemented one another.
[Typical Significance]
This case represents a vivid example of how China’s maritime courts have earnestly implemented the “Fengqiao Experience” for the new era in the maritime domain, leveraging cross‑jurisdictional judicial cooperation and the achievements of digital court development to efficiently resolve a major international maritime dispute. By breaking down barriers of territorial jurisdiction, the case coordinated with maritime courts across multiple regions and maritime‑related agencies such as port border inspection authorities, thereby expediting cross‑jurisdictional ship‑arrest procedures and securing a critical window for subsequent mediation. In light of the time‑sensitive nature and high economic costs inherent in international shipping disputes, the court adhered to the principle of equal protection of the rights and interests of both Chinese and foreign parties, employing flexible mediation to bridge adversarial differences and shift from a “lose–lose” outcome to a “win–win” result. Relying on an integrated online platform, the court replaced cumbersome paper‑based processes with rapid data transmission, overcoming bottlenecks such as difficulties in serving documents across jurisdictions, protracted ship‑release procedures, and limited interagency collaboration. This approach offers a replicable and scalable model for maritime courts nationwide, paving the way for “fingertip” ship‑release solutions.
Case Six
Leveraging the water-based “one-stop” multi‑party dispute resolution mechanism to pool resources and strengthen collaboration, we are providing services to support the development of Hainan Free Trade Port as an international shipping hub.
— Dispute over a maritime salvage contract between a Chinese salvage and wreck‑removal company and a Portuguese‑registered company
[Basic Facts of the Case]
On July 21, 2025, a Bolivian‑flagged cargo vessel owned by a Portuguese company, while transiting a certain sea area, ran aground at high tide and was unable to refloat on its own due to the impact of Typhoon “Wipha.” There was a risk of marine environmental pollution caused by hull damage and fuel leakage, prompting the vessel to issue an urgent distress call to the Chinese maritime authorities. Upon receiving notification from a local maritime administration, a Chinese salvage and wreck‑removal company undertook towing and rescue operations, successfully completing the mission. Following the rescue, the Chinese company sought payment of salvage fees and related expenses from the Portuguese‑owned vessel’s owner; however, the latter refused to acknowledge these claims, leading to a dispute. After multiple rounds of mediation conducted by the maritime administration proved unsuccessful, the authority, in accordance with the “Collaborative Mechanism of the Multilateral Dispute Resolution Center for Shipping,” guided the parties to file a lawsuit with the Haikou Maritime Court.
【Mediation Methods and Outcomes】
This case is a dispute over an international maritime salvage contract. Resolving it appropriately in accordance with the law not only ensures equal protection of the legitimate rights and interests of both Chinese and foreign parties, but also directly demonstrates the maritime court’s capacity for handling foreign-related cases and its judicial credibility, thereby serving as an important model for supporting the development of the Western Land-Sea New Corridor as an international shipping hub. To this end, the Haikou Maritime Court undertook the following measures: First, it proactively clarified the applicable laws and policies to guide the parties toward amicable mediation. Although the two parties held significantly divergent views on the salvage fees, they did not dispute the facts or the evidence and both expressed a willingness to mediate. Taking into account that the cargo vessel owned by a Portuguese company needed to expedite its voyage to complete its loading schedule and faced the risk of delays due to an approaching typhoon, the collegiate panel adopted a “putting oneself in the other party’s shoes” approach, actively encouraging the parties to pursue mediation first and thereby facilitating an efficient resolution of the dispute. Second, leveraging a coordinated dispute-resolution mechanism, the court worked collaboratively to address the conflict. Given the specialized nature of maritime rescue operations involved in this case, the court assigned a panel comprising experienced maritime judges and people’s mediators to oversee the mediation process. Relying on the “Multilateral Collaborative Mechanism for Resolving Shipping Disputes,” the court joined forces with key personnel from the maritime administration to form a professional mediation team, ensuring the expertise and objectivity of the mediation. At the same time, the court actively coordinated with relevant foreign‑vessel agency firms to provide free translation services, thereby guaranteeing the Portuguese company’s right to participate in the proceedings through bilingual mediation and effectively overcoming communication barriers. Third, by utilizing the “One Network, One Database” system, the court clarified the points of contention and reached a definitive resolution. By making full use of the Legal Answers Network and the Case Database, the court elucidated the relevant legal principles and provided detailed interpretations of international conventions and established precedents in maritime salvage cases, enabling the Portuguese company to clearly understand its legal liabilities. Simultaneously, the court guided the Chinese party to adjust its claims reasonably in light of the foreign party’s financial capacity, ultimately leading to a mediated settlement in which the Portuguese company paid US$50,000 in salvage fees to a Chinese salvage and wreck‑removal company in a single lump sum.
[Typical Significance]
The international shipping hub of the New Western Land–Sea Corridor serves as a core maritime engine for the development of the Hainan Free Trade Port and a vital port‑based support for its closed‑border operations. Efficiently and impartially resolving various foreign‑related maritime disputes is not only an essential requirement for equally safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of domestic and foreign shipping market entities, but also a key measure for strengthening the judicial safeguards underpinning the shipping hub and enhancing the international credibility of China’s maritime justice system. In this case, the Haikou Maritime Court, leveraging an on‑water “one‑stop” multi‑dispute‑resolution mechanism and coordinating with maritime administrative authorities to pool collaborative efforts, effectively overcame communication barriers and specialized challenges in cross‑border cases. By harnessing digital judicial resources through the “One Network, One Database” platform, it precisely identified the legal issues at stake, thereby providing robust legal foundations and case‑law support for mediation. Moreover, by fully capitalizing on the institutional advantages of mediation, it balanced the practical demands of both Chinese and foreign parties, ensuring equal protection of their lawful rights and interests, and offering a replicable, scalable model for the diversified resolution of similar foreign‑related maritime disputes.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Shen Xinyu
Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12