

Editor’s Note:
On May 23, 2026, a seminar focusing on the current practical challenges and responses in electronic evidence, together with the first anniversary celebration of Beijing Xinglai (Wuhan) Law Firm, was successfully held. Drawing on several real‑world cases, Attorney Wang Jun, director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, thoroughly examined how to leverage electronic evidence to navigate the profit‑driven pitfalls inherent in judicial proceedings, thereby reconstructing the facts and safeguarding rights. At the conclusion of her presentation, she distilled three critical skills that criminal defense lawyers must master in this new phase—valuable guidance for legal professionals.



Wang Jun Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm


The topic I’m sharing today is “Peering into Profit‑Driven Justice Through Electronic Data.” This reflects my reflections and insights gained over the past year or two as I’ve worked alongside Professor Liu Pinxin, and it also summarizes our practical experience. The content is organized into four parts: first, clarifying what electronic data can achieve; second, defining profit‑driven justice and identifying its manifestations; third, focusing on how electronic data can illuminate such practices; and finally, discussing the competencies required of lawyers and the implications for their professional development.
I. Electronic Data: Not Only an Independent Category of Evidence, but Also the “King of Evidence”
From the perspective of the evolution of evidence, we have progressed from human testimony and physical evidence to electronic evidence. As Professor Liu Pinxin has observed, electronic data has become the “king of evidence” in the new era, often surpassing physical evidence in terms of authenticity and other attributes.
Electronic data is not merely the digitalization of traditional physical evidence or testimonial evidence. The Regulations on Several Issues Concerning the Collection, Extraction, and Examination and Adjudication of Electronic Data in Criminal Cases, jointly issued by the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, and the Ministry of Public Security, explicitly state: “Testimonial statements by witnesses, statements by victims, confessions and defenses of defendants, and the like, when recorded in digital form, do not constitute electronic data.” Traditional testimonial evidence does not automatically become electronic data simply because its mode of recording has changed.
Electronic data takes many forms: WeChat chat logs, database records, program code, transaction histories, call logs, and more. Any evidence stored, processed, or transmitted in digital form that can substantiate the facts of a case is considered electronic data.

Liu Pinxin, “Essentials of Electronic Evidence Examination”
From the perspective of legal practice, Professor Liu Pinxin, in his work “Electronic Evidence Law,” puts forward “ Examine, count, select Within the threefold extensibility framework, we examine electronic data in litigation, and these three steps are indispensable.
First, “Jian”—the expert opinion. This is what we instinctively think of: because electronic data is highly technical and beyond the comprehension of lawyers, it is typically presented in the form of an expert opinion. When challenging such opinions, aside from scrutinizing standard aspects like the expert’s qualifications and the scope of the assignment, the most common issues we encounter are “unclear data sources” or “inconsistencies with common sense.” However, starting solely from the written expert report often allows only for raising reasonable doubts, which rarely succeed in undermining the judge’s inner conviction. To substantiate these doubts, one must rely on the electronic data itself, together with the corresponding evidence‑collection records, to rebut them.
The examination of the forensic methodology is equally critical. Let me cite a recent case—a matter involving the unauthorized control of a computer information system. The defendant was a company that developed software applications for feature phones, creating several utility apps tailored to such devices. The public prosecution alleged that the source code underlying these apps constituted “trojan programs” used to unlawfully control the computer information system. What did the forensic institution do? It extracted the software’s source code and conducted a static analysis, concluding that the code exhibited certain functionalities sufficient to qualify it as a trojan program.
However, upon comparing the findings with the “Technical Specifications for Software Functional Verification,” we determined that software functional verification must include dynamic testing, rather than relying solely on static source-code analysis. Static source-code review can only confirm that the code was designed to implement a particular functionality at the time of writing; it does not equate to the actual functionality observed when the software is executed on a specific operating system. The two are entirely distinct and cannot be treated as equivalent. This case underscores the practical necessity of systematically cross-referencing the relevant standards item by item and, on that basis, articulating our expert opinions.
Second, “number” — the data itself. This requires employing technical methods to conduct in-depth mining and analysis of massive volumes of electronic data, to determine what these data can reveal, what they can reflect, and how we can leverage them to our advantage. Let me offer two brief examples:
Date Modified: Open any Word document, right-click on its properties, and you’ll see the creation date, modification date, and last access date. The modification date can serve as evidence of when the file was finalized. I once handled a case involving the infringement of citizens’ personal information; the judicial authorities commissioned an expert appraisal on April 1, 2018. Normally, once samples are collected and the appraisal is commissioned, those samples should remain unchanged. However, in the screenshots of the samples attached to the appraisal report, I discovered that the modification date was listed as April 17—meaning the samples had been altered after the appraisal was commissioned. We requested the expert to appear in court, and after several rounds of questioning, the expert admitted on the spot that the samples were no longer in their original condition and had indeed been tampered with.
Data cleaning/deduplication: In a case involving the infringement of citizens’ personal information, the investigating authorities extracted and analyzed the phone numbers stored on the defendant’s mobile device, concluding that there were 20,000 entries. However, after removing duplicates, only 120 entries could be matched to specific names and phone numbers. The discrepancy between 20,000 and 120 exceeds 160-fold. Such a substantial disparity provides significant assistance to the defense.
Third, “Obtaining” — the evidence-gathering process. This is a crucial step in ensuring the legality and authenticity of the evidence. For example, a “Site Inspection Record” might state that the inspection took place in the office of a certain police station. This creates a contradiction: was the inspection conducted at the victim’s company premises, or was it carried out remotely from the police station?
Another issue is the checksum. While this does indeed serve as a strong indicator of compliance with standards, whether it can truly ensure data accuracy and integrity depends on the specific circumstances. The standard practice is to extract the data. Previously , compute a checksum on the original storage medium; extract Afterward On the hard drive storing the data, a checksum is computed using the same algorithm; only when the two match can the authenticity of the data be verified. However, in many cases today, no checksum is calculated prior to extraction, and one is retroactively computed afterward—without any corresponding audio or video recording to corroborate it. In such instances, the resulting checksum carries no evidentiary weight regarding the data’s provenance.
I observed in the evidence‑collection screen recording of another case that, when extracting data, the investigators “moved” all files from the defendant’s computer’s Recycle Bin to a newly created folder on the desktop; once the “move” was complete, the Recycle Bin was emptied. This indicates that this type of “move” is a… Cut The process is neither replication nor, much less, mirror imaging. Mirror imaging and replication differ fundamentally; we must not rely solely on the data presented at the surface while neglecting to scrutinize the underlying information.
II. From Assistance to Guidance, from Challenge to Presentation of Evidence
The role of electronic data in lawyers’ case handling has undergone three stages of evolution:
Step one: assist in case handling, serving as a supporting role. Methods for challenging the “three characteristics” of evidence include verifying the integrity of the evidence, validating the consistency of hash values, and confirming the legality of the evidence‑collection process. Hash‑value verification tools employ various algorithms—such as MD5, SHA‑1, and SHA‑256—and these algorithms are not interoperable nor reversible. Therefore, we must not merely determine whether a hash value exists; we must also ascertain which algorithm was used and whether that algorithm is fixed.
Step two: guide the case-handling process, serving as a mentor. Delve deeply into the value of data, analyzing file modification timestamps, login IP addresses, associated accounts, and patterns of user behavior, while employing “counter‑investigation” thinking to break through defensive stalemates.
In a case involving the operation of an illegal casino, I identified numerous issues from a data‑driven perspective. For example, Power of Attorney : A company’s technical employee authorized a forensic appraisal agency to access the company’s database backend and extract data. Is such authorization valid? Under the law, only the data owner—either a legal entity or the de facto controller—has the authority to grant such permission. Does a technical employee possess this right? Furthermore, there is an issue with the authorized party: can authorization be directly granted to a third party? In criminal cases, the sole lawful entity empowered to extract data is the investigating authority. If the investigating authority lacks the requisite technical capabilities, the General Provisions on Forensic Examination Procedures provide for delegation to a qualified appraisal institution; however, when the appraiser extracts data, an investigator must be present to witness the process. A unilateral authorization by a technical employee allowing a third party to access the database is entirely devoid of legality and validity.
For example, Backup file Automatic backups can ensure data integrity and are therefore acceptable; however, with manual backups, since you have the option to select which files to back up, their authenticity and originality cannot be guaranteed.
Step three: conduct a penetrating review and take center stage. By shifting from “passive cross-examination” to “proactive evidence presentation,” we can leverage objective, authentic electronic data to directly establish the factual basis of a case, thereby effectively challenging the prosecution’s evidentiary framework. For example, consider the credibility of a complainant’s statement: the complainant claims that on a specific date, they logged into a certain gaming platform, opened a blind box, and suffered a loss. Without examining electronic data, it would be nearly impossible to disprove the veracity of such testimonial evidence; however, we can now use backend database logs to verify whether the complainant was indeed online at that time, whether there were any top-up records, and whether a loss actually occurred.
III. Justice Driven by Self-Interest: When Fairness Becomes Aligned with Profit-Oriented Objectives
Profit-driven justice, put simply, refers to a situation in which judicial organs, in the course of handling cases, are unduly influenced by non‑legal factors—such as local protectionism, departmental interests, and economic targets—rather than being guided solely by facts and the law. This misalignment causes the purpose of justice to deviate from “impartial administration of justice” to “pursuit of profit.” Such practice represents a departure from the rule of law and undermines the authority and public trust in the legal system.
Profit-driven judicial practice manifests in four typical ways:
First, the struggle over jurisdiction. Abusing the “principle of close connection,” deliberately creating jurisdictional links to vie for case‑jurisdiction is, in essence, a scramble for the substantial economic benefits that accompany such cases. For example, in the Wuhu fraud case, the defendant sold collectibles across the country; yet jurisdiction was assigned solely on the basis of a single victim filing a report in Wuwei County, Wuhu City. Is this wrong? It would seem not. However, from the perspectives of ascertaining the facts and ensuring procedural efficiency, such jurisdictional connections may prove inadequate—this issue is even more pronounced in cybercrime cases. Fortunately, in March 2025, the Ministry of Public Security issued the “Regulations on Jurisdiction over Inter‑Provincial Criminal Cases Involving Enterprises,” which explicitly stipulates: “For cybercrimes with dispersed locations and unclear primary places of commission, jurisdiction shall lie with the public security organ at the location of the enterprise.”
Second, infringement of property rights. There is a failure to distinguish between assets involved in a case, an overuse of confiscatory criminal charges, and the criminalization of economic disputes, with property being seized through criminal means. A typical example is the “arresting businesspeople to attract investment”–style case of illegal control over computer information systems: the public security authorities of Province A detained an entrepreneur from Province B in Province A, demanding that the entrepreneur invest and establish a business there in exchange for release. As a result, the entrepreneur did invest and was released; yet a year later, the authorities arrested him again.
Third, the tendency toward criminalization and confiscation of property. In the gray area between criminal and non-criminal conduct, there is a tendency to find the defendant guilty; and when faced with a choice between one offense and another, there is a preference for selecting the charge that allows for the confiscation of illicit gains or the imposition of ancillary property-based penalties.
Fourth, the investigation firm becomes involved. Using external technical firms to extract, preserve, or even authenticate electronic evidence may give rise to legal issues, such as procedural irregularities and an unwarranted expansion of the scope of application. As previously noted, except in cases where public security organs entrust forensic institutions to collect evidence, the legality of having external technical firms assist public security organs in extracting and preserving data may be assessed by reference to Article 128 of the Criminal Procedure Law and Article 213 of the Regulations on Procedures for Handling Criminal Cases by Public Security Organs, which provide: “Investigative personnel shall conduct site inspections or examinations of places, objects, persons, and corpses related to a crime. When necessary, they may assign or hire individuals with specialized knowledge to carry out such inspections or examinations under the supervision of the investigators.”
Although the aforementioned provisions do not specifically address electronic data, their application by analogy within the scope of “site inspection” and “examination” is at least tolerable and understandable. The problem arises when, in practice, the assistance provided by such external technical firms often extends beyond mere data extraction through inspection and examination to encompass forensic analysis, auditing, and other tasks that lie outside the purview of criminal investigation—tasks that may even be financially tied to the amount of assets seized, impounded, or frozen by the investigating authorities. This is a direct manifestation of conducting investigations solely for the purpose of securing convictions and pursuing personal gain.
Judicial Reality: Judicial authorities are more concerned with whether the substantive elements of a crime are met. If the substantive elements are satisfied, even in cases involving profit‑driven judicial practices, such issues may be addressed internally among the relevant case-handling personnel and are unlikely to have a fundamental impact on the outcome of the case; and even when jurisdiction is transferred, the case will still undergo a substantive trial afterward (though the assurance of impartiality may be somewhat enhanced). Therefore, At all times, while addressing procedural issues, we must also consider the substantive issues concurrently.
IV. Electronic Data: Three Major Application Scenarios Revealing the Profit-Driven Nature of Judicial Practice
Electronic data is a powerful tool for uncovering the aforementioned issues. I have identified three core review scenarios:
Application 1: Reviewing “Whether to Initiate a Case” — Establishing a “Key Events Timeline Before and After Case Filing”
By mapping out the key steps in the case‑filing process along a timeline, we can systematically assess each stage. Prior to filing, we scrutinize online monitoring logs and examine whether the case‑related database shows any irregular registrations or logins, or any unauthorized creation or modification of data. After filing, we closely monitor the seizure procedures for computers, mobile devices, and other relevant equipment on the day of arrest, as well as the collection and preservation of electronic evidence. Through horizontal comparisons and vertical traceability, we verify the legitimacy of case acceptance at its very source.
Application II: Reviewing “Whether Prosecution Should Be Initiated” — Establishing a “Chronology of Major Events Before and After the Forensic Examination”
Did the expert witness personally conduct the examination? IP addresses and document authors both serve as investigative leads. The core review of an expert opinion encompasses: whether the examination process adhered to established procedural standards; whether the methods employed are scientifically sound and reproducible; and whether the evidence examined is objectively authentic and legally obtained. At the same time, attention should be paid to the database’s backend operation logs—registration logs, login logs, and modification logs—in order to identify anomalies that may indicate underlying issues.
Application Three: Reviewing “Whether Seizure, Freezing, or Confiscation Should Be Ordered” — Safeguarding Legitimate Property Rights
First, we review the legality of the procedural steps—verifying whether the date of issuance of the legal documents authorizing seizure, detention, or freezing is compliant, whether all formalities have been duly completed, and whether proper notice has been served. Second, we clarify the ownership of assets—making full use of bank transaction records, business contracts, personnel relationships, financial statements, and other relevant data to clearly determine the authenticity of the transactions, the sources of funds, and the actual ownership. In one case involving the operation of an illegal casino, as counsel for a third party, we conducted extensive investigations and evidence‑gathering in another province, demonstrating that the third party maintained genuine, lawful business dealings with the company at issue and that the third party was not established solely to obtain illicit proceeds.
Here is a common misconception among judicial authorities: The objects of property subject to seizure and freezing are not entirely identical to those subject to enforcement. The scope of property seizure and freezing may be strictly limited to the proceeds of the offense and may not extend to lawful assets; by contrast, enforcement may encompass lawful property—particularly where illicit funds have been squandered or cannot be recovered. Some judges contend: “If I do not freeze his lawful assets now, might this later render it impossible to recover the ill-gotten gains?” However, such concerns lack legal basis; even during the trial phase, measures of property seizure and freezing are confined to assets involved in the case, the proceeds of the crime, and illicit funds and items. This apprehension on the part of the judge clearly disregards the defendant’s legitimate property rights. Enforcement, being a subsequent stage, involves a different category of property and must not be conflated with seizure and freezing.
V. Conclusion: The Three Core Skills for Criminal Defense Lawyers in the New Era
First, the awareness of review. Maintain a heightened awareness of the need to scrutinize both procedural and substantive aspects of cases through electronic evidence, particularly when handling matters that may entail risks of biased or self‑serving judicial outcomes. This is the most important and valuable takeaway from today’s seminar: it underscores the powerful role that electronic data can play—not merely in addressing issues of admissibility, authenticity, and relevance, but also in reconstructing objective facts.
Second, a spirit of skepticism. Do not blindly accept case files and transcripts, nor take the prosecution’s evidence at face value. When you detect something amiss—such as data that defies common sense or an unclear source of data—you must conduct further investigation; do not stop at merely noting that the information “defies common sense.”
Third, the appropriate method. We don’t need to be as proficient as professional forensic experts, but we should at least have a basic understanding. For example, how long does it take to conduct an examination? How long does it take to boot up a computer? Can it be done in 30 minutes? If an examination of a computer takes only ten minutes, we must investigate further—what exactly was done, and was there any tampering? Similarly, creating a disk image is by no means something that can be accomplished in just three or five minutes.
Electronic data is hailed as the “king of evidence” because it is objective and authentic, difficult to tamper with, and any attempts at manipulation leave clear traces. However, the truth does not reveal itself automatically; it requires lawyers to employ a technical mindset and proactively uncover it. In the new era, the core competitive edge of criminal defense lawyers no longer hinges solely on oral advocacy; it increasingly depends on sophisticated data‑driven defense strategies. By delving into the minutiae of electronic data and cutting through procedural complexities, we can both safeguard the legitimate rights and interests of the parties involved and counteract profit-driven judicial biases, thereby upholding judicial fairness.
Author Biography
.
Wang Jun
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Founding Partner
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Head of its Management Committee; Executive Director of the Civil–Criminal–Administrative Integration Research Base jointly established by the Criminal Law and Criminal Procedure Institute of China University of Political Science and Law and Xinglai Law Firm; and Director of Xinglai’s Center for Official‑Related Crimes. Holds undergraduate and master’s degrees from Huazhong University of Science and Technology. A member of the Criminal Procedure Law Specialized Committee and the Women Lawyers Working Committee of the 12th Beijing Lawyers Association, and a Senior Research Fellow at the Southern Finance Legal Research Institute. Selected for LEGALBAND’s 2026 China Top Lawyers Ranking in the “White‑Collar and Business Crime” category, recipient of the ALB Legal Awards’ NARA Annual Managing Partner Award, named among LEGALBAND’s Top 15 Female Lawyers and Top 15 Rising Partners in China, and recognized as a Visionary Leader by Commercial Law’s The Visionaries, as well as featured on LexisNexis’s Elite List, among other accolades.
He has published numerous professional articles in leading journals such as People’s Procuratorate and China Lawyers, and was featured on the cover of the book “Walking with the Law” published by the Chinese Culture Publishing House. He is a dual‑certified Data Protection Officer (DPO) and Data Protection Officer for Privacy (DPOPIPL) through the International Information Science Examination Institute (EXIN). He has successfully defended multiple criminal cases resulting in acquittals, possesses extensive practical experience in criminal–civil intersection cases and property‑related sentencing defenses, and excels in representing clients in official‑duty and cybercrime matters, particularly having amassed substantial hands‑on expertise in electronic data examination.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Shen Xinyu


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12
