
Table of Contents
I. The Pros and Cons of Two Models: The “Both-And” Dilemma We Face
II. The Possibility of Integration: Integration Is Not an Extreme Concept
III. Data is the Core Link in Integration: Shareable, Quantifiable, and Traceable
One approach: Strengthen the operations service platform with data.
Pathway Two: A Clear Data-Driven Internal Collaboration Mechanism
Pathway Three: Data-Driven Customer Management System Optimization
IV. Starry Practice: Exploring the Integration of Two Models
Starry Practice No. 1: High Proportion of Public Investment
Xinglai Practice No. 2: Establishing a Comprehensive Assessment System
Star-Lai Practice No. 3: Assessing Lawyers’ Learning Motivation and Business Development Initiative Through Data
Xinglai Practice No. 4: Integrated Exploration in Branch Office Development
V. Conclusion: Integration Rather Than Opposition
Many people wonder: Is Xinglai a corporate‑style or a partnership‑style law firm? This very question underscores the legal profession’s growing need to explore hybrid models for law‑firm management. This article examines the integration of partnership and corporate structures in law‑firm operations and reveals Xinglai’s unique operating model.
I. Advantages and Disadvantages of the Two Models:
The “both… and…” dilemma we face
First, we must squarely acknowledge the respective strengths and weaknesses of partnership‑based and corporate‑structured law firms. Partnership‑type firms are characterized by a strong personal ethos, high flexibility, and robust incentive mechanisms, but they also entail higher risks and greater fragmentation. By contrast, corporate‑structured firms exhibit a pronounced collective identity, a high degree of integration and standardization, and clear economies of scale, yet they often suffer from insufficient incentives and limited flexibility. These advantages and disadvantages are well‑known and widely recognized within the legal profession.
I extracted a table from a management book, which presents a foreign scholar’s comparative analysis of intermediary service firms—such as accounting firms and law firms—under corporate and partnership structures. The analysis examines their distinguishing features across key dimensions, including core concepts, management systems, operational models, human resources, and market positioning. The table clearly highlights the differences between these two organizational forms.
A Comparative Analysis of the Operational Models of Partnership- and Corporation-Based Law Firms (Standard Version)
Swipe left or right to view more
Here’s the question: With a clear understanding of the respective strengths and weaknesses of these two models, how can we achieve the best of both worlds—leveraging the powerful incentives of a partnership structure while also benefiting from the high‑quality, standardized empowerment offered by a corporate structure? This is the central issue I’d like to explore today: How can these two models be seamlessly integrated?
II. The Possibility of Integration:
Integration is not an extreme concept.
Based on my five years of experience in law firm management, integration is not an extreme, either/or proposition; in fact, every law firm exhibits some degree of integration. Some firms have low levels of integration, others fall in the middle, and still others are highly integrated. At one end of the spectrum are fully commission-based firms, where partners merely share a brand name while each handles their own matters and assumes their own risks—often without even knowing one another. At the other end are highly integrated models, such as those adopted by certain top-tier “red‑circle” firms.
However, as far as I can tell, even the most common commission-based law firms exhibit varying degrees of integration.
At its most fundamental level, integration is embodied in a unified mid‑office platform—covering administration, finance, and case management. Going a step further, it hinges on whether the law firm can establish and share a robust brand‑promotion platform. If the firm can leverage a multi‑dimensional approach to amplify and extend its branding efforts, enabling every lawyer to shine on the platform and ensuring that individual achievements and perspectives are amplified through the firm’s collective outreach, then lawyers will reap tangible benefits, gradually fostering greater reliance on the platform.
The greatest challenge lies in human resource allocation and coordination. Lawyers are most accustomed to working independently, and the biggest hurdle to overcome is business collaboration. Except when confronted with areas they know nothing about—where they are “forced” to seek partnerships—more often than not, lawyers rely on their strong self‑learning capabilities and choose to handle matters on their own rather than team up with other attorneys who specialize in more narrowly defined practice areas. When such inter‑lawyer coordination and resource allocation fail to materialize, it fundamentally undermines the prospects for integrated development.
III. Data is the Core Link in Integration:
Shareable, quantifiable, and traceable
In the process of integrating and developing these two models, how can data serve as the central link? The foundation for this exploration lies in clearly defining data’s key attributes: shareability, quantifiability, and traceability.
One approach: Strengthen the operations service platform with data.
The core component of the operations service platform is the co‑creation and sharing of a knowledge platform. By uploading lawyers’ individual knowledge, experience, and case files to the OA system, these resources are transformed into collective data assets, enabling widespread sharing and reuse. As law firm managers well know, this initiative is extremely challenging to implement, but it is by no means impossible to pursue.
We’ve built a unified brand‑promotion platform. Take, for example, Kuaying Digital Business Cards—every law firm in our network uses it. It’s so easy to use that both our established attorneys and newly hired colleagues are eager to adopt it. It has replaced all previous paper and image‑based business cards, achieving widespread adoption and becoming one of the key channels for standardizing our corporate communications and reinforcing our brand identity. Thanks to its innovative design and centralized management, we also consistently receive positive feedback from clients.
Leverage data‑driven precision matching to optimize resource allocation. A lawyer’s business card sharing can reveal their willingness to proactively develop new clients. If they fail to share or consistently refrain from forwarding to new contacts, they may be better suited to team‑based or salaried roles; conversely, if they actively promote themselves, the firm can tilt its collaboration priorities or tailor distinct development strategies. For lawyers who are reluctant to self‑promote, team‑oriented work or support‑function roles may be more appropriate; meanwhile, for those who proactively market themselves, the firm can offer targeted internal training and external outreach opportunities.
Pathway Two: A Clear Data-Driven Internal Collaboration Mechanism
In terms of internal collaboration, the firm has established cross‑practice teams and assigned each lawyer a specialized expertise tag, laying the groundwork for inter‑lawyer cooperation at the firm level. Moreover, we have consistently encouraged young lawyers to publish more articles and engage in continuous learning; however, their motivations vary across different stages of their careers. When serving as team members or salaried associates, they may be reluctant to write, but once they become independent, they develop a sense of urgency and recognize the need to produce more content, enhance their professional visibility, and attract new clients. When allocating collaborative opportunities, the firm can use these insights as a reference.
Pathway Three: Data-Driven Customer Management System Optimization
In litigation‑focused law firms, achieving unified client management is extremely challenging. Nevertheless, this approach is certainly worth exploring. In my vision, if we can eventually design a fair and reasonable profit‑sharing mechanism through the same digital client‑management framework—gaining broad consensus—it would significantly enhance both the efficiency of client management and the firm’s professional brand image. Moreover, while unified client management is difficult to implement, sharing client needs is relatively straightforward; we could start by building on this foundation.
The above pathways are not necessarily exhaustive; they are offered merely as a starting point.
IV. Starry Practice:
Exploring the Integration of Two Models
Xinglai’s mission is to “go all out to cultivate more Xinglai Stars”—not just a single “star,” but lawyers at every stage of their careers, across different practice areas and professional phases. We leverage the firm’s resources and platform to support and empower them.
In early 2026, Xinglai will celebrate its fifth anniversary. I refer to these first five years as the “First Five-Year Period.” At Xinglai, although the founding partners initially focused on criminal defense, the firm was established with a compliance‑oriented practice. At that time, corporate compliance was just beginning to take root, and we devoted the entire firm’s resources to building out our compliance practice—necessarily shedding the hallmarks of litigation and shifting toward a non‑litigation model: all lawyers are salaried or hourly‑paid; partners operate on a commission basis, and during project collaborations, we can match lawyers according to specific needs, eliminating any sense of division or compartmentalization among smaller teams; every lawyer logs their billable hours, and work efficiency is assessed based on those records; moreover, the firm implements a rotational training system, ensuring that each lawyer gains experience and grows across both litigation and non‑litigation areas.
This compliance‑focused business model persisted through the end of 2024. Following policy adjustments, we undertook a strategic transformation, reorienting ourselves toward “cross‑disciplinary” matters involving criminal, civil, and administrative law, and returning to our core strength: litigation. Law firms that prioritize litigation inevitably adopt management approaches distinct from those that emphasize non‑litigation practice; however, we have largely retained the integrated management framework established during our compliance‑driven phase. This historical evolution has enabled us to seamlessly integrate these two models.
I compared the previous table and annotated it based on Xinglai’s situation (with the parts that align with Xinglai highlighted in red). The results show that our firm’s characteristics far outweigh those of a partnership, reflecting a high degree of integration. This is also the key driver behind our ability to attract top talent—many lawyers ask: What can this law firm offer me? Beyond differences in commission rates, what else can I gain?
A Comparative Analysis of the Operational Models of Partnership- and Corporate-Structured Law Firms (Xinglai Edition)
Swipe left or right to view more
Starry Practice No. 1: High Proportion of Public Investment
The law firm sets aside a designated percentage of its budget as risk and development funds, fostering among all attorneys a shared sense of risk‑sharing and collective growth.
All expenses associated with the law firm’s professional seminars and workshops are borne by the firm. For attorneys who have a clear practice focus and a strong desire to promote their expertise, the firm provides tailored opportunities for visibility and networking based on individual circumstances. In addition, newly admitted partners are given the chance to serve as in-house trainers, presenting on topics in which they excel—this serves as an initial step in internal marketing. In terms of platform‑building efforts such as public‑affairs initiatives, infrastructure development, and brand promotion, Xinglai allocates roughly 20% of its operating costs to these activities—a notably substantial share.
Xinglai Practice No. 2: Establishing a Comprehensive Assessment System
We do not assess performance solely on revenue generation; instead, we take a holistic approach, considering factors such as whether lawyers are building knowledge assets, engaging in public‑interest work, and collaborating across teams (at year‑end, we track the number of cases each lawyer has worked on with others and compare this to prior years to gauge whether collaborative awareness has strengthened). By adopting a multi‑dimensional framework, we conduct all‑round evaluations and use these assessments to encourage lawyers to embrace an integrated, cross‑functional development mindset.
In terms of incentive mechanisms, we are also exploring the following: Should there be commission-based rewards for teams that demonstrate strong internal collaboration? And should those who accumulate significant knowledge assets receive corresponding recognition as well? By aligning our incentive structures with these goals, we aim to guide lawyers in shifting their mindset—from awareness to concrete action.
Star-Lai Practice No. 3: Assessing Lawyers’ Learning Motivation and Business Development Initiative Through Data
We compile statistics on registration for bar association and law firm professional training programs, using this data as a benchmark to assess lawyers’ enthusiasm for continuous learning. The digital business card platform integrates event registration with live‑stream sharing, enabling tracking of brand‑building initiatives and the outcomes of knowledge‑sharing efforts. Data reveal that newly independent young lawyers have issued anywhere from a few dozen to several hundred digital business cards within six months. By analyzing visitation metrics, we can gauge whether a lawyer actively builds relationships, engages with clients and peers, and promotes their practice. Based on these insights, law firms can provide targeted support and opportunities tailored to individual needs.
Starry Practice Four: Integrated Exploration in Branch Office Development
Xinglai established its Wuhan branch last year and is set to open a Hefei branch this year. In addition to making the entire case‑handling process transparent, synchronizing financial information, sharing our business‑training platform, and pooling marketing channels, we are also taking another step: treating each branch as an operational unit of the headquarters.
For example, the soon-to-be‑established Hefei branch has founding partners whose strength lies in international practice; accordingly, the branch will be branded as “international‑focused.” The headquarters will no longer maintain a separate international‑practice department, thereby avoiding any competitive overlap with the branch. When the headquarters undertakes international matters, it will either assign them directly to the branch for execution or collaborate with the branch on their handling. By positioning the branch as an extension of the headquarters’ business functions, this approach further reinforces an integrated operating model.
In talent development and marketing, we also bring lawyers from both the headquarters and our branch offices onto a single platform. For example, we have established ten practice departments and ten research centers, and we extend opportunities for leadership positions in these units to our branch offices as well. Performance evaluations are conducted on an equal footing, with the overarching goal of breaking down the barriers between headquarters and branches to build cohesive practice teams.
In terms of financial allocation, although our existing branches operate primarily under a franchise model, we fully respect their independence while also guiding them toward greater integration. Today, the commission rates at the branch level are very close to those at headquarters, with differences of only one or two percentage points. I am confident that, as recognition of an integrated operating model grows, the financial allocation system will naturally and comprehensively evolve toward full integration.
V. Conclusion:
Integration, not opposition
Partnership and corporate structures are not mutually exclusive; rather, they can be integrated, with the distinction lying solely in the degree of integration. Data has the power to reshape management—beyond efficiency, the key lies in refining managerial logic and optimizing value‑allocation frameworks. Each law firm will pursue its own unique path, yet the overarching trend toward such integration is one on which we can all agree.
This article is compiled and published based on remarks delivered by Wang Jun, Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, at the “Wanxiang·Symbiosis—Data-Driven Narratives, Operations That Create Value” digital growth salon series for the legal industry. The event was hosted by Kuayin Digital Business Cards.
Author Biography
.
Wang Jun
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Founding Partner
Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Head of its Management Committee; Executive Director of the Civil–Criminal–Administrative Integration Research Base jointly established by the School of Criminal Law and Justice at China University of Political Science and Law and Xinglai Law Firm; holds undergraduate and master’s degrees from Huazhong University of Science and Technology. Member of the Criminal Procedure Law Specialized Committee and the Women Lawyers’ Working Committee of the 12th Beijing Lawyers Association, and Senior Research Fellow at the Southern Finance Legal Research Institute. Recognized with numerous accolades, including ALB’s “NARA Annual Managing Partner Award,” LEGALBAND’s Top 15 Chinese Female Lawyers and Top 15 Rising Partners, as well as being named among LexisNexis’ The Visionaries—Leading Visionaries—and other prestigious honors.
He has published numerous professional articles in leading journals such as People’s Procuratorate and China Lawyers, and was featured on the cover of the book “Walking with the Law” published by the Chinese Culture Publishing House. He is a dual‑certified Data Protection Officer (DPO) and Data Protection Officer for Privacy (DPOPIPL) through the International Information Science Examination Institute (EXIN). He has successfully defended multiple criminal cases resulting in acquittals, possesses extensive practical experience in criminal–civil intersection cases and property‑related sentencing defenses, and excels in representing clients in official‑duty and cybercrime matters, particularly having amassed substantial hands‑on expertise in electronic data examination.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12










