Practical Approaches to Managing Corporate Criminal Risks

Shen Xinyu
Star Lai Law Firm
Partner
When
Previously, certain entities without financial qualifications have devised closed-loop transaction schemes—under the guise of “supply-chain finance” or “bill‑of‑exchange financing”—that involve routing documents and payments without actual goods being exchanged, thereby providing enterprises with de facto loans. While these arrangements may appear to involve sales contracts and the circulation of negotiable instruments, they in fact fabricate trade chains and lack any genuine movement of goods. Once a company defaults on repayment, the financiers often resort to filing criminal complaints to exert pressure, effectively “criminalizing” what is, in essence, a civil dispute. As a result, companies that once sought financing find themselves transformed into defendants in criminal cases, with their operations brought to a standstill.
Take as an example a typical case handled by the author: In order to secure financing, Company B implemented a “circular goods‑trade‑plus‑bill‑settlement” financing scheme devised by investor Company Z, creating a closed‑loop transaction in which funds flowed from Company Z, through intermediary purchaser Company A, to Company B, and bills of exchange were endorsed by Company B back to Company Z. In reality, no genuine delivery of goods took place during the financing process, and the acceptance bills issued by Company B served merely as forward‑looking promises to repay at maturity. During the early stages of the collaboration, Company B was able to make timely repayments; however, its cash flow subsequently collapsed, resulting in the default of bills totaling over RMB 3 million. At that point, rather than filing a civil action based on the underlying financing arrangement, Company Z directly brought criminal charges against the person in charge of Company B for bill‑fraud. Both the first‑instance and second‑instance courts convicted the defendant, but the case was later remanded for retrial upon the instruction of a higher people’s court. The core issue highlighted by this case is: How can enterprises identify the criminal risks inherent in such financing schemes? And what compliance‑related safeguards should be put in place?
Risk Identification
Criminal risks in corporate financing typically exhibit three key characteristics: first, the transaction structure is complex, involving multiple parties and contracts, with the true intent obscured by superficial formalities; second, the funding party lacks financial qualifications and circumvents regulatory oversight under such guises as “buying and selling,” “agency,” or “services”; and third, contract provisions may conceal adverse liability for breach of contract and unilateral interpretive authority. Once a default occurs, the funding party may resort to criminal charges as a debt-collection tactic. Companies should remain vigilant when reviewing financing proposals.
Compliance Strategy
Financing enterprises should establish three lines of defense across the pre‑, in‑, and post‑event dimensions.
First line of defense: Pre-emptive risk control in financing decisions. When selecting financing channels, enterprises should prioritize legal compliance reviews over financial cost considerations. Specific measures include:
(1) Verify the counterparty’s qualifications by checking, via the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System, the official websites of financial regulatory authorities, and the Judgment Documents Website, whether the other party holds the requisite financial licenses and by reviewing its past litigation records.
(2) Conduct a穿透 analysis of the transaction structure, requiring the counterparty to provide a complete transaction flow diagram and a full contractual chain, to identify any irregular arrangements such as “documentary trade without actual goods,” circular trading, or self‑buying and self‑selling. If circumstances are detected—such as the absence of genuine delivery of goods, closed‑loop fund repatriation, or price differentials that effectively constitute interest—the financing proposal shall be rejected; and
(3) Establish a negative list system, placing counterparties that lack lending qualifications or employ complex structures to circumvent regulatory oversight on an internal blacklist and prohibiting cooperation with them.
Second line of defense: Full-process traceability of transactions. With respect to financing arrangements already in place, companies should continuously preserve and document compliance‑related evidence throughout the performance of their obligations, so as to avoid being placed in a disadvantaged position should disputes arise in the future. Specific measures include:
(1) If settlement is conducted via negotiable instruments, it is essential to ensure that there are genuine transactions involving goods or services, and to retain supporting documentation such as procurement contracts, logistics documents, acceptance certificates, and VAT invoices, thereby ensuring that “every shipment can be verified and every document can be matched.”
(2) Enter into a clear loan agreement that explicitly sets forth the principal amount, interest rate, term, and liability for breach of contract, thereby avoiding disguised interest charges through concealed mechanisms such as purchase‑sale price differentials, service fees, or consulting fees. This ensures transparency in financing costs and facilitates the reconstruction of the true legal relationship in judicial proceedings; and
(3) Prior to making significant financing decisions, engage legal counsel with expertise in both financial matters and criminal compliance to review the relevant contracts and issue a written legal opinion, which will serve as an internal decision‑making basis and as evidence to demonstrate the company’s lack of criminal intent in the future.
The third line of defense: crisis response and procedural remedies. Once a company experiences payment delinquency in its financing arrangements and the other party has either issued a threat to file a criminal complaint or has already filed one, the company should immediately activate its emergency response plan. Specific measures include:
(1) Collect all materials demonstrating that the transaction structure was designed by the other party, and preserve relevant evidence, including correspondence, WeChat chat records, draft contracts, meeting minutes, and the like, to prove that the other party was fully aware of the absence of a genuine trade background and that no “erroneous perception” existed; as well as
(2) Compile historical performance records—such as the repayment ratio and communication logs—as well as information on the enterprise’s and its responsible persons’ asset status and the actual use of funds, to establish an evidentiary chain demonstrating the absence of any intent for unlawful appropriation, thereby clarifying that the default stems from operational difficulties rather than malicious fraud.
Conclusion
The author recommends that companies integrate criminal compliance into their day-to-day risk management framework: have the legal department or external counsel conduct regular risk assessments of financing channels and counterparties; provide business personnel with training on identifying criminal risks; and establish a multi-tiered review process for financing contracts. Compared with the substantial costs of post‑event remediation, proactive compliance investments represent the most cost‑effective “risk‑mitigation insurance” for enterprises.
Criminal law should serve as the last line of defense in social governance, not the first “tool” deployed in commercial disputes. Only by proactively establishing and front‑loading compliance safeguards can enterprises turn risks into barriers and achieve steady, predictable growth amid uncertainty.
This article was published in the June 2026 issue of Commercial Law, under the original title: “The ‘Criminal Cognitive Gap’ in Supply Chain Finance and a Path to Compliance Resolution” 。
Attorney Profile
.
Shen Xinyu
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Deputy Director of the Management Committee
Partner
Deputy Director of the Management Committee and Partner at Beijing Starrise Law Firm. He has served as a member of the 13th and 14th CPPCC Committees of Hohhot, an arbitrator at the Hohhot Arbitration Commission, an expert on the Supreme People’s Procuratorate’s Expert Advisory Network for Civil and Administrative Prosecution, Deputy Secretary-General of the Corporate Compliance Law Professional Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association, a director on the Board of Directors of the Municipal Local Legislation Research Association, an expert in criminal matters on the Provincial Pool of Specialized Legal Professionals, a professional under the provincial third-party supervision and assessment mechanism for corporate compliance in cases involving criminal offenses, a specially appointed legal supervisor at provincial detention centers, a member of the provincial construction industry association’s legal expert pool, a hearing officer at the district-level People’s Procuratorate, and an executive committee member of the 12th Women’s Federation of Hohhot as well as a member of the Youth Federation. With sixteen years of practice, he possesses extensive experience in handling difficult and complex criminal cases, having successfully secured numerous acquittals and decisions not to prosecute. He is particularly adept at managing cases that intersect criminal, civil, and administrative law, as well as high‑end, intricate commercial litigation and arbitration matters involving corporate entities.
Editor and Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Shen Xinyu


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Contact number: 027-82288828
Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Building E, Weilan Business Harbor, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916
Related News
2026-11-12
