CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

On the afternoon of August 1, 2026, The 22nd “Top Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum At Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm Successfully held, special symposium “ Practical Challenges in Property Defense and Legislative Improvements ”。


This forum is hosted by The forum was hosted by the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” of Beijing and co-organized by Zhongtong Law Firm in Beijing. The guests attending this forum include the initiators of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” forum: Yang Kuangsheng, Director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm; Xu Lanting, Honorary Director of Beijing Junyong Law Firm; Qian Lieyang, Director of Beijing Zihua Law Firm; Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm; Wang Zhaofeng, Director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm; Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm; Mao Lixin, Honorary Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm; Zhu Yonghui, Director of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm; and Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm; Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm; and Zhang Baicheng, an attorney at Beijing Zihua Law Firm, attended the meeting and participated in the seminar.


This forum has also invited Professor Wang Zhixiang, Director of the Institute of Foreign and Comparative Criminal Law at Beijing Normal University, and Professor Guo Shuo, Dean of the Capital Research Institute (Beijing Legislative Research Institute) at China University of Political Science and Law, served as panel commentators. They also invited Professor Fan Chongyi, Honorary Dean of the Institute of Procedural Law at China University of Political Science and Law and a first‑level professor, to deliver the conference summary. Yang Dakang, the host of the legal self-media platform “Dakang’s Living Room,” served as the moderator. This forum was supported by media outlets including Fazhi Net, China Economic Report, and Caixin.com. More than eighty experts, scholars, and lawyers from law schools, the legal profession, and industry media attended in person. The forum was broadcast live in a hybrid online–offline format, drawing widespread attention from the legal academia, the bar, judicial authorities, and the media.


✦

Opening

✦

Zhao Chunyu

The forum officially commenced at 1:30 p.m. The opening ceremony was hosted by… Attorney Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm and Deputy Secretary-General of the Ten-Person Forum on Criminal Defense. Host. Attorney Zhao Chunyu pointed out that, “The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Over the course of nine years, the forum has consistently upheld the principles of openness, pragmatism, rationality, and continuous improvement, keeping pace with judicial reform and steadily contributing insightful perspectives to the field. This forum focuses on “Practical Challenges in Property‑Related Defense and Legislative Improvements,” a topic of great practical significance against the backdrop of steady progress in amending the Criminal Procedure Law. Property‑related defense has now extended throughout the entire criminal procedure, touching on such areas as campaigns to eradicate organized crime and corruption and offenses committed by public officials; yet it continues to face structural challenges, including strong procedural dependency, the absence of standing for third parties, fragmented avenues for redress, and the reversal of the burden of proof. In the current legislative process to revise the Criminal Procedure Law, refining the disposition of property involved in criminal cases has been designated as a key priority. It is therefore timely to map out the practical difficulties and explore appropriate legislative pathways—precisely the value of this forum’s deliberations.


Ouyang Jihua

The forum was addressed by Ouyang Jihua, Executive Director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm. Attorney Ouyang Jihua first, on behalf of all the colleagues at Zhongtong Law Firm, extended a warm welcome and heartfelt gratitude to the distinguished experts and scholars in attendance. He noted that since its inception in 2018, the “Ten Criminal Defense Experts” Forum has remained committed to examining cutting-edge issues, advancing professionalization and standardization, and fostering a harmonious, collaborative ecosystem for criminal defense, thereby establishing itself as a highly influential platform for professional exchange within China’s criminal defense field. Attorney Ouyang further pointed out that the forum’s theme—property‑related defense—is both a focal point and a significant challenge in criminal practice; from the disposition of assets in organized‑crime cases to the identification of property involved in official‑duty offenses, each issue bears directly on the substantive protection of the legitimate rights and interests of the parties concerned. He then outlined how, over its twenty-four years of development since its founding, Zhongtong Law Firm has consistently upheld the cultural ethos of “upholding impartiality and integrity, pursuing shared values and harmony,” cultivating a tradition characterized by Party building as the guiding force, professional excellence as its foundation, succession and talent cultivation as its cornerstone, and active engagement in public service. Finally, he… We hope that this symposium will offer valuable insights and contribute to the improvement of the property defense system, and We wish this forum every success.


✦

First half

✦

Wang Bo

The first half of the forum was chaired by Attorney Wang Bo, a partner at Beijing Shangquan Law Firm and secretary of the Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers Forum. Serve as the host.


Xu Lanting

The first speaker in the first half of the forum was Lawyer Xu Lanting, Honorary Director of Beijing Junyong Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “How Lawyers Should Conduct Defenses in Property‑Related Criminal Cases.” He began by analyzing the current predicament in practice—where defenses focus heavily on personal liberty while paying insufficient attention to property—and argued that this phenomenon stems primarily from the lack of effective institutional safeguards for lawyers undertaking property‑related defense work. Specifically: first, investigative authorities wield excessively broad powers to seize, impound, and freeze assets, with inadequate oversight and redress mechanisms; second, prosecutorial review and supervision of seized property are largely formalistic, and the standards for handling such property and the rules governing the presentation of evidence remain unclear; third, courts tend to treat disputes over seized property in a perfunctory manner, rendering sentencing provisions vague, and the procedural framework for conducting independent adjudication requires further refinement. Notably, the recent issuance of documents such as the “Two Quality‑and‑Efficiency Standards” and the “Interpretation (II) on Embezzlement and Bribery” has sent positive signals, providing clear legal grounds for judicial organs to manage seized property and for lawyers to mount property‑related defenses.


Building on a clear distinction between the narrow and broad connotations of property‑related defense, Attorney Xu Lanting advocates integrating “penal‑property defense” with “defense concerning the disposition of assets involved in the case,” focusing on the following key areas: giving equal weight to the defense of personal rights and property rights, upgrading legal principles, and restructuring professional capabilities; intervening at the earliest possible stage to seize opportunities for property‑related relief; centering on evidentiary defense while concentrating on the nature and ownership of the assets; and coordinating with family members to pool resources and strengthen the overall defense effort.


Attorney Xu Lanting recommends: systematically regulating and proceduralizing compulsory measures such as seizure and asset freezing; reforming the current situation in which the decision-making and enforcement authorities are conflated, thereby strengthening oversight and redress mechanisms; narrowing the scope of application of confiscation of personal property and requiring judges to adhere strictly to the principle of restraint in its use; improving the accusatory and adjudicative procedures for the disposition of case‑related assets, fully safeguarding the rights of defense of both the defendant and the counsel, while also permitting interested parties to participate substantively in court proceedings.


Zhang Baicheng

Attorney Zhang Baicheng of Beijing Zihua Law Firm delivered a keynote address on behalf of Attorney Qian Lieyang, the director of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, titled: “Examining from the Perspective of Judicial Practice the Necessity of Defense Counsel’s Involvement in the Sentencing of Additional Penalties.” The statement points out that, in criminal trials, adversarial exchanges over conviction and principal sentencing have become routine; however, property‑related ancillary penalties such as fines and confiscation of property are almost never subjected to courtroom deliberation. Seizure, impoundment, and freezing of assets are typically carried out unilaterally by the investigating authorities during the preliminary investigation phase, while judgments often dispose of涉案财物 in a perfunctory, one‑off manner, resulting in de facto “closed‑door discretion.” The consequences of this practice were particularly evident in the case of Xu’s manipulation of the securities market: the court imposed a fine of RMB 11 billion and ordered the confiscation of illicit gains totaling RMB 9.3 billion, yet the total value of family assets subject to seizure was extraordinarily large. Crucially, there was no clear procedural mechanism for identifying and separating the lawful share belonging to family members, leaving the defendant’s spouse to endure years of litigation—ranging from objections to enforcement and applications for state compensation to divorce proceedings.


The statement further dissects the root causes: they include both a mindset that prioritizes personal liberty over property and a lack of clear guidelines for determining fines, as well as an institutional arrangement in which asset seizure, freezing, and restraint precede but relief follows. Particularly worthy of reflection is the phenomenon of “procedural inversion”: Article 279 of the Interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law has long mandated that courts conduct investigations into assets involved in a case, yet this provision remains largely unenforced in practice. By contrast, the special procedure for confiscating illegal proceeds in cases where the suspect or defendant has absconded or died is equipped with a full set of procedural safeguards, including public notice, participation by interested parties, court hearings, and avenues for appeal and protest. Seizing the window of opportunity presented by the inclusion of amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law in the legislative agenda, the statement puts forward five recommendations: integrate the disposition of assets involved in a case into the court’s investigation and adversarial proceedings; require the judgment to itemize and explicitly determine the disposition of such assets; make the execution of property‑related penalties contingent upon prior identification and division of assets; grant defense counsel the right to investigate and gather evidence, and afford non‑parties procedural participation rights; and standardize the scope of asset seizure, freezing, and restraint during the investigative phase. The statement underscores that these measures are by no means intended to exonerate offenders, but rather to ensure that punishment is confined to the offender himself, thereby safeguarding the legitimate property of the family.


Liu Weidong

The speech delivered by Attorney Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm, was titled “Defense Regarding Property Involved in Official‑Related Criminal Cases.” — Taking ten real cases handled by myself as examples ». Attorney Liu Weidong, drawing on actual cases he has handled, elaborated from four perspectives. The first concerns the determination of the scope of assets, emphasizing the proper treatment of commingled property. The second focuses on the legality of asset seizure, attachment, and freezing; attorneys should carefully examine whether such measures were taken prior to the filing of the case and whether they exceed the authorized scope. Frostbite Third, property‑related defense requires tailored strategies at different stages: during the investigation phase, it is inadvisable to hastily return assets that remain in dispute, as this could be construed as an admission of guilt; at the review‑and‑prosecution stage, emphasis should be placed on face-to-face communication with investigators to glean critical information; and during trial, each item of evidence must be rigorously challenged, with property‑related evidence not presented en bloc. Attention should also be paid to inconsistencies among the evidence, and witnesses should be called to testify when necessary. Fourth, lawyers must apply the law accurately in property‑related defense, for example by ensuring that the defendant’s and family’s essential living expenses and their sole residence are preserved in accordance with the law, and that fines and confiscated property are enforced only after civil claims have been satisfied. Attorney Liu Weidong stated that there is ample room for effective property‑related advocacy, and that lawyers have much to contribute—by providing professional representation, they can safeguard their clients’ legitimate property rights.


Wang Zhaofeng

Lawyer Wang Zhaofeng, director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, believes that to mount an effective defense concerning property involved in a case, the first step is to clarify the logic underlying the identification of such property. Although China’s Criminal Procedure Law currently lacks a uniform definition of “property involved in a case,” according to regulations issued separately by the Ministry of Public Security and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, such property must possess the following characteristics: 1) it must be seized and preserved by the agency handling the criminal case; 2) it must be obtained during the course of the criminal proceedings; 3) its seizure must comply with legally prescribed methods and formalities; and 4) it must be relevant to the case. Of course, each of these criteria remains subject to debate in practice, and there are frequent instances of non‑compliance. In addition to seizure, detention, and freezing, administrative custody is also employed in practice; however, this measure not only lacks a statutory basis but also lacks detailed procedural guidelines, leading to arbitrary application and numerous problems. The burden of proof regarding property involved in a case should rest with the prosecution and must meet the standard of being both conclusive and sufficient—neither presumptions nor vague formulations will suffice.


With regard to the logic underlying the identification of assets involved in a case, defense counsel must first prioritize property‑related defenses and adopt a holistic approach that encompasses the entire procedural lifecycle. Methodologically, both procedural and substantive defenses should be given equal weight, with due emphasis on procedural safeguards. Careful attention should be paid to the collection and cross‑examination of property‑related evidence, and counsel should skillfully advance arguments grounded in property‑based defenses, seeking the establishment of dedicated procedural mechanisms for such claims. In terms of remedies, appeals and complaints must be vigorously pursued. Furthermore, the determination of criminal proceeds should focus on tracing the origin of assets, distinguishing between mixed investment returns, and differentiating between venture capital and孳息 (fruits or income generated from an asset). The characterization of criminal instruments should hinge on whether they are used exclusively or occasionally. Additionally, counsel should address distinctions between personal and family assets, as well as between corporate and family property, while also scrutinizing bona fide third‑party acquisitions, thereby effectively safeguarding the legitimate property rights of all stakeholders in criminal proceedings.


Zhao Yunheng

Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, delivered a speech titled “Protection of Third-Party Property in the Disposition of Case-Related Assets.” ». He argues that, in refining the disposition of property involved in criminal cases, particular attention should be paid to safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of third parties, thereby addressing the current practice in many cases where third-party property is infringed upon—and, in some instances, third parties are even held criminally liable. To this end, Attorney Zhao recommends adopting a three‑pronged approach. First, procedurally, it is essential to recognize third‑party stakeholders as parties to the proceedings and grant them standing. At present, the legal framework is overly rudimentary, offering only general principles for protecting third‑party rights; third parties lack procedural rights, resulting in the denial of such fundamental entitlements as the right to information, the right to participate in court hearings, the right to defense, and the right to appeal. Third parties should be accorded party status, with their participation guaranteed at every stage—from seizure, attachment, and freezing through judgment to enforcement. Second, substantively, the criteria for identifying and distinguishing property involved in criminal cases should be refined. Specifically, clear standards must be established—either through concrete benchmarks or illustrative examples—for determining what constitutes illicit proceeds, instruments of crime, and evidence of criminal activity; for delineating which assets subject to fines or confiscation belong to third parties and thus deserve protection; and for defining “necessary living expenses.” Such clarity will help reduce discretionary leeway. Third, organizationally, the capacity to review property ownership should be strengthened. Many issues concerning the identification of the origin and nature of property involved in criminal cases fall within the realm of civil property‑law relationships, areas in which public security, procuratorial, and judicial personnel may lack the requisite expertise and experience. Therefore, civil‑law specialists should be brought into the process. Moreover, a mechanism of mutual oversight among the public security, procuratorial, judicial, and enforcement authorities should be instituted, enabling prompt referral of any identified problems. Finally, an independent litigation regime for third‑party property claims should be explored, with civil adjudicatory bodies participating, so as to ensure accurate findings of fact and law.


Zhao Chunyu

Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm, addressed the topic “The Boundaries of Improper Property Interests Derived from Bribery.” 》 She delivered a presentation on this topic. She pointed out that obtaining a competitive advantage through bribery may be deemed as “seeking improper benefits”; however, the property gains derived from such a competitive advantage cannot automatically be classified as “improper property‑related benefits obtained through bribery.” Subsequently, citing a corporate bribery case she personally handled—where the amount involved totaled RMB 100.9 million—she proposed four analytical dimensions for determining whether a benefit qualifies as an “improper property‑related benefit obtained through bribery”: First, assess whether all the business activities at issue originated from official arrangements. If the briber already had similar clients and stable revenues prior to the bribery, it is inappropriate to presumptively conclude that all operating profits constitute improper property‑related benefits derived from bribery. Second, examine whether the bribing entity invested its own capital, labor, technology, and management, and assumed market risks. If the proceeds obtained through bribery include reasonable cost expenditures, such costs should be deducted when determining the extent of the improper property‑related benefits. Third, evaluate whether the bribing entity’s lawful operations and the implicated activities can be accounted for separately. If it cannot be demonstrated that official assistance extended to all business activities, one cannot leap from the premise that “some operations were secured through bribery” to the conclusion that “the entire enterprise’s operations are unlawful,” thereby seeking to recover all profits. Fourth, consider the role played by the qualifications and licenses obtained through bribery in the enterprise’s overall operations. If the evidence presented only establishes that the qualifications were acquired improperly but fails to demonstrate a necessary causal link between those qualifications and specific profits, then the subsequent operating profits should not be subject to full recovery.


Wang Zhixiang

The commentator for the first half of the forum was Professor Wang Zhixiang, Director of the Institute of Foreign Criminal Law and Comparative Criminal Law at the Law School of Beijing Normal University, as well as a professor and doctoral supervisor. Professor Wang summarized the presentations of the six speakers in the first half and distilled their core consensus into three key points: first, property‑related defenses must be addressed at an earlier stage; second, such defenses require independent rules of evidence and procedural safeguards; and third, the protection of third‑party property represents the most pressing institutional gap at present.


At the theoretical level, Professor Wang Zhixiang focuses on analyzing three key points of contention in property‑related defense. First, there is a debate over the expansion versus restriction of the definition of illicit proceeds. The direct‑association standard should be upheld: illicit proceeds consist solely of property directly obtained through the crime and any孳息 derived therefrom, and should not be arbitrarily extended to include indirect gains; otherwise, the scope of illicit proceeds could be unduly broadened. In practice, three criteria should be established—direct association, traceability, and the deduction of lawful costs. Second, there is a predicament in providing property‑related relief to third parties. Currently, initiating such relief procedures is difficult, the burden of proof is reversed, and available avenues for redress are inadequate, leaving third parties unable to obtain timely information or effectively protect their rights. The key to addressing this issue lies in establishing a rapid hearing mechanism for third‑party objections. Third, the question concerns the reasonableness of fines and the boundaries of judicial discretion. The existing standards for fine‑based penalties are vague, and the upper limit is largely nominal. It is recommended that the amount of the fine be determined reasonably by comprehensively considering factors such as the value of the offense, the offender’s financial capacity, the impact on employees’ employment, and the extent of restitution.


At the legislative and institutional levels, Professor Wang Zhixiang recommends adding a dedicated chapter on the disposition of property involved in criminal cases to the Criminal Procedure Law, clearly defining illicit proceeds and enumerating grounds for exclusion, and introducing provisions to safeguard the interests of third parties outside the case. At the judicial level, it is advisable to promote a specialized courtroom procedure for handling property involved in criminal cases, establish mechanisms for the participation of non‑parties in litigation, and refine the pre‑trial asset management system. At the law‑enforcement level, it is essential to shift mindsets, strengthen oversight, rectify the longstanding enforcement bias toward personal liberty at the expense of property, institute a lifelong accountability mechanism for the disposition of property involved in criminal cases, and enhance training for case-handling personnel to systematically improve their overall competence.


Professor Wang Zhixiang concluded by stating that the rise of property‑related defense marks a profound transformation in criminal rule of law, urging every legal professional to reassess their knowledge framework and professional ethos. He expressed hope that today’s discussion would help advance the refinement of China’s property‑related defense system.


✦

Second half

✦

Yang Dakang

The second half of the forum was moderated by Yang Dakang, the founder of the legal self-media platform “Dakang Parlor.”


Mao Lixin

The first speaker in the second half of the forum was Lawyer Mao Lixin, Honorary Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm. He addressed the “three distinctions” in the disposition of assets in organized‑crime cases. ” 》 On this topic, he elaborated on the challenges encountered in judicial practice when distinguishing between “illegal proceeds and lawful property,” “the individual’s property and the property of third parties,” and “personal property and the property of corporate legal persons,” as well as proposed corresponding solutions. He argued that the scope of “illegal proceeds” should be strictly delimited: administrative violations and the identification and confiscation of associated illegal proceeds ought to be referred to the competent administrative authorities; and any proceeds generated from reinvestment of such illegal proceeds should take into account the legitimate capital, technology, labor, and other costs invested by the perpetrator. With respect to the assets of suspects or defendants who have absconded or died in organized‑crime cases, these should, in principle, be handled through the procedure for confiscating illegal proceeds set forth in Chapter IV of Part V of the Criminal Procedure Law; under circumstances where the individual is tried in absentia and cannot appoint counsel to participate in the proceedings, such assets may not be confiscated under the label of “organized‑crime assets.” Furthermore, a clear distinction must be maintained between personal property and the property of corporate legal persons; even if it becomes necessary to freeze or confiscate personal equity held in the name of a suspect or defendant, the property of the corporate legal person itself must not be directly seized, impounded, or frozen, nor may the lawful property of the corporate legal person be directly pursued or confiscated in proportion to the individual’s shareholding.

                                                   

Zhu Yonghui

Attorney Zhu Yonghui, director of the Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, delivered a presentation on “Property‑Based Defense in Bribery Cases Involving the Receipt of ‘Commercial Opportunities.’” He compared distinct defense strategies under two scenarios—principal‑guaranteed and investment‑type—and emphasized the need to determine whether what was received constitutes a definite property interest or merely a commercial opportunity. He argued that bribery involving “guaranteed returns regardless of outcomes” as a commercial opportunity exhibits three non‑market characteristics: specificity of the intended recipient, risk aversion, and a quid pro quo between power and money. Among these, risk aversion represents a key point for defense; accordingly, counsel should ascertain whether the defendant made genuine capital contributions and whether they participated in management by providing labor. The amount of the bribe should be fixed at the value of the opportunity at the time of receipt, rather than treating all subsequent business profits as part of the bribe; at a minimum, the respective shares should be distinguished. Finally, he pointed out that when calculating the bribe amount, “indirect gains” must not be extended indefinitely and must bear a causal link to the commercial opportunity itself. Where multiple causes converge to produce a final benefit, determining how to assess the proportionate weight attributable to the commercially obtained opportunity is a matter worthy of careful consideration and legislative refinement.


Mao Hongtao

Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm, addressed “The Standardized Application of Enterprise Custody and Proxy Management Measures in Cases Involving Organized Crime.” 》 He delivered a keynote address on the topic. He argued that corporate trusteeship and custodianship embody the institutional intent of “safeguarding market entities and protecting employees’ employment,” yet, owing to weak statutory foundations and a lack of procedural safeguards, practical implementation suffers from issues such as overly broad application, disjointed governance mechanisms, insufficient operational guidelines, and inadequate avenues for redress. He pointed out that, at present, the institutional basis for trusteeship and custodianship is confined to Article 12 of the 2019 “Opinions” issued jointly by the Supreme People’s Court, the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, the Ministry of Public Security, and the Ministry of Justice. Meanwhile, the Criminal Procedure Law provides only three property‑disposition measures—seizure, impoundment, and freezing—and neither trusteeship nor custodianship has been codified at the legal level; even the Anti‑Organized Crime Law, which entered into force in 2022, makes no mention of these arrangements. Furthermore, the “operational assets that should not be seized, impounded, or frozen” specified in the Opinions are sometimes extended in practice to cover the entire corporate entity. After a trusteeship team takes office, the boundaries of governance authority and responsibility between it and the original shareholders’ meeting or board of directors remain unclear. Moreover, supporting rules governing the appointment, duration, fees, and oversight of trusteeship institutions are still lacking, leaving affected stakeholders without clear channels for redress. He proposed the following measures: first, explicitly designate trusteeship and custodianship as special measures for the disposition of assets involved in organized crime within amendments to the Anti‑Organized Crime Law or the Criminal Procedure Law, and clarify their legal nature in accompanying implementing rules; second, exercise prudent discretion in determining applicable subjects, avoiding the simplistic approach of subjecting all large enterprises implicated in organized crime to trusteeship, and refraining from imposing trusteeship on enterprises that operate normally, maintain stable operations, and pose no risk of asset dissipation; third, shift the decision‑making process for trusteeship from internal approval by the investigating authority to a procedure whereby “the investigating authority submits a request, followed by a ruling of the people’s court at the same level,” with major asset‑related trusteeships requiring hierarchical reporting and filing with the provincial-level court; fourth, establish statutory qualifications for trusteeship institutions, ensure transparency in the selection process, and mandate recusal of any parties with conflicting interests; fifth, set an initial trusteeship period of no more than six months, with a total term generally not exceeding the conclusion of the first-instance trial, and institute a phased‑evaluation system; sixth, grant independent rights of objection to non‑involved shareholders, directors, major creditors, and employee representatives, thereby establishing a redress chain comprising “objection–review–reconsideration”; and seventh, stipulate that trustees bear the duty of a “diligent manager,” and that they shall be held liable for damages resulting from improper performance of duties, in accordance with relevant provisions of the Company Law.


Yang Kuangsheng

Lawyer Yang Kuangsheng, director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, presented his views on “Several Difficult Issues in Property‑Related Defense in Organized Crime Cases.” He reviewed the evolution of property‑related defense as it entered the litigation process, noting that such defense is emerging as a new paradigm in legal advocacy and that related issues should be addressed comprehensively in the ongoing revision of the Criminal Procedure Law. He then offered his perspectives on four challenging questions concerning the disposition of assets and defense strategies in organized crime cases. First, regarding escrow and entrusted management, he analyzed several practices observed in case handling, pointing out that these arrangements lack sufficient legal basis and clear substantive guidance. He argued that if this system is to remain in place, relevant judicial interpretations and legislative provisions must be clarified and refined. Second, he addressed whether all interests derived from enterprises established through the defendant’s investment constitute illicit gains. He emphasized that profits generated by legally established enterprises—founded with lawful funds and duly approved—should be recognized as legitimate and cannot be subject to confiscation as illegal proceeds. Third, he examined the burden of proof concerning the lawful origin of assets held by the defendant during the period of accusation. Fourth, he considered whether judicial authorities may re‑seize or dispose of lawful property that the defendant had already disposed of prior to the incident. He maintained that, before the offense occurred, the defendant has the right to dispose of his lawful property in good faith, and any third party who acquires such property in good faith through a gift should enjoy legal protection.


Cheng Xiaolu

Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, used a share‑transfer case as a starting point to discuss the challenges faced by third parties in protecting their property rights. A major state‑owned enterprise, having transferred its equity through a legitimate property‑rights trading platform and received RMB 800 million in proceeds, was surprised five years later to learn that the buyer’s funds originated from illegal or criminal activities. As a result, a court issued an enforcement order mandating the return of those funds without compensation.


This case highlights three structural dilemmas in the protection of third-party property rights during criminal asset recovery: First, on the substantive level, the court rejected T Company’s bona fide acquisition on the ground that the equity transfer had not been registered; if the full amount is forcibly ordered to be returned, who will bear the loss resulting from the substantial devaluation of the equity? Second, procedurally, the investigating authority issued a letter demanding that T Company return the funds, yet failed to notify T Company of its right to participate in the litigation as required by law, nor did it reflect this in the judgment; the ruling merely stipulated in general terms that “asset recovery shall continue,” without identifying the specific party to be pursued. Third, at the enforcement stage, a “statement of circumstances” issued by the criminal court was used in lieu of an enforceable judgment as the basis for execution, gravely violating the principle of procedural fairness. Finally, with respect to avenues for redress, objections and reviews at the enforcement stage address only procedural matters, not the merits; judicial supervision is predicated on “correcting erroneous judgments,” leaving no mechanism for addressing omissions in the trial; and prosecutorial oversight lacks binding force, thereby comprehensively obstructing remedies for third parties.


Attorney Cheng Xiaolu recommends establishing an independent “action in rem” procedure to safeguard third‑party participation and the right of appeal; clarifying the specificity requirements for criminal property‑related judgments to eliminate vague rulings; prohibiting the use of “explanatory statements” as a substitute for formal judicial documents in enforcement proceedings; and introducing a substantive review mechanism into the execution‑objection process to address third‑party substantive defenses. This case serves as a warning: recovering illicit gains and mitigating losses must not come at the expense of market transaction security, and it is imperative to promptly address institutional gaps in the handling of property‑related matters.


Guo Shuo

In the second half of the meeting, by Guo Shuo, Dean of the Capital Institute (Beijing Legislative Research Institute) at China University of Political Science and Law, Professor at the Institute of Litigation Studies, and Doctoral Supervisor. Provide feedback. Professor Guo Shuo pointed out, The current Criminal Procedure Law is, in essence, a “criminal procedure law focused on persons,” with a long-standing absence of institutional provisions addressing property-related matters. This phenomenon stems from the historical context of its enactment and lies at the root of many contemporary challenges in property‑related defense. The issue of property involved in criminal cases is set to become a major highlight of the ongoing revision of the Criminal Procedure Law, potentially encompassing improvements to measures such as seizure, impoundment, and freezing, as well as the disposition of such property.


Drawing on the forum presentations, Professor Guo Shuo provided a detailed analysis of three specific issues related to asset disposal. First, The disposition of property involved in criminal cases lacks a legal basis. For instance, measures currently in use—such as custodial management and takeover—impinge upon citizens’ constitutional rights yet fail to comply with the principle of legislative reservation; these should be refined at the statutory level. Secondly, property‑related defense raises interpretive controversies under the law. Taking the scope of “opportunity‑derived” illicit gains as an example, the judicial interpretation… [2017] No. 1 The judicial interpretation conflicts with the 2026 determination by the State Administration for Market Regulation that the scope of illegal gains is limited to “directly obtained” proceeds. Third, The status of third parties is absent in the Criminal Procedure Law. The concept of “third party,” as established by the judicial interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law, lacks a corresponding legal standing within the statute itself, thereby leaving the procedural safeguards for third parties’ rights to participate and to seek redress inadequate.


Professor Guo Shuo suggests that resolving the issue of handling case‑related property requires a two‑pronged approach: strengthening judicial oversight of seizure, impoundment, and freezing measures at the preliminary stage, and establishing a relatively independent procedure for the disposition of such property at the subsequent stage, thereby safeguarding the rights of third parties to participate in litigation.


Fan Chongyi

Honorary Dean of the Institute of Litigation Studies at China University of Political Science and Law, Distinguished Professor of the First Grade, and Doctoral Supervisor Fan Chongyi summarized and commented on the proceedings of this conference. Professor Fan Chongyi points out that the current practical challenges in handling property involved in criminal cases can be summarized into six key areas: First, the legislative framework is fragmented, with property‑related procedures subordinated to personal‑prosecution proceedings and lacking an independent procedural regime; second, substantive criteria for classification are vague, leaving no clear distinctions among six categories of property—illicit proceeds, instruments of crime, lawful property, jointly owned property, and property acquired in good faith by third parties—thus preventing tiered treatment of assets subject to both criminal and civil law; third, there is an imbalance in the allocation of pre‑trial powers of seizure, freezing, and detention, with investigative authorities exercising autonomous decision‑making, prosecutorial oversight lagging behind, and a mechanism for lawyer participation absent; fourth, remedies for third parties are inadequate: they lack party status, have no independent right to bring suit, and the written‑review model struggles to ensure substantive adjudication; fifth, legislation is silent on the custody and preliminary disposition of property involved in criminal cases, and segmented custody risks devaluation of such assets; and sixth, inter‑agency coordination and a comprehensive legal supervision system covering the entire process remain underdeveloped.


At the level of legislative improvement, Professor Fan Chongyi proposed… The legislative reform should be guided by the principle of giving equal weight to personal rights and property rights, while incorporating the “integration of civil, administrative, and criminal law.” ” The approach adheres to the principles of proportionality, good faith and prudence, and comprehensive redress, and establishes a dedicated chapter to ensure seamless coordination across the entire chain. Specifically, it includes: Six recommendations: First, add an independent chapter on the disposition of property involved in criminal cases to the Criminal Procedure Law, thereby establishing a procedure for actions concerning property; second, clearly define the scope of six categories of property, establish tiered criteria for distinguishing between criminal and civil matters, and enshrine the principles of proportionality and good‑faith prudence in the statute; third, institute a mechanism separating the authority to issue seizure, freezing, and detention orders from enforcement powers, ensuring that lawyers can participate in property‑related defense at an early stage; fourth, develop a tiered system for safeguarding the rights of third parties outside the case, granting them pre‑trial objections, courtroom participation, and the right to bring independent lawsuits; fifth, establish a centralized third‑party custody system for property involved in criminal proceedings, standardizing the priority of debt repayment; and sixth, create a closed‑loop prosecutorial oversight mechanism covering the entire process, along with inter‑agency coordination. Professor Fan Chongyi concluded by expressing his hope that, through the discussions at this forum, a specialized… Report to and submit to the relevant authorities to promote the development of the system for handling property involved in cases and the improvement of the criminal procedure system!


At the conclusion of this conference, “The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” ” Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, Secretary-General of the Forum, expressed gratitude on behalf of the Ten‑Person Criminal Defense Forum. The event lasted nearly five hours, during which eleven speakers and two commentators offered incisive insights, while Professor Fan Chongyi’s concluding remarks elevated the discussion to a new level. Fan Chongyi The professor has proposed compiling the outcomes into a special report, signing it, and submitting it to the relevant authorities. This generous support and sense of responsibility represent a profound endorsement of the forum, and we are determined to live up to this trust. The disposition of assets involved in criminal cases not only concerns the legitimate property rights of the parties concerned but also bears on the survival and development of market entities and the very foundations of a law-based business environment. Meanwhile, the myriad challenges currently facing asset‑related defense practice compel us to seek solutions at the institutional level. We will keep these directives firmly in mind, translating the findings of this symposium into concrete actions that advance the revision of the Criminal Procedure Law, thereby elevating asset‑related defense from the margins to the center, from a subsidiary role to an independent one, and contributing our modest share to the progress of the rule of law.


Introduction to the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum

“The Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, It was jointly initiated and established in early 2018 by ten criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. The initiators include: Yang Kuangsheng of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm, Xu Lanting of Beijing Junyong Law Firm, Qian Lieyang of Beijing Zihua Law Firm, Hao Chunli of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm, Liu Weidong of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm, Wang Zhaofeng of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm, Zhao Yunheng of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, Mao Lixin of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, Zhu Yonghui of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm, Beijing… Dongwei Law Firm Mao Hongtao and nine other criminal defense lawyers in Beijing. Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, serves as the Forum’s Secretary-General, while Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm, holds the position of Deputy Secretary-General.

The purpose of establishing this forum is: Jointly examine cutting-edge issues in criminal defense, advance the professionalization and standardization of criminal advocacy, promote a rational and reasoned culture of criminal defense, foster a harmonious and mutually reinforcing criminal defense ecosystem, and contribute modest efforts to the development of criminal defense and the rule of law in China.

Since the establishment of the “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum, it has successively convened discussions on topics including: “Criminal Defense in the Context of the Implementation of the Supervision Law”; “The Draft Amendment to the Criminal Procedure Law”; “The Impact of the Integration of Arrest and Prosecution on Criminal Defense”; “The Current Situation of Difficult Access to Meetings with Clients and the Protection of Lawyers’ Defense Rights”; “Protection of Property Rights of Private Entrepreneurs Involved in Criminal Cases”; “An Interpretation of the ‘Four Opinions’ on Cases Involving the Campaign Against Organized Crime and Evil Forces”; “Practical Issues in Defending Financial‑Related Crimes”; “The Application of Evidence Rules in Criminal Defense”; “The Relationship Among Prosecution, Defense, and Adjudication in Cases Involving Plea Bargaining and Acceptance of Punishment”; and “The Impacts and Changes Brought by the Interpretation of the New Criminal Procedure Law on Criminal Defense.” “The 11th ‘Ten-Person Forum on Criminal Defense’ and Symposium on Lawyers’ Participation in Corporate Compliance” “Implementation of the Legal Aid Law and Criminal Defense” “Defense in Fraud Crimes” “The Necessity of Holding Criminal Second-Instance Trials and Ways to Improve Them” “Prevention and Correction of Wrongful Cases Involving Enterprises, along with Mechanisms for Filing Appeals and Seeking Retrials” “Challenges and Strategies in Defending Against Financial and Securities‑Related Crimes” “Amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law and the Improvement of the Defense System” “Evidence-Based Defense Practice: Principles and Methods” “Reflections on and Improvements to the Current Relationship Between Defense and Trial” The Coordination Between the Two Laws and Defense in Official‑Duty Crime Cases under the “Three‑Pronged Approach” (Standardization, Rule of Law, and Regularization) ”“ Examination and Cross-Examination of Oral Evidence ”“ Practical Challenges in Property Defense and Legislative Improvements ” It has organized twenty-two specialized forums on topical and cutting-edge issues in the field of criminal justice. Each forum invites experts from legislative and judicial bodies, criminal law scholars, renowned defense attorneys, and stakeholders from various sectors who are concerned with criminal defense, offering multi‑dimensional perspectives to analyze and evaluate criminal defense practice, discuss legislative and practical issues in the field, and advance the rule of law in criminal matters, thereby generating a positive social impact.



Source: Criminal Defense Ten-Person Forum Official Account


Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996


Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province

Contact number: 027-82288828



Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Building E, Weilan Business Harbor, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916


Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license