
Practical Approaches to Managing Corporate Criminal Risks
Ding Wen
Su Zhongming
In
In the era of rapid digital economic growth, e‑commerce has become a driving force behind socio‑economic development. The collection, storage, processing, and transmission of information have become routine operations for businesses, and data has increasingly emerged as a core asset in corporate competition. Some enterprises, in pursuit of profit, resort to illegally obtaining, selling, or disclosing personal information, and even employ web‑scraping technologies to steal data, thereby exposing themselves to significant criminal risks.
This article, drawing on judicial practice, identifies key types of risks and proposes corresponding mitigation strategies to help enterprises strengthen their data security defenses.
Criminal risk
Illegally obtaining, selling, or providing personal information. Under China’s Criminal Law, anyone who, in violation of relevant state regulations, sells or provides others with personal information of citizens, and where the circumstances are serious, shall be deemed to have committed a crime. According to Article 5, Items 3 through 8 of the Interpretation by the Supreme People’s Court and the Supreme People’s Procuratorate on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Handling Criminal Cases Involving the Infringement of Citizens’ Personal Information, “serious circumstances” are specifically defined as follows: (3) Illegally obtaining, selling, or providing fifty or more items of information relating to a person’s whereabouts, communications, credit records, or property; (4) Illegally obtaining, selling, or providing five hundred or more items of other personal information—such as accommodation details, communication records, health and physiological data, or transaction information—that may endanger personal safety or property; (5) Illegally obtaining, selling, or providing five thousand or more items of personal information not covered by Items 3 or 4; (6) Where the quantity does not meet the thresholds set forth in Items 3 through 5, but the aggregate quantity, calculated according to the corresponding proportional standards, nonetheless reaches the relevant threshold; (7) Where the illegal gains exceed RMB 5,000; (8) Where personal information obtained in the course of performing official duties or providing services is sold or provided to others, and the quantity or value thereof meets at least half of the thresholds specified in Items 3 through 7.
In practice, enterprises can easily exceed the statutory threshold for personal data processing when handling large volumes of personal information. For example, illegally collecting user data and storing hundreds of sensitive records in a single instance, or批量 selling customer data to third parties—such actions can cross the criminal‑law line with just one transaction.
Even more alarming is that if an enterprise knowingly provides personal information to another party that intends to use it for fraud or other criminal activities, it will meet the threshold for initiating a criminal investigation regardless of the quantity of data involved or the profits derived. Many enterprises harbor vulnerabilities in their information management systems or deliberately circumvent regulatory requirements by processing personal data in violation of the law—unaware that such conduct has long since transcended the realm of administrative offenses and carries substantial criminal risks. Not only may the enterprise itself be subject to hefty fines, but the relevant supervisors and directly responsible personnel may also face imprisonment, detention, and additional fines, resulting in severe consequences.
Unauthorized access to obtain data. Some enterprises, in order to attract customers by offering data services that exceed their authorized scope, may employ web crawlers to illegally scrape orders, customer information, and other data from competitors’ platforms, thereby readily constituting the crime of illegally obtaining data from a computer information system.
In a typical case of illegally obtaining data from a computer information system released by the Supreme People’s Procuratorate, Shanghai Z Company, without authorization or permission from Shanghai E Company, employed “external crawling” and other illicit technical means, as well as exploited vulnerabilities in E Company’s web pages, to bypass and circumvent cybersecurity measures such as IP‑based access restrictions and CAPTCHA verification, thereby unlawfully acquiring vast amounts of store‑related information stored by E Company. Additionally, through “internal crawling,” Z Company leveraged account credentials it had obtained for logging into E Company’s merchant platform, along with a self‑designed browser plug‑in, in violation of the merchant‑side user agreement, to further extract large volumes of store‑related data. As a result, an enormous trove of merchant information—possessing substantial commercial value—was illegally accessed, while E Company also incurred increased traffic‑related costs, leading to direct economic losses exceeding RMB 40,000. Consequently, the public security authorities referred Z Company to the procuratorial organ for review and prosecution on suspicion of the crime of illegally obtaining data from a computer information system.
In addition to the aforementioned common criminal risks, the corporate data domain may also give rise to offenses such as damaging computer information systems, failing to fulfill obligations for network security management, aiding and abetting cybercrime, infringing upon trade secrets, and fraud. Consequently, effectively managing data—covering collection, acquisition, storage, processing, and transmission—has become an essential obligation for enterprises.
Response Strategy
As previously noted, the unlawful acquisition, sale, or disclosure of personal information, as well as unauthorized access to systems to obtain data, have become frequent criminal risks faced by enterprises in the era of big data. Companies must, before such risks materialize, establish a robust dual-layer defense—combining legal compliance with technical controls.
Establish and improve the data security management system. Enterprises shall strictly comply with the Data Security Law, the Personal Information Protection Law, the Cybersecurity Law, and other relevant laws, regulations, and industry-specific provisions. They must establish and refine data security management systems that are aligned with their operational models, ensuring that all data processing activities are lawful and compliant. An effective data security management system or data compliance framework may serve as a key factor in judicial determinations to exclude intentional criminal liability on the part of the entity.
Collect information in compliance with applicable laws and conduct regular self-assessments. Enterprises should clearly define data security responsibilities across all departments, establish data classification and grading management guidelines, conduct regular self-assessments for compliance, and prioritize the identification of high‑risk areas such as the use of web‑scraping tools and app permission requests. For any vulnerabilities identified, they must maintain an inventory and implement remediation within a specified timeframe.
Strengthen technological prevention and control. Enterprises must deploy systems for data encryption, access control, and other security measures; implement multi-factor authentication for access to core data; monitor in real time for anomalous activities such as unauthorized downloads and bulk exports; and promptly take corrective actions when detecting suspicious behavior.
Strengthen personnel management. Upon onboarding, employees should be required to sign a data confidentiality agreement; upon departure, their system access rights must be promptly revoked, and their data holdings verified. Regular legal training should be conducted to clarify relevant liabilities and enhance employees’ risk awareness.
Optimize the risk response process. Once a company becomes subject to criminal proceedings, it should promptly retain the services of a specialized criminal defense attorney to clarify the boundaries between corporate and individual liability. If the misconduct stems from an employee’s personal actions, the company may submit its compliance framework along with evidence of the employee’s improper conduct, leveraging truthful and objective documentation to seek mitigation or even exoneration of the company’s criminal liability.
This article was published in the December 2025/January 2026 bimonthly issue of Commercial Law, under the original title: “Criminal Risks of Corporate Data and Practical Responses” 。
Author Biography
.
Su Zhongming
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Director of the Compliance Business Center
Bachelor of Laws from Jilin University, Master of International Law. Awarded the “Crown—Classic Case Award” at the 2025 Guike Annual Conference. Among the first cohort to obtain the Senior Corporate Compliance Officer certification, he has spent over a decade in legal affairs, asset management, and risk control and compliance within the guarantee and financial leasing sectors, amassing extensive experience in corporate investment‑financing due diligence, hands‑on financial leasing operations and risk management, as well as contract administration. Since joining Beijing Starrise Law Firm, he has led numerous projects involving compliance frameworks for cases, central state‑owned enterprises, public institutions, and private companies; spearheaded the construction of the Jiaxing City Compliance Demonstration Zone; and has been frequently invited to deliver lectures and training sessions at prestigious academic institutions—including Renmin University of China’s School of Law, where he participated in the “Corporate Compliance Case Study” master‑class series, and Central University of Finance and Economics’ “Interdisciplinary Forum on Criminal, Civil, and Administrative Law Practice”—as well as at major central state‑owned enterprises.
Business Areas:
Corporate compliance management and emergency response to major risks, corporate investment, financing, and M&A, corporate management consulting, and resolution of civil and commercial disputes involving enterprises.
.
Ding Wen
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Lawyer (former)
He holds a Bachelor of Laws degree from Soochow University and a Master of Laws degree from the University of Edinburgh. He has extensive practical experience in bankruptcy liquidation and civil‑commercial dispute resolution, having directly participated in numerous criminal cases involving legal aid and providing clients with long‑term legal services. From 2020 to 2023, he served as an attorney at Beijing Dongwei Law Firm; he is currently a full‑time attorney at Beijing Starrise Law Firm.
Business Areas:
Bankruptcy liquidation, civil and commercial dispute resolution
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12



