CN/EN

All
  • All
  • Product Management
  • News and Information
  • Introduction content
  • Business outlets
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Corporate Video
  • Corporate Portfolio

Practical Approaches to Managing Corporate Criminal Risks


 

Yang Qichen


 

Star Lai Law Firm

Partner


 

In

In the course of corporate bidding and tendering, “collusive bidding” is a critical issue that demands close attention; even if such conduct is undertaken by an employee acting on their own initiative, the enterprise may still bear legal liability. This article seeks to identify the root causes of legal risks arising from individual employee actions and, drawing on relevant case law, offers guidance for enterprises in establishing robust risk‑prevention frameworks.


 

Root cause of risk

As a legal fiction, an enterprise must have its actions carried out through natural persons; accordingly, the conduct of employees in tendering and bidding activities is readily deemed to be official acts, with the enterprise bearing the corresponding liability.


 

The relationship between behavioral manifestations and job duties. When determining whether an employee’s conduct constitutes official duty, the focus is not merely on whether the act was carried out in the entity’s name, but rather on whether the content of the conduct bears an intrinsic connection to the scope of the employee’s duties. In the case involving Jiangsu W Company, the court of first instance held that although Chen, the bidding officer of W Company’s N‑city branch, submitted a bid in the company’s name, thereby giving the appearance of official conduct, his actions—taken by exploiting his position—were not intrinsically related to his official duties, did not serve the company’s interests, and were not attributable to any significant managerial negligence on the part of the company. Accordingly, Chen’s conduct was deemed to be personal in nature.


 

However, the appellate court held that, based on both formal and substantive criteria, Chen’s conduct exhibited the hallmarks of official duty. Moreover, other employees in various positions at Company W participated in both the bidding and the bid‑opening processes; therefore, the company should be deemed to have taken part in the tender. At the same time, it was not established that the company had fulfilled its primary risk‑mitigation obligations during the credit‑approval stage. Consequently, the court concluded that Company W bears corresponding administrative liability for Chen’s actions.


 

The dual-penalty system for corporate crimes. In cases of corporate crime, in addition to imposing a fine on the corporation, the directly responsible senior management and other persons bearing direct responsibility must also be held accountable.


 

Under the Tendering and Bidding Law, the legal definitions of “tenderer” and “bidder” are based on the principle of “legal persons or other organizations.” However, in judicial practice, entities engaged in tendering and bidding, along with their responsible personnel; tendering agencies and their staff; and members of the evaluation committees may all qualify as criminal subjects. If an employee’s conduct is determined to have been carried out “in the name of the entity, with the illicit proceeds belonging to the entity, and in accordance with the entity’s overall will,” the enterprise itself may be deemed a criminal subject.


 

Rules of presumption and the burden of proof. The Regulations for the Implementation of the Bidding Law lists the circumstances constituting “collusive bidding among bidders,” “collusive bidding between the tenderer and the bidder,” and “circumstances deemed to constitute collusive bidding among bidders.” Notably, the “deemed” presumption reduces the burden of proof on the investigating authorities while increasing the burden of defense on the enterprises; moreover, if an enterprise seeks to rebut the investigating authority’s determination, it must also bear the burden of proof.


 

In a case in Zhejiang, the electronic bidding documents submitted by Companies A and B during the tender process shared identical machine-generated codes. The evaluation committee deemed this to constitute an unwarranted degree of similarity. Subsequent investigation further revealed that both bidding documents had been prepared solely by Dong, an employee of Company B. Although both companies denied colluding in the bid and asserted that the actions were attributable to individual employees, the investigating authorities nonetheless imposed administrative penalties on both companies and their directly responsible personnel.


 

In the aforementioned W Company case, the company argued that the employee, Chen, engaged in unauthorized acts such as forging seals, which it characterized as personal conduct. Nevertheless, the court held the company liable, reasoning that “Chen held a digital encryption certificate with the company’s consent, and key stages of the relevant project’s bidding were conducted entirely via electronic documents; moreover, Chen was authorized to exercise certain decision‑making powers.” This demonstrates that, absent sufficient rebuttal evidence capable of overturning the finding that the company failed to fulfill its risk‑prevention obligations, the company may still be held accountable.


 

Risk Escalation and Prevention System

Employees’ unauthorized collusion in bidding may expose the enterprise to administrative penalties; if the circumstances meet the statutory thresholds for amount, severity, or repeated violations, such conduct may even constitute a criminal offense.


 

Moreover, employees may engage in bribery, accepting bribes, or infringing upon citizens’ personal information—actions undertaken to achieve collusive objectives, conceal unlawful conduct, or expand illicit gains. The Second Criminal Division of the Supreme People’s Court has clarified that bid-rigging does not bear a causal relationship with such other acts under criminal law and should therefore be punished as multiple offenses. Consequently, if employees commit additional illegal or criminal acts in furtherance of collusion, the enterprise’s legal risks will be further exacerbated. To effectively mitigate the legal risks associated with unauthorized bid-rigging by employees, companies must establish a multi‑layered preventive framework.


 

Preemptive Prevention: Institutional Foundations and Granular Privilege Assignment. (1) Improve management systems: Clearly define approval authorities at each stage, prohibit employees from independently handling digital certificates or posting security deposits, and establish standardized procedures for preparing tender documents, along with robust review and audit‑trail mechanisms. (2) Strengthen compliance awareness: Conduct regular training on bidding‑related laws and regulations, have employees sign Compliance Commitment Letters, and clearly delineate accountability for violations. (3) Rigorously manage third‑party collaborations: Perform due diligence on intermediary organizations and other partners to ensure they do not simultaneously provide services to competitors, thereby preventing conflicts of interest and potential confusion of interests.


 

In-process control: technical monitoring and process transparency. (1) Electronic Management: Employ technical measures to restrict editing permissions for tender documents, implement IP‑address tracking and version control, and ensure full traceability throughout the document‑creation process. (2) Closed‑Loop Fund Management: Bid bonds and other payments must be made via corporate bank accounts; employees are prohibited from using cash or personal accounts. (3) Segregated Responsibilities: Separate roles are assigned to the preparation, encryption, and upload stages of tender documents, with different personnel responsible for each phase, thereby reducing the risk of single‑person manipulation.


 

Post-incident response: evidence preservation and legal remedies. (1) Establish a response mechanism: Upon discovering that an employee has engaged in unauthorized bidding, immediately suspend their access rights and preserve electronic data, communication records, and other relevant evidence to prevent loss or destruction of such evidence. (2) Seek professional support: Promptly retain counsel with experience in criminal–civil intersection cases to assess the risk profile and develop a tailored legal strategy. (3) Leverage administrative–criminal coordination: If an administrative investigation has already been initiated, proactively submit evidence demonstrating that the company has fulfilled its reasonable duty of oversight, thereby seeking to avoid the initiation of criminal proceedings.


 

Author Biography

.

Yang Qichen

Beijing Starrise Law Firm

Partner

Bachelor of Laws and Bachelor of Management from China University of Political Science and Law. He serves as a practicum mentor at the School of Criminal Justice of China University of Political Science and Law, and is a mining rights appraiser and a senior corporate compliance professional, holding qualifications to practice in the securities and futures sectors. With many years of experience working in the procuratorial organs of Beijing Municipality and the organizational departments of district Party committees, he has participated in the handling of hundreds of cases, including offenses against property, crimes infringing on personal rights, crimes endangering public safety, economic crimes, official misconduct, sexual offenses, gambling-related crimes, drug offenses, crimes harming environmental and resource protection, crimes involving organized crime and evil forces, and cases subject to compulsory medical treatment procedures, thereby accumulating extensive practical expertise in criminal justice.


 

Since commencing practice, he has handled a wide range of major and complex cases, including economic crimes, official‑duty crimes, crimes perpetrated by organized criminal groups and triad‑like organizations, offenses endangering public safety, and mining‑related crimes. In numerous instances, his defense efforts have resulted in outcomes such as non‑prosecution, dismissal or modification of charges, and mitigation or reduction of penalties.


 

Business Areas:

Criminal defense, appeals and complaints, and corporate criminal risk prevention.


 


 

This article was published in the February 2026 issue of Commercial Law, under the original title: “Corporate Legal Risks Arising from Employees’ Individual Conduct: Collusive Bidding” 。
 


 


 


 


 

Layout: Wang Xin

Reviewed by: Management Committee


 

Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing

 


 

Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province

 

Related News

CONTACT US

Contact us


Beijing Headquarters

Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing

Phone: 010-64011566

Email: contact@xinglailaw.com


Wuhan Branch Office

Address: Room 1001, Huangpu International Center, Zhaojiatiao, Jiang'an District, Wuhan City

Phone: 027-82288828

Email: admin@xinglailaw-wuhan.com


Hefei Branch Office

Address:Room 1703-1710, Building E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei City

Phone: 15850561916

Email: contact@xinglailaw-hefei.com

.

Follow us

.

Digital Star Come

Case Consultation

Experienced lawyers offer free, no-obligation consultations to provide tailored solutions.


%{tishi_zhanwei}%

Copyright 2025 Beijing Xinglai Law Firm

Tags: Website Development:300.cn Beijing Certificate

Business license