
"
Based on the analysis presented in the preceding series of articles, the preferential rights enjoyed by homebuyers must be grounded in their status as “consumers of commercial housing,” meaning that they must be natural persons purchasing a home to meet their residential needs. So, apart from… “Commercial Housing Consumer” Beyond this, can other entities that have acquired property rights in real estate be afforded legal protection?
"
PART 01
1. Protection of the Rights of Ordinary Homebuyers
In addition to consumers of commercial housing, there are other ordinary homebuyers, such as those who purchase property for investment purposes or for business purposes. The rights of these ordinary homebuyers are… It also enjoys a certain degree of priority under specific circumstances. 。
a. Conditions for priority over ordinary claims
In accordance with Article 28 of the “Provisions of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Handling by People’s Courts of Cases Involving Objections to and Review of Enforcement,” as well as Article 14 of the “Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on the Application of Law in Adjudicating Cases of Objections to Enforcement,” where a typical homebuyer is unable to complete the transfer of ownership due to reasons not attributable to themselves and raises an objection to real property registered under the name of the enforced party, provided that… Already in possession of the property, already signed the contract, and already paid the full purchase price. In certain circumstances, it can be resisted. Ordinary monetary claim The execution of.
Article 127 of the “Notice of the Supreme People’s Court on Issuing the Minutes of the National Courts’ Conference on Civil and Commercial Trials” further clarifies that, so long as the buyer has taken affirmative steps—such as submitting the transfer‑registration documents to the housing registration authority or making a request to the seller to effect the transfer registration—or can demonstrate a reasonable cause for the failure to complete the transfer, such circumstances shall be deemed to constitute “failure to complete the transfer not attributable to the buyer’s own fault.”
b. Conditions Prior to Special Claims
Article 13 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on Issues Concerning the Application of Law in Adjudicating Cases of Objections to Enforcement provides that, where an ordinary purchaser raises an objection to real property registered in the name of the judgment debtor, and has executed a purchase contract and paid consideration sufficient to satisfy the corresponding principal claim, such purchaser may further assert rights against the priority enforcement of construction‑project payment claims and mortgage rights.
The Supreme People’s Court has issued further interpretations on the understanding and application of this provision. The legal basis for this provision is the system of subrogation set forth in Article 524 of the Civil Code, under which homebuyers have a legitimate interest in performing the relevant obligation. The funds paid by homebuyers to the executing court are limited to the market value of the property itself. The amount of the debt discharged likewise corresponds to the share of the claim attributable to the property and the portion of any encumbrances thereon; it is not necessary to satisfy the entire claim held by the enforcing creditor against the debtor. If a third party remits the full purchase price into the escrow account at market value and such funds have not been misappropriated by the real estate developer, then, similar to the circumstances addressed in this provision, the conditions for discharging the principal claim are met, and, in principle, the provisions of this article may be applied by analogy. At the same time, some argue that even if funds in the pre-sale escrow account are misappropriated, such risk should not be borne by the homebuyer.
In accordance with the aforementioned provisions and opinions, if an ordinary homebuyer has paid the purchase price to the court, It may be used to satisfy the developer’s corresponding debts. In such cases, the purchaser’s rights may be deemed to take priority over the construction project payment lien and the mortgage right. Moreover, these debts should not be construed as the developer’s entire liability; rather, a comprehensive assessment must be made, taking into account the market value of the property and the proportion of the developer’s liabilities attributable to each individual unit.
PART 02
2. Protection of Rights in Debt-for-Property Settlements
In addition to acquiring a house through cash payment, there is a special circumstance in which a property is used to satisfy a debt (where the developer assigns the property to the creditor). In such cases, although the creditor is not entitled to the special protective regime afforded to homebuyers, the Supreme People’s Court’s judicial interpretation nonetheless reserves priority for the creditor’s rights.

a. Generally, debt is settled by mortgaging the property.
According to Article 15 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Legal Issues Concerning the Trial of Cases Involving Objections to Enforcement, in typical cases where a house is used to settle a debt, if the purchaser (i.e., the creditor who received the house in satisfaction of the debt) and the judgment debtor meet the following conditions: (1) a genuine creditor‑debtor relationship exists and the due date for performance of the obligation has passed; (2) the amount of the debt settled by the house is substantially equivalent to the actual value of the subject matter of enforcement at the time of settlement; (3) a third party had lawful possession of the real estate prior to the seizure; and (4) registration of the transfer of ownership of the real estate has not been completed through no fault of the third party, then the purchaser shall have rights in respect of the house. It may take priority over ordinary claims. , but it still lags behind mortgage rights and construction‑project priority claims.
b. Special Cases – Payment in Kind Property
In the context of debt-for-property settlements, there is a special scenario known as “construction‑for‑property,” whereby a developer uses real estate to offset unpaid construction fees owed to the contractor.
Given that construction‑in‑settlement housing may itself possess the characteristics of a priority right to payment for construction projects, Article 17 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People’s Court on Several Legal Issues Concerning the Adjudication of Cases Involving Objections to Enforcement provides special provisions regarding such housing: if, prior to the seizure, the construction contractor has exercised its priority right to payment for construction works, entered into a lawful and valid agreement with the judgment debtor—i.e., the project owner—to settle the debt by valuing real estate, and the amount of debt settled is substantially equivalent to the actual value of the enforcement subject at the time of settlement, the contractor may assert its rights in respect of the construction‑in‑settlement housing. Superior to ordinary claims and mortgage rights 。
It is worth noting that the aforementioned judicial interpretations concerning ordinary homebuyers and debt-for-property settlements do not explicitly address “newly built commercial housing”; therefore, with respect to… Existing-home transactions There is also room for application.
Conclusion
When real estate developers face a debt crisis, the law, in order to protect individuals’ right to subsistence, grants “super-priority” to homebuyers who meet certain conditions. A series of judicial interpretations issued by the Supreme People’s Court have not only clarified that the rights of commodity‑housing consumers take precedence over construction‑project payment liens, mortgage rights, and other creditor claims, but have also established corresponding remedies for homebuyers in different circumstances.
In practice, the protection of homebuyers’ rights requires not only clear statutory provisions but also the proactive assertion of those rights by the entitled parties. Whether through the execution‑objection procedure to safeguard expectancy rights in rem or through an action for execution objection to assert priority in recovering purchase payments, both constitute crucial avenues for translating legal norms into effective practical protection.
END
※ Some images were generated by AI tools.
Previous Issues Recap
Opinion | Zhang Bingxu and Han Meijun: An Analysis of Homebuyers’ Super-Priority Rights (Part I)
Opinion | Zhang Bingxu and Han Meijun: Homebuyers’ Super-Priority Rights (Part II)
Opinion | Zhang Bingxu and Han Meijun: An Analysis of Homebuyers’ Super-Priority Rights (Part III)
Opinion | Zhang Bingxu and Han Meijun: An Analysis of Homebuyers’ Super-Priority Rights (Part Four)
Attorney Profile
.
Zhang Bingxu
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Zhang Bingxu holds a Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University and a Master of Laws from Washington University in St. Louis. He practiced for many years at top-tier law firms, providing legal services to leading companies across multiple industries, including China Life Investment, Vanke, Yintai Investment, Wangfujing, and Huabin Investment. Attorney Zhang specializes in civil and commercial dispute resolution, investment and M&A, and corporate legal advisory, with a deep focus on the real estate, insurance‑fund investment, and biopharmaceutical sectors. In the area of dispute resolution, he has handled numerous complex civil and commercial litigation and arbitration matters, with aggregate claim values totaling several billion yuan, successfully helping clients recover substantial losses. In the investment and M&A space, he has participated in landmark projects spanning real estate, insurance‑fund investments, and the biopharmaceutical industry, with cumulative transaction values exceeding ten billion yuan. As a long‑term corporate legal counsel, he provides routine compliance support, assists in establishing risk‑management frameworks, and conducts legal assessments of business models for numerous real estate groups, insurance asset‑management institutions, and biotechnology companies, actively engaging in their strategic decision‑making processes.
Business Areas:
Civil and commercial dispute resolution, legal services for real estate and insurance‑fund investments, and ongoing corporate legal advisory services.
.
Han Meijun
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University; Master of Civil Procedure Law from Tsinghua University. Awarded the “Crown—Rising Star Lawyer Award” at the 2025 Guike Annual Conference, and recognized on Legal 500 China’s Elite list in the “Dispute Resolution” practice area.
Previously employed at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing. With more than seven years of experience in civil and commercial dispute resolution, he has represented clients in dozens of complex, high‑profile litigation and arbitration matters. The disputes he has handled encompass equity transfer disputes, earn‑out agreement disputes, private equity fund and trust contract disputes, guarantee contract disputes, private lending disputes, corporate resolution validity disputes, and trade secret infringement disputes, among others. These cases have been adjudicated by such judicial bodies as the Supreme People’s Court, the higher people’s courts of various provinces and municipalities, the China International Economic and Trade Arbitration Commission, and the Beijing Arbitration Commission.
We excel at crafting systematic dispute-resolution strategies for our clients, spanning everything from front-end transaction‑risk assessments and the design of commercial negotiation frameworks to pre‑litigation evidence‑chain consolidation and preservation‑strategy development, all the way through courtroom advocacy and enforcement‑driven recovery. We provide end‑to‑end, one‑stop services that help clients stand out in complex legal disputes, seamlessly aligning their business objectives with legal imperatives.
In addition to civil and commercial disputes, the firm also focuses on the cultural and entertainment sectors, specializing in music‑related and film‑and‑television investment disputes. With extensive experience in compliance and crisis communications, it provides end-to-end risk management and rights‑protection solutions for leading platforms, talent agencies, and public figures.
Business Areas:
Civil, commercial, and administrative dispute resolution; ongoing corporate legal services; corporate bankruptcy and liquidation.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Management Committee


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Related News
2026-11-12

