
Editor’s Note:

On the afternoon of August 1, 2026, the 22nd “Ten Criminal Defense Lawyers” Forum was successfully held at the Zhongtong Law Firm in Beijing, with a special symposium on “Practical Challenges and Legislative Improvements in Property‑Related Defense.”
The following individuals participated in the forum’s discussions and delivered remarks: Yang Kuangsheng, Director of Beijing Zhongtong Law Firm; Qian Lieyang of Beijing Zihua Law Firm; Xu Lanting, Honorary Director of Beijing Junyong Law Firm; Liu Weidong, Director of Beijing Guanheng Law Firm; Wang Zhaofeng, Director of Beijing Zhoutai Law Firm; Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm; Mao Lixin, Honorary Director of Beijing Shangquan Law Firm; Zhu Yonghui, Director of Beijing Jingdu Law Firm; Mao Hongtao, Director of the Management Committee of Beijing Dongwei Law Firm; Cheng Xiaolu, Chair of the Partners’ Meeting at Beijing Starrise Law Firm; and Zhao Chunyu, Director of the Criminal Law Committee at Beijing Yingke Law Firm, among others.
This forum was moderated by Wang Bo, a partner at Beijing Shangquan Law Firm, and Yang Dakang, the founder of the legal self-media platform Dakang Parlor. The forum also invited… Professor Wang Zhixiang, Director of the Institute of Foreign and Comparative Criminal Law at Beijing Normal University, and Professor Guo Shuo, Dean of the Capital Research Institute (Beijing Legislative Research Institute) at China University of Political Science and Law, served as panelists, while Professor Fan Chongyi, Honorary Dean of the Institute of Procedural Law at China University of Political Science and Law, was invited to deliver the closing remarks.
The following is the keynote address delivered by Attorney Zhao Yunheng, Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm, at the forum, which has been compiled and published for the benefit of all.
Zhao Yunheng
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Honorary Director


In recent years, the disposition of assets involved in criminal cases has drawn widespread attention. However, one particularly salient issue has yet to receive adequate scrutiny: how should the property of third-party stakeholders—those with interests outside the case—be protected?
These past few days, we’ve encountered a rather intriguing case. Two years ago, a woman sold two of her vehicles and completed the transfer of ownership as required. Recently, local police have been tracking her down, alleging that she is suspected of the crime of illegally disposing of seized or frozen property—specifically, that she sold vehicles that had already been ordered by a final judgment to be confiscated from a notorious gang leader. They’re now giving her an ultimatum: either retrieve the vehicles or pay the corresponding proceeds; otherwise, she will face arrest.
This minor case has brought to light a particularly pressing issue: no one ever notified her. The vehicle was registered under her name, yet she remained unaware of when it was seized, frozen, or impounded; whether she had any say in the matter after such measures were taken; how the case was subsequently handled; and on what grounds the judgment was rendered or the enforcement carried out. When she sold the car, there were no records of seizure, freezing, or impoundment—otherwise, the transfer of ownership would have been impossible, and no buyer would have stepped forward. Now, long after all the vehicles had been sold, she not only faces the prospect of losing her assets but also risks criminal liability. The problems underlying this situation are thus strikingly evident.
Yesterday, the central authorities convened another meeting, announcing the launch of another year-long special campaign to combat organized crime and eliminate evil forces, with a particular focus on online platforms and so‑called “soft violence.” This once again raises the issue of seizing assets and cutting off funding channels. However, in practice, is such asset‑seizure and funding‑cutting carried out accurately? Are innocent parties inadvertently harmed, or are the financial lifelines of individuals unrelated to the case being severed? In our experience, whenever a case involving organized crime—or even ordinary property‑related offenses, including those of a corruption nature—arises, investigators often proceed to ransack homes and companies, freezing bank accounts and cards not only of the accused but also of close and distant relatives. As a result, these individuals are unable to pay social security contributions, collect their salaries, or cover living expenses and childcare costs, severely disrupting their daily lives. Even when they file objections, the process of review and verification can drag on for an extended period, and restitution may ultimately fail to be implemented in a timely manner. Therefore, as we discuss this issue today, we must integrate the protection of third‑party property into the broader framework of revising the Criminal Procedure Law, and work together to explore how to improve relevant safeguards.
In particular, the new year’s special campaign, which is about to commence, focuses on online platforms. As everyone knows, these digital platforms involve far more complex legal relationships than traditional organized‑crime offenses. They implicate platform operators, merchants, livestreaming hosts, end‑consumers, and others; consequently, the property‑related legal issues they raise give rise to a host of novel challenges. This calls for thorough research and the development of targeted countermeasures.
Now, I will share my personal views from three perspectives. Some of these technical points have already been touched upon by colleagues in their articles and presentations.
First, the legal status of third‑party stakeholders must be clearly defined in procedural law, their standing in litigation must be safeguarded, and they must be treated as full parties to the proceedings. Only then will these stakeholders have a genuine opportunity to intervene in the defense of their own property. Otherwise, as in the example I just cited, a third party may find that their property has been disposed of without their knowledge—and they may even be implicated in criminal liability.
If this legislative amendment designates interested parties as parties to the proceedings, it must begin by establishing a right to information: that is, whenever property is subject to inquiry, seizure, or freezing, the relevant parties must be notified, enabling them to raise objections. Failure to publish notices or inform third parties is improper, and investigative authorities cannot rely solely on the statements of suspects or defendants claiming that certain property belongs to them—often, such claims reflect mistaken perceptions or overlook the complex ownership relationships involved, which may implicate the property rights of third parties. By granting third parties the right to access information and, further, the rights to present evidence, cross‑examine, participate in trial proceedings and defense, and file execution‑related objections, their legal status can be effectively safeguarded.
However, the existing legal provisions are largely principled and rather fragmented. For example, the Criminal Procedure Law stipulates that third parties with an interest in the case have the right to apply to participate in proceedings concerning the disposition of property, yet it remains unclear precisely what that “right” entails. The Supreme People’s Court’s interpretation of the Criminal Procedure Law grants judges considerable discretion, allowing them, when deemed necessary, to notify third parties to join the litigation. But what constitutes “necessary”? As we know, judges generally conclude that it is not necessary; even when we raise objections to the exclusion of illegally obtained evidence or call witnesses to testify, judges often deem such steps unnecessary. The law leaves too many loopholes—this is poor legislative technique. Terms like “when necessary” should be eliminated; once a third party raises an objection and asserts a right, that alone should suffice to establish necessity, don’t you think?
At present, the most refined provision is the system of trial in absentia—applicable when the defendant is in hiding or has died—specifically designed to adjudicate matters involving property. Under this regime, a public notice must be issued to inform third parties and enable them to participate in the proceedings. However, merely posting such a notice raises practical questions: who would actually see it? In a tiny corner of an online platform or a newspaper, amidst hundreds of densely packed, small‑format notices, expecting ordinary citizens to locate and read it is unrealistic. Moreover, in many cases, the judicial authorities already possess leads about third parties and are aware that the property at issue may be subject to dispute and that these individuals can be contacted; in such situations, they should provide individualized notification rather than settling for a generic public notice. Thus, the rules governing trial in absentia remain flawed, primarily because the procedural framework fails to clearly define the status of third parties and to establish their right to participate in the litigation as parties.
Secondly, in substance, the criteria for identifying and distinguishing property involved in a case should be refined, particularly with regard to the standards for determining the property of third parties. At present, merely stating that such property ought to be identified and protected is far from sufficient. We should, as in civil law, establish clear standards for proving ownership—for example, defining what constitutes illegal proceeds, stolen funds, or illicit goods. Does a project payment obtained through bid-rigging count as such? If a defendant borrowed my car and used my residence to commit a drug‑related offense, must my car and home necessarily be classified as instruments or evidence of the crime and confiscated? The assets of officials convicted of official misconduct or organized‑crime bosses are even more complex, often including lawful property, jointly owned assets, and property subject to ownership disputes. Should we therefore further refine the criteria for their identification? This also raises questions such as: What qualifies as “necessary living expenses”? How large a dwelling is deemed essential? And what level of monthly subsistence allowance is appropriate for adults and children? When corporate equity and associated profits are at issue, the situation becomes even more complicated; in practice, there are no established standards for such determinations, and third‑party corporate rights are frequently infringed upon by default.
The final aspect—perhaps one that has not yet been widely discussed, and for which I have not yet found an appropriate term—is, in terms of institutional arrangements, the need to enhance the capacity to review property‑rights issues, thereby ensuring that legal relationships are accurately delineated. While procedural rules and substantive standards already exist, relying solely on criminal investigators, prosecutors, and criminal judges to handle such matters would clearly fall short. This is a cross‑disciplinary issue, involving complex real‑property relations as well as the application of corporate law and various civil and administrative statutes; criminal justice practitioners, who seldom encounter these matters in their day‑to‑day work, may lack the necessary expertise.
Is it possible, from a jurisdictional standpoint, to adopt the approach of absent‑property adjudication—allowing the court in the place where the crime was committed to institute proceedings and adjudicate disputed property—by bringing a separate action on an independent cause of action outside the criminal trial, thereby creating a new type of litigation and a novel triangular relationship? Alternatively, from an organizational perspective, should personnel from the civil and administrative departments be involved at every stage, from the prosecutor overseeing the investigation to the judge presiding over the trial?
We further hope that, while refining the provisions governing the status, procedures, and substantive aspects of legal proceedings, the various authorities will exercise mutual checks and balances and oversight, thereby addressing the practice of investigative agencies unlawfully seizing the property of third parties. Moreover, we call for due consideration to be given to objections raised by third parties at all stages, including the enforcement phase, and for the institutional design of an effective mechanism to reverse erroneous measures of investigation, freezing, or seizure, as well as erroneous judicial rulings, so as to promptly rectify such errors.
It is hoped that experts, legislators, and the judiciary will all engage in thorough reflection on these issues and work together to advance the rule of law. Protecting the lawful property of the people is not merely a slogan; rather, it must be firmly grounded in due regard and implemented through effective, practical legislative and judicial mechanisms. Otherwise, the problems that have already arisen may reoccur, and in the complex socio‑economic relationships of the future, they could be further exacerbated.



Source: Criminal Defense Ten-Person Forum Official Account
Attorney Profile
.
Zhao Yunheng
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Honorary Director
Honorary Director of Beijing Starrise Law Firm and Doctor of Law from Peking University. He serves as a director of the Chinese Society of Criminal Procedure, a specially appointed legal supervisor for detention centers under the Ministry of Public Security, a part-time master’s supervisor at Peking University School of Law, Vice President of the Peking University Financial Alumni Association, a part-time professor at the Master of Laws Institute of China University of Political Science and Law, and an off-campus graduate mentor at the School of Law of Beijing Foreign Studies University. He also holds the positions of Deputy Director of the Corporate Compliance Law Professional Committee of the All-China Lawyers Association, Legal Expert with the Beijing Municipal Commission of Planning and Natural Resources, and Member of the Corporate Compliance Working Committee of the All-China Federation of Industry and Commerce.
Layout: Wang Xin
Reviewed by: Shen Xinyu


Beijing Headquarters Address: 17th Floor, China Resources Building, No. 8 Jianguomen North Avenue, Dongcheng District, Beijing
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Contact number: 027-82288828
Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Building E, Weilan Business Harbor, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916
Related News
2026-11-12

