
"
The preceding section discussed the general principles governing compensation liability in cases of involuntary vacating of a property after signing a lease. This article continues by examining how to handle several special circumstances:
"
PART 0 1
Can the deposit, late payment penalty, and cancellation penalty be applied concurrently?

In second-hand home transactions, contracts typically stipulate a daily penalty for late payment, and some buyers also pay a deposit to the seller. If, after delaying payment for several months, the buyer decides to withdraw from the purchase, three liabilities may arise simultaneously: the return of the deposit, the penalty for late payment, and the penalty for breach of contract upon withdrawal. Can all three be applied at the same time?
At present, there are no uniform national judicial guidelines on this issue. Drawing on the adjudicative views issued by the Third Intermediate People’s Court of Beijing regarding disputes over liquidated damages in second-hand housing sales, the application of default interest for late payment is premised on the condition that “the buyer is in arrears but the contract remains in force.” If the buyer ultimately and unequivocally indicates that they will no longer perform the contract, thereby constituting a fundamental breach, and the seller seeks to claim liquidated damages for repudiation of the contract, Late payment penalties and cancellation penalties should not be applied cumulatively. 。
Regarding the rules governing earnest money, judicial practice generally holds that, in a real estate sales contract, the earnest money is typically paid by the buyer to the seller. When the contract is performed as agreed, the earnest money is credited toward the purchase price. If the buyer breaches the contract and the seller seeks to withhold the earnest money while also claiming liquidated damages, the court should clarify the legal implications to the parties and require them to Choose one position 。
An exception applies: if the contract expressly stipulates that the deposit is a forfeiture deposit, it may be applied concurrently with liquidated damages. According to Article 23 of the “Guiding Opinions of the Beijing Higher People’s Court on Several Legal Issues Concerning the Adjudication of Disputes over House Sales Contracts (Trial Implementation),” where one party has already committed a breach, upon the fulfillment of the agreed conditions, both the forfeiture penalty for the deposit and liquidated damages may be applied simultaneously.
PART 0 2
How should compensation be handled when only a letter of intent has been signed, but no formal contract has been executed?
Some homebuyers, though optimistic about a property, may hesitate to make a final decision and instead sign a letter of intent (or a subscription agreement, reservation agreement, or similar document) to secure the unit and agree to execute a formal purchase contract at a later date. If, before the formal contract is signed, the buyer changes their mind and decides not to proceed with the transaction, what liabilities will they face?
According to Article 2 of the “Minutes of the Meeting of the Beijing Higher People’s Court on Several Difficult Issues in Adjudicating Disputes over House Sales Contracts,” after a preliminary agreement is concluded, if one party refuses to enter into the house sales contract without justifiable reason, the request by the complying party to compel the breaching party to conclude the sales contract through litigation will generally not be supported. In other words, if the buyer changes their mind and refuses to sign the formal contract, the seller has no right to seek judicial enforcement of the contract; however, the buyer is not entirely exempt from liability. Under the relevant provisions of the Civil Code, in such cases… The homebuyer must compensate the seller for losses to the seller’s legitimate expectations.

In accordance with Article 2 of the “Guiding Opinions of the Beijing Higher People’s Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Disputes over House Sales Contracts (Trial Implementation)” and Article 5 of the relevant guidelines for adjudicating house sales disputes, if the preliminary agreement contains a deposit clause, the penalty provisions applicable to deposits shall apply. If no deposit clause is stipulated, or if the deposit amount is insufficient to compensate the non-breaching party for its actual losses, the breaching party shall compensate the non-breaching party for reasonable expenses incurred in concluding the contract, as well as for losses arising from missed business opportunities due to reliance on the conclusion of the contract.
It is particularly important to note that the aforementioned rules apply only when the contract in question is an agreement in contemplation of contract—that is, a contract whose purpose is merely to lock in the intention to transact, without expressly setting out core transaction terms such as the purchase price, payment method, or date of possession. If the preliminary agreement already contains all the essential elements of a formal sales contract, it may be deemed by the court to be a definitive contract, even if it does not use the official standard form issued by the housing and urban–rural development authorities. In such cases, pursuant to Article 4 of the “Notice of the Tianjin Higher People’s Court on Lawfully and Properly Adjudicating Disputes over House Sales Contracts,” the seller is entitled to require the buyer to bear liability for breach of contract in accordance with the terms of a formal sales contract.
PART 0 3
Both parties are at fault/breach of contract
A transaction often fails to close smoothly without one party being entirely at fault. For example, if the contract stipulates that the seller vacates the property and the buyer pays the purchase price, but the buyer fails to raise funds promptly and the seller likewise does not vacate in a timely manner, both parties have breached their contractual obligations.
In this regard, Article 592 of the Civil Code provides that if both parties breach the contract, each shall bear the corresponding liability; if one party’s breach causes loss to the other and the other party was at fault in causing the loss, the amount of damages may be reduced accordingly. Referring to the judicial opinion of the Third Intermediate People’s Court of Beijing, where both parties are in breach, full liability cannot be directly excused merely because both have committed breaches; rather, it is necessary to Depending on the nature of each party’s breach, the order in which the corresponding contractual obligations were to be performed, and the extent to which the breach contributed to the resulting damages, it is determined whether a right of defense based on prior performance exists, whether both parties are in breach, or whether there is contributory negligence; ultimately, the court exercises discretion to reduce or exempt one party from liability for damages.
Practical Implications
1. Contract clause design: Clearly define the specific circumstances constituting a “fundamental breach” (e.g., payment overdue for more than 15 days) and the liquidated damages standard (e.g., 20% of the total house price). The supplementary agreement should explicitly set out the criteria for determining force majeure and change of circumstances to avoid future disputes. The earnest money clause must clearly specify the nature of the earnest money and its relationship to the application of liquidated damages.
2. Preservation of Evidence: The party that has complied with the contract should retain evidence of the other party’s breach, such as chat records, call recordings, and proof of late payments, as well as reports assessing the difference in property value and receipts for expenses incurred in protecting their rights. If the breaching party seeks to mitigate its liability, it should gather evidence showing problems with the other party’s performance, such as inspection reports on housing quality issues or proof that the other party failed to vacate the premises on time.
3. Prompt action: If you decide to check out, promptly notify the other party in writing—e.g., by EMS mail with “Termination Notice” clearly marked—and retain proof of delivery to avoid delays that could lead to higher claims from the other side. Afterwards, try to negotiate with them—for example, arrange for installment payments of any liquidated damages—to prevent being deemed to have breached the contract maliciously.
4. Litigation Preparation: When the non-breaching party files a lawsuit, they must demonstrate the link between the liquidated damages and the actual losses. When the breaching party defends, they should present evidence showing that the agreed-upon liquidated damages are excessive—such as housing price data from the same residential complex—and also point out the other party’s fault to seek a reduction in liability. If possible, aim for mediation to save time and costs.
Conclusion
Judicial decisions are always influenced by policy and, in turn, must take social impacts into account. During periods of rising housing prices, a common type of dispute arises when government restrictions on home purchases are introduced, rendering buyers ineligible to purchase. Both judicial interpretations and court practice tend to protect buyers’ interests and penalize sellers who breach contracts by refusing to sell. By contrast, during periods of falling housing prices, the most frequent disputes involve stalled construction projects and claims that properties fail to meet delivery standards. Relevant judicial practice generally prioritizes protecting sellers’ interests and focuses on sanctioning buyers who default on contracts and seek to withdraw. Therefore, At present, it is becoming increasingly difficult for homebuyers to have their requests to cancel a purchase granted, and courts are also inclined to hold them liable for greater damages. Homebuyers should exercise greater caution when deciding to terminate a housing contract, carefully and comprehensively gathering relevant evidence to seek judicial support for their request to withdraw from the contract and to mitigate their liability for damages.
(Some images generated by AI tools)
Author Biography
.
Zhang Bingxu
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Zhang Bingxu holds a Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University and a Master of Laws from Washington University in St. Louis. He practiced for many years at top-tier law firms and has provided legal services to leading companies across various sectors, including China Life Investment, Vanke, Yintai Investment, Wangfujing, and Huabin Investment. Attorney Zhang specializes in civil and commercial dispute resolution, investment and M&A, and corporate legal advisory, with a particular focus on real estate, insurance‑fund investments, and the biopharmaceutical industry. In dispute resolution, he has handled numerous complex civil and commercial litigation and arbitration matters, with aggregate claim values totaling several billion yuan, successfully recovering substantial losses for his clients. In the investment and M&A space, he has participated in landmark projects spanning real estate, insurance‑fund investing, and biotechnology, with combined transaction values exceeding ten billion yuan. As a corporate counsel, he provides day‑to‑day compliance support, designs risk‑management frameworks, and assesses the legality of business models for numerous real estate groups, insurance asset‑management institutions, and biotechnology companies, deeply engaging in their strategic decision‑making.
Business Areas:
Civil and commercial dispute resolution, legal services for real estate and insurance fund investments, and ongoing corporate legal services.
.
Han Meijun
Beijing Starrise Law Firm
Partner
Partner at Beijing Starrise Law Firm; holds a Bachelor of Laws from Tsinghua University and a Master’s degree in Civil Procedure. Member of the Civil Procedure Law Committee of the 12th Beijing Lawyers Association. Recognized as one of the “Top 10 Arbitration Lawyers” in The Litigation’s Reputation Choice Awards for 2026, named to the Legal 500 China Elite list for Dispute Resolution in 2025, and recipient of the “Crown – Rising Star Lawyer Award” at the Guike Annual Conference, among other accolades. Previously practiced at Zhonglun Law Firm in Beijing. With over eight years of experience in civil and commercial dispute resolution, has represented clients in dozens of complex, high‑profile litigation and arbitration matters. Specializes in disputes involving equity transfers, earn‑out agreements, private equity funds and trust contracts, guarantee agreements, private lending, validity of corporate resolutions, and trade secret infringement. Has provided legal services to major corporations and institutions including Lenovo Group, Charoen Pokphand Group, China Merchants Group, and PAG, adept at crafting comprehensive, systematic dispute‑resolution strategies—from front‑end risk assessment and negotiation planning, through pre‑litigation evidence gathering and preservation, to courtroom advocacy and enforcement of judgments—delivering end‑to‑end, one‑stop solutions.
Previous Issues


Beijing Headquarters Address: No. 8, Jianguomen North Street, Dongcheng District, Beijing 17th Floor, China Resources Building
Contact numbers: 010-64011566, 18811162996
Wuhan Branch Address: Room 1001, 10th Floor, Huangpu International Center, Jiang’an District, Wuhan, Hubei Province
Contact number: 027-82288828
Hefei Branch Address: Rooms 1703–1710, Block E, Weilan Business Port, No. 188 Qianshan Road, Shushan District, Hefei, Anhui Province
Contact numbers: 0551-68127192, 15850561916
Related News
2026-11-12

