CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

Note: This document has been compiled and revised based on Attorney Cheng Xiaolu’s remarks at the 20th Criminal Defense Ten‑Person Forum, held under the “Three‑fold Approach” (standardization, rule of law, and regularization), which focused on the interface between the two laws and the defense of official‑duty crimes.


 

Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm


 

I will now address three key aspects: the practical challenges of mounting an effective defense in cases involving official misconduct, an analysis of the underlying causes, and a discussion of how criminal defense lawyers can expand their scope of engagement within the context of the new Supervision Law and the “three‑pronged” reform of discipline inspection and supervision.


 


 

I. The Practical Dilemmas of Effective Defense in Cases of Official Misconduct


 

Following the reform of the supervisory system, the landscape of defense in cases involving official misconduct has undergone a fundamental transformation, and lawyers in practice now confront numerous unprecedented challenges, which can be summarized as follows:


 

(1) The proportion of defendants who neither plead guilty nor accept the penalty has been rising, and instances of recantation after referral to the judiciary occur from time to time.


 

In stark contrast to the conviction‑and‑plea‑agreement rate of over 85% in ordinary criminal cases, the rate for official‑duty crimes is markedly lower. According to a search and statistical analysis conducted on the China Judgments Online database, in 2020, 17,349 cases involving embezzlement and bribery were concluded, yet only 4,767—approximately 27.5%—were resolved through the application of the conviction‑and‑plea‑agreement procedure. Even more concerning is that many defendants plead guilty during the investigation phase, only to retract all or part of their admissions at the review‑and‑prosecution or trial stages. This suggests that the reliability of “guilty” statements obtained during the investigative phase is questionable, raising potential issues regarding their voluntariness and authenticity and introducing significant uncertainties and challenges for subsequent defense strategies.


 

(2) The exclusionary procedure is rendered hollow, and procedural defenses are effectively meaningless.


 

In practice, instances of disguised coercion—such as “pointing, questioning, and extracting confessions” or threatening the safety of relatives—along with inducements to elicit confessions, occur frequently. Although the Criminal Procedure Law explicitly establishes the exclusionary rule for illegally obtained evidence, in cases involving official misconduct, this rule is difficult to implement effectively. When defense counsel seeks to obtain access to the complete, synchronized audio‑video recordings of investigative interrogations in order to verify the legality of the evidence‑gathering process, such requests are rarely granted. It is commonplace for these recordings to remain unproduced, for supervisory investigators to fail to appear in court, and for the exclusionary procedure to be little more than a formality. Prosecutors and courts often refuse on the grounds that “supervisory investigations do not fall within the investigation stage” or that “obtaining the recordings requires coordination with the supervisory authority,” resulting in the exclusionary procedure being rendered hollow and reduced to a mere procedural exercise.


 

Even before the reform of the supervisory system, criminal trial reference cases involving official misconduct had already established a rule on the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence. In Case No. 1140 of the Supreme People’s Court’s “Criminal Trial Reference” (the case of Zheng Zuwen for embezzlement, bribery, and abuse of power), the Guangzhou Intermediate People’s Court rendered the first-instance judgment; following an appeal by the procuratorate, the Guangdong High People’s Court ultimately dismissed the appeal and upheld the original verdict. That guiding case explicitly held that confessions extracted through threats to the safety of family members constitute an unlawful method that “inflicts mental suffering on the defendant” and must therefore be excluded. However, since the reform of the supervisory system, we have scarcely encountered any such cases involving the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence.


 

(3) The right to appointed counsel is subject to improper interference, and the phenomenon of “seat‑blocking defense” is particularly pronounced.


 

It is not uncommon for supervisory authorities, directly or indirectly, to instruct or threaten the family members of those under investigation not to retain counsel—particularly not to engage lawyers from other jurisdictions, such as Beijing. In most cases, family members opt to yield, reluctantly accepting the designated local attorney, which has given rise to the widespread practice of “placeholder defense” and seriously undermines the right of the person under investigation to effective legal representation.


 

(4) Abusing the practice of splitting cases to dismantle the defense coalition of co-defendants.


 

In cases involving joint criminal offenses, supervisory and procuratorial authorities tend to assign defendants who have pleaded guilty and accepted punishment to one case file, while those who do not plead guilty and adopt a staunchly defensive stance are assigned to another. Although the prosecutors appearing in court and the members of the collegial panel remain identical across the separate cases, this division effectively isolates the defendants from on‑the‑spot cross‑examination, making it difficult for the defense counsel of the non‑guilty defendant to challenge the confessions of co‑defendants and thereby hindering the ability to expose factual inconsistencies. In essence, this practice undermines the effectiveness of the defense.


 


 

II. An Analysis of the Causes Behind the Difficulty of Effective Defense in Official-Crime Cases


 

The aforementioned predicament is no accident; it stems from profound institutional and systemic factors:


 

(1) The absolute opacity of investigative procedures and the absence of external oversight


 

During the stage of supervisory investigation, lawyers are not permitted to intervene, creating a completely closed “black box” environment devoid of external oversight. Unchecked power inevitably carries the risk of abuse. The absence of legal counsel means that the legality of evidence‑gathering rests entirely on the self‑restraint of the supervisory authorities, leaving the person under investigation without timely legal guidance and unable to prevent them from making false statements out of fear or coercion.


 

(2) The mechanism for seeking instructions and reporting has weakened the independent judgment of the procuratorate and the courts.


 

The supervisory commissions do not implement a case‑handling accountability system; all decisions must be made through collective deliberation at meetings and often require approval from the next higher‑level supervisory commission. This leaves lower‑level procuratorial and judicial organs with little say in handling cases, forcing them to seek frequent instructions and reports and making it difficult for them to render independent judgments. When a procuratorate seeks to obtain audio or video recordings, it must “request” permission; and when initiating procedures to exclude illegally obtained evidence, it must obtain approval from the superior authority and engage in “communication and consultation” with the supervisory commission. Such arrangements amount to a self‑undermining of institutional capacity, thereby rendering oversight ineffective.


 

(3) Judicial personnel face real‑world occupational risks, which constrain their courage.


 

The Supervisory Commission possesses oversight and investigative authority over all public officials, including judges and prosecutors. In practice, there have already been instances in which judges were escorted away on the spot by supervisory commission personnel during court proceedings. This latent professional risk compels judicial officers, when adjudicating cases referred by the supervisory commission, to tread with extreme caution, reluctant to adopt restraint measures—such as ordering the production of audio‑visual recordings or excluding illegally obtained evidence—that might appear to “contravene” the commission’s intentions. Meanwhile, defense lawyers find themselves “dancing on the edge of a blade while shackled,” with their room for effective advocacy severely curtailed.


 

(4) The system of specially appointed supervisors has failed to achieve its intended purpose.


 

Although the 2018 Measures for the Work of Special Supervisory Commissioners of the National Supervisory Commission were introduced with the intention of instituting external oversight, in practice the system has remained largely invisible. Its selection procedures, duties and powers, and operational channels all remain unclear, and many lawyers—and even legal professionals—remain unaware of its specific mechanisms, thereby preventing it from providing effective, systematic oversight of the performance of duties by supervisory personnel.


 


 

III. Paths of Defense Counsel Participation and the Expansion of Their Functions in the Context of the New Law


 

On December 25, 2024, the 13th Meeting of the Standing Committee of the 14th National People’s Congress adopted an amendment to the Supervision Law of the People’s Republic of China. The revised law will take effect on June 1, 2025. This legislative overhaul is substantial, adding 46 new articles, amending 74, and revising 32; it introduces significant changes in key areas such as the system of coercive measures, the duration of detention, and mechanisms for redress of rights, sparking widespread attention and debate within the legal community, particularly among lawyers. The revision process was relatively low-key, and the introduction of new measures—such as “compulsory appearance,” “custodial control,” and “ordering to await investigation”—along with the extension of detention periods, could, if fully applied, substantially lengthen the total period of deprivation of personal liberty. Against a backdrop where lawyers are unable to meet with their clients and effective external oversight remains lacking, these developments have heightened concerns within the profession about potential abuses of power and the adequacy of safeguards for individual rights.


 

However, Article 5 of the New Law The newly added principles—such as “equal rights and responsibilities,” “adhering to statutory procedures and performing duties impartially,” “respecting and safeguarding human rights,” and “protecting the legitimate rights and interests of those under oversight and related personnel”—along with the overarching provision to “minimize the impact of investigations on enterprises’ normal production and business operations,” have been enshrined. Furthermore, a system of specially appointed supervisors has been established. The nationwide initiative to standardize, legalize, and institutionalize discipline inspection and supervision work, currently underway, sends a strong signal of rule-of-law governance.


 

Therefore, the defense attorney must… Shift in mindset We should not adopt a blindly pessimistic stance; rather, we ought to keenly discern the positive changes brought about by legal reforms, identify and cultivate new avenues for business growth and functional expansion within the existing legal framework, and proactively move service delivery upstream—extending our scope from traditional stages of review, prosecution, trial, and defense to encompass the investigation phase and even proactive risk prevention. In some cases, even at the very outset of an investigation, we… We have entered into a legal advisory agreement at the request of the client’s family, providing legal assistance and guiding them on how to protect their rights in accordance with the law.


 

(1) Implement proactive criminal risk prevention, Specialized lectures have been organized for public officials, entrepreneurs, and their family members to explain the new Supervision Law and its Implementing Regulations, helping them understand the supervisory authorities’ investigation procedures, powers, and the rights and obligations of those under investigation. Participants are also guided on how to remain calm and uphold the principle of seeking truth from facts should they be placed under investigation or subjected to detention, thereby avoiding making confessions against their will under pressure. They are advised to back up and securely store important documents and to establish contact in advance with a trusted attorney.


 

(2) Investigation Phase: Upon receipt of a mandate from the client or their family, provide comprehensive legal advisory services.


 

Although lawyers may not meet with the suspect or defendant in their capacity as defense counsel, they may accept mandates from family members and other relevant parties to provide legal advice and assistance. They should guide family members in articulating their demands in a lawful and rational manner, refrain from taking extreme actions, and cooperate with the supervisory authorities’ lawful investigations.

 

1. During the period of being placed under investigation, the law does not prohibit meeting with a lawyer. An attorney may provide legal assistance directly to the individual concerned without obtaining the consent of the supervisory commission.

 

2. Assistance in applying for a change of coercive measures: Pursuant to Article 50 of the new Supervision Law, persons under supervision, those placed under detention, and their close relatives are entitled to apply for a modification of the supervisory or detention measures. Upon receipt of the application, the supervisory authority shall render a decision within three days; if it decides not to modify the measures, it shall notify the applicant and provide the reasons for its refusal.

 

3. Handle requests for restitution with due diligence: To guide family members in responding to the supervisory commission’s demand for restitution, we provide professional strategies. It is generally advisable not to agree to full restitution while the facts remain unclear; instead, wait until the review-and-prosecution stage, when the indictment opinion has been issued and the case has become relatively clear, before making a decision, thereby avoiding unnecessary financial losses.

 

4. Safeguarding the legitimate rights and interests of enterprises: Pursuant to Article 43, Paragraph 3 of the new law, criminal defense attorneys may assist relevant parties—particularly business operators—in cooperating with investigations, safeguarding personal and property rights, avoiding or minimizing adverse impacts on the normal course of a company’s production and operations, preventing investigative authorities from abusing their powers to unlawfully interfere with business activities, and protecting property rights.

 

5. Assist in exercising the right to appeal: Article 69 of the new law provides an exhaustive list of six categories of circumstances that may be subject to appeal. With respect to acts by supervisory authorities and their staff that violate laws and regulations or infringe upon the lawful rights and interests of the person under investigation, such person, together with their close relatives and interested parties, shall have the right to file an appeal with the authority concerned. They may also engage an attorney to assist them, or even accompany them in person, to facilitate negotiations.

 

6. Serving as the entrusted agent for the disposition of property involved in a case: Articles 141 and 142 of the Regulations for the Implementation of the Supervision Law stipulate that, when freezing or disposing of assets such as stocks and funds, the “rights holder or their legal representative or authorized agent” must be notified. Lawyers may formally accept an engagement to act as agents in the disposition of such assets, directly negotiate with the supervisory authorities, and safeguard the lawful property rights of their clients.

 

7. Activate oversight channels for specially appointed supervisors: Article 62 of the Supervision Law introduces a system of specially appointed supervisors, stipulating that “ The supervisory authorities may, as required by their work, appoint special supervisors from among representatives of various sectors. Such special supervisors shall, in accordance with the relevant regulations, exercise oversight over the performance of duties by the supervisory authorities and their staff. If conventional avenues of redress, such as appeals, are obstructed, lawyers may examine the situation and endeavor to assist family members in bringing it to the attention of the designated ombudsman, requesting that the ombudsman fulfill their statutory oversight duties and thereby opening a new auxiliary channel for the protection of rights.

 

(3) In judicial proceedings: Uphold comprehensive, intelligent defense and safeguard rights in accordance with the law.

 

Once the case enters the review-and-prosecution and trial stages, counsel should continue to give equal weight to both substantive and procedural defenses.

 

It can play a role in assessing the legality of coercive measures and reviewing whether extensions or recalculations of detention are lawful. If, during a meeting with the defendant, allegations arise of coerced or induced confessions or of inaccurate records, every effort should be made to request the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence and to obtain synchronized audio‑video recordings; moreover, applications should be filed with the court and the procuratorate to order investigations and gather evidence, and, when necessary, independent investigative steps should be undertaken. Even in the face of substantial obstacles, procedural violations must be fully exposed in court, engaging in effective adversarial proceedings against the prosecution, and exercising the rights to file complaints and appeals. Any illegal or disciplinary misconduct uncovered should be consistently reported to higher‑level supervisory commissions and procuratorial organs through appeals and complaints, while also actively seeking assistance by submitting requests to specially appointed supervisors, thereby ensuring that rights are protected in accordance with the law.

 

At present, in numerous official‑duty crime cases handled by my team, through lawful and compliant appeals, complaints, and investigative evidence‑gathering efforts, coupled with effective defense, we have achieved preliminary results. Some cases have been remanded for retrial, while others have secured a second court hearing—despite the fact that the courtroom debate had already concluded, the second hearing entails re‑questioning, re‑presentation of evidence, and a renewed presentation of defense arguments. With regard to the reported irregularities in case handling, the relevant authorities have received the submitted materials and have replied that they will address the matter in accordance with the law.

 

In sum, the amendment to the Supervision Law represents a rebalancing between strengthening anti-corruption functions and enhancing the protection of human rights. It poses challenges in terms of expanded powers while also presenting opportunities to underscore the rule of law. For defense lawyers, mere criticism and pessimism are unhelpful; the key lies in accurately identifying changes, responding to them with sound judgment, and proactively seeking transformation. Although lawyers have not been formally granted defense rights during the investigation phase, by interpreting and applying provisions in the new law—such as those on “rights protection,” “the right to appeal,” and “authorized representation”—their scope of practice can be substantially broadened, leaving ample room for effective advocacy.


 

Attorney Profile

.

Cheng Xiaolu

Beijing Starrise Law Firm

Chairman of the Partners’ Meeting

Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm, Director of the Civil–Criminal–Administrative Integration Research Base jointly established by the School of Criminal Law and Justice of China University of Political Science and Law and Xinglai Law Firm, and a Ph.D. in Law from Renmin University of China. She previously served in the procuratorial organs of Beijing, earning the titles of “Outstanding Public Prosecutor of Beijing” and “Top Ten Research Experts.” She is a member of the Criminal Law Committee of the All China Lawyers Association, an appointed supervisory lawyer for detention centers under the Ministry of Public Security, Deputy Director of the Criminal Procedure Committee of the Beijing Lawyers Association, and Deputy Director of the Judicial Credibility Professional Committee of the Beijing Credit Society. She also serves as an off-campus practical mentor in criminal defense at Peking University, Renmin University of China, Central University of Finance and Economics, Shandong University, and other institutions. With more than twenty years of extensive experience in criminal justice, she has successfully handled a series of high‑profile, impactful cases involving economic crimes, organized crime, official misconduct, and complex civil‑criminal intersections. She has provided specialized criminal legal services to numerous large enterprises and was consecutively recognized in Chambers Greater China’s Legal Guide for Dispute Resolution in both 2026 and 2025; featured on LEGALBAND’s Top Chinese Lawyers Ranking in the “White‑Collar and Business Crime” category; and named among the “15 Outstanding Female Lawyers (North China)” in LegalOne’s Client Trust Awards for China. She has received many other prestigious honors as well.


 

Layout: Wang Xin

Reviewed by: Management Committee


 

Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

 


 


 

Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province

 


 

Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license