Criminal defense marks the starting point of Xinglai Law Firm’s journey, and it is also the very foundation upon which we have, over the past five years, steadfastly pursued excellence and upheld integrity. It concerns liberty and life, scrutinizes evidence and legal principles, and stands as a highly challenging yet immensely valuable field within the broader endeavor of advancing the rule of law.
In complex cases involving the intersection of criminal, civil, and administrative law, precise criminal adjudication often serves as the key to unlocking the broader impasse. Exceptional criminal defense not only provides ultimate protection for individual rights but also clears the fog at the boundary between business and crime, thereby safeguarding both corporate continuity and the integrity of the business environment.
The ten exemplary cases selected this time collectively highlight the Xinglai Criminal Defense Team’s professional expertise and experience accumulated over the past year. —from precisely distinguishing among different offenses in high‑profile vaccine‑safety cases to overturning sentencing outcomes by breaking through entrenched local judicial practices; from leveraging data‑driven defense to secure a decision of non‑prosecution for an expert reviewer, to meticulously scrutinizing evidentiary ambiguities and exonerating entrepreneurs. Each case is a formidable battle, and every defense embodies our unwavering commitment to the highest standards of professional integrity.
This is the criminal‑law chapter of Xinglai’s fifth‑anniversary annual report, inviting you to review it together and experience the rationality and human warmth at play in the pursuit of the rule of law.
Criminal Defense Case
2025 Starry Selection
※ The cases are listed in no particular order; they are arranged alphabetically by the first letter of the lead counsel’s name.
1. Case of the production and sale of substandard drugs by a former company in Northeast China and its de facto controller, Gao Moumou.
Lead Counsel: Cheng Xiaolu
This case originated seven years ago with a nationwide scandal involving vaccine safety, in which a company in Northeast China was exposed for falsifying production and testing records for a particular vaccine. At the time, the matter attracted widespread public attention and constituted a major case with implications for public safety, social stability, and government regulatory oversight. Attorney Cheng Xiaolu, as one of the lead defense counsel in this case, became involved in July 2018 to defend the company’s chairman, Mr. Gao. Handling this case required not only addressing legal issues but also maintaining a high level of political awareness and demonstrating comprehensive professional expertise. The case presented multiple procedural and substantive disputes, spanned an extended period, and placed significant physical and psychological demands on both the defense counsel and the client. Moreover, the case posed a high degree of technical complexity, with substantial controversy over the application and interpretation of the law—issues that touched upon specialized knowledge of vaccine manufacturing, the determination of causal relationships under criminal law, and other intricate matters, thereby substantially increasing the difficulty of the defense.
This case spanned seven years and finally went to trial at the first instance in December last year. Gao was charged with multiple offenses, including manufacturing and selling substandard drugs, embezzlement in office, misappropriation of funds, accepting bribes as a non‑public official, and corporate bribery. At the first instance, the court ultimately found that the charge of embezzlement in office did not stand and reclassified the offense of manufacturing and selling substandard drugs as manufacturing and selling counterfeit or substandard products.
2. From a sentence of five years and nine months to nine months: Attorney Xing Lai successfully challenged the judicial precedent on “operating a casino.”
Lead Attorneys: Cheng Xiaolu, Qi Jiaqi
This case arose in a city in southern China. The procuratorial authorities charged the defendant with participating in a certain type of gambling operation and, on the basis of his share of the rake, designated him as a principal offender, recommending a sentence of five years and nine months. At the time, local authorities virtually imposed a blanket conviction for the offense of running a casino, and, pursuant to local regulations, the penalty had already reached the statutory maximum for the second sentencing bracket. Adding to the difficulty, all co-defendants had pleaded guilty, while the principal offender remained at large, leaving very little room for defense.
Through meticulous defense, Attorneys Cheng Xiaolu and Qi Jiaqi successfully persuaded the court to convict their client of gambling and impose a nine-month sentence. The legal team first reconstructed the key facts by carefully reviewing the case file and conducting incisive questioning during the trial: the defendant had merely been lured into participating in an ad hoc gambling event, neither serving as an organizer nor assuming any managerial responsibilities.
On this basis, the defense is advanced from three perspectives: first, regarding the characterization of the offense, the distinction between the crime of operating a casino and the crime of gambling is delineated across six dimensions, while also invoking the context in which the sentencing disparity between the two offenses has widened following the Eleventh Amendment to the Criminal Law, thereby breaking with judicial inertia; second, the legality of local standards is challenged, with particular reference to how one province has set its sentencing guidelines for online casinos.
Analogical reasoning is applicable to offline chess-and-card game cases, yet it exceeds the scope of statutory interpretation; third, it redefines the status of co‑offenders, arguing that the parties occupy a subordinate position, thereby leading the court to designate all individuals involved in the case as accomplices.
Ultimately, the first-instance court reclassified the offense as gambling and sentenced the defendant to nine months’ imprisonment. Following the procuratorate’s appeal, the defense counsel engaged in thorough communication, successfully persuading the higher-level procuratorate to withdraw its appeal. This case not only secured justice in an individual instance but also broke with local judicial inertia, providing valuable guidance for the handling of similar cases.
3. Breaking the deadlock in data-driven defense: The bid evaluation expert involved in a bid-rigging case was ultimately not prosecuted.
Lead Counsel: Shen Xinyu
This case is a certain region Derivative cases arising from a thirteen-year retrospective investigation in the field of tendering and bidding. In 2021, during the evaluation of a construction project in City H, evaluation expert A, acting on behalf of an agency, granted “appropriate preferential treatment” to a specific bidder, B. Following B’s successful bid, A accepted a remuneration from the agency. A is now under criminal investigation for suspected collusion in tendering.
Upon accepting the client’s mandate, Attorney Shen Xinyu crafted a meticulously tailored defense strategy centered on the pivotal issue of whether the subjective scoring preferences of the decision‑maker had a material impact on the tender outcome. First, he obtained all expert scoring sheets and conducted simulation tests based on data analysis, demonstrating that even after excluding A’s scores, B still secured the contract by a substantial margin, thereby establishing that A’s scoring did not materially affect the result. Second, he rigorously reviewed each item against the evaluation criteria, confirming that A’s scores remained within an acceptable range and did not violate the relevant evaluation rules. In addition, Attorney Shen Xinyu researched and submitted several non‑prosecution decisions in similar cases as reference, employing a dual‑pronged approach—combining statistical analysis with case‑law comparison—to bolster the persuasiveness of his argument. Ultimately, after two rounds of remand for supplementary investigation, the procuratorial authority rendered a discretionary decision not to prosecute.
This case provides a quintessential example for addressing how to characterize and defend against the subjective, biased scoring practices of bid‑evaluation experts in criminal cases involving tendering and bidding. It underscores the pivotal role of data‑driven argumentation in legal defense, safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of technical professionals while offering practical guidance for standardizing judicial determinations in the field of bid evaluation, thereby demonstrating Attorney Shen Xinyu’s expertise in data‑based advocacy.
4. By thoroughly investigating evidentiary ambiguities and clarifying the boundaries among the parties involved, the case involving 6.95 million yuan in illegal fundraising ultimately resulted in a decision not to prosecute.
Lead Counsel: Shen Xinyu
This case is a typical example of an economic crime involving a large number of victims. Between 2011 and 2014, while A served as the head of JR Pawnshop, a subsidiary of the JR Group, the group’s de facto controller, B, was convicted of the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits for using the company to raise funds from the public. However, even after the judgment was rendered, the proceeds of the crime remained unenforced and unrecovered. Perceiving that B lacked the ability to repay, some investors in the scheme turned their attention to A, alleging—on the grounds that A was a managerial-level official within the JR Group—that A too had committed the crime of illegally absorbing public deposits, with the amount involved totaling RMB 6.95 million.
Upon accepting the client’s mandate, Attorney Shen Xinyu focused on constructing a defense strategy around the central dispute—whether A is the actual party involved in the case. First, he clarified the boundaries of legal liability by demonstrating that the investigating authorities had conflated A’s employer, JR Pawnshop, with B’s JR Investment Company, which was used for illegal fundraising. He collected and submitted more than ten pieces of evidence proving that the two companies were entirely independent in terms of personnel and operations, and that A had no connection to JR Investment Company, thus establishing that A was not a party to the case. Second, he meticulously scrutinized evidentiary inconsistencies, uncovering that some of the individuals who filed the accusations may have been relatives or friends of C, an employee of the JR Group. Furthermore, the police reports exhibited issues such as consistent handwriting and instances of uniform revisions, raising reasonable suspicions of maliciously shifting liability. Accordingly, he requested supplementary investigations centered on these key points. Ultimately, it was confirmed that several alleged investors were relatives or friends of C, that C had filed the reports on their behalf, and that many of them did not even know A; moreover, the funds had been lent to the JR Group through C, directly undermining the factual basis for criminal charges. Subsequently, after the case was twice returned for additional investigation, the procuratorial authority issued a decision of non-prosecution due to insufficient evidence.
This case is a typical example of how investors in mass‑impact economic crimes maliciously shift liability in an attempt to mitigate their losses. Through meticulously delineating the boundaries among the parties involved and thoroughly scrutinizing evidentiary ambiguities, Attorney Shen Xinyu successfully refuted false accusations, thereby fully demonstrating his professional expertise in handling complex criminal cases involving large numbers of victims.
5. Case of Zhou Moumou involving bribery: The absence of overseas evidence undermines the core charges, and assets worth tens of millions involved in the case have been unfrozen.
Lead Attorneys: Wang Jun, Chen Yujie
Zhou, a mid-level executive at a state-owned enterprise, has been placed under investigation by the National Commission for Supervision and the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection on suspicion of embezzlement, bribery, accepting bribes through influence peddling, offering bribes, and money laundering. The prosecution alleges that the total amount involved exceeds RMB 40 million, with the aggregate sentence for all charges exceeding 40 years. Most of the funds implicated have been squandered, and only RMB 10 million has been recovered. In addition, the investigating authorities have seized and frozen two properties owned by the defendant’s close relatives, as well as several bank accounts.
Upon accepting the mandate, Attorney Wang Jun’s team established a comprehensive, three‑pronged defense strategy encompassing conviction, sentencing, and asset disposition.
On the issue of conviction, the team focused its efforts on the core charge of accepting bribes by leveraging influence. The investigating authorities exhibited significant deficiencies in key evidence, particularly in overseas evidence, and there were substantial gaps in linking such foreign evidence with domestic evidence, making it difficult to establish a coherent evidentiary chain. In light of this, Attorney Wang Jun advanced a defense of not guilty, thereby securing substantial room for defense on behalf of the client.
In sentencing, the team adopted a pragmatic approach, engaging in expert-level communications with the prosecution prior to trial on issues of fact, evidence, and legal application. This ultimately resulted in a plea bargain, under which the prosecution proposed a minimum sentence of 20 years’ imprisonment—imposed cumulatively for multiple offenses—within the scope of its sentencing guidelines, thereby securing a relatively favorable outcome for the client.
In the area of asset disposition, Attorney Wang Jun submitted new evidence demonstrating that the seized and frozen assets were lawful, persuading the court to urge the supervisory commission to lift the seizure on two properties valued at tens of millions held by the defendant’s close relatives and to unfreeze funds totaling over RMB 4 million across multiple bank accounts belonging to the family, thereby safeguarding the family’s legitimate property rights.
This case is a foreign-related, classified‑information‑involving official‑crime matter designated for handling by the National Commission for Supervision and the Central Commission for Discipline Inspection. With an enormous sum of money at stake and complex legal relationships, it places exceptionally high demands on the professionalism and systematic approach of the defense. The course of proceedings and the outcome of the case fully demonstrate the StarLai legal team’s exceptional expertise.
6. Hong’s illegal business operation case: The second-instance court achieved a precise breakthrough, lifting the freeze on tens of millions of yuan in lawful assets.
Lead Counsel: Wang Weining, Chen Yujie
In the first instance, Hong was found to have engaged in unauthorized securities‑related business activities without approval, involving sums exceeding RMB 30 million, and was sentenced to five and a half years’ imprisonment for the crime of illegal business operations. At the same time, substantial lawful assets were frozen as proceeds of the offense. Attorney Wang Weining’s team intervened at the second-instance level.
Upon accepting the mandate, the team promptly conducted a thorough review of all case files and hundreds of accounting ledgers, uncovering significant issues in the first-instance proceedings: with respect to legal application, jurisdictional provisions were incorrectly applied; on the evidentiary front, the threshold for the admissibility of witness testimony was lowered, an erroneous audit report was relied upon to improperly determine the amount of illegal business activities, and evidence insufficient to dispel reasonable doubt was used to impose disproportionately severe penalties; as for property matters, funds representing equity interests were characterized as civil disputes and left unaddressed, yet were nonetheless confiscated as proceeds of crime.
Based on the foregoing, the team promptly formulated a defense strategy: First, with respect to witness testimony, multiple rounds of telephone interviews were conducted using the witness list to demonstrate that the alleged facts remain unclear and the evidence is insufficient. Second, regarding the audit report, hundreds of accounting ledgers and thousands of individual entries were meticulously cross‑checked, revealing an error of nearly RMB 10 million in the reported amount of illegal business operations, thereby establishing that the auditors violated China’s Certified Public Accountant Auditing Standards. Third, concerning property issues, the company’s equity structure and relevant agreements were thoroughly reviewed to prepare a legal opinion, which was then fully articulated during the second‑instance court proceedings.
Ultimately, the appellate court accepted the argument that certain facts were unclear and the evidence was insufficient, and remanded the case for a new trial. The case is currently undergoing retrial.
7. Promoting the recognition of corporate criminal liability and enabling prosecutors to amend indictments in court, resulting in the bank president’s sentence being reduced to the statutory minimum.
Lead Counsel: Wang Weining, Fu Xuehang
In 2022, Some Earth A special task force was established to investigate a case involving the illegal issuance of loans totaling RMB 6.6 billion by a rural‑township bank. Public security authorities imposed coercive measures on three managerial personnel, treating the matter as an individual offense. Attorney Wang Weining served as counsel for the bank’s president, Mr. Chen, arguing—on grounds such as the attribution of illicit gains and the decision‑making process—that the case constituted corporate crime rather than individual wrongdoing, while emphasizing the liability of the major shareholder. Following multiple rounds of consultation, the procuratorial authorities ultimately accepted this view, designating the bank as the criminal entity and recommending a lenient sentence for Mr. Chen. Given the exceptionally large sum involved and the fact that, in cases of unlawful loan issuance, the investigating authorities have, for the first time in the region, taken the defense counsel’s arguments into account in holding the bank accountable as a corporate offender, this case represents a landmark development.
In 2024, A certain place The Public Security Department reassigned jurisdiction over the case. Following investigation, the investigating authorities determined that, in addition to illegally issuing loans, Chen had committed 30 separate instances of accepting bribes as a non‑state employee. During the review and prosecution stage, Attorney Wang Weining’s team engaged in active communication with the prosecutors and submitted legal opinions, thereby safeguarding the earlier investigative findings. As a result, the new prosecutor adopted the previous prosecution authority’s relatively lenient sentencing recommendation for the crime of illegally issuing loans, while successfully reducing the number of alleged offenses to 14 and lowering the total amount involved from RMB 29 million to RMB 16 million. At the first‑instance trial, the legal team meticulously examined the evidence and persuaded the prosecutor to amend the indictment on the spot, further reducing the charged amount to RMB 9.15 million—a scenario that is exceedingly rare in judicial practice. In September 2025, the first‑instance judgment was rendered, ultimately recognizing only seven counts of bribery totaling RMB 3.96 million and imposing the minimum possible sentence on Chen. The defense achieved remarkable results and earned high praise from the client.
8. Having had the “organized crime” label removed and the charge of coercive trading overturned, Cao’s case involving the liquefied petroleum gas industry was granted a suspended sentence.
Lead Counsel: Wang Weining, Fu Xuehang
At the end of 2023, an entrepreneur in the liquefied petroleum gas industry in a certain region. Cao, a certain person Numerous individuals, including its employees, have been placed under criminal coercive measures, as investigators suspect their involvement in organized‑crime and gang‑related offenses. Attorney Wang Weining and his team promptly intervened, conducting investigations and gathering evidence to clarify the policy and industry context of the case, as well as the specific sequence of events. They also submitted opinions to the public security authorities on issues such as the legal characterization of the matter. Following the lawyers’ efforts, the public security organs no longer maintained the original classification as organized‑crime or gang‑related activity; instead, they transferred the case for review and prosecution on two charges—suspected coercion in transactions (five instances) and infringement of citizens’ personal information (with particularly serious circumstances)—both of which carry potentially severe penalties.
During the review-and-prosecution stage, the legal team, on the one hand, examined the case file and meticulously analyzed testimonial evidence to demonstrate that the “victim” entered into the transaction voluntarily and that the defendant did not employ coercive or threatening tactics. On the other hand, by scrutinizing the statutory elements of the offense, they argued that the facts of this case do not meet the legal criteria for forced trading. As a result of the lawyers’ efforts, the prosecutor ultimately reduced the number of alleged instances of forced trading in the indictment to one and proposed a sentencing range of three to four years. At the trial stage, the legal team maintained their defense that the defendant’s conduct did not constitute the crime of forced trading, further delving into the facts to reconstruct the true circumstances of the case. During cross-examination, they convincingly highlighted the passive nature of the transaction between the defendant and the victim, and raised robust challenges to the methodology used to determine the quantity of personal information obtained in the charge of infringing upon citizens’ personal information. Following the first-instance court hearing, the court decided to release the defendant on bail pending trial.
In July 2025, the procuratorial organ amended the indictment, no longer charging the defendant with the crime of forced trading. That same month, the court sentenced the defendant to a suspended sentence for the crime of infringing upon citizens’ personal information. Throughout the investigation, review-and-prosecution, and trial stages, the legal team meticulously advanced their strategy, systematically reducing the alleged facts and weakening the strength of the charges, ultimately achieving a dual reversal—both in the characterization of the case and in the sentencing.
9. Precise Defense: From Co‑perpetrator in a One-Million-Yuan Fraud Case to “Not Guilty” on the Ground That Criminal Liability Should Not Be Pursued
Lead Counsel: Yang Qichen
Following remote, off-site review of case files, Attorney Yang Qichen promptly conducted a detailed verification with the client; gathered from the client favorable evidence pertaining to their identity and professional activities; filed motions to subpoena key evidence, such as missing complete bid‑evaluation materials; and maintained ongoing communication with the prosecutor regarding the characterization of the case.
Under an overall strategy of pleading “not guilty” on the grounds of “insufficient evidence” and seeking a decision of “no prosecution” through “guilty plea and acceptance of punishment,” the defense maintained, on the one hand, that the evidence on file was inadequate to establish the substantive conduct of bid‑rigging by the client, nor did such conduct bear a causal relationship, in the criminal law sense, to the outcome of the tender. On the other hand, the defense emphasized the client’s status as an accomplice—engaged as an employee to perform routine administrative tasks, without criminal intent—and highlighted mitigating circumstances such as voluntary self‑surrender. Furthermore, given the unique context in which the client was required to be addressed collectively with other co‑defendants, the counsel, alongside the submission of the defense brief, also provided the prosecutor with numerous case examples illustrating acquittals, decisions of no prosecution, and exemptions from criminal penalties under various factual scenarios. Through sustained follow‑up and ongoing communication, the counsel ultimately persuaded the prosecutor to adopt these arguments and issue a decision of no prosecution.
The outcome of this case both upholds the principle of legality in criminal law and reflects a criminal policy that balances leniency with severity. Through meticulous evidentiary advocacy and sustained communication and negotiation, we helped the client secure a favorable result.
10. Precise Defense: From Joint Principal Offender in a One-Million-Yuan Fraud Case to “Not Guilty” on the Ground That Criminal Liability Should Not Be Pursued
Lead Counsel: Zhang Hongming, Wang Zihan
In this case, the client, A, was placed under criminal detention by the public security authorities as an accomplice to fraud for lending his ID card, opening bank accounts, and collecting wages on behalf of his friend, B. The incident arose when B used A’s identity to secure employment at multiple companies in Beijing and receive salaries; upon discovering this, the companies reported it to the police. During the investigation, the public security authorities treated A and B as co‑offenders, and obtained certain incriminating statements, including that A had opened several bank accounts within a short period, that his accounts received frequent deposits over the course of a month, and that he charged B a small fee each time he processed transfers.
Upon accepting the mandate, Attorneys Zhang Hongming and Wang Zihan promptly met with the client. Through meticulous communication and a thorough review of the evidence, they identified a critical breakthrough: there was a temporal discrepancy between A’s alleged involvement and the period during which B committed the fraud, thereby laying the groundwork for the subsequent defense.
The defense counsel advanced arguments on five grounds: First, A was unaware of B’s fraudulent scheme and was never disclosed any details thereof by B. Second, A lacked the subjective intent to unlawfully appropriate the funds; upon receipt of the wages, A promptly remitted the full amount to B without retaining any portion. Third, A never had any contact with the victim and did not engage in any fraudulent conduct. Fourth, the modest fees collected by A amounted to less than 1% of B’s actual proceeds, constituting a purely civil‑law compensation. Fifth, there was no shared intent or concerted action between A and B; A’s conduct predates B’s fraud, amounting to pre‑emptive, one‑sided assistance that fails to satisfy the elements of complicity.
Ultimately, during the review of the arrest stage, the procuratorial organ decided not to approve the arrest. In accordance with Article 79, Paragraph 2 of the Criminal Procedure Law, the public security organ lifted the bail pending trial imposed on A on the grounds that criminal liability should not be pursued.
✦
•
✦
The cases outlined above represent the Star Lai Criminal Defense Team’s steady progress over the past year. From high‑profile, sensitive matters to novel and complex disputes, and from steadfast adherence to procedural fairness to groundbreaking substantive advocacy, we have consistently approached each case with due respect and responded to every mandate with professional rigor.
The path of criminal defense is long and fraught with obstacles, yet perseverance will lead to success. At Xinglai, we aspire to take the next five years as a fresh starting point, continuing to uphold professional integrity and humanistic concern, striving for truth and justice in every case, and contributing our modest efforts to the building of a law-based China.
With this, the StarLai Five-Year Anniversary Showcase of Selected Cases has officially come to a close. We extend our heartfelt gratitude to every supporter for your attention and thoughtful review—your discerning eyes have helped amplify the rule-of-law significance of these cases. Though the case showcase has concluded, our pursuit of professional excellence knows no bounds. In the intricate intersection of criminal, civil, and administrative law, at the crossroads of business and jurisprudence, the team at StarLai will continue to uphold both professionalism and reverence, shining as a beacon that cuts through the fog and harnessing the power of the rule of law to guide the steady advancement of commerce.
✦
•
✦
Previous Issues Recap
One-Year Anniversary | Xinglai’s Annual Performance Review — Criminal Defense Edition
Editors: Fu Xuehang, Wang Xin
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee
Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12